MADPET High Resolution, MR-compatible PET Nuclear Medicine

29.01.2014
Nuclear Medicine Imaging
MADPET
High Resolution, MR-compatible PET
Cooperation between Physics and Nuclear Medicine
Goal: 3D Distribution of radiotracer in vivo
Based on detection of gamma rays (140 keV, 511 keV)
-High resolution (mm)
Sibylle I. Ziegler
-High sensitivity (dose, acquisition time)
Department of Nuclear Medicine, Technische Universität München
-Minimizing measurement of scattered radiation
PET Block Detector
Why Solid State Detectors in Nuclear Medicine?
BGO, LSO, LYSO Block Detector:
• Coincidence window: 4 - 12 ns
• Energy resolution: ~ 12 - 25%
Solid state light sensors
Solid state detectors for direct detection
Crystal identification
• Compact
B
X=
• High granularity
(B+D) - (A+C)
(A+B+C+D)
• Scalable modules: dedicated tomographs
y
A
C
D
(A+B) - (C+D)
y=
• Insensitive to magnetic fields: multimodal imaging
(A+B+C+D)
X
29.01.2014
3
1
29.01.2014
Nuklearmedizinische Klinik und Poliklinik
Avalanche Photodiodes (APDs) vs. PMTs
PRO:
• very compact
• high quantum efficiency
• low bias voltage
• insensitive to magnetic fields
MADPET Prototype
6 Modules
4 mm
avalanche photodiode array
(Hamamatsu)
LSO crystals
(3.7 x 3.7 x 12 mm3)
CON:
• noise
• low gain
• low timing resolution
- Energy resolution: 15%
- Spatial resolution: 2.3 mm
- sensitivity: 13 cps / µCi
Eur J Nucl Med 2001
MPI
Clinical PET/MR
Advanced Lab Course in Physics
MADPET-1 “Revival”
• 3x 32 channel Sampling-ADC for data
acquisition, Based on electronics for COMPASS
(E18, A. Mann and I. Konorov)
• Readout via USB and Linux-Computer
• Data analysis with ROOT (CERN)
Siemens mMR
Seite 7/16
2
29.01.2014
Nuklearmedizinische Klinik und Poliklinik
Sensitivity/Resolution Parallax Error
Biograph mMR
high sensitivity
X bad spatial
resolution
• PET:
• 448 detector blocks with
X low sensitivity
good spatial
resolution
• 8 x 8 LSO crystals and
• 3 x 3 APDs each
• Axial FOV: 25.8 cm
Courtesy of Siemens
• Spat. resolution: 4.3 mm
trade-off between sensitivity and spatial resolution
DOI?
Depth-of-Interaction (DOI) Measurement
Examples of detector schemes
MADPET-II
Individual readout of
Two LSO layers
1.6 mm x 1.6 mm
light sensor
crystal
crystal
LSO
GSO
light sensor
ratio of signals
DOI
light sensor
crystal
monolithic APD array
light sensor
signal shape
DOI
individual layers
DOI
16 channel
preamplifier
2 cm
70 mm Diameter
3
29.01.2014
Nuklearmedizinische Klinik und Poliklinik
MADPET-II Prototype with 384 Channels
Transaxial reconstruction of 10 line sources
Silicon Photomultipliers (SiPMs)
• Array of Geiger-mode APDs
cell
With DOI
Without DOI
Pros
• Insensitivity to magnetic fields
• High gain (> 105)
• Fast (~ 1 ns rise time) TOF
Cons
• Limited dynamic range
• Optical crosstalk
• Temperature dependence
Mean FWHM in central slice: (1.25±0.08) mm
MADPET3
Example: Hamamatsu MPPC
LYSO-SiPM Module
LYSO crystals (four 1 x 1 x 20 mm3 crystals,
St. Gobain), polished surface, wrapped in reflector foil
PET Prototype based on SiPMs (Hamamatsu MPPCs)
• Proof of principle and first experience with SiPMs
• LYSO (Lutetium Yttrium Oxyorthosilicate) scintillators
Interface Card
• 6.63 g/cm³, Zeff=7.2, energy res. 10% @ 662 keV, 32000 ph/MeV, 40 ns decay time, 420 nm peak
•
•
•
•
Individual readout of 1 x 1 x 20 mm³ crystals
64 ch, no preamps at frontend
