IPE CAS - International Energy Agency

IEA-MOST Workshop: Advances in deployment of fossil fuel technologies
Efficient oil and gas refining with oil shale:
Technology overview and new development
Guangwen Xu
Institute of Process Engineering, Chinese Academy of Sciences
State Key Laboratory of Multiphase Complex System
Advanced Energy Technology Group(AETG)
June 24, 2014, Beijing
AET Group
Contents
 Highlight on world oil shale
resource and technologies
 Highlight on China oil shale
resource and technologies
 A new refining technology
development in IPE-CAS
 Concluding remarks
IPE CAS
Highlight on world oil shale
resource and technologies
IPE CAS
World energy resource in 2013
1011 equivalent barrel
Resource
Reserves
Crude oil
13.1~16.3
Oil sand (including char)
3.3~4.9
Heavy oil
4.9~8.2
Oil shale
(including char and gas)
16.3~24.5
Others
4.9~16.3
* The int. exploitation and processing of oil shale, 2014,1, SINO-GLOBAL ENERGY
Crude oil
Oil Sand
Heavy oil
Oil Shale
Oil shale: A sedimentary rock contains a
solid organic material known as kerogen. It
has low organic content (<35 wt.%), high ash
content (50~85 wt.%) and H/C is above 1.2.
IPE CAS
World Shale oil distribution
Country
Potential oil reserve (107 t)
Annual oil production (104 t/a)
America
30000
——
Russia
3900
——
Zaire
1400
——
Brazil
1200
20
Canada
630
——
Jordan
520
——
Morocco
500
——
Australia
450
——
China
4760
80
Estonia
250
66
Italy
140
——
Total
43750
166
* The int. exploitation and processing of oil shale, 2012, SINO-GLOBAL ENERGY.
IPE CAS
History of oil shale utilization
Combustion for energy
Year
Retorting for oil and gas
Shale oil and gas production
1900s
Directly used as solid fuel by combustion.
1970s
Commercial production of shale oil and gas by retorting.
1990s
Petroleum oil industry suppressed shale oil production.
2000s
High price and shortage in petroleum, the shale oil
production has been renewed.
IPE CAS
Major countries refining oil shale
Brazil
• Petrosix process
• Total shale oil production is about 200 kt/a.
China
• Fushun retort
• Total shale oil production is about 1000 kt/a.
Estonia
• Kiviter and Galoter process
• The 2nd largest shale oil producer after China
• The total shale oil production is about 600 kt.
Other countries: USA, Australia, Jordan, Russia
IPE CAS
Retorting / Pyrolysis technology
True in-situ retorting
In-situ underground
retorting
Modified (half) in-situ retorting
Gas heat carrier
Direct heating
Solid heat carrier
Aboveground
retorting
Indirect heating
IPE CAS
In-situ underground retorting
 For deep low-grade oil shale, being economic possible.
 Polluting underground water and rack stratum.
 Research mainly in America, but no industrial appl.
Heating method
 Conductive heating (ICP): Electric heating sticks
 Convective heating (EGL): Aeration of hot flue gas
 Radiant heating (Lawrence Livermore): Radio frequency
IPE CAS
Reported major technologies
Technology
Shell’s Conversion
Process (ICP)
Exxon mobil
ElectrofracTM
American Shale Oil
(AMSO, previously
known as EGL)
Heating supply
Electric heating
Electric conducting
material
Pyrolysis gas
2
10
——
340~400
——
300~425
Complex, high electricity
consumption
Combine retorting and
sodium carbonate
production.
Difficult for
moisture-removing
Heating rate
(℃/day)
Retorting
temperature (℃)
Features
Schematic
diagram
1,000 feet
Surface
processing
Overburden
Producers
Heater holes
Oil shale
IPE CAS
Difficulty for in-situ retorting
 No mature technology for industrial utilization
 Low heating rate and heat transfer efficiency
 Pollution of underground water and rack stratum
around the working section
 Low permeability of oil shale layers
 Low oil yield (60% against Fischer Assay)
 Problems for ground subsidence
IPE CAS
Aboveground Retorting Technology
Oil shale
Oil shale
Shale oil
Oil shale
热灰
Oil
Heating
gas
Gas
油气
半焦
Char
Indirectly heated
Low heat transfer
efficiency and
Difficult for scale-up
Flue gas
Combustion
Furnace
煤
Hot ash
Gas heat carrier
For big particles and
Relatively low yield
O2
Char
Solid heat carrier
For small particles but
high dust contamination
IPE CAS
Kiviter Retorting (Estonia)
Oil shale
 1981, a 1000t/d Kiveter furnace
was completed in Estonia.
