Ila Tanna

World health organization – depression
• Depression is commonest psychiatric disorder
affecting about 154 million people
worldwide.
• More than 90 percent of people who commit
suicide have a diagnosable mental
disorder, commonly a depressive disorder
Despite advances in pharmacotherapy, a significant proportion
of depressed patients are considered treatment-resistant.
Poor compliance, side effects, or lack of desired effects are not
uncommon with antidepressant medications.
2
To provide a comprehensive overview of the evidence based
literature on Ayurvedic treatment of Depression with the
clinical data including
the studies on recent nutritional interventions and the
neurobiological mechanism to mediate its beneficial effect.
The PubMed, Medline, PsycInfo databases and other
authentic websites were searched for the literature and
published research articles related to Ayurvedic cure in
depression.
Author’s own research work evaluating the role of omega 3
fatty acids in etiopathogenesis and management of the
depression has also been included in the present article.
35 clinically diagnosed patient using DSM IV diagnostic criteria for minor &
major depressive illness were administered
Kushmanda Ghrita : 20 ml in two divided doses
Duration of treatment: 1 month
Symptoms
Scale
Mean ± SD
d
t
p
BT
AT
HRSD
9.86±1.56
2.80±1.41
7.06±1.71
24.36
<0.001
HARS
6.09±1.24
1.29±1.06
4.79±1.07
26.20
<0.001
IMSD
5.05±1.10
5.80±1.05
0.74±1.01
4.35
<0.001
IMSID
3.22±0.80
3.74±0.98
0.51±0.89
3.43
<0.01
Rajni Chandre et al., AYU, 32(2), 2011
6
An open labeled randomized clinical trial involved 90 depressive patients
(DSM IV diagnostic criteria for depression) were divided in three groups.
Group
Dose
Duration
Imipramine (n=30)
150 mg /day
3 months
Sertaline (n=30)
150 mg /day
Ayurvedic formulatuion: (n=30)
Aqueous extract of
Brahmi (Bacopa monnieri),
Shankhapushpi (Convolvulus pluricaulis),
Jyotishmati (Celastrus paniculatus),
Jatamansi (Nardostacys Jatamansi)
(equal amount)
1 gm in two divided
doses
Jyotsana Bhargva, Zafar Yab Khan, Jr of Clinical & Diagnostic Research, 2012, vol 6(2)
7
Effect on Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression &
Side effects observed during treatment
Groups (HRDS)
BT
AT
p
Imipramine
27.83±2.30
13.67±4.74*
P<0.01
Sertaline
25.87±1.18
14.23±3.51*
P<0.01
Ayurvedic formulation
25.33±1.22
14.60±2.11*
P<0.01
Side effect
Imipramine
Sertaline
Ayurvedic formulation
Dry mouth
18
2
0
Weight gain
3
0
0
Urinary retention
4
2
0
Sedation
20
0
1
Agitation
3
0
0
Tremors
5
0
2
Tachycardia
12
1
0
Abdominal dicomfort
9
3
1
Nausea
0
8
0
Saxual dysfunction
4
2
0
Jyotsana Bhargva, Zafar Yab Khan, Jr of Clinical & Diagnostic Research, 2012, vol 6(2)
8
Nerve tissue possesses one of the highest concentrations of fatty acids in
the body, with approximately 20% of the dry weight of the brain
comprised of long-chain fatty acids.
Essential for both the structure and function of nerve cells
Omega 3s – ALA – alpha linolenic acid
EPA – eicosapentaenoic acid
DHA – docosahexaenoic acid
PUFA
Omega 6s – Lenoleic acid
Gamma linoleic acid
Dihomo gama linoleic acid
Arachidonic acid
Survey – OBSERVATION
Depressed subjects
N=130
(Diagnostic criteria: DSM-IV for
Major depression)
Ila Tanna, H M Chandola et al., 2012
Non-depressed healthy
subjects
( IPGT & RA)
N=100
Overall results of consumption of dietary articles by
depressive patients and non-depressive healthy
volunteers
Parameter
Diet containing Omega 3
Fatty acid
Diet articles interfering
with conversion of ALA to
EPA & DHA
7/7/2014
Group
Mean±SEM
(MSC)
Depressed
125.02±2.34
Non-depressed
165.61±4.45
Depressed
58.05±1.74
Non-depressed
Ila Tanna, H M Chandola et al., 2012
t
P
S
8.59
<0.001
HS
3.71
<0.001
HS
48.54±1.84
12
Comparative effect of therapy over BDI
Group
< 50%
 50%
Total
A
27.00
8.00
35
B
B
12.00
33.00
45
12.00
33.00
45
C
12.00
8.00
20
A
27.00
8.00
35
C
12.00
8.00
X2
p
S
19.78
<0.001
HS
6.04
<0.05
S
2.03
>0.05
NS
20
Ila Tanna, H M Chandola et al., 2012
14
Depression
Imbalance of
neuro transmitters
Vacha
Chitraka
Daruharidra
Daruharidra
Ashwagandha,
Vacha,
Pippali, Maricha,
Daruharidra
Dopamine ↑
Nor epinephrine ↑
Serotonin ↑
Sleep problems ↓,
Irritability↓, anxiety↓
Memory↑, appetite↑,
loss of libido↓
Fatigue↓
depressed mood↓,
Concentration↑,
interest↑motivation↑
Pleasure↑,
motivation↑
Ila Tanna, H M Chandola et al., 2012
Vacha:
GABAnergic
activity
Antidepressant:
Shunthi &
Haridra
Omega-3s & Mood disorder
promote transmission of the chemical messengers
Positive emotions
(e.g., dopamine)
Emotional stability
(e.g., serotonin)
BDNF
Provides neuro protection,
Enhances neurotransmission, Anti depressant effect
bipolar disorder,
unipolar depression,
borderline personality disorder etc.
