ANNUAL REVIEW 2013 Promoting safe and sustainable alternatives to hazardous pesticides Welcome 2013 has been a notable year for PAN UK in many ways. Pesticide problems have featured as headline news across national television, radio, online and print news media. PAN UK has campaigned for many years to highlight the harmful effects of neonicotinoid pesticides on bees and other pollinators. In 2013, we joined forces with the Environmental Justice Foundation (EJF) to launch a joint campaign to persuade the UK Government to introduce a moratorium on these bee-toxic pesticides pending further independent research on their effects. This campaign reached its peak in the spring of 2013, when, along with a coalition of other environmental and wildlife organisations, we organised the highly successful, and much reported, March of the Beekeepers in Parliament Square in London. Shortly after that demonstration, the European Commission introduced a European Union-wide two year moratorium on certain types of neonicotinoid pesticides. PAN UK Director Keith Tyrell with long standing PAN UK supporter and ethical fashion designer Katherine Hamnett Despite the success of this campaign, it represents only a small fraction of the work undertaken by PAN UK on many fronts in 2013. For example, we were active on public awareness raising through publications such as Pesticides on a Plate and continued our internationally recognised work in Africa to clear the continent of obsolete and highly hazardous pesticides, and to train small-holder cotton farmers in profitable organic cultivation. We also provided technical and scientific expertise to other organisations working to end the use of highly hazardous chemical pesticides. Keith Tyrell Director, PAN UK March 2014 All photos © PAN UK 2013 2 PAN UK | ANNUAL REVIEW 2013 The problem with pesticides Many pesticides are highly hazardous to human health and the environment, and are responsible for the poisoning of millions of people, livestock and wildlife worldwide. Some have been linked to cancer. Some are based on WW2 nerve gases and damage the nervous system, whether insect, animal or human. Many disrupt the hormonal balance in our body, threatening our potential to reproduce, and to have healthy offspring. Pesticides can remain in the environment for decades, accumulating in the fatty tissues of animals and contaminating water, soil and air far from where they are used. Pesticides are a major global killer The World Health Organisation estimates that over 350,000 people die every year from acute pesticide poisoning, but admits that this is a significant under estimate. The World Health Organization estimates that over 350,000 people die every year from acute pesticide poisoning, but admits that this is a significant underestimate. The majority of these deaths occur in the developing world where pesticides that are illegal in Europe are still widely available, and where farmers receive little or no training in how to avoid exposure. What is more, the above figure does not include deaths or ill-health from cancer or other chronic diseases caused by pesticide exposure. Chronic health problems from pesticides not only cause human misery, but also represent a major drain on developing world economies. The UN Environment Programme (UNEP) estimates that the costs of illness and injury associated with pesticide use in sub Saharan Africa in 2005 was US$ 4.2 billion – this is almost as much as the region received in overseas aid for healthcare (excluding Aids programmes) that year (US$ 4.4 billion). And the situation is getting worse. UNEP estimates that between 2015 and 2020 the health costs of pesticide exposure in sub-Saharan Africa will amount to US $90 billion. Pesticides are also a major cause of indebtedness Poor training, unfair trading arrangements, exploitative markets and unscrupulous pesticide suppliers all combine to drive small farmers into debt. For example, pesticides can eat up around 60% of a smallholder cotton farmer’s income in West Africa. Farmers who take out loans at the beginning of the season to buy their inputs all too often find their harvests are too meagre to pay off the debts at the end of the year. In the fifteen years before 2010, over a quarter of a million small farmers committed suicide in India alone. Not only were pesticides a contributory cause of indebtedness in many of these cases, but many farmers used pesticides to take their lives. In fact, across the developing world more than 60% of suicides are by pesticide poisoning. PAN UK | ANNUAL REVIEW 2013 3 As well as the human tragedy, pesticides are responsible for massive environmental problems, from water pollution wiping out the ecosystems in rivers and streams - even coral reefs as rivers flush the chemicals into the sea - to biodiversity losses as the building blocks of ecosystems are disrupted. Some rivers in Africa are so polluted that livestock such as cows and goats regularly die after drinking from them. Campaigning for change Since its inception in 1982, PAN UK has worked tirelessly to apply pressure to governments, regulators, policy makers, industry and retailers to reduce the impact of harmful chemical pesticides. Over the years PAN UK has achieved many significant successes through its campaigning and lobbying activities, and this continued to be the case in 2013. Creating a buzz about