A New Generic Method for Quantifying the Scale Predictability of

A New Generic Method
for Quantifying the Scale Predictability of Fractal Atmosphere
Xingqin Fang and Ying-Hwa Kuo
University Corporation for Atmospheric Research
and National Center for Atmospheric Research,
Boulder, CO 80307
Abstract
We revisit the issue the predictability of a flow which possesses many scales of
motion raised by Lorenz (1969), and apply the general systems theory of Selvam
(1990) to error diagnostics and predictability in the fractal atmosphere. We then
introduce a new generic method to quantify the scale predictability of the fractal
atmosphere following the assumptions of the intrinsic inverse power law and the
upscale cascade of error. In this method, the whole-scale eddies are extracted against
the instant zonal mean without the need of auxiliary information, and the ratio of
noise (domain-average square of error amplitudes) to signal (domain-average square
of total eddy amplitudes), referred to as noise-to-signal ratio (NSR), is used as a
measure of forecast skill. The time limit of useful predictability
for any
wavenumber
of the fractal atmosphere can be determined by the criterion
, where
is the Golden Ratio. By
definition, the NSR is flow-dependent. In addition, the time series of the logarithm
with base
of NSR,
, have consistent stable variations in different ranges
of forecasts, thus have strong stationarity, which is advantageous for model
verification. An important advantage of this new NSR method over the widely used
anomaly correlation coefficient (ACC) method is that it can detect the successive
scale predictability of different wavenumbers without the need to perform scaledecomposition explicitly.
As a demonstration, the NSR method is used to examine the scale predictability of
the National Center for Environmental Prediction (NCEP) Global Forecast System
(GFS) 500 hPa geopotential height. With the ability to reveal the predictive skills on
different scales as well as the model error growth between scales, the NSR method
can be used for model inter-comparison to provide useful insights on the relative
performance of different global models (e.g., NCEP GFS vs. ECMWF) on different
scales.
Key words: noise-to-signal ratio; scale predictability; fractal atmosphere; general
systems theory; model inter-comparison.