General considerations

SIGN Symposium - Sept. 2014
Taylor Spatial Frame:
Clinical Applications
John E. Herzenberg, MD, FRCSC
Director, ICLL
Sinai Hospital, Baltimore, Maryland
Clinical Prof. – Univ. Maryland
Disclosures:
Research and institutional support from:
Smith Nephew
Orthofix
Ellipse
Example: Deformity only. No LLD.
Options: Internal or external fixation
Internal Fixation
External Fixation
Example: Deformity plus LLD
Options: external fixation only!
Gavriel Ilizarov
Professor Ilizarov and Carlo Mauri smoking in the O.R.
Charlie Taylor
J. Charles Taylor: Spatial Frame
• Patent filed 1996
• Awarded 17/3/1998
• Expires17/3/ 2015
Phillipe Moniot, 1985 (13 years before JCT):
First patent on a hexapod Ilizarov device
TSF vs Ilizarov
• hardware is easier than Ilizarov
• computer based correction
• versatile for complex deformities
• learning curve is acceptable
Which is more accurate: Ilizarov or TSF?
• N= Ilizarov (79) TSF (129)
• Goal of correction achieved (all cases):
Ilizarov 56%
TSF 91%
Hexapod
“Stewart” Platform (1965)
2/3 Ring
Baltimore Center – 2014
TSF = most common fixator for limb
lengthening and deformity correction.
Exceptions:
- most straight lengthening we use
internal lengthening nails (femurs > age
8-10; tibias > age 14-16)
- very small children may need Ilizarov
frames
2 y.o. boy
Congenital Pseudarthrosis
of Tibia
(Hypertrophic type)
CPT
(HNU)
2 weeks Post-op
4 weeks Post-op
TSF: Advantages
• Preconstruction not required
• No need for special constructs for
rotation/translation/angulation
• Easily reprogrammed during treatment
• Able to mix ring sizes and orientations
• Able to do multilevel corrections
48 year-old woman s/p ORIF for tibia fx
(motorcycle)
• hypertrophic non-union
• valgus - procurvatum deformity
• broken hardware
Origin
Origin
CP
CP
Apply Reference
Ring to distal
segment.
centering bolts overlapped
AP frame offset
centering bolts overlapped
Lateral view frame offset
Add fixation…
Completed fixation
Post-op radiographs
Final
Pre-op
Final Step
16 y.o. with varus and
3 cm LLD from growth
arrest
Medial compartment
osteoarthritis
Early post-op
2/3 ring
2/3 ring
End of correction:
Mechanical axis
passes through
the Fujisawa
point
12 year old girl
with knee fusion
following severe
trauma:
double level oblique
plane
deformities
TSF strategy:
2 frames
3 rings
procurvatum
valgus
valgus
recurvatum
TSF strategy:
Distal reference for
femoral deformity.
Proximal reference for
tibial deformity.
Apexes = origins
Reference ring
During treatment
At frame removal
At follow-up
Three-level Deformity Correction
17 y.o. boy
Fibular Hemimelia
s/p lengthening
Has valgus,
hyperpronatted foot
and LLD
Intraoperative Images
Elevating
periosteum off
tibia + fibula
Kirschner wire to
prevent proximal
migration of gigli saw
Osteotomy of
fibula and tibia
Postop Radiographs
Initial postop
Distraction at
osteotomy site
Angular correction
at osteotomy
Final
Post-op
• 18 yo male, genu varum,
also wants height
2 weeks
post-op
PRE-OP
POST-OP
• 39 year old x-ray tech, s/p
HTO for knee pain --• BAD COMBO
• Varus tibia + valgus femur
2 weeks
post-op
6 weeks
4 months
post-op
post-op
Final
post-op
35 year old man
previous open tibia
fracture.
Now has stiff
nonunion
& ankle equinus
contracture
Strategy:
Two level deformity
Double level treatment
TSF for mal-non-union
TSF for ankle
equinus
contracture
Residual program to achieve 10° of dorsiflexion
initial
after running residual program
Consolidation
phase –
TSF struts
changed to
Ilizarov struts
(better x-ray
access and
more dynamic)
Equinus Contracture
16 y.o. girl Bilateral Radial Club Hand s/p centralization,
16 y.o. girl Radial Club Hand s/p centralization, relapse
PLAN: Ilizarov Wrist Reconstruction + Lengthening
GSW:
Oblique Plane
Malunion
Humerus
Distal Reference Ring
U-Osteotomy
14 y.o. girl with diastrophic dysplasia –
Equinovarus foot after many operations
Early regenerate bone
Post-op
Pre-op
17 y.o. spina bifida girl
with supinated forefoot
NOTE: “stacked” metatarsals
U-plate with tapped ends
Is the Ilizarov Fixator obsolete?
TSF = Fixator of choice for
most limb lengthening and
deformity correction.
EXCEPTIONS:
small children needing baby
Ilizarov frames
TSF: Disadvantages
•
•
•
•
Internet access required
Expensive ~10,000 $ per frame
If reused 10 times, then cost = 1,000 $ per frame
Learning curve
25th Annual Baltimore Limb Deformity Course
August 27-31, 2015
www.deformitycourse.com
TSF in the Developing World:
Is it realistic?
Francel ALEXIS, MD
Chief of Orthopedics
Haiti Adventist Hospital
No Disclosures
HUEH residents, Port au Prince, Teaching Seminar, Adventist, 2012
TSF: Deformity Correction
Is it useful in austere environments in the
Developing World?
Requirements:
• skilled surgeon
• internet access
• time and commitment
• cooperative patients
• TSF program at HAH
• Used regularly at HAH since 2010
n = 90
• Used rings/struts are donated from USA
surgeons; reused (recycled)
Some TSF cases done at Haiti
Adventist Hospital…
Distal Tibia Malunion in 14 y.o.
boy [neglected for 10 years]
Valgus + LLD
Neglected Blount’s in 27 y.o. man
• Bilateral Blount’s R>L
• Never treated
• He had to quit school
because of this deformity
• 45° deformity
Before
After
Second
side…
Bilateral Neglected
Clubfoot
• 14 y.o. girl
• Unable to wear normal shoes
• Difficulty walking
Miter Frame TSF
Genu Valgum Hypophosphatemic
Rickets
•
•
•
•
14 y.o. girl
Unable to stand and walk
Mostly crawling
Unable to go to school, have
friends and live a normal life
Severe Genu Valgum/Rickets
Left side, then right side..
left
right
No External Rotation, L. arm
(Brachial Plexus Palsy)
Unable to externally rotate the
left arm since birth.
Pre and final
Neglected Right Clubfoot in
Adult Woman
“Ponsetaylor” TSF
Neglected Right Clubfoot in Adult
Before
After
Unilateral
Blount
Disease
•
•
•
•
•
22 y.o. young man
Familial Hypophosphatemic rickets
Severe genu valgum
Unable to stand
Has to crawl
Immediate Post-Op
After Correction
During treatment, after
removal…
Happy patient!
TSF in the Developing World…
It can be done!
25th Annual Baltimore Limb Deformity Course
August 27-31, 2015
www.deformitycourse.com