Evaluation of MPPC photon sensors for the PHOS - Indico

Evaluation of MPPC photon sensors
for the PHOS upgrade in ALICE at CERN
ATHIC 2014
7.Aug.2014
K.Tarunaga
D.Sato, T.Sugitate
Hiroshima University, Japan
Outline
•
•
•
•
PHOS (PHOton Spectrometer)
Time of Flight
MPPC (Multi-Pixel Photon Counter)
Basic study using a laser pulser
- Signal distribution, Gain and Linearity
• Timing study using cosmic-ray
- Event selection, Time-walk correction and Timing resolution
• Summary
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
2
PHOS (PHOton Spectrometer)
• PHOS characteristic
- Lead-tungstate crystals(PWO) read out with APD
- High granularity
- High energy resolution σ/E = 3.5% (at 1 GeV)
• Physics goal
- Measurement of direct photons
-> Precise measurement at low energy is critical.
• Upgrade purpose
PWO Crystal
APD & Preamplifer
- Neutral hadron rejection (e.g. anti-neutron)
-> Good timing resolution is required.
(~ sub-nano seconds)
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
3
𝑇𝑂𝐹𝛾 − 𝑇𝑂𝐹 𝑛 > 3𝜎
Time of Flight
𝛾 and 𝑛 are distinguishable
Counts
n
3𝜎
γ
n
γ
PHOS
TOF
β =p/E
required resolution σ [ns]
1
0.71
2.12
2
0.89
0.61
3
0.95
0.28
4
0.97
0.16
5
0.98
0.10
Required Resolution (anti-neutron mass: 1 GeV)
p [GeV/c]
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
4
MPPC (Multi-Pixel Photon Counter)
• Single photon sensor consisting of multiple APD pixels
• High gain (105~106)
• Good timing resolution
• Operable in a magnetic field
MPPC S12572-025C
(http://hamamatsu.com)
Hamamatsu Photonics
Type No.
S12572-010C
S12572-025C
ATHIC 2014
MPPC & Preamplifer(Current amp)
Sensitive
Number of
Pixel Size
Area
Pixels
3×3 mm2 10×10μ m2 90,000
3×3 mm2 25×25μ m2 14,400
Kazuya Tarunaga
5
Basic study using a laser pulser
Wavelength:403nm
Power:174mW
Width:80ps
MPPC
Laser Head
1kHz
Optical
Fiber Cable
Filter
HV
63~72V
Pulser
Gate Generator
•
•
•
•
Measurement of Gain
Bias voltage dependence
Temperature dependence
Linearity
ATHIC 2014
In a Temperature Control Unit
Temperature Control Unit
-25~25℃
1ch
CS-ADC
(RPC-022)
Gate
8cm
Optical
Fiber Cable
Filter
MPPC
Gate
MPPC
Kazuya Tarunaga
6
A distribution of
the photon peaks,
compared with
a Poisson distribution
of n = 2.6
Signal distribution
2p.e.
1p.e.
0p.e.
3p.e.
4p.e.
5p.e.
6p.e.
7p.e.
8p.e. 9p.e.
The data seems deformed
from the pure poisson
because of cross-talks and
after-pulses.
• Single photon detection and good separation of photon peaks when
the number of incident photon is small.
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
7
Low temp.
(-25℃)
Gain
14.4k-type
High temp.
(25℃)
d
90k-type
d: the average distance
between the peaks
𝑑×𝑟
𝐺𝑎𝑖𝑛 =
𝑒
r: ADC resolution 0.25 [pc/ch]
e: elementary charge 1.602×10-19 [C]
• Gain becomes higher as temperature goes down.
• Gain is proportional to the bias voltage.
• 2 types of MPPC have different gain properties.
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
8
ADC Mean [ch]
Linearity
𝑓 𝑥 = 𝑝0 × 1 − exp −
𝑝1
𝑝0
×𝑥
Linear Plot
𝑝0: number of pixels
𝑝1: photon detection efficiency
• The 90k-type has around 10
times wider dynamic range
than that of 14.4k-type.
• The data for very intense lights
are not reproduced by this
function due to a possible
short recovery time.
ATHIC 2014
ADC Mean [ch]
Expected Number of Photons
Kazuya Tarunaga
Log-Log Plot
Expected Number of Photons 9
Timing study using cosmic-ray
ADC
Gate Generator
Gate
TDC
Coincidence
Start
Temperature Control Unit: −25℃
• A coincidence of two finger counters with PMT’s produces a trigger for
a punch-through event.
• MPPC, APD and all PMT’s are read out by CAMAC ADC and TDC.
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
10
Event selection
Cosmic-Ray event
Noise event
• Applying pedestal cuts of PMT’s ADC distribution to extract punchthrough muon events
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
11
Time-walk correction
threshold
The trigger timing of a leading discriminator
depends on its pulse height.
