An Approach to Microbiological Testing of Raw Materials Utilizing

B2 - Objectionable Microorganisms in NonSterile Pharmaceutical Drugs
Presented by: Thuy Bui
An Approach to Microbiological Testing of Raw
Materials Utilizing Microbial Growth Potential
Assessment
Kim Bowers
Manager, Quality Science and Technology
Pfizer, Andover MA
Presented by:
Thuy Bui
QC Microbiology
Manager, Pfizer, Inc.
2
1
B2 - Objectionable Microorganisms in NonSterile Pharmaceutical Drugs
Presented by: Thuy Bui
3
4
2
B2 - Objectionable Microorganisms in NonSterile Pharmaceutical Drugs
Presented by: Thuy Bui
5
Presentation Outline
• Objective
• Overview
• Microbial Growth Potential
• Raw Material Assessments: 2 examples
• Considerations for the routine testing laboratory
• Summary
6
3
B2 - Objectionable Microorganisms in NonSterile Pharmaceutical Drugs
Presented by: Thuy Bui
Objective of this presentation
• An assessment approach to determine the type
of microbial testing required for raw materials.
This approach was developed in Andover, and is
aligned with the general Pfizer process.
• Assessment parameters:
– Monograph present?
– Is material of natural origin?
– Microbial quality attributes:
• Microbial growth potential
7
Overview
• Raw materials used during biopharmaceutical
manufacturing should be assessed for
microbiological testing requirements prior to use
at the site
– EU guidelines for Good Manufacturing Practice for Medicinal
Products for Human and Veterinary Use, Annex 2: Manufacture of
Biological active substances and Medicinal Products for Human
Use
– USP <61>, <1111>
• Harmonized with EP, JP
8
4
B2 - Objectionable Microorganisms in NonSterile Pharmaceutical Drugs
Presented by: Thuy Bui
Overview
• Although the microbiological test methods are
clearly defined per USP <61>,<62> and <85>,
the requirements for determining the type of
microbiological testing to perform are not as
clearly defined
• This can lead to inconsistencies in the approach
to microbiological testing.
9
Overview
• Pfizer, Andover is a low bioburden
biopharmaceutical manufacturing site
• The QC Microbiology Laboratory performs both
bioburden (total count) and endotoxin testing on
raw materials
• In most cases, there is no established limit
(monograph) for these materials, and the limit is
set based on validation data, historical
information from the vendor and/or from similar
raw materials
10
5
B2 - Objectionable Microorganisms in NonSterile Pharmaceutical Drugs
Presented by: Thuy Bui
Overview
• Pfizer Andover has developed an assessment
strategy for determining the requirements for
microbial testing by utilizing a system based on
the microbial quality attributes of the raw
material.
• The approach looks at various factors that
contribute to microbial growth potential.
11
Determination of Microbial Growth
Potential
• Microbial growth potential looks at multiple
factors including storage, packaging and
temperature
• Key factors are:
• Nutrient availability
• Antimicrobial properties
• Water activity
• pH
12
6
B2 - Objectionable Microorganisms in NonSterile Pharmaceutical Drugs
Presented by: Thuy Bui
Nutrient Availability
The availability of a nutrient source can be difficult to
determine. A key factor is whether the raw material is
naturally occurring or synthetic/refined
Growth Promoting
Known to promote
Description
growth of
microorganisms
Minimal Nutrients
Contains minimal levels of
nutrients not as readily
utilized for microbial
growth
No
nutrients
Contains no
organic
compounds
13
Antimicrobial Properties
• An antimicrobial agent is known to reduce
microbial population and/or destroy
microorganisms. A reference is required (USP,
in-house study, etc.)
Antimicrobial Properties Categorization
Known
Antimicrobial
No
Undetermined
Yes
Properties
14
7
B2 - Objectionable Microorganisms in NonSterile Pharmaceutical Drugs
Presented by: Thuy Bui
Water Activity
• Water activity(aw) is the amount of free water in a
substance and is associated with microbiological activity.
It serves as an indication of potential metabolic activity.
As per USP <1112>:
Water Activity
Microbiological Activity
<0.75
Inhibitory
<0.60
Growth ceases
Solution with < 0.88
Inhibitory to most
Category
High
Moderate
Low
Liquid with aW of
>0.88
0.60-0.88
<0.60
Solid with aW of
>0.88
0.75-0.88
<0.75
15
pH
• Microbial cells require a physiological pH. A cell’s
ability to survive in high or low pH depends on its
ability to correct for the difference between inside and
outside the cell (stability of the biochemical properties
of the microorganism).
