Cochlear implants and the NHI - South African Cochlear Implant Group

Cochlear implants
and the NHI:
Dani Schlesinger
Chris Hani Baragwanath Academic Hospital
Cochlear Implant Programme
READY OR NOT….
NHI IS COMING
The background

National Rehab Task Team Meeting 2013
 Query - Will CIs will be covered by NHI?
 Response – They have not been given consideration

Taken to National ST&A Forum
 Suggestion - Prepare a motivation to submit to
National Rehab Directorate
 Goal - Get CIs incorporated into rehab plan,
allowing them to be considered in NHI planning and
costing
 Request for SACIG to look at this
What will NHI mean?
What will NHI mean?
The NHI promises to…
 ‘ensure
that everyone has access to
appropriate, efficient and quality health
services…This will entail major changes
in the service delivery structures,
administrative and management
systems’
(Government Gazette, 2011)
Implementation of NHI will require
Transformation of the healthcare financing
model
 Better regulation of healthcare pricing
 Improvement in quality of healthcare
 Strengthening of the planning, information
management, service provision
 Overhauling of management systems

(Government Gazette, 2011)
Public vs Private sector

8.3% of GDP spent on health
Private sector
Public sector
4.1% of GDP
4.2% of GDP
8.2 million people
42 million people
Fragmented, underresourced
Unsustainable for schemes
Impoverishing healthcare costs

NHI intends to ensure that everyone has access to a
defined comprehensive package of healthcare services
via accredited and contracted public and private
providers
(National Treasury: Intergovernmental Fiscal Review, 2011)
Objectives of NHI




Provide improved access to quality
health services for all South Africans
To pool risks and funds for equity and
social solidarity
To procure services on behalf of the
entire population and efficiently mobilize and
control key financial resources
To strengthen the under-resourced and
strained public sector so as to improve
health systems performance
Why this matters to SACIG

Impact on all sectors
◦ Public CI programmes may be funded by NHI
◦ Private CI programmes may
 See a reduction in medical aid patients
 Select to be contracted to provide services to NHI

The possibility of future universal screening
◦ Increased numbers referred for diagnosis, CI
assessment and intervention


Need to give input into standards for protocols,
minimum standards and financial requirements
Costing
◦ Realigning budgets
◦ Costs of services and costs to patient
Principles of NHI
Principles of NHI
Application to CI
The right to access
• CI as standard of care
• Hearing as a human right
Social solidarity
• Cross-subsidisation
Effectiveness
• CI as an evidence-based intervention
• Positive health outcomes
Appropriateness
• Adoption of new and
innovative health service
delivery models
• Responsive to local needs
• Who should be a candidate in NHI?
• Local access?
• Distance support / telehealth
Equity
• Those with greatest need; timely access
Affordability
• Commodity vs public good
• Cost effectiveness
• Repairs, upgrades, consumables, school
Efficiency
• Clear criteria, protocols & team function
• Referral systems
• Tender process; value for money
Quadruple Burden of Disease
1.
HIV/AIDS and TB
 SA - 0.7% of world population but 17% of HIV-infected
 23 times the global average prevalence
 TB infection rate is among the highest in the world
 TB and HIV/AIDS co-infection rate is 73%
2.
Maternal, infant and child mortality
3.
Non-communicable diseases
4.
Injury and violence
(Lancet Report, Coovadia et al, 2009)
Relevance:
 Rationale – Right to access hearing for those affected
 Logistical - Dramatic increase in candidates
 Strategic – Align services with HIV/ TB packages of care
Dimensions to consider
The 3 Dimensions of Universal Coverage
◦
Considerations for Cis
Population Coverage
What numbers would
Refers to the proportion of the population that we hypothesise?
has access to needed health services
Service Coverage
It refers to the extent to which a range of
services necessary to address health needs of
the entire population are covered
What is the package of
services required?
SACIG guidelines?
Financial Risk Protection
It refers to the extent to which the population
is protected from catastrophic health
expenditure
Catastrohpic costs
Impact of HL & CIs
FM systems
Consumables
Schooling
(WHO, 2010)
Benefit packages
Must be ‘fair and rational’
 Defines services considered as achievable for SA
commensurate with its resources
 Different levels of care within public sector
 Propose how to reduce barriers to access
 Demonstrate health system performance
 Norms and standards of care
 Cost-efficiency according to international benchmarking
from countries of similar economic development that
have successfully implemented such processes
Comprehensive evidence-based packages of care for
each level of service delivery

Accreditation

Office of Health Standards Compliance
◦ Inspection
◦ Norms and standards
◦ Office of the ombudsperson



All health establishments (public and private)
to meet standards of quality
Adherence to referral procedures
Accreditation standards specify minimum
range of services to be provided at different
levels of care
Reimbursement
Initial phase - global budgets
 Gradual migration towards diagnosis
related groups (DRGs) with a strong
emphasis on performance management
 Preparation for contracting with private
providers
 Medical schemes will coexist

◦ No more tax subsidies
Information required going forward
◦ Incidence of severeprofound SNHL
◦ Impact of hearing loss
◦ Candidacy criteria
and protocols
◦ Norms and
standards for CI
programmes
◦ Minimum range of
services
◦ Referral pathways
◦ Cost:benefit for pts
◦ Population size –
Entire EHDI pathway
◦ Human resources
◦ Additional elements
– early intervention, FM
systems (educ. support?)
◦ Costing - to NHI;
procurement of devices
◦ Relation to HIV and
TB burden of disease
End product?

Proposal to combine CI document with
HPCSA task team outputs:
◦ EHDI
◦ School-based hearing screening
◦ Ototoxicity
Integrated package of care for
individuals with hearing loss within NHI