pesticides Our main campaign in 2013 focused on the role pesticides play in the recent declines in bees and other insect pollinators essential to our food supply. Populations of bees and other insect pollinators have fallen dramatically in the past decade and there is growing scientific evidence that pesticides, particularly neonicotinoid pesticides, are playing a significant role. Like many other insecticides, neonicotinoid pesticides are acutely toxic to bees and other pollinator species. But it is also emerging that these insecticides are having chronic effects at very low doses. Studies have shown that repeated exposure to pollen and nectar contaminated by neonicotinoids can disrupt foraging behaviour, homing ability, communication and larval development. It can also negatively affect the immune system of bees, making them more susceptible to parasitic and disease infections. In February, PAN UK and the Environmental Justice Foundation (EJF) launched a joint-campaign to protect the UK's bee and pollinator populations and safeguard the ecological and economic services they provide. The campaign called for a UK Pollinator Action Plan to include: • • • 4 A near term ban on neonicotinoid pesticides; Government incentives and support for the adoption of pollinator-friendly farming practices and restoration of bee habitats; and Government-funded, independent research into declining bee populations and the role of pesticides. ... there is growing scientific evidence that pesticides, particularly neonicotinoid pesticides, are playing a significant role. PAN UK | ANNUAL REVIEW 2013 A hive of activity PAN UK’s activity in campaigning towards these ends in 2013 included: ... headline news in national television, radio, online and print news media. • Contributing evidence to the House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee which subsequently reported in April 2013, and recommended that the UK Government implement a moratorium on the use of certain types of neonicotinoid pesticides on crops attractive to bees, and that it support such a proposal in the EU; • Working with supermarkets to identify how they could reduce, and ultimately eliminate, neonicotinoids from their supply chains; • Lobbying the Secretary of State for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs by urging him to support a moratorium on neonicotinoids, and initiating a letter writing campaign by the public to pressure their own MPs to support a moratorium too; • Co-ordinating a letter published in the Sunday Times in April signed by many celebrities and high profile campaigners, calling on the UK Government to take action to protect bees and other pollinators; and • Organising the March of the Beekeepers in Parliament Square in London in April, along with EJF and a coalition of environmental and wildlife groups. The demonstration was headline news in national television, radio, online and print news media, and even featured prominently on the BBC’s satirical panel show Have I Got News For You. PAN UK Director Keith Tyrell giving one of many media interviews at April's March of the Beekepers in Parliament Square. PAN UK | ANNUAL REVIEW 2013 5 Europe acts At the end of April the European Commission (EC) announced its intention to introduce a two year suspension on the use of certain types of neonicotinoid pesticides on crops attractive to bees. The suspension came into force in December 2013. While PAN UK welcomed this measure as a step in the right direction, we were disappointed that it did not go as far as the complete moratorium we believed necessary to protect bees and other pollinators. As we enter 2014, PAN UK is working to ensure the EC measure is implemented effectively and we continue to campaign for a complete moratorium on the use of neonicotinoid pesticides, and for a thorough and independent review of the science. Raising awareness PAN UK has always worked to raise awareness among the general public about the harm caused by pesticides. We do this in various ways, including publishing information booklets, leaflets and posters, as well as through our online communications channels. Pesticides on a Plate Our most significant publication in 2013 was our booklet Pesticides on a Plate: a consumer guide to pesticide issues in the food chain. This analysis of pesticide residues present on food consumed in the UK showed that the levels of pesticide residues in our food have been steadily increasing, and as much as 40% of the food we eat now contains them. Residues found in several fruit categories exceeded Government limits, while a number of the most frequently detected pesticides are highly toxic and have been linked with developmental defects, cancers and other disorders. The booklet also provided consumers with information on how they could reduce their exposure to pesticides, and urged the government and retailers to do more to reduce the use of harmful pesticides in the food chain. Pesticides on a Plate: a consumer guide to pesticide issues in the food chain can be downloaded at www.pan-uk.org/files/ pesticides_on_a_plate_2013_final.pdf 6 Pesticide residues in our food have been steadily increasing, and as much as 40% of the food we eat contains them. PAN UK | ANNUAL REVIEW 2013 Making a real difference on the ground PAN UK also works directly with partners in the developing world and supports projects that