Flax seed oil
Omega 3 FA
ALA
Increases BDNF
α - Lenolenic acid
Rapidly diffuse
from plasma to
brain
Induces hippocampal
neurogenesis
Sub-chronic
treatment
with ALA
Improves synaptic plasticity
and synaptogenesis
Induces antidepressant like
behavior in animal models
Ila Tanna, H M Chandola et al., 2012
Which can also be related to additive
or synergic interactions with .serotonin,
norepinephrine or dopamine pathways
 Physical and mental relaxation causes
1.
decrease in level of brain cortisone and adrenaline
2.
synchronization of the brain wave (alpha waves)
3.
strengthening of mind and spirit which continuing even
after the relaxation.
 A study , “Psychoneuroimmunologic Effects of Ayurvedic Oil-Dripping
Treatment” shows that Shirodhara has
 anxiolytic and
 ASC (Altered State of Consciousness) - inducing effects, and
 promotes a decrease of noradrenaline and exhibits a sympatholytic
effect, resulting in the activation of peripheral foot skin circulation and
immuno-potentiation.
Kazuo et al., The Alternative & Complementary Medicine, 2008
There are reasonable evidences related to Ayurveda for its use as first line
treatment in mild and moderate cases of major depression and as a second line
monotherapy or augmentation to western pharmacotherapy in moderate to
severe depression.
Panchakarma procedures like Shirodhara, Nasya, etc. provide beneficial
effect.
Omega 3 fatty acid deficiency is one of the contributing factor to depression
and Atasi taila can be used as monotherapy or as an adjuvant to other
Ayurvedic drugs to correct the omega 3 deficiencies.
1.
Kornstein SG, Schneider RK. Clinical features of treatment-resistant depression. J Clin Psychiatry
2001;62:18-25.
2.
Ikemoto A, Nitta A, Furulwa S,Ohishi M, Nakamura A, Fujii Y, Okuyama H: Dietary omega 3 fatty acid
deficiency decreases nerve growth factor content in rat hippocampus. Neurosci Lett 2000; 285: 99-102
3.
Rajni Chandre et al., Clinical evaluation of Kushmanda Ghrita in the management of depressive illness;
AYU, vol. 32(2), 2011
4.
Jyotsana Bhargva, Zafar Yab Khan, Comparative evaluation of the efficacy and side effects of Imipramine,
Sertaline and an Ayurvedic formulation in patients of depression; Jr of Clinical & Diagnostic Research, vol
6(2), 2012.
5.
Sunilkumar M.Chabanur, Narayan Prakash, “A Clinical Study on Shireeshadi Yoga in the Management of
Kaphaja Unmada w.s.r.to Depressive Disorders”, MD thesis, Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences,
Karnataka, Bangalore, 2011
6.
Ila Tanna, H.M. Chandola, Rajesh Kukmar, Role of Omega 3 fatty acids in etiopathogenesis of depression
and evaluation of flax seed (Linum usitatissimum Linn.) oil as an adjuvant to Ashwagandhadyarishta in its
management, Ph.D. Thesis, Dept. of Rog Nidan & Vikriti Vigyan, IPGT & RA, GAU, Jamnagar, 2013.
7. Delion S, Chalon S, Guilloteau D, Besnard JC, Durand G (1996). Alpha lenolenic acid dietary
deficiency alters age related changes of dopamineric and serotonergic neurotransmission in the rat
frontal cortex. J Neurochem 66:1582-1591.
8. S, Chalon S, Guilloteau D, Besnard JC, Durand G (1994). Chronic dietary alpha lenolenic acid
deficiency alters dopamineric and serotonergic neurotransmission in the rats. J Nutr 124:246-2476.
9.
Dermar Jr., Ma,K., Chang, L, Bell. J.M., Rapoport, S.I., 2005. Alpha lenolenic acid does not
contribute appreciably to docosahexanoic acid within brain phospholipids of adult rats fed a diet
enriched in docosahexaenoic acid. J. Neurochem. 94, 1063-1076.
10. Kazuo Uebaba, Feng-Hao Xu, Hiroko Ogawa, Takashi Tatsuse, Bing-Hong Wang, Tatsuya Hisajima,
Sonia Venkatraman. The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine. December 2008,
14(10): 1189-1198. doi:10.1089/acm.2008.0273.
11. Ila Tanna, H.M.Chandola, Therapeutic Efficacy of Various Shirodhara on Stress induced insomnia;
Ayurveda Sameekshawa, Volume II, Part VII, Sri Lanka, 2011.
12. http://www.brightthub.com/health/alternative-medicine/articles/24593.aspx retrived on 1/9/2010