Collaborative Relationship Management

Collaborative Relationship Management in
Outsourced Business Relations
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
European Outsourcing Association
Prepared for: EOA Spain
Version: v 2.0
Date: 21 February 2014
1
Dominique Kindt
Chris Bell
1.
2.
3.
4.
About With
Relationship Management Literature
Business context & Market challenges
How we deliver
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
Content
2
About With
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
1
3
• We are strong believers in the service economy, and the
increasing reliance on each other to succeed. While
outsourcing will continually increase, we think that good
relationships are key rather than trying to find a better party
over and over again. We want to be a niche company and help
clients with relationship management
• In 2013, our methodology, approach and technology platform
have been recognized by IWT as an innovative service offering
and awarded a grant. As such, we are very proud to carry the
IWT label of “Innovative Company”.
http://www.iwt.be
IWT (Agentschap voor Innovatie door Wetenschap en Technologie) is
the government agency for Innovation by Science and Technology.
IWT supports companies and research centres in realizing their
research and development (R&D) projects. They offer not only access
to Flemish support but also funding programmes of the European
Commission. Moreover, they stimulate every type of collaboration
through Flemish and European innovation networks.
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
About us
4
Why we created
Independent
(Out)sourcing
Consultants
End-user
(client)
companies
maturity
increase
Advisory
Niche
companies
(TPI,
EquaTerra,
Alsbridge,
Everest,
PA, …)
Big 4
Companies
enter market
(standardised)
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
1. (Out)sourcing Advisory Services market is changing
5
2. The main issues and challenges with (out)sourcing are
not in the initial phases of a “deal”
Strategy &
Selection
(5 to 7 months)
Honeymoon
A good contract is not a guarantee for a good service
delivery and relationship. Even without a contract, service
delivery can be up to standards and satisfaction of all
parties involved.
Service delivery relationship
(4 to 6 years)
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
Why we created
6
Procurement & Sales
Management
1. Focus on transaction
and categories
2. Unit price and cost
saving driven
3. Continuous competitive
atmosphere through
RfPs, benchmarking
and negotiations
4. Short-term individual
gain oriented
Collaborative Relationship
Management
Evolve
1. Focus on trust and
value for money
2. Added value and
optimisation driven
3. Growing collaborative
atmosphere through
structured feedback,
open communication
and performance mgt
4. Long-term mutual
benefit oriented
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
Why we created
7
Relationship
Management
Outsourcing
Advisory
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
Why we created
8
Relationship Management
Literature
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
2
9
• Collaborative Relationship Management is “tangible” and
can be based on KPIs (not only a “soft” domain )
• 4 recognized standards related to Collaborative
Relationship Management
• The 18 C’s model for a successful long-term outsourcing
arrangement (University of Portsmouth)
• Building Relationships that Create Value: Collaboration and
partnerships in the supply chain (Cranfield School of Management)
• Vested Outsourcing - A Better Way to Structure Outsourcing
Contracts (University of Tennessee)
• Collaborative business relationships (BS 11000)
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
Relationship Management
10
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
18 C Model
11
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
Building Relationships that Create Value
12
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
A Better Way to Structure Outsourcing Contracts
13
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
Collaborative business relationships
14
Added Value
Why engage in Collaborative Relationship Management?
Source: Research by the CIO Executive Board
“Reducing defections in the relationship with
5% boosts profits 25% to 85%”
Source: TPI
“There is a potential of 35% to 55% value
leakage in total if the relationships are not
properly managed”
(10% to 20% in duplicate efforts or wasted
resources; 20% to 30% from problems not
managed and performance not at expected
levels; 5% to 10% in wrong vendor deployment
and untapped opportunities)”
Source: EquaTerra
Source: Jill Griffin – Customer Loyalty
“36% of respondents said
the biggest team resolution
for 2012 is improving crossfunctional collaboration.
Nearly 28% of respondents
said enhancing stakeholder
relationships and alignment
was the top initiative for
2012”
Source: Iasta Insights poll
“63% of companies
believed they were
losing an average of
25% of contract value
due to poor governance
or relationship
management”
Source: IAOP
Market Conclusion:
Post-award
relationship
management remains
vital to prevent value
leakage
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
“54% of organizations report challenges with managing IT vendors effectively”
“61% of outsourcing buyers
admitted to placing more
emphasis on setting up their
outsourcing contract than on
managing it, making it a major
factor for dissatisfaction”
15
Business context &
Market challenges
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
3
16
Context & Business Problem
Active Business Relationship
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
Negotiation and Selection Phase
• 4 to 6 month negotiation throughput-time
• Active role for procurement, active role for vendor
management (if present)
• Support of external “deal maker” expert consultants
to shape the contractual environment
• 4 to 6 year service delivery period
• Passive role for procurement, active role for vendor
management (if present)
• Focus on service delivery where initial expert
consultants are no longer involved
17
• The current market offers a toolset that is “not-fit-for-purpose”
to identify, chart and actively manage your business
relationships
• A sample of the current available market toolset with their
specific “oversight” focus:
Benchmarking
projects with
financial peercomparison focus
Surveys to
measure client or
end-user
satisfaction
CRM platforms to
store and analyse
customer data
Contract
Management
repositories for
legal & compliance
depts.