Phantoms are rotated
SADC data acquisition
• Features
• Typical energy resolution
• 20% FWHM
• Coincidence time resolution
• 4.8 ns FWHM
• Iterative MLEM image reconstruction
4 x 1 SiPM (mppc) matrix from Hamamatsu
Pulko et al. TUM 2010
4
29.01.2014
Name der Klinik
Data Acquisition
E18 SADC with USB readout
• 32 channels per SADC
• Independently digitized
• 10 bit ADC
• 80 MHz sampling rate
MADPET3 Prototype
MLEM reconstruction
System matrix including
detector response function
Measurement: 2 line sources, 0.73 mm separation
• USB 2.0 readout with Linux
• Pulse maxima and timestamps
• Processed with C++ and ROOT
SiPM based PET
SiPM for high resolution PET
KETEK PM1150NT
• Readout electronics less demanding
• High granularity one-to-one coupling
achievable
• Heavily parallel readout needed
KETEK GmbH München
www.ketek.net
• PM1150NT
• 1.2 x 1.2 mm²
50 µm cells
70% FF
no optical trenches
• Characteristics important for PET
• Peak sensitivities @ 420 nm with a PDE up to 60%
• Operating range 28 – 34 V
• SMD package 2.0 x 2.5 mm²
• Temperature coefficient of breakdown is 18 mV/K
• Gain M is very temperature stable dM/dT < 1%
• Gain M = 8 · 106 at 20% Uover
5
29.01.2014
Photodetection Efficiency PDE
Gain Variation with Temperature
PM1150NT: PDE > 60% @ 420 nm
PM3350: < 1% @ U over ,rel > 10% PM1150: < 1% @ U over ,rel > 6%
• High PDE is the key for good timing and energy resolution
• less need for temperature and bias control
GAGG
BGO
LYSO
• 60% PDE for blue light, 45% PDE for green light
• Suitable for LYSO, GAGG and BGO
• Both SiPM types
• Key feature all KETEK SiPMs have in common
Temperature Coefficient
22% OV
0,00
12% OV
-0,50
dM/dT*1/M [%]
-1,00
-1,50
-2,00
PM3350
-2,50
PM1150
-3,00
-3,50
-4,00
0,00
PDE measured by Y. Mousienko, CERN
Coincidence Timing
2x PM3350 (3x3 mm², 50µm cell size) + 2x identical crystals
5,00
10,00
15,00
20,00
25,00
30,00
Relative Overvoltage [%]
MADPET4 preclinical PET/MR development
PET insert for a 7T small animal MRI
7T animal MR
• Crystals wrapped in Teflon and coupled with silicone
• Only events in the photopeak are taken into account
• Coincidence Time Resolution
• 210 ps for 2x2x6 mm³ LYSO
• 446 ps for 2x2x6 mm³ GAGG
• Requirements PET frontend
• High spatial resolution < 1.5 mm
• DOI (depth of interaction): dual ring concept
• Individual crystal readout for high rate capability
• Inner diameter ~10 cm, outer ~15 cm
6
29.01.2014
MADPET4
• Crystal length determines sensitivity
• Sensitivity is essential for PET
• Design study:
• Inner layer
1.5 x 1.5 x 6 mm³ LYSO
• Outer layer
1.5 x 1.5 x 14 mm³ LYSO
MADPET4 Monte Carlo Simulations
GATE simulation of Derenzo-like phantom using the 6-14 geometry
• Phantom fills 87% of the FOV
• 6 minutes simulation of 511 keV back-to-back emission in x-y plane
• All rods clearly visible
• Crystals are rotated and not blockwise
• Results in better and more
homogenous sensitivity in the FOV
• 330 crystals per ring, 8 rings in axial direction resulting in 2640 channels
MADPET Activity
•
Very fruitful cooperation: physics and nuclear medicine
•
Driven by technology
•
Group at the clinic is the link to application
Acknowledgments
Florian Schneider
Ian Somlai
Gizem Seker
Jorge Cabello
Stephan Paul
Igor Konorov
Dieter Renker
ERC Mumi
FP7 EndoTOFPETUS
FP7 TRImage
University of Tokyo
7