Nishuane Well Presentation

NISHUANE WELL REPORT
TO TOWNSHIP COUNCIL
April 29, 2014
Presented by: Montclair Water Bureau Director Gary Obszarny
WATER BUREAU
RESILIENCE
“Resilience is the ability of a community to withstand shocks
while still maintaining its essential functions, and to recover
quickly and effectively. Simply put, resilience is what enables
a municipality to survive, adapt, and thrive in the face of
sudden catastrophe or stresses.” *
Resilience for communities like Montclair means reducing
our vulnerability and increasing preparedness for coming
disruptions by linking planning, mitigation, and adaptation.
*Source: www.resilientamerica.org
WATER BUREAU
CONSUMPTION/CONVEYANCE
Average Day (2013):
Montclair Residents
5.314 MGD
Water conveyed for Glenridge Borough
0.870 MGD
Water conveyed for Passaic Valley Water Commission 0.038 MGD
Water provided to New Jersey American Water
WATER BUREAU
0.240 MGD
WATER SOURCES
Average Day (2013):
Municipal ground wells 1.228 MGD
Glenfield Well
.774 MGD
Lorraine Well
.027 MGD
Rand Well
.246 MGD
Purchased water:
Well water:
WATER BUREAU
77%
23%
What is “firm capacity”?
NJ DEP Division of Water Supply & Geoscience:
FI R M C APAC IT Y – Adequate pumping equipment and/or
treatment capacity (excluding coagulation, flocculation and
sedimentation) to meet peak daily demand, when the largest
pumping unit or treatment unit is out of service. The value is
represented in MGD (million gallons daily).
WATER BUREAU
Permitted Allocation
Total Firm Capacity:
Lorraine Well .288 MGD
Rand Well .576 MGD
Wanaque Reservoir (PEAK MONTH 120%) 5.64 MG
Glenfield Well .864 MGD
(Potential new source – Nishuane Well 1.18 MGD)
WATER BUREAU
High Tank 2.5MG
Low Tank 1.5MG
Lorraine Well .288MGD
WAPS
Rand Well .576MGD
Nishuane Well 1.18MGD
Glenfield Well .864MGD
GSPS 5.64MGD at 120%
What is an “adequate supply” of water?
Wanaque Reservoir Allocation:
Average Yearly Day =
4.70 MG
Current State requirement: Peak Month 120% = 5.64 MG
Previous State requirement: Peak Day 150% =
WATER BUREAU
7.05 MG
March 27, 2014: “Inadequate Water Supply”
State of New Jersey, Department of Environmental Protection,
Division of Water Supply & Geoscience:
The Montclair Water Bureau has a deficit in at least one of its daily,
monthly, or yearly limits.
“Please be advised that a purveyor with insufficient capacity who is
not actively pursuing additional supplies may be determined by the
Department under N.J.S.A. 58:1A-14 as being ‘inadequate to serve
its users’ and be subject to a Departmental Administrative Order
to ‘develop or acquire additional water supplies sufficient to
provide that service’.”
WATER BUREAU
Department of Environmental Protection
CHRIS CHRISTIE
Govemor
. KIM GUADAGNO
Lt. Govemor
Mail Code 401-04Q
Division of Water Supply & Geoscience
Water System Operations Element
Bureau of Water System Engineering
401 E. State Street- P.O. Box 420
Trenton, New Jersey 08625-0420
Tel #:'(609) 292-2957- Fax#: (609) 633-1495
http://www .nj .gov/dep/watersupply/
BOB MARTIN
Commissioner
March 7, 2014
Gary Obszarny
Montclair Water Bureau
54 Watchung Avenue
Montclair, NJ 07043
Re:
Montclair Water Bureau, PWSID NO. NJ0713001
Inadequate Water Supply
Dear Gary Obszarny:
The Bureau of Water System Engineering (Bureau) has recently updated the Division of Water Supply and
Geoscience's Public Water System DeficiUSurplus Table for your water system (available on the web at http://www.ni-qov/dep/watersupply/pws.htm). According to the DeficiUSurplus Table, the Montclair Water
Bureau has a deficit in at least one of its daily, monthly, or yearly limits (see attached table) as defined at
N.J.A.C. 7:1 0-11.5(e) et seq.
