Martino: Update from EFSA – APDESK Suitability check

Suitability Check of dossiers
on Food Enzymes and
services for applicants and
other stakeholders
Carla Martino
Applications Desk Unit
Info Session on Applications
Technical meeting on Food Enzymes
27/05/2014
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
TODAY’S
TODAY
S PRESENTATION
Applications
pp
Desk as a front office
and support desk for applicants
„
„
„
„
Centralise and harmonise workflow on
applications
Suitability check of dossiers on Food
Enzymes
APDESK web form
Customer oriented approach
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
APDESK VISION AND MISSION
Vision
Our vision is to facilitate high quality
applications for regulated products
that enhance innovation.
Mission
Lead a front office and support desk
for all stakeholders with respect to
applications for regulated products.
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
CENTRALISATION OF APPLICATIONS
Applications are submitted to EFSA
Individual
scientific
units
EFSA / APDESK
Risk assessment
FIP
U it
Unit
FEED
U it
Unit
9Reception
9Acknowledgement
9Administrative issues
9 Completeness check
9…
VALID application
GMO
U it
Unit
NUTRITION
U it
Unit
PESTICIDES
U it
Unit
BIOHAZ
U i
Unit
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
FOOD ENZYMES – WORKFLOW APPLICATIONS
Applicant
EC
Regulations
EC
1331/2008
234/2011
Reception
EFSA
30 WDS
(legal DL)
Suitable
Not suitable
Validity (by EC)
Risk Assessment
Negotiated
deadline
Adoption by the
Panel
15 WDs*
Publication
*EFSA aims at publishing the
opinion 15WDs after adoption
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
FOOD ENZYMES – WORKFLOW SUITABILITY CHECK
Applicant
Dossier
EUROPEAN
COMMISSION
Regulations
EC
1331/2008
234/2011
Mandate
+
Dossier
EFSA
Performs
suitability
it bilit check
h k
(30 WDs legal
DL)
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
OVERVIEW ON DOSSIERS IN EFSA (update 27
27.05.2014)
05 2014)
41 dossiers received by EFSA:
Number
Outcome
23
S it bl
Suitable
1 Opinion adopted
18 Under risk assessment phase
4 Additional data requested during the risk Status in EFSA Register of Question
Finished
In progress
assessment Additional data request
10
Under suitability check
Under consideration
8
Not suitable
Waiting for full dossier
Link to check the status of an application in the EFSA Register of Question:
http://registerofquestions.efsa.europa.eu/roqFrontend/questionLoader?question=EFSA‐Q‐20xx‐xxxx
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
SUITABILITY CHECK (1)
APDESK overview table
Key
d
documents
t
to consult
in order to
prepare an
application
How to prepare and submit an
application:
li ti
http://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/faq
s/docs/apdeskhowtofoodadd.pdf
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
SUITABILITY CHECK (2)
Administrative check Æ
9 name of the applicant
9 list of bibliographical references
9 confidential parts of the dossier
Scientific check Æ
9 based on the following guidance
documents:
1. Guidance
1
G id
off the
th Scientific
S i tifi Panel
P
l off Food
F d Contact
C t t
Material, Enzymes, Flavourings and Processing Aids
(CEF) on the Submission of a Dossier on Food
Enzymes for Safety Evaluation (EFSA-Q-2007-080)
http://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/efsajournal/pub/1305.ht
m
2. Explanatory Note for the Guidance of the
Scientific Panel of Food Contact Material, Enzymes,
Flavourings and Processing Aids (CEF) on the
Submission of a Dossier on Food Enzymes (EFSA-Q2014-00183)
http://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/supporting/doc/579e.pdf
3. Guidance on the risk assessment of genetically
modified microorganisms and their products
intended for food and feed use (EFSA-Q-2009-00521)
http://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/efsajournal/pub/2193.ht
m
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
SUITABILITY CHECK – POSITIVE ASPECTS
¾
¾
¾
¾
Technical dossiers follow the structure of
the EFSA guidance
Administrative information well
documented
Bibliography provided
Description of intended uses provided
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
NON SUITABILITY – MOST COMMON ISSUES IDENTIFIED (1)
1. Chemical
composition
i i
Information to be provided in
Technical
h i l Dossier
i
9
Batch-toB t h
Batch
variability
Batch identification number
C
Consistent
i t t iinformation
f
ti
on th
the chemical
h
i l
composition between Certificates of
Analysis/Annexes and main text
Explanation of differences observed
9
Methods of
analysis
To be provided for parameters analysed
(e.g. enzyme activity, ash, protein)
9
Significant
side activities
To be documented with experimental data,
information on their inactivation to be
provided
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
NON SUITABILITY – MOST COMMON ISSUES IDENTIFIED (2)