bring real economic, health and environmental benefits to communities. The main areas of this activity in 2013 were: Sustainable cotton PAN UK has worked successfully over recent years with smallholder cotton farmers in Benin, West Africa, to train them in profitable, non-chemical cotton farming techniques. The results have brought greater income, improved health and greater food security and safety for those participating in the projects. In 2013 we launched new projects to deliver these benefits further: Benin Cotton Trade – building an environmentally friendly route to poverty reduction This one year project, funded by TRAID, was an extension to our existing organic cotton programme which has already improved the livelihoods of 1700 smallholder cotton farmers in Benin. It was designed to help small scale cotton farmers in the Djidja, Setto and Sinendé regions of Benin in West Africa to reap the economic, health and environmental benefits of sustainable organic cotton production. The three regions that the project works in suffered catastrophic flooding in 2010, and as a result farmers lost an entire season’s cotton crop and were unable to take part in the programme. The key elements of the project were to: ... reap the economic, health and environmental benefits of sustainable organic cotton production. • Build participating farmers’ capacity to adopt sustainable approaches to cotton production and improve productivity through on-farm training and exchange with successful farmers from regions where organic farming is more established; • Help farmers to overcome the impact of recent floods on soil structure and quality through intensive training in soil remediation and soil management techniques; • Build farmers’ capacity in organic seed collection and management; • Strengthen organic cotton farmers’ organisations; and • Build capacity for advocacy by organic farming organisations. PAN UK | ANNUAL REVIEW 2013 7 Working with local partner L’Organisation Béninoise pour la Promotion de l’Agriculture Biologique (OBEPAB) the project sought to: • Extend the area benefitting from project activities from 206 ha to 500 hectares; • Increase the number of farmers supported in the regions of Djidja, Setto and Sinendé from 315 to 550; • Achieve at least 20% increase in cotton productivity by at least half of the participating farmers; and • Strengthen farmers’ organisations at village, district and national level so they can negotiate effectively on their members behalf. A neem mill in Gogbede, Benin - ground seeds from the neem trees surrounding the village, when mixed with water and soap and sprayed on the cotton plants, is very effective at deterring pests. 8 This technology has already transformed the health and financial well-being of several thousand smallholder cotton farmers in Benin, West Africa. PAN UK | ANNUAL REVIEW 2013 A new approach to tackling pesticide dependency and improving livelihoods in Africa This project, funded by the JJ Charitable Trust, will improve the productivity of Ethiopian smallholder farmers by introducing a safe and effective new approach to pest management based on beneficial insects. Working with the Australian Cotton Research Institute, PAN UK successfully developed a harmless “food spray”, made with cheap local materials such as yeast and sugar, that attracts beneficial insects into African cotton fields to feed on pests. This technology has already transformed the health and financial well-being of several thousand smallholder cotton farmers in Benin, West Africa. This new project will adapt the food spray to Ethiopian environmental and cultural conditions and will train over 2,000 farmers in PAN UK’s cotton programme in the Arba Minch area of the Ethiopian Rift Valley (see below). As the project progresses, we will develop training materials to spread the technology far beyond to benefit cotton growers throughout Africa. Specifically, the project aimed to: ... the project will increase income, improve health and food security for around 2000 smallholder farmers and 300 plantation workers • To launch a pilot project to trial and refine the food spray technology and tailor it to Ethiopian conditions; • To develop and test a training programme and supporting materials to facilitate the widespread adoption of the food spray technology; and • To train 2,000 smallholder cotton farmers in the Arba Minch area of the Ethiopian Rift Valley in how to make effective use of food sprays for pest management, thereby improving their livelihoods, well-being and environment through a reduced reliance on hazardous and expensive pesticides, while also improving the productivity and profitability of their cotton growing. Tackling pesticide dependency in cotton production in the Ethiopian Rift Valley This three year project, funded by TRAID, will help cotton farmers in the Ethiopian Rift Valley adopt alternative methods of pest control to replace highly hazardous synthetic pesticides. Building upon PAN UK’s experience of successfully supporting similar projects across various parts of sub-Saharan Africa, the project will increase income, improve health and food security for around 2000 smallholder farmers and 300 plantation workers in the Awash Valley region of the Ethiopian Rift Valley. PAN UK | ANNUAL REVIEW 2013 9 The key elements of the project are to: • Provide extension support and training