This time-walk effect is corrected with
a standard technique.
discriminator signal
time
ATHIC 2014
𝑇𝐷𝐶 =
Kazuya Tarunaga
𝑝0
𝐴𝐷𝐶
+ 𝑝1
𝑝0, 𝑝1: 𝑐𝑜𝑛𝑠𝑡
12
MPPC and APD timing resolution
𝑇𝑂𝐹𝑀𝑃𝑃𝐶
𝑇𝐷𝐶𝑃𝑀𝑇1 + 𝑇𝐷𝐶𝑃𝑀𝑇2
= 𝑇𝐷𝐶𝑀𝑃𝑃𝐶 −
2
𝑇𝑂𝐹𝐴𝑃𝐷
MPPC
𝑇𝐷𝐶𝑃𝑀𝑇1 + 𝑇𝐷𝐶𝑃𝑀𝑇2
= 𝑇𝐷𝐶𝐴𝑃𝐷 −
2
APD
𝜎𝑀𝑃𝑃𝐶 = 0.50 ± 0.02 ns
𝜎𝐴𝑃𝐷 = 13.4 ± 0.4 ns
• σMPPC = 0.5 ns for MPPC and σAPD = 13.4 ns for APD are found for the
same events.
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
13
Summary
• Basic study using the laser pulser
- MPPC is tested in the range from -25 to 25 degrees.
- The gain of MPPC is proportional to the bias voltage.
- The 90k-type has around 10 times wider dynamic range than that of
14.4k-type.
• Timing study using cosmic-ray
- σMPPC = 0.5 ns for MPPC and σAPD = 13.4 ns for APD for the energy
deposit of about 300 MeV equally distributed along the crystal length.
• The anti-neutron energy deposit is larger and concentrated in a small
space than this event, therefore a better timing resolution can be
expected.
• Simulation study is needed to evaluate the realistic PHOS performance
with MPPC.
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
14
Backup
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
15
MPPC Spectrum
2p.e.
1p.e.
0p.e.
Laser On
3p.e.
0p.e.
Laser Off
4p.e.
5p.e.
6p.e.
7p.e.
8p.e.
1p.e.
• Single photon detection and good separation of photon peaks when
the number of incident photon is small
• When the laser off, the 0p.e. peak exists and the 1p.e. peak
corresponds to dark count
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
16
Crosstalk and Afterpulse
In a MPPC pixel, secondary photons
different from the incident photon might
be generated in the avalanche process.
an incident photon
Crosstalk is a phenomenon that these
secondary photons leak out into adjacent
pixels and detected.
In a MPPC pixels, the generated carriers
are sometimes trapped by crystal defects
in the avalanche process.
Afterpulse is a phenomenon that the
pulse different from the true pulse is
generated by the carriers are released.
γ’
a secondary photon
an incident photon
trapped by
crystal defects
released at a certain
time delay
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
17
Before Event Selection
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
18
Before Event Selection
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
19
After Event Selection
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
20
After Event Selection
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
21
Result
PMT1+PMT2
PMT3
MPPC
APD
ATHIC 2014
Timing Resolution σ [ns]
0.0765 ± 0.002
0.109 ± 0.003
0.504 ± 0.016
13.4 ± 0.4
Kazuya Tarunaga
22
100+8+1ns
PMT1
100+8+1ns
100+4+1ns
100+8+1ns
PMT2
APD
26ns
MPPC
2ns
PMT3
Width:60ns
G.G.2
2ns
Cool Box
8ns
FAN
IN/OUT
D
I
S
8ns SHAPER 1ns 1ns C
R
8ns
I
8ns
8ns
ATHIC 2014
ATT
A
C
D
S
C
G.G.4-8
Width:20ns
Delay:1200ns
1ns
G.G.5
2ns
2ns
2ns
G.G.6
G.G.3 8ns
Width:7μs
G.G.4
2ns
1ns
1ns
G.G.7
2ns
2ns
2ns
2ns
2ns
2ns
G.G.8 2ns
1ns
8ns
1ns COIN1
COIN2
1ns
1ns G.G.1
1ns
Width:15ns
Threshold:25mV
Width:20ns
Kazuya Tarunaga
A
P
D
H
C
Width:7μs
53ns
53ns
58ns
4ns
53ns
4ns
T
D
C
2
T
D
C
1
Width:20ns
TDC1 Full Scale:118ns
TDC2 Full Scale:2μs
23
The circuit diagram of MPPC preamplifier
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
24
The circuit diagram of APD preamplifier
ALICE collaboration, ALICE high-momentum particle identification: Technical Design
Report, CERN-LHCC-98-019, http://cdsweb.cern.ch/record/381431
ATHIC 2014
Kazuya Tarunaga
25