As a result of this determination, this Bureau will not accept any applications for Water Main Extension or
connection permits to the existing system which have an associated water demand. In addition, pursuant to
N.J.A.C. 7:10-11 .10(b)4, any connections or extensions to the water system with a water demand which do not
need a permit from this Bureau may not be undertaken. Until the water system deficit is corrected, no new
development projects with a water demand are allowed; only water main repairs and replacement may
proceed.
Please be advised that a purveyor with insufficient capacity who is not actively pursuing additional supplies
may be determined by the Department under N.J.S.A. 58:1A-14 as being "inadequate to serve its users" and
be subject to a Departmental Administrative Order to "develop or acquire additional water supplies sufficient to
provide that service". Therefore, it -is strongly recommended that you develop a plan and schedule to provide
an adequate supply. Although under certain conditions the Department may agree to allow specific projects to
be connected while a water system is implementing a program by which additional, guaranteed water will
become available, the Department strongly recommends that water systems take proactive steps to acquire
sufficient water supply to meet anticipated growth far in advance of a project's need for water supply.
Should you have any questions concerning this matter, please contact Xenia Feliz at (609) 292-2957 or by email at [email protected]. When contacting the Department, please reference the PWSID No.
NJ0713001 and Letter No. WCP140001 .
Sincerely,
s>~
Section Chief, Engineering South Section
Bureau of Water System Engineering
Enclosure
cc:
Northern Bureau of Water Compliance and Enforcement
Mayor and Council of Montclair Twp
NJEMS\sd_deficit_surplus_ no_capacity 01 091 4
PWSID #: 0713001
County: Essex
Name: Montclair Water Department
Firm Capacity:
Allocation Limits:
(Monthly}
(Yearly)
6.504
Last Updated: 12/05/13
Updated By: X.F.
MGD
94.000 MGM
856.000 MGY
Five Year Peak Demand:
(Daily)
7.212
MGD
Month/Year 07/2011
(Monthly) 223.579 MGM
Month/Year 07/2011
(Yearly) 2035.484 MGY
Year
2011
Bureau of Safe Drinking Water Comments:
Updated .up to Sept. 2013.
Contract Limits:
(Monthly} 268.840 MGM
(Yearly) 2571.500 MGY
Total Limits:
(Monthly) 362.840 MGM
(Yearly) 3427.500 MGY
Allocated Demand:
(Daily)
(Monthly)
(Yearly)
Deficit/Surplus:
(Monthly) 136.951 MGM
(Yearly) 1373.888 MGY
0.149
2.310
18.128
MGD
MGM
MGY
Total Peak Demand:
(Daily)
7.361
MGD
(Monthly) 225.889 MGM
(Yearly) 2053.612 MGY
Firm-Peak Total:
(Daily)
WAP Number: 5245
Bureau of Water Allocation Comments:
-0.857
MGD
MONTCLAIR’S OPTIONS
Nishuane Well with current design
Nishuane Well with $200,000 with building & site enhancements
Treatment at Oak Street, stripper building, gazebo design
Glenfield well location, no stripper building, gazebo design
Lease/purchase water
WATER BUREAU
NISHUANE WELL, CURRENT DESIGN
$2.1 million cost
1.12 MG additional water
.864 MG firm capacity
Well currently permitted
Construction permitted
WATER BUREAU
NISHUANE WELL with $200,000 building & site enhancements
$2.3 million cost
1.12 MG additional water
.864 MG firm capacity
Well currently permitted
Construction permitted with additional labor/materials
WATER BUREAU
TREATMENT AT OAK STREET stripper building, gazebo design
$3.35 million cost
1.12 MG additional water
.864 MG firm capacity
Well permit requires modifications – new construction permit
Additional Nishuane Park space required at 2 sites
Additional public hearings required
WATER BUREAU
GLENFIELD WELL LOCATION (no stripper building, gazebo design)
$4.1 million cost
1.12 MG additional water
.864 MG firm capacity
Well permit requires modifications – new construction permit
Additional Glenfield Park space required
Additional public hearings required
5,000’ raw water pipe
2,500’ finished water pipe
WATER BUREAU
GAZEBO DESIGN
20’ X 20’ conceptual design
WATER BUREAU
COST COMPARISON TO LEASE OPTION (per 100 gallons)
*Lease Option
Total cost per
year/1MGD
Lease Option
Nishuane as is
$2.1 mil
Nishuane $200K
$2.3 mil
Oak St/ building
$3.35 mil
Glenfield
$4.1 mil
Year 1: $479, 245
$0.131
$0.081
$0.085
$0.107
$0.122
Year 2: $484,037
$0.132
$0.081
$0.085
$0.107
$0.122
Year 10: $524,143
$0.143
$0.081
$0.085
$0.107
$0.122
Year 23: $596,523
$0.163
$0.037
$0.037
$0.037
$0.037
* At 1% increase/yr.
