Ferdinando Squitieri_introduzione

Ferdinando Squi-eri, Roma, 21/11/2014 Mala$a di Hun+ngton George Hun+ngton, 1872 choreia deriva dal Greco χορεία (un /po di danza), per via dei rapidi movemen/ del tronco e degli ar/ simili ad una danza incontrollabile MALATTIA HUNTINGTON: UNA STORIA DI STIGMA E DISCRIMINAZIONE
CHARLES DAVENPORT - 1916
Realizza il primo pedigree su larga scala di una famiglia con l’Hun/ngton andando indietro di 12 generazioni A seguito di questo, pubblica un paper sull’ American Journal of Insanity dal /tolo “Hun/ngton's Chorea in Rela/on to Heredity and Eugenics” Director of the Biological Laboratory at Cold Spring Harbor, New York, USA and founder of the Eugenics Record Office La sua teoria è: “ from just a few progenitors came a vast number of vic+ms” mo/vo per cui è opportuno procedere a “immigra+on restric+ons, surveillance of families, and compulsory sterilisa+on” Quest ar+colo è stato per anni considerato nella le<eratura biomedica un testo fondamentale sulla mala$a di Hun+ngton PERCY R VESSIE, 1932
Vessie traccia l’albero genealogico della famiglia di un suo paziente, andando a ritroso fino agli antena/ immigra/ nel New England nel 17mo secolo Iden/fica in tre coppie sposate provenien/ dal villaggio di Bures, Suffolk, in Inghilterra, i “portatori” della mala[a di Hun/ngton negli USA Psichiatra del Connec/cut Per Vessie, le accuse di stregoneria contro una donna di quella famiglia dimostravano la presenza della mala$a di Hun+ngton in quel nucleo familiare Vascello John Winthrop ADOLF HITLER, 1933
This law, which was to be implemented on January 1, 1934 called for the steriliza/on of "lives unworthy of life". These "unworthy lives" included those persons suffering from congenital mental retarda/on, schizophrenia, manic-­‐dpressive insanity, epilepsy, Hun+ngton's chorea, hereditary blindness, hereditary deafness, grave bodily malforma/on, and severe alcoholism. To enforce the steriliza/on laws, Nazi leadership created special "Hereditary Health Courts." All physicians were legally required to report to the courts anyone they encountered who fell into any of the categories for steriliza+on. As a result, by 1937 some 225,000 individuals had been sterilized by German authori/es, a figure that was roughly ten /mes the number in the United States. Commifee to Combat Hun/ngton's Disease : Hun+ngton Disease Society of America Commission for the Control of Hun/ngton’s Disease (US Congress) MALATTIA HUNTINGTON: UNA STORIA DI STIGMA E DISCRIMINAZIONE
Dr Milton Wexler (psicoanalista
e psicologo clinico, padre di
Nancy) fonda la Hereditary
Diseases Foundation dopo
che alla moglie viene
diagnosticata la MH
Nancy e i suoi collaboratori
vanno in Venezuela, studiano
un’unica famiglia di 18.000
componenti e raccolgono oltre
4.000 campioni di sangue
grazie allo studio di questi
campioni, James Gusella
localizza il gene della malattia
72,6: 971-­‐983, 26 March A novel gene containing a trinucleo+de repeat that is expanded and unstable on Hun+ngton's disease chromosomes Marcy E. MacDonald, Chris/ne M. Ambrose, Mabel P. Duyao, Richard H. Myers, Carol Lin, Lakshmi Srinidhi, Glenn Barnes, Sherryl A. Taylor, Marianne James, Nicolet Groot, Heather MacFarlane, Barbara Jenkins, Mary Anne Anderson, Nancy S. Wexler and James F. Gusella CAG oltre 36 worldwide described a pathological range
starting beyond 35 CAG repeats, with 36–39
repeats representing
a ‘low-penetrance’
NEURODEGENERATIVE
DISEASE
range that tends to be associated with very
late age at HD onset, if the disease manifests at all (Figure 1). Until recently, expansions in the 27–35-CAG range—termed
Ferdinando
Squitieri
intermediate
alleles—were considered to
NEWS & V
sibility that people carrying an HTT allele
that falls within the intermediate range can
Figure 1 | Multiple ‘shades’ of CAG trip
show marked
behavioural changes, includfollow-u
CAG repeat stretch inlongitudinal
the HTT1 gene
fro
ing suicidal ideation and sent
apathy.