SLA and KPI tools
for operational
tracking &
measurement
Process modelling
software to
structure
governance
Audits to highlight
process
deficiencies or to
assess maturity
Project
management &
financial
dashboards
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
Market Challenges
18
Market Challenges
Relationships
Services
Products
& People
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
Evolution of Service Provider offerings & Client needs
19
• Collaborative Relationship
Management will serve as
an “influencer” to more
effectively engage with the
existing market toolset. It
requires:
• Understanding of the
strategic intent of the
organisation
• In-house coordination
• Coordination with the
activities of the involved
external organisations (i.e.
mainly service providers)
Benchmarking
Satisfaction
Surveys
Dashboards
Collaborative
Relationship
Management as
influencer for:
Audit
Process
Modelling
CRM
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
Collaborative Relationship
Management as Influencer
Contract
Repository
KPI
Measurement
20
How we deliver
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
4
21
• We are a specialized “technology enabled advisory” company
and help our clients with managing their internal and external
business relationships: from the creation of a business
relationship all the way up to the maintenance of existing
relationship portfolios.
Business Relationship Services
Relationship Creation
A collaborative approach for:
• Providing strategy advisory
• Assisting in relationship selection
procedure
• Due diligence & Negotiation support
• Developing the Contract
• Delivering Transition support
Relationship Maintenance
•
•
•
Create deep insights in your
relationship drivers & detect
possible misalignments
Ensure simplicity & consistency in
relationship management
Provide a collective memory over
different business relationships
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
Business Relationship Services
22
1. Methodology for Collaborative Relationship
Management based on University Research and Market
Standards. Our methodology key aspects:
• Intuitive data capturing and data reporting method
• Focus on the key topics that matter in business (outsourcing, offshoring, shared services) relationships
• SaaS software platform to support our complete Service Delivery
lifecycle
2. A practical Service Delivery Approach to engage with the
Client and Service provider in 4 phases:
•
•
•
•
Intake: engage with both parties
Collect: data collection through polling
Improve: reporting and workshops
Embed: guide towards successful improvement completion
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
How we deliver
23
with offers a structured service approach to help engage in
Collaborative Relationship Management supported by intuitive data
capturing tooling and executed through experienced professionals
Structured
Approach
Standardised and
repeatable Relationship
Management approach
based on University
Research and Market
Standards:
• Data Reporting:
Relationship Archetypes©
• Data Capturing: Relationship
Indicators©
• Action based Relationship
Management Improvement
Plan with embedding
support & SaaS platform
Intuitive
Tooling
Experienced
Professionals
Bi-lateral and intuitive online poll platform assessing
objective and subjective
aspects of the relationship
Seasoned advisors with full
(out)sourcing lifecycle
experiences
We capture a view on your
relationship portfolio from
different angles: Risk,
Governance, Delivery,
Culture, Compliance,
Pricing and Contract.
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
1. Our Methodology
Engaged in international
(out)sourcing deals
Thought Leaders in the
market
24
1. Our Methodology
c) Service & Client Provider
“Twin” Relationship Indicators ©
• The 18 C’s model for a successful long-term
outsourcing arrangement (University of Portsmouth)
• Building Relationships that Create Value:
Collaboration and partnerships in the supply chain
(Cranfield School of Management)
• Vested Outsourcing - A Better Way to Structure
Outsourcing Contracts (University of Tennessee)
• Collaborative business relationships (BS 11000)
b) Reporting on
Relationship Archetypes ©
d) SaaS software platform
with back-end / front-end
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
a) University Research &
Market Standards
25
• Identify business relationships
• Tailor our service approach
• Identify groups and poll
participants
• Select Relationship
Indicators© & Templates
• Activate on-line polling and
evaluation platform
• Collect “positions” per
poll participant
• Perform interviews and
report on progress
• Create activities and
allocate owners &
stakeholders
• Owner manages activities
on-line (progress / comments)
• Structural follow-up of
activity plan with sponsors
• Create Relationship
Management
Improvement Plan
• Relationship
Archetype© mapping
• Deliver report and perform
interactive workshops
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
2. Our Services Delivery
Approach
26
What’s in it for you
• Long-term partnership loyalty is beneficial to both the client & the
provider (i.e. long-term investments in relationship management have
a rewarding payback to both as a renewal with same provider is more
cost efficient than re-letting in the market)
• Attention for relationship management not only on strategic level but
equally on tactical and operational level results in prioritizing on-thefield actionable improvement actions that connect with the teams
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.
• Aligned teams will perform better and more efficient due to a limitation
in needless escalations and miscommunications
• Continuous improvement or Innovation proposals can be specifically
designed to resolve a certain misalignment in the business relationship
27
www.with-services.com
Copyright © WITH BVBA 2014 All Rights Reserved.