Elise Vallet Associate Vice President, Global Quality Risk

Presented By:
Elise Vallet
P4 –The Road to Better Risk Identification and Root Cause Analysis
EliseVallet
AssociateVicePresident,Global
QualityRiskManagement,
Sanofi
1
SANOFI KEY FIGURES
Present in
40countries
4 bn
Boxes
produced and
distributed per
year
A global healthcare company engaged in the research, development, manufacturing and marketing of healthcare solutions.
~85 bn
112
Galenic units
produced per
year
Industrial sites
45 000
Employees
in Industrial
Affairs
110 000
employees
2014 PDA/FDA Pharmaceutical Quality System (ICH Q10) Workshop
on Quality Risk Management
P4 –The Road to Better Risk Identification and Root Cause Analysis
Manufacturing an extremely diverse products portfolio …..
CONSUMER
HEALTHCARE
RARE
DISEASES
NUTRACEUTICALS
COSMETICS
GENERICS
MEDICAL
DEVICES
DIABETES
VACCINE
MEDICINAL
PRODUCTS
HUMAN
VACCINES
INNOVATIVE
PRODUCTS
ANIMAL
HEALTH
Quality Risk Management scope within Sanofi All entities, all product types
 112 manufacturing sites , 430 CMOs, 50 Distribution centres, 150 commercial affiliates and 26 R&D sites
 Cosmetics, Neutraceuticals, Generics, CHC,
Solid and Injectable drugs, Rare disease , Vaccines
Quality Risk Management is integrated in all Quality Systems
Dedicated organization Dedicated processes and tools
A philosophy based on full transparency
2014 PDA/FDA Pharmaceutical Quality System (ICH Q10) Workshop
on Quality Risk Management
Presented By:
Elise Vallet
P4 –The Road to Better Risk Identification and Root Cause Analysis
 Dedicated organization
 A fully integrated network of dedicated managers to lead QRM into the Quality systems within the Quality operations
 A network of ~300 trained champions on the field to develop and maintain sustainable risk awareness
 A strong interactive network to continuously improve the QRM system
~ 300 people
~ 25 people
Answer site needs
Train site personnel
Be the expert
Support & advice
Collect site needs
& experience
Be part of the network
Site RM
focal point
Share experiences
Site
Ops Units
Critical Risk
Management
tool
QRM
Customers /operations
needs
Training modules
QRM network
M ANPOWER
MEAN S
MEDIA
1
2
3
QRM systems & development e-room
Global QRM tools & approaches
3.1---- physical working conditions ( noise , temperature, li ghting, tidying …)
3.2---- relational working conditions (working atmosphere, urgence ,
2.1 ---- manufacturing, packaging and/or
hierarchic al relat io nship , coworkers relationship, counterorder….)
1. 5----mistake, omiss ion
analysis equipment and their
confusion, carelessness,
3.3---- manufac toring,packaging,sampling workshops, warehouse, la boratory
instruments of control : calibration,
negligenc e.
environement: temperature , humidity , light , Tidying…
qualification, mai ntenance
1.4---- numbers (adpated
2.2 ---- other assiociated control equipment
to the job)
NO N-C OMPLIANC E :
like: weighing machine, pH met er, …
1.3---- medical aptitude
A. Con fusi on
2.3 ---- utilities equipment for compressair,
1.2 ---- training, know-how,
steam, water , electricity : adequate
B. Wro ng or mi ssi ng pri nting
abilit y, certificat ion
capacity, calibration, qualif icat ion,
C. Wro ng quantiti es
1.1---- technical , GxP rules , saf et y,
maintenance …
D. Wro ng com ponent
knowledge
E . Deviation in the manufacturi ng
operation
F. Non-compl iance to the
specifications
of theMarketin g Auth orizati on :
5.8---- Ut ilities : wat er , steam ,
activi ty, aspect, purity, stability …
electricity, compress air ,…
G. Other deviation
5.7---- sample for control
5.6---- fi ni shed products aft er rele ase
6.8---- SOPsdescri bingprocessus
5.5---- finished productbefore release
6.7---- organization SOPs
5.4----S emi-finished product sbef ore the
6.6---- st orage instructions
sec ondary pack aging
6.5---- process, cleaning, analytical validations
4.3---- anal ytical t rend analysis
5.3----Bulks before the primarypac kaging 6.4---- analy tical instructions
4.2---- calculation
5.2---- On-going products at the preparation 6.3---- SOPs / inst ructions of use of equipment
4.1---- qualityof data .
5.1---- Rawmaterials, process water ,
6.2---- inst ructions of pack aging, manufacturing, cleaning
pack aging materials.
6.1---- instruc tions of reception, sampling
ME AS URES
MATERI ALS
METHODS
4
5
6
2014 PDA/FDA Pharmaceutical Quality System (ICH Q10) Workshop
on Quality Risk Management
Presented By:
Elise Vallet
P4 –The Road to Better Risk Identification and Root Cause Analysis
 Dedicated processes and tools
 Escalation of Quality events process at the heart of QRM to proactively identify potential Quality risks from the field
 A standardized process for the evaluation and communication of risks at the right level of management
 A system of alerts management for a multi‐disciplinary coordinated approach and timely risk treatment
 Risk Management Reporting of critical quality risks with mitigation plans for integration into decision‐making and priority setting . RQN
Risks
Alerts
Risk Management Report (RMR)
for each Operational Unit
Moderate
Low
Low or moderate
level of control
Quality LRP package
For each Operational Unit
Long Range
Plan
Senior Management of Operations
2014 PDA/FDA Pharmaceutical Quality System (ICH Q10) Workshop
on Quality Risk Management
Presented By:
Elise Vallet
P4 –The Road to Better Risk Identification and Root Cause Analysis
 One integrated IS platform
5 interconnected modules for managing Quality systems including QRM
Worldwide system deployed in all entities
● Quality Risk Management,
● Quality Third Party Management (subcontractors, suppliers, service providers), ● Audit Management , ● Events and associated CAPAs Management ,
● Change control management
 QRM framework  Consolidation of a Bottom‐up and Top down risk management process  Risks ultimately managed at the lowest level for ownership and mitigation
 Integration of risks management at the strategic and tactical level
Global Quality
Risk areas
Risk Profile
Interviews
Risk domains assessment
Global level
Trend analysis of Risk domains (Qualitative & Quantitative)
Operational Q‐RMR
Manufacturing sites, Supply Chain, R&D, IS, Commercial Operations
Operational
level
PHENIX QRM Module (database)
2014 PDA/FDA Pharmaceutical Quality System (ICH Q10) Workshop
on Quality Risk Management
Presented By:
Elise Vallet
P4 –The Road to Better Risk Identification and Root Cause Analysis
Our strategy :
“Drive the move towards a risk aware mindset in which risk management is an integrated part of the way we do business”
Thank you Elise Vallet
Associate Vice‐President
Global Manufacturing Quality Operations
Sanofi
[email protected]
2014 PDA/FDA Pharmaceutical Quality System (ICH Q10) Workshop
on Quality Risk Management
Presented By:
Elise Vallet