The
a type of prodro
zones, with subtle, heterogeneous
and
authors argue that these behavioural
manianticipating
typical
with the intermediatemany
and years.
low-penetran
festations, which were observed
amongThese
50 ne
individuals with intermediatecurrent
allelesthinking
(5.1% on
‘normal’ range of CAG
of the total study cohort) during
a 4-yearnatur
The
unstable
|
NATURE REVIEWS
NEUROLOGY 2013 longitudinal follow-up period, may repre-
‘Fifty shades of grey’ in the
Huntington disease gene
NEWS & VIEWS
DISEASE
Huntington disease is causedNEURODEGENERATIVE
by a CAG repeat
expansion in the huntingtin
repeats in HTT unde
sent a type of prodromal HD, potentially
‘Fiftyhas
shades
of grey’
in the
anticipating typical
motor symptoms
by
to undergo
intergener
length
gene.Chromosome
A repeat length
of 35 CAGs
long been
accepted
asCAG
therepeat
cut-off
4
many years. These new findings challenge
Huntington
gene
the
pathological
trip
current thinking
on what
constitutes the
point beyond which the expansion
becomesdisease
pathological,
but recent findings
‘normal’ range of CAG repeats.
Ferdinando Squitieri
of animal a
The unstablestudies
nature of the trinucleotide
indicate that intermediate expansions
(27–35 repeats) are associated with
Huntington disease is caused by a CAG repeat expansion in the huntingtin
repeats in HTT underlies their propensity
36–39
10–26
27–35
patient40+
brains have d
to undergo intergenerational expansion into
gene. A repeat length
of an
35 CAGs
has long been accepted as the cut-off
either a distinct behavioural phenotype
or
endophenotype.
the pathological triplet range. Moreover,
point beyond which the expansion becomes pathological, but recent findings
CAG CAG
G CAG
CAG CAG CAG mosaicism
CAG CAG of
CAGthe
CAG CAG CAG
C
studies of animal and cell models and
indicate
that intermediate
(27–35
associated
CAexpansions
G CAG
Gdoi:10.1038/nrneurol.2013.128
CAG repeats)
CAG are
CAG
CAG with
CAG CAG
CAG have
Squitieri, F. Nat. Rev. Neurol. advance online
publication
25 June
2013;
CAG CAGsomatic
CAG neur
patient brains
documented
differentiated
either a distinct behavioural phenotype or an endophenotype.
mosaicism
of the CAG
length
in
CAG CAG
G CAG
CAG CAG CAG CAG CAG
CAG
CAGrepeat
CAG
CAG
genomic
instabili
differentiated the
neurons,
indicating that
CAG CAG
G CAG
CAG CAG CAG CAG CAG
CAG
CAG
CAG CAG
the genomic instability
also Full
operates
at an
Low
Huntington disease (HD) is oneHuntington
of nine
be
mutable,
potentially
increasing
in
size
2
AGNormal
AGmutable,Intermediate
CAG
CAGincreasing
CAG in CAG
CAG
CAG intraindividual
CAG
CAG repeat
CAG leve
disease (HD) isCone
ofCAG
nineG Cbe
intraindividual
level.
Therefore,
potentially
size
penetrance
penetrance
expansions
samples,
neurological disorders that C
known
toG Cand
extending
the
pathological
in
G CAG
AGto
CAGtopathological
CAG
CAG rangeCAG
CAG
CAGblood
CAG
CAG
expansions
in periph
neurological disorders that are known
to
andareAextending
the
range
in CAGin peripheral
result from a CAG repeat expansion in an
offspring, but never themselves associated
as were measured in the PHAROS study,1
C
A
G
CAG
G
C
AG
CAG
CAG
CAG
CAG
CAG
CAG
CAG
CAG
CAG
may theoretically
in length
from those
affected
the huntingtin but
with
a pathological
phenotype. Evidence
result from a CAG repeat expansion
ingene—in
an this case,
offspring,
never
themselves
associated
asdiffer
were
measured
in
CAG
CAG
CAG
CAG CAG
in the brain.