in Integrated Pest Management (IPM) and organic methods to 2000 small farmers and 300 plantation workers using participatory approaches such as Farmer Field Schools; • Introduce novel pest control techniques, which have proved successful in other parts of Africa, such as food sprays to attract beneficial insects to control pests; • Make plantation owners aware of the economic benefits of IPM to encourage them to cut pesticide use; • Raise awareness of pesticide hazards through community based health monitoring; and • Establish local farmers’ organisations to represent farmers’ interests and enable them to secure better terms when negotiating sales. Working with local partner PAN Ethiopia, the project will: • Increase farmer income through higher productivity and lower input cost and, in the case of 500 self-selecting farmers, through an organic premium; • Improve food security and food safety as IPM techniques are also applied to food crops; • Improve farmer and plantation worker (and their families’) health by raising awareness of pesticide hazards , providing information on how to minimise exposure to pesticides and reducing reliance on pesticides; and • Improve environmental quality through reduced pesticide pollution. Biodiversity Pesticide impacts on biodiversity in Ethiopian Rift Valley and agro-ecological solutions This three year project funded by the UK Government’s Darwin Initiative to tackle the effects of pesticides on the biodiversity of the Ethiopian Rift Valley. It aimed to improve the capacity of Ethiopian scientists, farming communities, government agencies and other stakeholders to: • 10 Identify key sites at risk from the harmful environmental effects of agrochemical use; Increase farmer income through higher productivity and lower input cost ... PAN UK | ANNUAL REVIEW 2013 • Monitor, measure and understand such impacts close to biodiversity-rich wetlands; • Develop and implement practical solutions based on agroecological farming; and, • Ensure that government policies support biodiversity conservation goals. Pesticide stockpiles in Africa Pesticide stockpiles in Africa and beyond represent a massive failure of pesticide management as well as an enormous burden on community health, local environments, and national budgets. PAN UK’s role in the multi-stakeholder Africa Stockpiles Programme (2004 – 2010) focused on improving community and civil society awareness and initiatives for sound management of pesticides to prevent such stockpiles accumulating again, as they are gradually removed from the continent. PAN UK’s Civil society against obsolete pesticides in Ethiopia, Mali, Nigeria, Senegal & Tanzania project, funded by the UK Government’s Civil Society Challenge Fund, drew to a close in 2013/4. Since 2009, seven small projects by PAN Africa members in the five countries have promoted community monitoring of pesticide impacts, trained store keepers, teachers, and local government agents, and helped civil society increase its collaboration with governments to increase compliance with pesticide legislation and reduce pesticide reliance by promoting non-chemical alternatives. The results of the individual projects are summarised in a new series of briefings by PAN UK. Pesticide stockpiles in Africa and beyond represent a massive failure of pesticide management. A second project component looked specifically at locust control pesticide stockpiles. PAN UK and its partners promoted community awareness of locust pesticide risks and alternatives, and got global support for a PAN International Declaration on Protecting People from Locust Impacts, calling for governments and agencies to: • Seek strategic participation of communities and Civil Society Organisations; • Recognise and deal with problems caused by overreliance on chemical options; • Use non-chemical alternatives first; and • Prioritise long term support for preventing locust problems. The project coordinated three high level events to present the PAN UK | ANNUAL REVIEW 2013 11 recommendations to decision makers, and through timely advocacy efforts with the Desert Locust Control Organisation in East Africa, and CLC Pro in West Africa, was successful in increasing involvement of communities in forecasting in East Africa, and in promoting alternatives in West Africa. Sharing our expertise PAN UK has a wealth of technical and scientific expertise which we contribute to the work of, and projects co-ordinated by, other organisations. In 2013 this included: Growing coffee without endosulfan Funded by, and undertaken on behalf of, the Sustainable Coffee Program powered by IDH, the United Nations Food & Agriculture Organisation (FAO) and the ISEAL Alliance (the umbrella association of social and environmental labeling standards schemes) this project aimed to provide practical guidance on methods of effective pest control in coffee farming without the use of the highly hazardous insecticide endosulfan. PAN UK's Stephanie Williamson and Norvis Vasquez talking to Nicaraguan coffee farmer Rogelio Villareyna about farming without endosulfan Through both desk research and field research in two Latin American regions, and working in partnership with the 4C Association, the project utilised PAN UK’s scientific and technical expertise to produce a variety of practical guidance materials and tools to assist coffee farmers. We interviewed and filmed