3% interest rate on construction costs over 20 years.
Included in price per 100 gallons, operations at $10,000/month running 12 months.
WATER BUREAU
NJDEP-Division of Water Supply & Geoscience
Page 1 of2
J)'QJf!:lji~~ -~~~!'! §~~{g;mJ ~Jgjt;i:di;~~~~
MONTCLAIR WATER DEPARTMENT
PWSID:
County:
0713001
Essex
Last Updated: 12/04/12
., Glossary of Terms Listed Below
Water Supply Firm Capacity: 8.202 MGD
Available Water Supply Limits
Monthly Limit
Yearly Limit
Allocation
94 .000 MGM
856.000 MGY
Contract
174.840 MGM
1715.500 MGY
Total
268.840 MGM
2571.500 MGY
Water Demand
Daily Demand
Monthly Demand
Yearly Demand
Current Peak
7.212 MGD ·
223.579 MGM
2035.484 MGY
Date
07/ 2011
07/2011
2011
Committed Peak
0.377 MGD
5.844 MGM
45.868 MGY
Total Peak
7.589 MGD
229 .423 MGM
2081.352 MGY
Water Supply Deficit or Surplus
Firm Capacity
0.613 MGD
Water Allocation Permit
39.417 MGM
490.148 MGY
Note: Negative v alues (a deficit) indicate a shortfall in firm capacity and/or div ersion privi leges or available
supplies through bulk purchase agreements.
Bureau of Water System and Well Permitting Comments:
Bulk purchases from NJDWSC.Include 150% and 120% overdraft provision fo r the maximum day and month
respectively. Updated up to Sept. 2012.
Bureau of Water Allocation Comments:
no comments provided
For more information concerning water supply deficit and surplus, please refer to:
"'Firm Capacity and Water Allocation Analysis (Pdf Format)
,. Currently Effective Water Allocation Permits by County
This report display s all effectiv e water allocation permits issued by the depa rtm ent.
,. Pending Water Allocation Permits with Requests for a Hearing
All pending water allocation permits with public hearing requests.
~Water Allocation Permits Made Effective within a Selected Timeframe
This report displays water alloction permits based on a specified date range.
Questions regarding safe demands and firm capacity please contact the Bureau of Water System
and Well Permitting at 609-984-6831 or for questions concerning water allocation and status
please contact the Bureau of Water Allocation at 609-292-2957.
Questions may also be sent to the Division of Water Supply
http://www.state.nj.us/cgi-bin/dep/watersupply/pwsdetail.pl?id=071300 1
2/26/2013
NJDEP-Division of Water Supply & Geoscience
Page 1 of 2
9"YJil;lli~~) Wi~~(eJ!j' §i§J~1!11 ~g~f~!:eJ:t){i~!W~Uu§)
MONTCLAIR WATER DEPARTMENT
PWSID:
County:
0713001
Essex
Last Updated: 04/05/13
ji<IGiossarv of Terms Listed Below
Water Supply Firm Capacity: 5.564 MGD
Available Water Supply Limits
Monthly Limit
Yearly Limit
Allocation
94.000 MGM
856.000 MGY
Contract
145.000 MGM
171 5.500 MGY
Total
239.000 MGM
2571.500 MGY
Water Demand
Daily Demand
Monthly Demand
Yearly Demand
Current Peak
7.212 MGD
223.579 MGM
2035.484 MGY
Date
07/2011
07/2011
2011
Committed Peak
0.377 MGD
5.844 MGM
45.868 MGY
Total Peak
7.589 MG D
229.423 MGM
2081.352 MGY
Water Supply Deficit or Surplus
Firm Capacity
-2 .025 MGD
Water Allocation Permit
9.577 MGM
490.148 MGY
Note: Negative va lues (a deficit) indicate a shortfall in firm capacity and/or diversion privileges or available
su pplies through bulk purchase agreements.
