PFO fatal.key

Fatale Skotomisierung des
offenen Foramen ovale (PFO)
Bernhard Meier
Universitätsklinik für Kardiologie
Inselspital
Bern
Interessenkonflikt: Forschungsunterstützung und Honorare
St. Jude Medical
Intricacy of Adult Interven2onal Cardiology Procedures
• Preven2on • Therapy
LAA Closure
PFO Closure
ASD Closure
Paravalvular MitraClip (Mitral) Leak Closure
TAVI
PCI
Palmares der kathetergestützten Herzeingriffe
1953 Rubio-Alvarez
1966 Rashkind
1966 Porstmann
1972
1975
1975
1977
1981
1982
1982
Galiano
King
Gianturco
Grüntzig
Singer
Gallagher
Inoue
1983
1986
1987
1990
1994
1998
2000
2001
Lababidi
Puel
Simpson
Palacios
Sigwart
Waxman
Bonhoeffer
Sievert
2002 Cribier
Pulmonale Draht-Klappenaufdehnung bei angeborener Verengung
Atriale Septostomie (Aufdehnung des Foramen ovale bei angeborener
Herzmissbildung)
Verschluss des Ductus Botalli (Querverbindung zwischen den grossen
Gefässen, die sich nach der Geburt nicht spontan verschlossen hat)
Koronare Drahtrekanalisation bei akutem Herzinfarkt
Verschluss des Vorhofseptumdefekts
Verschluss von Gefässfisteln mit Drahtkringeln
Koronardilatation (Ballon-Herzkranzgefässaufdehnung)
Ballonaufdehnung einer Isthmusverengung der Hauptschlagader
Verödung einer elektrischen Leitung im Herzen (His-Bündel)
Ballonaufdehnung der verengten Mitralklappe (zweitwichtigste
Herzklappe)
Ballonaufdehnung der verengten Aortenklappe (wichtigste Herzklappe)
Stentimplantation im Herzkranzgefäss
Plaque-Exzision aus dem Herzkranzgefäss (Atherektomie)
1992 Bridges: PFO Verschluss
Balloneröffnung des Perikards
Alkoholschrumpfung der überdicken Herzkammerscheidewand
Zugang in den Herzbeutel durch das Herzohr für Medikamentengabe
Ersatz der Pulmonalklappe (drittwichtigste Herzklappe)
Verschluss des linken Vorhofohrs als Alternative zur Blutverdünnung bei
Vorhofflimmern
Ersatz der Aortenklappe
TEE
PFO and ASA
Angiography
LA
LA
PFO
PFO
Zinsli Annemarie 08.11.1941, 05.07.2010 Baden
RA
ASA
RA
ASA
Eustachian Valve
Weshalb ist ein PFO gefährlich?
Thrombus Stuck in PFO
(Ramani GV, J Am Coll Cardiol 2012;59:e19)
• 77-year-old woman
• chest pain and dyspnea
--> surgery with good outcome
“caught in the act”
Ariel Sharon (Scheinermann)
1928-2014
Coma after cerebral hemorrhage
2006-2014
January 11, 2014
• It was the evening of December 18, 2005. • Ariel Sharon (78 years, prime minister of Israel), was on his way home, when he suddenly had difFiculties articulating. • He was diagnosed with a transient ischemic attack (TIA) and recovered quickly. • A plausible reason for his TIA was identiFied: a patent foramen ovale (PFO). • He was slated to undergo percutaneous PFO closure after the Holidays on January 5, 2006. • Until the procedure, the prime minister was treated with low-­‐molecular weight heparin. • However, the day before the scheduled procedure, he collapsed at home. • Hemorrhagic stroke was the diagnosis. • Tragically, he never recovered from this incident and remained in a coma for 8 years, until his death in January 2014.
Pflegefachfrau mit 2 Teenager-Buben, 39jährig
wird nie mehr sprechen wegen eines Hirnschlags
Sie hatte seit 10 Jahren
unter schwerer Migräne
gelitten!
