How to find targets for new magic bullets?

How to find targets for new magic bullets?
Hans Georg Sahl
IMMIP – Pharmazeutische Mikrobiologie, Universität Bonn
The lasting combat –
new antibiotics and bacterial resistance
Introduction of novel
antibiotic classes
1950
Aminoglycosides
1940
Penicillin
1952
Macrolides
1962
Quinolones
2000
Oxazolidinones
1935
Sulphonamides
1949
Tetracyclines
1930s
1940s
1950s
1960s
1970s
1942
Sulphonamide
resistance
1950s
-Lactamresistance
1961
MRSA
1972
Multiresistent
Salmonella
typhi
Examples of
bacterial
resistance
development
1958
1962
Glycopeptides Streptogramines
1968
Tetracycline
resistance
2003
Lipopeptides
1980s
1986
VRE
1990s
2000s
1990s
Fluoroquinolone
resistance
2000s
First
resistances
against
linezolid
and
daptomycin
1997
Discovery
of VISA
2002
VRSA
?
Antibiotic Targets
Approaches for the discovery of novel antibiotic classes
Advantages
- antibiotic activity
Problems
- Unspecific – toxicity
- old or new ?
- MoA: time consuming
- overmining of actinobacteria
Advantages
- target specificity
- automation, robotics
- target structures > rational drug design
- combinatorial chemistry
Problems
- Lack of antibiotic activity > uptake/efflux
- Specific aspects of MiOs neglected:
- Essentiality ?
- What is a good target ?
- How to combine the advantages and avoid the problems ?
- How to find a good target ?
Bacterial Cell Biology
Novel Isolation and Screening Technology
Cell Wall Biosynthesis in
Staphylococci
GlcNAc
III
MurNAc
peptidoglycan
C55-P
PBPs
P
Pi
cytoplasm
II
P
P
P
P
P
P
MraY
P
P
UDP
MurG
UMP
MurF
P
P
UDP
DdlA
P
P
FemABX
5 x Gly-tRNA
D-Ala + D-Ala
D-Ala-D-Ala,
ATP
ATP
I
MurE, MurD, MurC
MurB, MurA
UDP-
UDP
UDP
L-Lys,
ATP
D-Glu,
ATP
L-Ala,
ATP
NADPH
PEP
Antibiotics – Tools to study biological processes
T ARG ETS
O
O
L
S
Lipid II : A most relevant target
•
•
Glyco(lipo)peptide
Antibiotics
Target sites on Lipid II
- e.g.Vancomycin
- Ramoplanin
Lantibiotics
Lantibiotics
Defensins
Ramoplanin
- Nisin
- Gallidermin
- Mersacidin
●
Defensins
- Plectasin
and related defence peptides
bactoprenol
Vancomycin
Antibiotics – Tools in Bacterial Cell Biology
Peptidoglycan
Cell Division
WTA
PknB
SleI
PBP
PBP
VicK
LytM
UppP
TagO
FtsQ
MurJ
MraY
FtsW
FtsQ
FtsL
RodA
TagA
MurG
FemX FemA
FtsB
FemB
EzrA
FtsZ
MnaA
ZapA
MurE
MurZ
MurD
MurC
based on an idea by Maria Senn
FtsA
GlyRS
MurF
Model by Tanja Schneider
FtsK
MurB
MurA
GlmU
GlmM
GlmS
Fruc-6-P
Why are penicillins such good antibiotics? - Do we know how penicillin kills?
Similarity in structure
Penicillin
peptidoglycan
D-Alanyl-D-Alanin
O
O
OH
OH
TP
TG
PBP2
O
O
N
N
S
N
R
O
N
R
O
PBP2-GFP localisation
untreated
penicillin-treated
Pinho & Errington, 2005
Antibiotics that target cell envelope structures re-sensitize MRSA to β-lactams
WTA
PG
LTA
cell division
PBP2a
murgocil
→ high functional interdependencies between the different cellular pathways
→ reset MRSA phenotype > re-sensitize resistant strains & restore antibiotic activity
Schneider, Pinho & Roemer. Curr Opin Microbiol, 2013
Mann et al., ACS Chem Biol, 2013
Koyoma et al., PLoS One, 2013
An irresistible newcomer
Teixobactin
Eleftheria terrae
(William Fowley, Norteastern University)
Ling & Schneider et al., Nature, 2015
Mode of action model
→ strongly limits resistance development
128
Fold-change in MIC
• binds to multiple targets
• of different cell envelope pathways
• highly conserved non-protein target structures
256
64
32
16
8
Teixobactin
4
Ofloxacin
2
1
producer
E. terrae
S. aureus
0,5
0
5
10 [days]
15
Time
20
25
Fluorescence based promotor-reporter fusions
(…)
P
sGFP
P
yvqF
vraS
Activation of the CWSS by treatment with CW active agents
Control – nothing added
Van 10X MIC
Control – Nal. Acid 10X MIC
Oxa 10X MIC
Control – Erythr 10X MIC
What can we learn from
antibiotics / natural products ?
Bacteria cells have a high degree of of functional organization
- not just a bag full of enzymes
- target biosynthesis machines and impact on their coordinated function
- physical cellular damage which cannot be managed by stress response sytems
- have two or more targets and activities
Prof. Dr. Tanja Schneider
Hannah Ulm
Anna Müller
Daniela Münch
Patrick Hardt
Marvin Rausch
Ina Bertholt
Dr. Beate Henrichfreise
Anna Klöckner
Stefania de Benedetti
Christian Otten
Henrike Bühl
Dr. Fabian Grein
Daniela Nusser
Nina Kuklinski
Dr. Iulia Chiriac
Dr. Miriam Wilmes
Michaele Josten
Christiane Szekat
Inge Luhmer Becker
Acknowledgement
Staphylococci
Chlamydia
produce
perform
kill
Antimicrobial Peptides
- Defensins
Cooperations
Heike Brötz-Oesterhelt
Alex Tossi, Yechiel Shai
Andreas Peschel, Fritz Götz
Arnie Bayer, Michael Yeaman
Leendert Hamoen
Bob Hancock
- Lantibiotics
- Lipopeptides
- Glycopeptides
Cell Wall
Biosynthesis
interfere
with
Funding
Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft
DFG- FOR 854
Research Ministry BMBF
DZIF (German Center of
Infection Research)
European Union
various projects