Bureau of Water System and Well Permitting Comments:
Updated up to Dec. 2012.
Bureau of Water Allocation Comments:
no comments provided
For more information concerning water supply deficit and surplus, please refer to:
)oo iFirm Capacity and Water Allocation Analysis (Pdf Format)
)l. leurrently Effective Water Allocation Permits by County
This report displays all effective water allocation permits issued by the department.
lo< IPendinq Water Allocation Permits with Requests for a Hearing
All pending water allocation permits with public hearing requests.
1'-IWater Allocation Permits Made Effective within a Selected Timeframe
This report displays water alloction permits based on a specified date range.
Questions regarding safe demands and firm capacity please contact the Bureau of Water System
and Well Permitting at 609-984-6831 or for questions concerning water allocation and status
please contact the Bureau of Water Allocation at 609-292-2957.
Questions may also be sent to the Division of Water Supply
http://www.state.nj.us/cgi-bin/dep/watersupply/pwsdetail.p1?id=0713001
4/ 11/2013
Page 1 of2
NJDEP-Division of Water Supply & Geoscience
")!!&;IIi~ ·~~~!? ;~'}5!?l1§Jn!l ~sffiff~!W~IlusJ
MONTCLAIR WATER DEPARTMENT
PWSID:
County:
0713001
Essex
Last Updated: 06/10/13
,.!Glossary of Terms Listed Below
Water Supply Firm Capacity: 6.504 MGD
Available Water Supply Limits
Monthly Limit
Yearly Limit
Allocation
94 .000 MGM
856.000 MGY
Contract
268.840 MGM
2571.500 MGY
Total
362 .840 MGM
3427.500 MGY
Water Demand
Daily Demand
Monthly Demand
Yearly Demand
Current Peak
7.212 MGD
223.579 MGM
2035.484 MGY
Date
07/2011
07/2011
2011
Committed Peak
0.377 MGD
5 .844 MGM
45.868 MGY
Total Peak
7.589 MGD
229.423 MGM
2081.352 MGY
Water Supply Deficit or Surplus
Firm Capacity
-1.085 MGD
Water Allocation Permit
133.417 MGM
1346.148 MGY
Note: Negative values (a deficit) indicate a shortfall in firm capacity and/or diversion privileges or available
supplies through bulk purchase agreements.
Bureau of Water System and Well Permitting Comments:
Updated up to Dec. 2012.
Bureau of Water Allocation Comments:
no comments provided
For more information concerning water supply deficit and surplus, please refer to:
lo<IFirm Capacity and Water Allocation Analysis (Pdf Format)
,. !Currently Effective Water Allocation Permits by County
This report displays all effective water allocation permits issued by the department.
~!< !Pending Water Allocation Permits with Requests for a Hearing
All pending water allocation permits with public hearing requests.
11-IWater Allocation Permits Made Effective within a Selected Timeframe
This report displays water alloction permits based on a specified date range .
Questions regarding safe demands and firm capacity please contact the Bureau of Water System
and Well Permitting at 609-984-6831 or for questions concerning water allocation and status
please contact the Bureau of Water Allocation at 609-292-2957.
Questions may also be sent to the Division of Water Supply
back to search results
Glossary of Terms
Allocation Limit: The maximum allowed by a valid Water Allocation Permit issued by the Bureau of Water
Allocation. This may be surface or ground water, and may be expressed in MGD, MGM, MGY or some
http://www.state.nj.us/cgi-bin/dep/watersupply/pwsdetail.p1?id=0713001
7/11/2013