PFO and Migraine
74 patients
73 patients
Dowson A, Circulation. 2008;117:1397-1404
Migraine and Stroke
Meta-Analysis
Schürks M, BMJ 2009;339:b3914
Migraine and Coronary Problems
Metaanalysis
Schürks M, BMJ 2009;339:b3914
PFO Causing MI
Courtesy Fabian Nietlispach, MD
TIAs, migraine with aura
Pre
Man 46 years, MI Out of the Blue
Post
Courtesy Ahmed Khattab, MD
25 mm Amplatzer PFO Occluder
Kohler Walter
27.09.1968
13.05.2014
Khattab
PA
Thrombus aspirated
through guiding catheter
PFO looked for and found while abciximab running
LAO
PFO Causing MI
Woman 46 y, chest pain 1 week after swollen and tender calf (courtesy Aris Moschovitis, MD)
Züttel Franziska 19.02.1967
18.07.2013 Moschovitis
LAO, end-systole
Long thrombus in RCA
Waffling of
territory of
dominant RCA
PFO Causing MI
Woman 46 y, chest pain 1 week after swollen and tender calf (courtesy Aris Moschovitis, MD)
<
1 cm
Züttel Franziska 19.02.1967
18.07.2013 Moschovitis
>
Thrombus extracted
RCA
ted
sten
PFO Causing MI
Woman 46 y, chest pain 1 week after swollen and tender calf (courtesy Aris Moschovitis, MD)
Züttel Franziska 19.02.1967
18.07.2013 Moschovitis
PFO looked for and found
Amplatzer 25 mm Cribriform Occluder
LA
SS
SS
LA
RA
RA
PFO / MI
• 46-year-old man
• Anterior ST↑
• Normal coronary
arteries except for
proximal LAD occlusion
• Severe LV impairment
• Orsiro Stent
• Amplatzer 25 mm PFO Occluder
Mehri Stefan
28.04.1969
18.01.2015
Pilgrim
Courtesy Thomas Pilgrim, MD
PFO / MI
End-systole
• 48-year-old man
• 1:30 a.m. admission
• Chest pain for several hours
• Anterior ST↑
• Normal coronary
arteries except for
proximal LAD occlusion
• Severe LV impairment
LAD occluded by embolus
Schelker Beat, 17.09.1961, 22.11.2009 Khattab
Reopened by wire
• Stent
• Amplatzer 25 mm PFO Occluder
PFO probed for, found, and occluded
LA
RA
LAD recanalized and stented
PFO / MI
• 45-year-old man
• Acute anterior MI with schock
Embolus
Embolus
Carvalho Pereira Adao Joaquim 03.09.1965, 17.06.2010 Wenaweser
Embolus
PFO closure with 25 mm Amplatzer Occluder
Post removal with basket
• Frau, 57 Jahre • Malaise and Präsynkope während Wanderung • Mit Helikopter in die Klinik geflogen
Briessinck Marie Jeanne, 18.12.1953, 20.08.2010
Dr. Aris MoschoviPs
Paradoxe Embolie mit floIerendem Thrombus im proximalen RCX und funkPonellem Verschluss der distalen RCX-­‐Aeste Resultat nach mehreren AspiraPonen mit Export 6F und (bei proximal persisPerendem Thrombus) mit dem 6F-­‐Führungskatheter selber
Dr. Aris MoschoviPs
LA
Nachweis des PFOs
Verschluss mibels Amplatzer PFO Occluder Device 25 mm. Frühe und späte Phase nach KM Gabe mit Darstellung von RA und LA
RA
• 53-year-old man
• Lingering chest pain for 3 days
• No prior history of CAD
• LV: anterior akinesia
PFO and multiple MIs
• Old recanalized (embolic?) occlusion of RCA
• Embolic occlusion of LAD extending into diagonal
Courtesy: Aris Moschovitis, MD
• Stent for LAD
• Amplatzer 25 mm PFO Occluder
LAO
LA
SS
NUNES JOAQUIM
03.10.1960, 07.04.2013,
Moschovitis
PFO Occluder
RA
RA
Akinesia in LAD territory
PFO looked for and found
Embolic
LAD occlusion
with thrombus
in diagonal
Long
recanalized
(embolic?)