Category
Solid
pH value
NA
Liquids
Neutral
6-8
Moderate
3.5-6 or 810
Extreme
<3.5 or >10
16
8
B2 - Objectionable Microorganisms in NonSterile Pharmaceutical Drugs
Presented by: Thuy Bui
Raw Material Assessment: Example 1
• Description of Raw Material
–It is a solid
–It is synthetic and highly refined
–Has a carbon source
–Has no known antimicrobial
properties
–Has a water activity of 0.38
17
Nutrient Availability & Antimicrobial
Properites for Example 1
Material is synthetic, has a carbon source,
equates to minimal nutrients
Growth
Promoting
Minimal Nutrients
No nutrients
Known
Antimicrobial
No
Undetermined
Yes
Properties
18
9
B2 - Objectionable Microorganisms in NonSterile Pharmaceutical Drugs
Presented by: Thuy Bui
Water Activity & pH for Example 1
Material is a solid with a water activity of 0.38
Category
High
Moderate
Low
Solid with aW of
>0.88
0.75-0.88
<0.75
Category
Solid
pH value
NA
Liquids
Neutral
Moderate
Extreme
6-8
3.5-6 or 8-10
<3.5 or >10
19
Determination of required testing for
Example 1
• Material has minimal nutrients, no
antimicrobial properties, low water activity
and is a solid
• Result = microbial growth potential,
requirement for in house microbial testing
(bioburden and endotoxin)
20
10
B2 - Objectionable Microorganisms in NonSterile Pharmaceutical Drugs
Presented by: Thuy Bui
Raw Material Assessment: Example 2
• Description of Raw Material
–It is a liquid
–It is synthetic and highly refined
–Has a carbon source
–Has antimicrobial properties
–Has a water activity of 0.80
–Has a pH of 3.3
21
Nutrient Availability & Antimicrobial
Properties for Example 2
Material is synthetic, has a carbon source,
equates to minimal nutrients
Growth Promoting
Minimal Nutrients
No nutrients
Material has antimicrobial properties
Known
Antimicrobial
No
Undetermined
Yes
Properties
22
11
B2 - Objectionable Microorganisms in NonSterile Pharmaceutical Drugs
Presented by: Thuy Bui
Water Activity & pH for Example 2
Material is a liquid with a water activity of 0.80
and a pH of 3.3
Category
High
Moderate
Low
Liquid with aW of
>0.88
0.60-0.88
<0.60
Category
Solid
pH value
NA
Liquids
Neutral
6-8
Moderate
3.5-6 or 810
Extreme
<3.5 or >10
23
Determination of Required Testing for
Example 2
• Material is synthetic, with minimal nutrients,
has antimicrobial properties, moderate water
activity and low pH
• Result = low microbial growth potential, no in
house testing required
24
12
B2 - Objectionable Microorganisms in NonSterile Pharmaceutical Drugs
Presented by: Thuy Bui
Considerations for Routine Testing
• During validation, stick with standardized test
methods
– Start with a standard test such as USP <61>, USP<85>
– Add rinses and/or neutralizers as needed, following
compendial guidance
25
Considerations for Routine Testing
• Simplest test method with clear instructions
– i.e. use a standard media (SCDA) even if alternate
media might give slightly better recovery
• Benefits to streamlined and simple approach:
– Right first time
– Standardized and quick training
– Fits in with Standard work/lean labs approach
26
13
B2 - Objectionable Microorganisms in NonSterile Pharmaceutical Drugs
Presented by: Thuy Bui
Considerations for Routine Testing
• Validation should include rationale for selection
of the test method
– Understanding of why the validation was done the way it
was
• Some frequency of periodic review of the limit
would be beneficial
– Revisit the established limit once a larger data set is
available.
– Establishment of the limit is preliminary and is based on
a small data set, historical information and similar raw
materials.
27
Summary
• Having a procedure in place to assess microbial
testing requirements provides the manufacturing
facility and the QC Microbiology laboratory the
following benefits:
– consistency in approach
– justification and rationale for testing
– streamlined process to ensure that the appropriate
testing is performed
28
14
B2 - Objectionable Microorganisms in NonSterile Pharmaceutical Drugs
Presented by: Thuy Bui
Acknowledgements
•
•
•
•
Thuy Bui
Lynn Johnson
Hilary Chan
Quality Science and Technology –
Microbiology (Pfizer, Andover, MA)
29
15