Developing a Path to Net Positive Energy Status in a Nutrient

Julian Sandino, PhD, PE, BCEE
IWA & WEF Fellow
VCS Denmark
Mads Leth
Per Henrik Nielsen
Carsten Steen
Soren Eriksen
Niels M. Askjær
CH2MHILL
Dru Whitlock
Tom Johnson
Tim Constantine
Dwight Houweling
• Nitrification increases O2 demand
– Longer sludge age during low temperature increases
biomass endogenous demand and larger aeration volume
also requires additional mixing
– NH3-N conversion to NO3-N typically doubles O2 demand
• Denitrification only partially recovers O2
• Unaerated zones for Bio P and Denitrification
require mixing energy
• Low Nutrient requirements could require filtration
(extra pumping?)
• Effective primary treatment reduces carbon load to
subsequent BNR basins, while increasing potential for
energy recovery from sludge
– Carbon needs for denitrification and P-removal must be
addressed (external carbon? WAS fermentation/hydrolysis?)
• Carbon present in sludge offers opportunity for
significant energy recovery : CHP Cogeneration
• Established in 1853 as
first modern waterworks
in Denmark
• 3rd largest water and
wastewater company in
Denmark. HQ in Odense.
• Operates 7 WTPs and 8
WWTPs with 3,400 km of
conveyance
Courtesy of Google Maps (Altered by CH2MHILL)
ø
• 385,000 PE BNR facility
• 76% energy self-sufficient in 2011
• Contribute towards achieving VCS’s corporate goal of
energy self-sufficiency and carbon neutrality by
2014.
• Identify energy optimization opportunities (EOOs):
concentrate on short-term, readily implementable
scenarios to reduce consumption and/or increase
generation, decreasing GHG emmissions
• Identify and document all options, including longer
term opportunities for positive net energy status for
future consideration
Ejby Mølle WWTP 2011 Annual Average Electricity Consumption
Thickening/Dewatering
Centrifuges
6.44%
Anaerobic Digestion
3.83%
Sludge Storage
1.56%
Activated Sludge
- Other
0.24%
Screen, Grit, and Grease
Primary Treatment Pumping to
3.88%
3.09%
Trickling Filters
Other
2.15%
5.59%
Pumping to Activated
Sludge
5.80%
Trickling Filters Stage 2 pumping
7.30%
Effluent Filters
10.43%
Activated Sludge WAS Pumping
0.22%
Activated Sludge RAS Pumping
0.86%
Activated Sludge Oxidation Ditch Mixing
2.09%
Trickling Filters Recirculation pumping
4.73%
Trickling Filters WAS/Humus Pumping
0.01%
Trickling Filters - Return
Pumping to Act Sludge
0.64%
Activated Sludge Oxidation Ditch Aeration
39.35%
Activated Sludge Anaerobic Zone Mixers
1.78%
• Adopted screening criteria
– Readily implementable;
Primarily process modifications
– Significant impact on energy
profile; Proven elsewhere
• Longer term Improvements for
– Implement chemical enhanced positive net energy status
• Short-listed EOOs
primary treatment (CEPT)
– Operate at shorter BNR system
solids retention time (SRT)
– Decommission TFs and convert
TF clarifiers to CEPT for wet
weather treatment
– Reduce effluent filtration
operation to 12 hours per day
– Co-digestion of high strength
waste by mid 2014
– Implement deammonification
for N removal in sidestreams by
2014; mainstream by 2015
– Replace oxidation ditch
mechanical aerators with fine
bubble diffused aeration
Energy Produced 2011
Additional Energy Produced
Additional Energy Saved
All Operational EOOs + Anammox + Diffusers
All Operational EOOs
Partial Effluent Filtration
Lower Bioreactor Sludge Age
No Trickling Filters
Energy Self-Sufficiency
Chemically Enhanced Primary Treatment
Existing Condition (Baseline)
75% 80% 85% 90% 95% 100% 105% 110% 115% 120%
Electrical
Energy
9,000,000
8,000,000
7,000,000
6,000,000
5,000,000
4,000,000
3,000,000
2,000,000
1,000,000
kWh/year
-
Production
Usage
25,000,000
2014
2013
2012
15,000,000
Production
10,000,000
2014
2013
2012
2011
5,000,000
kWh/year
2010
Electrical +
Heat Energy
Usage
2009
2011
2010
2009
20,000,000
• Full-scale evaluation of co-digestion with
organic waste
• Implementing sidestream and mainstream
deammonification for N control
• Developing “hybrid” aeration concept by
combining mechanical and diffused aeration
systems
High-strength waste
increases biogas
generation
Co-digestion in
Anaerobic digesters
Energy Recovery from
cogeneration
(heat and electrical)
Sidestream
deammonification
Mainstream
hydrocyclones
• Plant-wide mass and energy balance
model used to evaluate operational and
facility energy optimization scenarios
• Collaborative approach identified
“operational” path to energy selfsufficiency
• Co-digestion and deammonification
(sidestream and mainstream)
capabilities will yield positive net energy
status by end of 2014
• VCS is well into achieving adopted goal
of achieving energy and CO2 neutrality
VCS & CH2MHILL and
Project Team
Project received 2013 WEX
Process Optimization award