RCA occlusion
Stented LAD
PFO and MI in Elderly
• 86-year-old woman
• Acute anterior MI at 10 pm
• Concurrent pulmonary embolism
Pre Aspiration
Aspirated Thrombus
Sahli Bethli 24.06.1928
25.08.2014
Wenaweser
PFO
Courtesy
Peter Wenaweser, MD
Post Aspiration
25 mm Amplatzer PFO Occluder
PFO —> LM Embolization
in Newborn
•
•
•
Boy, 4 days
18-hour delivery
Born in cardiogenic shock
Thrombus
Lötscher Nathan, 14.12.2014, 18.12.2014
Pfammatter
Thrombus
Thrombus
PFO Causes
Anterior MI
Perrone Michele
13.05.1954
21.03.2014
16.04.2014
Räber
PFO
looked for,
found,
and closed
1 month after primary PCI:
partial recovery
of anterior wall function
PFO-Near-Death in Healthy 26-Year-Old Ice-Hockey Player
Sudden severe angina and hypotension at 2 a.m.
Courtesy A. Khattab, MD
PFO in TEE
Bärtschi André, 11.05.1988, 15.12.2014
Longish thrombus in LAD
25 mm Amplatzer PFO Occluder
After stent
PFO-Death in Healthy 34-Year-Old Man, 1 Day after a Soccer Bruise to the Thigh
Sudden collapse: cardiogenic shock --> catheterization under cardiac massage
Di Giorgio Roberto, 30.05.1977, 24.07.2011 Pilgrim
Pilgrim T, J Invasive Cardiol 25:162-164, 2013
Autopsy
Huge infarction
Femoral
vein
thrombus
at
bruise
Culprit
PFO
Pulmonary
embolus
also
found
Eur Heart J 2014;35:2971
(fatal outcome)
Abecasis Joao
ECM
O
PFO-Death in Healthy 46-Year-Old Woman after Face Lifting
LA
Wiestner Marianne 31.01.1967
01.05.2013 Diehm, Nietlispach, Kadner
PFO
RA
Multiple coronary artery occlusions
(under ECMO support)
PFO
Cardiogenic shock and death
4 days
after emergency heart surgery
Multiple pulmonary embolisms
and Death
Pavoni D, J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 2012;59;1329
PFO!?
• 26-year-old man
• Occasional smoker,
recently cannabis
• Lysis failed
• Nice therapy
• Wrong diagnosis
Sürder D, Kucher N, Eberli FR, Roffi M
EHJ 27:2631, 2006
After extraction
Mobile Mass in the Left Main Coronary Artery
Baris Ikitimur, MD, Tevfik Gurmen, MD, Ali Tabakan, MD, Kaya Suzer, MD
Istanbul, Turkey
(Ikitimur B, J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 2010;55;e131)
PFO!?
Ikitimur B
PFO not mentioned!
Multivessel Spontaneous Coronary Artery Dissection!?
35-year-old woman, 12 days post-partum
PFO!?
PFO not mentioned!
