Dosimetry - Melodi 2014

MELODI2014 Workshop
Barcelona, Spain. October 6-9, 2014
MELODI 2014: Integrating observational and experimental research
Parallel Session 3: Dosimetry
-
Microdosimetry-Nanodosimetry from track structures to early
billogical effects on DNA. (Carmen Villagrasa, IRSN, France)
-
Internal contamination (Augusto Giussani, BfS, Germany)
-
Biological Dosimetry (JF Barquinero, UAB, Spain)
DISCUSSION:
-
How to contribute / improve MELODI SRA regarding dosimetry?
 Synergisms between MELODI and EURADOS SRAs.
M.A. Lopez, MELODI2014
Barcelona, October 6-9, 2014
1
MELODI2014 Workshop
Barcelona, Spain. October 6-9, 2014
Micro- & Nano-dosimetry: from track structure to early
biological effects on DNA (C. Villagrasa, IRSN)

Experimental and simulation techniques are being developed/improved to
determine the parameters in the physical and chemical interaction of ionizing
radiation on biological matter resulting in undesirable biological effects.
effects
 Nanodosimetric measurements
Which is the target volume relevant for studying the
biological response? It depends of the biological end-point
Cellular
u a sca
scale:
e micrometer
c o ete
 Ce
 Sub-cellular scale (e.g. DNA): nanometer
nm scale
εi
Track structure
investigation
- Jet Counter (NCBJ),
(NCBJ) StarTrack (INFN) and Ion Counter (PTB)
- Measurement of the frequency distributions of ionization
cluster size in a gas (equivalence with water is fulfilled)
M.A. Lopez, MELODI2014
Barcelona, October 6-9, 2014
2
Nanodosimetry : Track structure simulations using Monte Carlo
Physical
interaction
with target
molecules
10-18s
Radicals
Radicals
diffusion
creation
ti
10-15s 10-12s 10-10 s
Physical stage
Physicochemical
h i l
stage
Repair
Biological effects:
processes,
DSB aberrations
DSB,
aberrations,
enzymatic
10-6s processes
1s-1h mutations ….
…….
Chemical
reactions
Chemical stage
Biochemical
stage
t g
Biological stage
Simulation
The simulation of the first stages used the
Geant4-DNA MC code capabilities improved with
new BioQuaRT data and methods. New molecular
DNA descriptions are used in the MC simulation
Biological
g
data are measured
by BioQuaRT team using
microbeam facilities (PTB,
Surrey university).
Early DNA damages results
3
3
MELODI2014 Workshop
Barcelona, Spain. October 6-9, 2014
Assessment of internal dose after intakes of
radionuclides (A. Giussani, BfS)
Extrinsic removal
Inhalation Exhalation
 Biokinetic Model:
metabolic
behaviour of
contaminants
inside the body Skin
Ski
after the intake
Respiratory
t
tract
t
model
Lymph
nodes
Direct absorption
Sweat
 Evaluation of
doses from
Intake:
Dosimetric
Models
(ICRP Dose
coefficients)
Ingestion
Subcutaneous
S
b t
tissue
Transfer
compartment
t
t
Liver
Gastrointestinal
t
tract
t
model
 Wound
Assessment of the Committed Effective Dose E(50) :
Kid
Kidney
E(50) mSv = I(Bq) * e(50)(mSv/Bq)
Skin
Other
where I(Bq) isorgans
the intake
Urinary bladder
e(50)
(50) mSv/Bq
S /B is
i the
th dose
d
coefficient
ffi i t (ICRP) =
committed effective dose when Intake
is 1 Bq
Urine
Faeces4
MELODI2014 Workshop
Barcelona, Spain. October 6-9, 2014
Assessment of internal dose after intakes of radionuclides
(A Giussani,
(A.
Giussani BfS)
Some issues for discussion:
-
-
Models are very complex and data are difficult or imposible to obtain
Different types of applications (dose coefficients, bioassay retention
and
d excretion
ti functions,…)
f
ti
) have
h
diff
different
t requirements
i
t off accuracy
and realism
Example: Iodine Model is ok, but embrio/fetus needs a more detailed
modeling
Importance of UNCERTAINTY and SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS: work
under development
p
on
- EURADOS WG7
- CURE Project (multidisplinary action where Epidemiologists,
Radiobiologists and Dosimetrists work together)
5
MELODI2014 Workshop
Barcelona, Spain. October 6-9, 2014
Usefulness and limits of Biological dosimetry (JF Barquinero, UAB)
 To assess dose due to a possible overexposure to ionizing radiation
based on a biological endpoint. Different scenarios:
Blood sampling
Retrospective
500mGy- 5 Gy
100-500 mGy
<100 mGy
Exposurre Dose
> 5 Gy
Recent
Damage
in DNA
Whole bod
Whole-body
Partial-body
Highly localized
Highly-localized
People involved
One or few
M.A. Lopez, MELODI2014
Barcelona, October 6-9, 2014
Tens
Hundreds
Thousands
Joan-Francesc BARQUINERO
6
Usefulness and limits of Biological dosimetry (JF Barquinero, UAB)
<100 mGy
100-500
100
500 mGy
500mGy- 5
GyGy
> 5
NO
YES
YES
NO
Detection limits - low doses
dic/cells
2/500
Confounding factors:
4/1000
Previous exposures to IR not
6/1500
related to the accident, CT scans….
•
dose estimation
95% confidence
dose
limits
((mGy)
y)
100
0
300
100
100
0
5
290
270
Dicentric scoring still remains de most sensitive method, most
frequently used and the best biological method for dose evaluation
 But! It is time consuming.
 To respond to a mass casualty event: NETWORKING
Harmonization is required: RENEB Project
Network of Biodosimetry labs
7
MELODI2014 Workshop
Parallel session 3: DOSIMETRY
From MELODI PRIORITIES:
PRIORITIES
 Characterization of spatial and temporal
energy deposition events (track structure
and dose rate) and their role in in lowdose radiation responses
(e.g. examination of radiation damage).
 Relationships between radio- and chemical
toxicity and their respective influence on
radiation-induced effects resulting from
incorporation (internal contamination) of
radionuclides
radionuclides.
 Identification, development and validation of
biomarkers for radiation induced health
(cancer and non-cancer) effects
 Consolidation of major cohorts suitable
for epidemiological studies
From EURADOS SRA:
• To improve understanding of spatial
correlations of radiation interaction
events
• To quantify correlations between track
structure and radiation damage –
• To better understand biokinetics &
dosimetry of internal emitters
• Radiological emergencies: To identify and
characterize new markers of exposure
p
and suitable biological end-points for
internal exposures
• Towards Improved
p
Radiation Risk
Estimates deduced from Epidemiological
Cohorts. To explore exposure pathways
not yet considered or validated (eye lens,
brain heart arteries/walls)
brain,
8
MELODI2014 Workshop
Barcelona, Spain. October 6-9, 2014
-
Microdosimetry-Nanodosimetry
Internal Dosimetry
Biological Dosimetry
 Can contribute to answer common questions of MELODI and
EURADOS SRAs
 Contribution
C t ib ti
t MELODI SRA - INTERNAL DOSIMETRY:
to
DOSIMETRY
-
Improvements needed in current biokinetic models to better
understand non-cancer effects of internal emitters:
e.g. vascular diseases
-
To improve fisiological approach, e.g. to introduce heart
arteries/walls for the assessment of the dose to blood, that
could be compared with dose assessments of biological dosimetry
M.A. Lopez, MELODI2014
Barcelona, October 6-9, 2014
9