MP11 - Evaluation of a Problem Solving Technique

Supporting
Caregivers
through Problem
Solving Therapy
Mary Chiu, PhD
Tim Pauley, MSc
Dunstan Pushpakumar, MPH,
Joel Sadavoy, MD, FRCPC,
Virginia Wesson, MD, MSc, FRCPC
Background
• Informal carers are essential in keeping persons
with dementia at home
• However, carers are susceptible to the
development of Caregiver Burden, which can
impair their ability to provide care
• The needs of carers have been overlooked due
to the lack of training for healthcare providers
and paucity of evidence to guide practice
Background (continued)
• PST is a systematic
approach to problem
solving shown to be
effective in alleviating
emotional distress and
improving problem
solving skills of carers
looking after persons
with a variety of
conditions
Purpose of the Study
• To evaluate the
effectiveness of a PST
training program when
delivered to informal carers
in the home, by case
managers who have
received training in PST
Hypotheses
Hypothesis 1
• By improving the ability to identify and define
problems, carers assigned to receive PST will
demonstrate improved task and emotional
coping
Hypothesis 2
• Through a systematic approach to solution
creation for identified problems, carers will
demonstrate improved self-perceived
competence and sense of mastery
Hypotheses (continued)
Hypothesis 3
• As burden is highly associated with care
recipient’s physical condition and disease
stage, neither group will demonstrate a
change in burden
Hypothesis 4
• Carers assigned to receive PST will
demonstrate reduced self-perceived stress
Methods
Methods (continued)
• Study design: concurrent, matched
cohort design
• Outcome measures:
– Coping Inventory for Stressful
Situations
– Mastery Scale
– Caregiving Competency Scale
– Perceived Stress Scale
– Zarit Burden Interview
Methods (continued)
• Inter-rater agreement was determined
– For independent evaluations of whether
PST was implemented as intended
• Intention-to-treat analysis was utilized
• Repeated measures ANOVA were conducted to
test study hypotheses
• Paired-samples t-tests were used for follow-up
pair-wise comparisons
– Bonferroni correction was used to reduce
likelihood of type I error
Results
Outcome Measures Score for PST Group
70
60
**
50
*
40
Score
Baseline
30
*
*
*
*
20
** = p < 0.01
* = p < 0.001
10
0
Task‐Oriented
Coping
Emotional Coping
Competence
Post‐intervention
Mastery
Outcome Measures
Burden
Self‐perceived
Results (continued)
Outcome Measures Score for Control Group
70
60
50
40
Score
Baseline
30
Post‐intervention
20
** = p < 0.01
* = p < 0.001
10
0
Task‐Oriented
Coping
Emotional Coping
Competence
Mastery
Outcome Measures
Burden
Self‐perceived
Discussion & Conclusions
• PST can be easily learned and delivered by
CCs
• PST grounded visits are more effective than
usual home visits
– Improves carers’ sense of caregiving
competence
– Increases task-focused coping
– Reduces emotion-focused coping
– Reduces burden
– Reduces stress
Discussion & Conclusion (continued)
• PST intervention may reduce reliance on
primary care, psychiatric services and
institutional services
• Effective partnerships between interprofessional groups and community agencies
can extend the reach of the expertise of
specialized healthcare institutions
• The project incorporated key elements of a
scalable, sustainable model disseminated to
diverse groups of professionals, carers and
persons with dementia
Discussion & Conclusion (Continued)
• Limitations
– Care recipients were not evaluated so it is not
possible to state whether the development of
carers’ problem-solving and other caregiving
capacities meaningfully improved outcomes
– Carers found the number of outcome
measures difficult
– This pilot was delivered in one location by
professionals integral to its development and
may be hard to replicate at other sites
Future Directions
• Development of a more targeted package of
outcome measures
• Exploration of further collaboration between
Mount Sinai Hospital and CCAC to effectively
expand the use of the PST intervention in the
community
• Significant expansion of system capacity for
dementia care and contribution to sustained
financial viability of the health care system
Acknowledgements
• This project is funded by the UHN AMO
Innovation Fund and is a collaboration between
Mount Sinai Hospital and Toronto-Central
Community Care Access Centre
• A special thanks to the CCAC care coordinators:
Belma Agustin, Bozena Kosciolek, Edith Lee,
Deanna Oad, Mira Olearczyk, Ann Poon; and to
the carergivers who participated.