Feeding
 Shale oil yield: 75~80% of
Fischer assay yield.
Oil and gas
Circulating gas
Combustor
 Advantages:
● Gas heating, heat-binding and
heat-dusting oil shale
● Easy to scale up and control
 Disadvantages:
● Big particles ( 25~125 mm)
● Low gas heating value
● Low utilization rate of char
Burner
Burner
Fireproof
Cold gas
circulation
Char controller
Char
IPE CAS
Petrosix Retorting (Brazil)
Precipitator
Oil shale
Compressor
Oil and gas
Retorting
furnace
Gas
Cyclone
Gas
Spray tower
Oil
Oil
Oil
Char
Heating furnace
Fuel gas
Water
Gasoline
Distillation
Cold circulating gas
Liquid fuel
1) Running rate: 95%; 2) High-HHV gas; 3) Large capacity (6000 t/d);
4) Steady running; 5) High oil yield (85~90% Fischer assay yield).
But a) Large particles (12~80 mm); b) Wasting char potential heat.
IPE CAS
Galoter Retorting (Russia)
 For 0~25 mm particle, Oil yield: 90%, High-HHV gas, Actually applied.
 High investment, Complex operation, Extensive maintenance.
Hot ash and
flue gas
Dust
removal
Ash
Power plant
Combustor
Separator
Mixer
Separator
Dryer
Pyrolyzer
Oil shale
Oil and gas
recovery
Char
Water
Air
Power plant
Shale oil
IPE CAS
Enefit-280 (Germany & Estonia)
Oil shale
(<6 mm)
Stack
Dust
Combustion
Pyrolysis gas
Dryer
Shale oil
Heavy oil
Retorting
Cooler
Hot air
making
Air
Air
Extra-heavy oil
Condenser
Modified Galoter: 6000t/d
IPE CAS
Tosco-Ⅱ Technology (America)
 Heat carrier: porcelain
balls at 680 ℃
Porcelain balls
Flue gas
Oil shale
(<12.7 mm)
 Preheated to 260 ℃
Pyrolysis gas
Naphtha
Air
 Pyrolysis at 480 ℃
Light oil
Retorting
Dryer
Heavy oil
Hot oil shale
Porcelain balls
Hot gas
Vapor
Combustion
Heater
Water
 Oil yield: > 90%
(Fischer assay yield)
 High investment
 Char not used
Water
 Hardly for large scale
Cooler
Shale
 High oil sludge
IPE CAS
Alberta Taciuk Process
(ATP, Canada & Austrilia)
62.5 m
Combustion
8.2 m
Oil and gas
Retorting
Seal
Preheating Cooling
Oil shale
(0~25 mm)
500℃
750℃
250
℃
It was said to have 6000 t/d with oil yield > 90% (Fisher assay), but
meeting many problems in China , such as complex operation and
maintenance, low running rate, high dust contamination.
IPE CAS
Lurgi-Ruhrgas (Germany)
 Ash : oil shale = 4:1
Flue gas
Pyrolysis gas
Air
preheater
Dryer
Air
Oil shale
(0~5 mm)
 Pyrolysis at 520 ℃
Cooler
Combustion
Feeding
Oil
Water
Pyrolysis
 Circulated ash: 720 ℃
 Oil yield: > 90%
(Fischer assay yield)
 High-HHV pyrolysis gas
Oil
Pyrolysis gas
Char
Finished 8-24t/d pilot, but no industrial plant.
 Char used in the system
 Complex system
 High investment
 High dust in oil
IPE CAS
Comparison of existing technologies
In-situ
Parameter
retorting
Gas heat carrier
Petrosix Kiviter
Solid heat carrier
Galoter Enefit-280
Tosco-Ⅱ
ATP
Lurgi-Ruhrgas
Reactor
Under
ground
Scale (t/d)
─
6200
1000
3000
6000
900
6000
8-24
Size (mm)
─
6-50
10-125
0-25
0-6
0-12.7
0-16
0-5
Oil yield
60
85-90
75-80
85-90
90
90
85-90
90
High
HHV
Low
HHV
High
HHV
High HHV
High HHV
High
HHV
High HHV
Heated
Pyrolysis
gas
Ash
Ash
Balls
Ash
Char
Gas product Low HHV
Moving bed
Heat supply
Char & gas
combustion
Flue gas
Problem
Many issues
to concern
Large particles
Rotating oven
Moving bed
High ash contamination, large oil sludge
IPE CAS
Highlight on world oil shale
resource and technology
IPE CAS
Unconventional energy resource in China
Name
Amount
Equivalent oil and gas
Coal bed gas
36.8×1012 Nm3
36.8×1012 Nm3 gas
Shale gas
35×1012 Nm3
35×1012 Nm3 gas
Oil shale
7199×108
476×108 t oil
20-50×1012 Nm3 gas
Oil sand
59.7×108 t
3-6×108 t oil
Heavy oil
>100×108 t
~50×108 t oil
Tight oil
>74×108 t
~74×108 t oil
t
Shale oil (476×108 t): about 2 times of petroleum reserves (233×108 t).