1. Chemical
composition
Information to be provided in
Technical Dossier
9
Optimum
pH/temperature
conditions
To be provided for main enzyme
activity/ies
9
Amino acids
sequence
To be provided if feasible to determine
together with info on potential
allerginicity
9
Modification of
the enzyme by
protein
engineering
Rationale for the modification to be
provided
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
NON SUITABILITY – MOST COMMON ISSUES IDENTIFIED (3)
2. Toxicological
data
Information to be provided in
Technical Dossier
9
Conformity of
tox batch
The conformity of the tox batch to
specification/chemical composition of food
enzyme under evaluation and its
representativeness
p
to be p
provided
9
Compliance of
tox studies with
GLP (OECD,
Directive
2004/10/EC)
(Art. 5(7) of
Regulation (EC)
234/2011)
GLP/OECD compliance statement to be
provided
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
NON SUITABILITY – MOST COMMON ISSUES IDENTIFIED (4)
3. Waiving of
t
tox
data
d t
9
Rationale for
waiving tox
data
4. Omission of
any
y information
required by
EFSA Guidance
9
Rationale for
omission of
any
mandatory
information
Information to be provided in
T h i l Dossier
Technical
D
i
Rationale in line with Regulation
g
((EC)) No
562/2012 or EFSA Guidance document on
food enzymes
Information to be provided in
Technical Dossier
Scientifically sound and well elaborated
justification for the omission to be
provided
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
WEB FORM TO ASK A QUESTION
www.efsa.europa.eu
/it/applicationshelpd
esk.htm
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
WEB FORM TO ASK A QUESTION
Requests per scientific area
(Nov 2011-Apr 2014)
Nutrition, 152
160
Pesticides, 138
140
Animal by products
Animal by‐products
Food ingredients, 114
120
100
Feed additives
Food contact materials, 103
Food contact materials
Food ingredients
Feed additives, 88
Food processing
Genetic modification
80
Nutrition
Food processing, 64
Other
60
Pesticides
Genetic modification, 41
Decontamination
Other, 33
40
NA
Animal by‐products,
12
Animal by
products, 12
20
Decontamination, 9
NA, 2
0
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
WEB FORM TO ASK A QUESTION
Requests
q
p
per affiliation
(Nov 2011-Apr 2014)
NGO/consumer group, 6
Consultant, 157
Other, 77
Private citizen/consumer, 37
Not indicated, 18
Public authority, 39
Science/academia, 66
NGO/consumer group
Other
Private citizen/consumer
Public authority
Science/academia
Industry
I d t
Industry, 356
Not indicated
Consultant
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
APDESK 2012
2012--2018: INTERACTIONS WITH STAKEHOLDERS
WHAT
Identify and map
stakeholders’
needs (survey)
APDESK
initiatives
Monitor
stakeholders’
satisfaction and
customer oriented
approach
Analysis of the
applicant’s profile’
(report)
WHEN
2012 - 2013
2014-2018
Feb 2015
Report
on stakeholders’
stakeholders
needs
http://www.efsa.eur
opa.eu/en/supportin
g/pub/482e.htm
Internal mandate
http://registerofquestion
s.efsa.europa.eu/roqFron
tend/questionLoader?que
stion=EFSA-Q-2014Q
00250 (mandate M2014-0106)
Internal mandate
http://registerofquesti
ons.efsa.europa.eu/roq
Frontend/questionLoad
er?question=EFSA-Q2013-00788
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
SERVICES ALREADY AVAILABLE IN EFSA
Web
form
Adoptiion of
Scientific
c Opinion
Info Session
on
Applications
Submis
ssion of
doss
sier
Web
form
Direct formal
communication
with applicants
(letters)
CC & RA
Evaluation period
Pre-submission
Prenotification
of outputs
(24h)
Post-adoption
Time
APDESK
web
section:
- FAQs
-How to
prepare an
application
table
bl
-Application
workflow
Guidance
documents:
-ADMINISTRATI
VE
-SCIENTIFIC
Application
workflow
with
estimated
deadline
Register of
Question
update
Plenary
meetings
Agendas &
Minutes
Rationale for
reaching
conclusions
provided in
scientific
opinions
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
CUSTOMER ORIENTED APPROACH
¾Work on-going
on going within the REPRO Department under EFSA
mandate M-2014-0106: Development of a Customer
oriented approach for regulated products (May 2013- Dec
2018)
1) Framework contract to monitor stakeholders’
satisfaction on services
se ices provided
p o ided by
b EFSA
2)) EFSA Internal Task force composed
p
of HoUs of
REPRO to analyze in-depth options for developing a
customer oriented approach for regulated products
¾ E-submission of applications
mandate M-2014-0076)
(Matrix
project,
EFSA
Info Session on Applications - Technical meeting on Food Enzymes 27/05/2014
Any questions? Get in contact with us through our web form!
form
http://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/applicationshelpdesk/askaquestion.
htm?ScientificArea=zero
Any information? Check out our web section!
section
http://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/applicationshelpdesk.htm
GRAZIE