Survived on anticoagulants only
Sardar MR, JINT 2014;7:e161-162
Eur Heart J. 2014;35:2046
Zimmermann FM
45-year-old woman with two previous embolic brain events and PFO
Courtesy: Luiz Carlos Simões, MD
Embolic Occlusion of Internal Cerebral Artery with PFO
• 58-year-old man with mild stroke
• 25 mm PFO occluder
Alshahumi Mufta 01.01.1950 13.05.2009
Pulmonary Embolism and Simultaneous Silent Embolic Occlusion of Left Carotid Artery
(Woman, 56 y, --> PFO closure and oral anticoagulation)
CT done for suspected pulmonary embolism
PFO looked for and found at TEE
Clot in
left
carotid
artery
Clot in
right
pulmonary
artery
Zwahlen Inge, 15.12.195408.03.2010
PFO closed with 25 mm Amplatzer PFO occluder
Simultaneous Embolic Occlusion of Left Carotid Artery and Multiple Coronary Arteries
(Woman, 63 y, intubated because of cardiogenic shock out of well-being, hemiplegic when waking up)
ASA
Anselmo Andrea Gabriela
Pilgrim
29.08.1961
04.12.2014
30.03.2015
Multiple coronary “lesions”, EF 20%
TEE
3 months later after multiple PCIs in 2 sessions, EF 30%
Bubbles crossing
PFO Occluder 25 mm
40-year-old man with massive pulmonary embolism,
died 2 hours after emergency surgery from acute stroke
PFO Barz Olaf 22.07.1970
01.06.2010 Kucher
Courtesy: Nils Kucher, MD
Simultaneous Embolic Occlusion of
•
•
•
•
Left Vertebral Artery (plus Embolically Stenosed Right Carotid Artery)
Dominant Left Circumflex Coronary Artery (LCX)
Celiac Trunk and Superior Mesenteric Artery
Left Iliac artery (plus Embolically Stenosed Aorta at Bifurcation)
(Woman, 49 y, sudden shock after several days of not feeling well)
Pre
Hauri Patrizia
05.04.1965
28.03.2015
29.03.2015 death
Moschovitis
Post
LCX
Pre
Mesenteric
Pre
Post
Celiac
Post
Pre
Post
Iliac
Died the following day (after additional abdominal vascular surgery) because of cerebral hemorrhage, autopsy refused
Stortecky S, J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 2011;58;1923
Pulmonary Embolism and Simultaneous Paradoxical Embolism to Dominant LCX with Inferior MI
(Woman, 69 y, 8-hour train ride with pre-syncope, severe dyspnea at rest, and inferior ST-elevation the next morning)
Schwartz Nanna 26.09.1941, 10.06.2010 Togni
Good course after
additional systemic
thrombolysis
Venous
Thromboembolism
(VTE)
and
Stroke/MI
Relative Risk of MI or Stroke
Provoked VTE
• 20-year population-based cohort study
• Danish medical databases
• No known cardiovascular disease
• 25 199 patients with deep venous thrombosis
• 16 925 patients with pulmonary embolism
• 163 566 population controls
No
con
side
rati
on o
f PF
O !!
Paper
First year hazard ratio
MI
1.60 (95% CI 1.35–1.91)
Stroke 2.19 (1.85-2.60)
Sørensen HT, Lancet 2007; 370: 1773–9
(Denmark, Italy, US)
Editorial
Lowe GDO, Lancet 2007; 370: 1743-4
(Glasgow)
20
PFO and D-Dimer
Stroke
570 patients with
• cryptogenic stroke
• TEE: PFO (42%)
Pulmonary Embolism
Kim YD, Thromb Haemost 2015
l
o
C
Vorkommen von PFO gemäss Alter
PFO in 263/965 Autopsien (Durchschnitt 27%)
Se
38
36
34
32
%
lek
Y = 34.613 - .121 * X; R^2 = .603
tiv
30
eS
28
ter
26
24
bli
ch
22
20
0
10
20
Hagen PT, Mayo Clin Proc 1984; 59: 17-20
30
40
50 60 70
Column
133
Alter
(Jahre)
80
ke
it?
90 100 110
Events per Year
PFO with
Closure
PFO
device
PFO
without
device
Medical
Treatment
(≥ 10 years of FU)
P=0.03
P=0.09
P=0.001
1,872 patient-years
1,394 patient-years
Wahl A, Circulation 2012, 125:803-812
P<0.001
Cost for Year of Life Saved (US$)
PFO closure at 30 years
0
• Bypass surgery for left main stem disease
7,000
• Betablocker after infarction
10,000
• Invasive strategy for coronary artery disease
10,000
• Cervical cancer screening
12,000
• Treatment of hypertension
13,000
• Statin therapy, secondary prevention
24,000
• TPA instead of streptokinase for infarction
33,000
PFO closu
• Hemodialysis
35,000
re at 2.6 y
ears 50,000
• Percutaneous aortic valve replacement
• PTCA for acute myocardial infarction
52,000
• Heart transplantation
54,000
• Fourth day of monitoring for acute infarction 105,000
• Statin therapy, primary prevention
150,000
• Seat belt
150,000
• Smoke detector
239,000
• Radiation control
834,000
Pickett CA, AJC 2014: $20,000.00 per case
• Air bag
1,500,000
*Frei A, Kardiovask Med 7:174-180, 2004