IPE CAS
Oil shale distribution in China
Oil shale distribution
North East (Liaoning, Jilin)
48%
Middle (Shanxi)
22%
3.5%-5%
Qinghai / Tibet
17%
5%-10%
West (Xinjiang)
10%
>10%
South (Guandong)
3%
IPE CAS
Oil shale refinery in China
 Back to 80 years ago, current shale oil production: ~80×104;
 Only technology: Fushun retort for particles > 12 mm;
 Being about 60% of the world total shale oil production.
Region
Oil yield (104 t/a)
Fushun
35.0
Beipiao
7.0
Diaobingshan
2.5
Longkou
12.0
Huadian
9.0
Wangqing
5.0
Dongning
1.5
Yaojie
5.0
Total
Technology
Scale (t/d)
Number
220
Fushun retort
(internally heated
moving bed)
140
100
20
40
Fushun retort
Fushun retort
Gas combustion
100/300
32/12
100
40
100
4
300
8
~800,000 t/a shale oil by retorting >15 mt/a large-size oil shale
IPE CAS
Fushun retorting technology
 First plant in 1930 at 50
t/d, 100 t/d in 1940;
 Low oil yield (<72 wt.%);
 Low gas heating valve;
 Low shale oil yield (65%
of Fischer Assay yield);
 Hardly scaling up (still ~
100 t/d per furnace);
 Hardly use char and ash /
water pollution;
 Only for large-size oil
Well industrialized, simple, low cost. shale (12-75 mm).
IPE CAS
Actual furnace and refieary
IPE CAS
Oil shale of different sizes
From mining
Small-size oil shale
IPE CAS
Another refinery in construction
In Shanxi Tongchuan
IPE CAS
DaGong (DG) process
From coal pyrolysis (started in 1980s, 150 t/d in 1992 for lignite);
Ash/char heat carrier, as Lurgi-Ruhrgas process for 0-10 mm fuel;
 Pyrolysis at 500 ℃, Oil yield: 92 % of Fischer Assay yield.
1) High dust in oil;
2) Blocking duct;
3) High heavy species content.
Drying
Combustion
Hot flue gas
Pyrolysis
Combustor
IPE CAS
Fluidized bed retorting
 Developed in 1969, and a 24 t/d was stopped in 1975 (by Maoming);
 Retorting at 475~480 ℃, combusting at 590~605 ℃;
 High shale oil yield, high-HHV gas, easy for scale-up, but high dust in oil.
Cold water
Waster gas
Hopper
Oil
Steam
Air
Ash
Air
Ash
Water
Crusher
Separator
Ash
Absorption
Oil
shale
Scrubbing
Distillation
Combustor
Pyrolysis gas
Retorting
Hot flue gas
24t/d
Light oil
Steam
Residue
Light shale oil
Heavy shale oil
IPE CAS
A new refining technology
development in IPE-CAS
IPE CAS
Concluding remarks
1) Oil shale is the unconventional oil resource that has the biggest reserves.
2) There are a few commercial refining technologies allowing shale oil
yields of 80-90%. While the gas heat carrier technologies only treat largesize oil shale (>10 mm) in moving bed, the solid heat carrier technologies
can accept fine oil shale by using rotating oven reactors, but there is
usually serious dust contamination.
3) Worldwide there is not any technology which can convert fine oil shale to
produce low-dust shale oil in high yield, which producing high heating
gas simultaneously.
4) Currently China has only the small moving bed retorting technology
(Fushun retorting furnace), which suffers from lots of problems including
low oil yield (65-72%), low gas heating value, and difficulty in using char.
5) A new technology is under development in IPE, CAS to treat fine oil
shale to produce shale oil in yield of about 90% of Fisher assay value and
almost free of dust.
IPE CAS
Thank you
for
your attention!
IPE CAS