Description of the Treatment Processes Studied - Esaa

20
Description of the Treatment Processes Studied for the
Treatment of Contaminated Soil from the Oil Freight Train
Derailment at Lac-Mégantic, QC
André Carange, Guillaume Bédard and François Dubé, LVM, a division of EnGlobe Corp.
The Lac-Mégantic derailment occurred when an unattended 74
car freight train carrying Bakken formation crude oil ran away and
derailed resulting in the fire and explosion of multiple tank cars.
Six million litres of light crude spilled over, under and through
Lac-Mégantic. A total of 31 ha were affected by the crude spill
leading to an estimation of 558,000 metric tons of impacted soil
in need of remediation. In the aftermath of the train derailment,
contaminated soils from the disaster areas were excavated and
transported to a temporary soil treatment facility pending the
selection of the treatment methodology and permitting process.
Various remediation methods exist for the treatment of impacted
hydrocarbons such as thermal, biological, and physico-chemical
methods. However, during the tendering process, LVM mainly
focused on two types of method: biological treatment and thermal
desorption methods for the treatment of the 560,000 metric tons
of soil impacted by the crude oil spill that occur at the city center
of Lac-Mégantic, QC. Both methodologies offer pros and cons on
different aspects:
The thermal desorption method offers faster results, it also requires
a smaller footprint than the biological treatment,
and generally, the contaminants end points are lower, allowing
for soil to be reused at Lac-Mégantic city center, therefore not
requiring clean backfill imports. It should be noted that this
process is thus more expensive because it also requires a large
amount of fuel as well as sophisticated air treatment equipment
in order to comply with Quebec Air Emission Regulations.
Furthermore, following the Lac-Mégantic disaster this process,
even though it is very effective, was considered less sociably
acceptable by the population of Lac-Mégantic.
As for the biological treatment process, it is well known and very
popular because it can easily be used to treat very large volumes of
hydrocarbons impacted soil at a smaller cost. This type of process
requires a longer treatment time frame and is very limited in terms
of contaminants concentrations and higher after-treatment end
points, therefore requiring host sites the disposal of treated soils.
Fortunately, several large industrial sites are located within the
area of Lac-Mégantic and they will eventually need soil for their
reclamations. Finally, biological process is a sustainable remedial
approach that requires less energy and offers small emission of
greenhouse gases.
66
Through the tender process, the biological case study was very
complex because it was unknown if the biotreatment of impacted
soil by Bakken crude oil of which the lighter fractions were burned
was achievable to the very low endpoints selected for the site.
After reviewing all the site characterization documents, it was
established that biological treatment was feasible, but that it may
require a number of host sites for the reuse of treated soil, such as
industrial sites that may need soil for their reclamation therefore
the need to import clean backfill for the site of
origin, Lac-Mégantic city centre. Considering all this, LVM decided
to opt for a biological process -by biopiles - for the treatment of
the major part of the impacted soil (530,000 metric tons) and for
the thermal desorption for the most recalcitrant impacted soil
(30,000 metric tons) at an offsite facility in Quebec.
This project involves the construction of six bioventing megaplatforms which will allow the treatment of 250,000 metric tons per
year. The Mega-Biopiles will be equipped with large blowers that
will be connected to a piping system, allowing essential aerobic
conditions within the soil in-treatment to the indigenous biomass
growth, and therefore the biodegradation of hydrocarbons.
To date this remedial project remains one of the greatest
challenges of the past decades in regards to sustainable
development and social acceptability.
Guillaume Bédard
Guillaume Bedard has been inspired by the environmental industry
for over 20 years. From Alaska to Brazil and Alberta to Europe, he
was privileged to support international clients with their many
environmental challenges. He has collaborated to the expansion
of Biogenie and Quantum Murray in the past and was involved
on projects from decommissioning to brownfield redevelopment.
Guillaume is now Vice President of Business Development for LVM
Engineering.
Remediation Technologies Symposium 2014