Karyn Butchard Lead Stroke Nurse Specialist West Herts NHS

Karyn Butchard
Lead Stroke Nurse Specialist
West Herts NHS Hospitals Trust




Case Studies
Not all as it seems………
Munchausen’s syndrome
Further work needed








Mr A. Flynn (68)
Lives in Kent – no family in UK
PMH – MI(X2), warfarin (INR 1.4)
Travelling on train from Rugby to Brighton
20.15 – sudden onset LSW, dysarthria
A&E at 22.55, CT NAD
Refused thrombolysis ( streptokinase 10 days
previous)
Self-discharged with inconsistent signs 4
days later









Mr. A. Hartley (68)
Lives alone in Solihull – brother in Felixstowe
PMH – HTN, IHD
Travelling on train from Felixstowe to Solihull
20.00 – sudden onset headache, LSW
Passengers called 999
CTH NAD – thrombolysed 22.30
Inconsistent signs
Self – discharged 22nd Feb – fully mobile








Mr. D. Phillips (65)
Lives in Dover – family in Australia
PMH – prev strokes, HTN
Stroke & thrombolysed 30/10 in Epsom
Self discharged
Train to Dover
Collapsed at St Albans
Brought to WGH







“Suicidal thoughts” following bereavement in
2010
Previous drug overdose
Rail network to travel UK – randomly
choosing destination
No fixed abode
Thrombolysed 18+ times
Referred to psychiatric team, accepted
admission to psychiatric ward
Self-discharged 12 hours later









Confirmed treatment throughout UK
Telemedicine
Taken part in research studies
Known to NHS fraud
Identity fraud confirmed Scotland - London
Transport police
Previous “confessions” & psychiatric input
Book outlining all travels and treatment
Attempt at suicide is dubious




Male in his 60’s
History – had a stroke
while on a train
Signs – may be
inconsistent/fluctuate
Appearance:
◦ tattoo “NZ”
◦ Missing teeth
◦ Chest burns from
cardioversion






PMH – MI, PE, HTN
Profession – hydraulic
engineer on ferries
No GP, NOK
uncontactable
Possessions: DVD
player, large suitcase
Refuses to allow
inspection of
possessions
Aggressive if
questioned and self
discharges

People with factitious disorder and Munchausen
syndrome
,
, or actually
. Their aim? To assume the status of
“patient,” and thereby to
,
,
and
or nonprofessionals
that they feel unable to obtain in any other
way. Unlike individuals who engage in malingaring,
people with factitious disorder and Munchausen
syndrome are not primarily seeking external gains
such as disability payments or narcotic drugs—
though they may receive them nonetheless. In some
cases, the fabrication or induction of illness is an
(Feldman)




No published cases
Not difficult to fake signs
High profile public campaigns
Speed of treatment decisions




No published report of Munchausen’s
syndrome and thrombolysis
Multiple thrombolysis safe in a “normal” brain
Abuse of NHS resources
No national alert system available to alert ED
and stroke teams

Pallis,C.A (1979) McIlroy was here. Or was he?
BMJ 1979, 1, 973-975