(HTT) gene. The classic clinical
feature
ofG CisAG
beginning
to emerge,
however, that
CAG CAG
CAGThe potential
CAGeffects
CAGof triplet
CAG
HD is a progressive, untreatable
with
intermediate
allelesEvidence
can
mosaicism
thatmay
extends
from the intertheoretically
affected gene—in this case, the huntingtin
with
pathological
phenotype.
CAand
Ga highly
CAG
G Cindividuals
AG
CAG
CAG CAG
CAG
CAG
CAG
CAG
CAG CAG diffe
mediate range in peripheral blood cells to
disabling chorea: an uncontrollable dancemanifest either a phenotype typical of HD
Squitieri, F. Nat. Rev. Neurol. advance online publication 25 June 2013; doi:10.1038/nrneurol.2013.128
ininthe
pote
(HTT)4p16.3
gene. The classic clinical feature
ofthat affectsisthebeginning
toendophenotype
emerge,
however,
that
like movement
individual for
or an
suggestive
of potenthe full expansion
brain brain.
cells withinThe
the
same individual
remain to be clarified.
many years, followed by severe rigidity, full Unaffected
tially developing the disease.Therefore, the
Affected
HD is a progressive, untreatable and
highly
with
intermediate
alleles
can
mosaicism that exte
dementia,
cachexia and,individuals
ultimately, death.
intermediate
HTT alleles are considered
to
The longer the CAG repeat expansion in the
represent something of a genetic ‘grey area’.
alleles in per
mediateHTTrange
disabling chorea: an uncontrollable
dancemanifest either
a phenotype typical of HD…the intermediate
HTT gene, the earlier the appearance of
Recently, a longitudinal analysis of indiare
considered
to
represent
Figure
1
|
Multiple
‘shades’
of
CAG
triplet
length
in
the
HTT
gene.
The
increasing
length
of
the
the first disabling
manifestation.
viduals at risk of HD
and controls, enrolled
like movement that affects the individual
for motoror
an endophenotype
suggestive
of potenthe
full ‘grey
expansion
in
something
of
a
genetic
Soon after the discovery of the HTT gene,
in the Prospective Huntington At Risk
CAG
repeat
stretch
in
the
HTT
gene
from
normal
size
to
expansion
goes
through
a
series
of
analysis of
large populations
patients
Study (PHAROS),
has highlighted the possame individual rema
many years, followed by severe rigidity,
full
tiallyof developing
the disease.Therefore,
the
area’
worldwide described a pathological range
sibility that people carrying an HTT allele
zones,cachexia
with subtle,
and intermediate
ambiguous
clinical
manifestations
potentially
associated
dementia,
and, heterogeneous
ultimately,
death.
HTT
alleles
are considered
tofactors that determine
The
the phenostarting
beyond 35 CAG repeats,
with 36–39
that
falls within
the intermediate
range can
repeats representing a ‘low-penetrance’
typic variability of patients carrying triplet
show marked behavioural changes, includthethe
intermediate
and low-penetrance
alleles.
Abbreviation:
HTT, huntingtin.
Thewith
longer
CAG repeat expansion
represent
of a genetic
. in the low-penetrance
expansions
range in the
that tends to be associated
with verysomething
ing suicidal ideation
and apathy.‘grey
The area’
…therange,
interme
‘‘
1
’’
?
QQQQQQ Sperimentalzione preclinica
nei modelli di MH
Pratica clinica MH
La malattia di Huntington
…una sola mutazione… molti diversi volti… Corea Rigidita’ Distonia Corea Depressione Distonia Aggressivita’ Rigidita’ Irritabilita’ Bradicinesia Psicosi Incoordinazione Apa/a Disturbi del movimento Sintomi psichaitrici Ossessioni Disfagia Compulsioni Disatria Dispercezioni Atassia Alto tasso suicidi Aprassia Insonnia Deficit cogni+vo Demenza Alterazioni ritmo Disturbi di memorIa Sonno/Veglia Difficolta’ di riconoscimento dei colori Disinibizione Difficolta’ di riconoscimento del gusto Atrofia muscolare Difficolta’ di riconoscimento delle emozioni Perdita del peso Incon/nenza HUNTINGTON: modello di studio UNA mutazione dominante TEST DNA ica n
i
l
c
ilità
b
a
i
r
Va
Insorgenza 90% Complicazioni della mala[a Durata di 15-­‐30 anni 90% 10%