more than 20 farmers certified under Fairtrade, Rainforest Alliance and Utz Certified standards and produced a set of videos showing their experiences and tips in managing the key Coffee Berry Borer pest using a range of IPM methods. Several of the farmers had formerly witnessed poisonings 12 ... effective pest control in coffee farming without the use of the highly hazardous insecticide endosulfan. PAN UK | ANNUAL REVIEW 2013 with endosulfan and urged other farmers to stop all use of this and other hazardous pesticides. This ‘real world’ information, ranging from smallholder farms to large estates which have successfully eliminated endosulfan, will help provide clear, practical guidance which the coffee sector can use to help more producers to shift away from this Stockholm Convention listed Persistent Organic Pollutant (POP) chemical. The videos (in Spanish and English), farm case studies and guidance on the pros and cons, costs and ease of use of different IPM methods will be uploaded in Spring 2014 on project partner 4C’s Tools Library web pages and linked to the PAN UK website. Action on Highly Hazardous Pesticides (HHPs) We provided tailor-made technical support and policy advice to a variety of not-for-profit organisations, sustainability standards and food companies during 2013 on identifying HHPs in their supply chains and developing plans to phase these out and phase in safer, ecologically based alternatives. PAN UK's analysis ... helped to secure a strong policy commitment from the Stockholm Convention to prioritise agroecological methods. We also played an active role in PAN International’s Working Group on HHPs and contributed to global civil society advocacy for a higher level of protection for human health and the environment in relevant policy forums, including the joint Stockholm POPs and Rotterdam PIC Conventions Conference of the Parties in May 2013 and the Joint Meeting on Pesticide Management of the FAO and WHO in October 2013. PAN UK’s analysis, which identified as HHPs 80 of the 109 pesticides proposed as substitutes for the POPs pesticide endosulfan, helped to secure a strong policy recommendation from the Stockholm Convention representatives’ meeting to prioritise agroecological methods over other pesticides in replacing endosulfan crop use. Pesticide residues in food in developing countries and food safety concerns PAN UK conducted a short literature review for Consumers International in February 2013 on this topic, to provide up to date background information for their small grants scheme for national CI affiliates on safe and healthy food projects. We will make use of the information assessed to produce a PAN UK briefing in 2014. PAN UK | ANNUAL REVIEW 2013 13 A big thank you PAN UK would like to thank all those that have helped to make 2013 such a successful and productive year. Funders The 1970 Trust The Anber Fund John & Susan Bowers Fund Chapman Charitable Trust City Bridge Trust The Co-op The Cuthbert Horne Trust Darwin Initiative DFID Civil Society Challenge Fund The Food & Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations The Bryan Guinness Charitable Trust The Sustainable Coffee Program powered by IDH ISEAL Alliance JJ Charitable Trust Marisla Foundation Organic Trade Board Po-Zu Footwear The Rowan Charitable Trust Charles Stuart Fund TRAID - Textile Recycling for Aid and International Development Unite the Union The Zephyr Charitable Trust Partners 4C Association Addis Ababa University Department of Zoological Sciences Africa Stockpiles Programme, Tanzania Environmental Justice Foundation Ethiopian Wildlife & Natural History Society L’Organisation Béninoise pour la Promotion de l’Agriculture Biologique Natural Resources Group ONG AMEN, Mali Pesticide Action Network - Africa Pesticide Action Nexus - Ethiopia Volunteers/Interns Ruth Aguilar Rina Guadagnini Claudia Quitian Norvis Vasquez 14 Judy Daniels Robert Mitton Arianne Reyes PAN UK | ANNUAL REVIEW 2013 Who's who at PAN UK Staff Dr Keith Tyrell – Director Dr Stephanie Williamson – Staff Scientist Nick Mole – Policy Officer Angela Russ – Programme Manager Paul Lievens – Communications Manager Geremew Tereda - Finance Officer Board of Trustees Lasse Bruun - Senior Campaigner on climate change and agriculture at Greenpeace Brazil Natasha Clayton - Director of Resources at FARM-Africa Dr Charlie Clutterbuck - Research Fellow, Centre for Food Policy, City University Vicki Hird - Senior Food Campaigner, Friends of the Earth Eileen Maybin - Head of Media, Fairtrade Foundation Dr Laura Potts - Dr Laura Potts works on issues of public health and the environment, and is an organic gardener Christopher Stopes - Founder Director of EcoS Consultancy Ltd., and former Head of Research at The Organic Research Centre - Elm Farm Jeanette Longfield OBE (Chair) - Co-ordinator of Sustain: The alliance for better food and farming Prof. Anthony Youdeowei - Independent IPM Consultant in African pesticide policy and food security programmes Adam Wakeley - Managing Director and Chairman of Organic Farm Foods Ltd The PAN UK team at the March of the Beekeepers. L-R Robert Mitton, Paul Lievens, Stephanie Williamson, Keith Tyrell and Nick Mole. Contact PAN UK Follow PAN UK The Brighthelm Centre North Road Brighton BN1 1YD www.pan-uk.org Telephone: 01273 964230 Email: [email protected] www.twitter.com/pan_uk PAN UK | ANNUAL REVIEW 2013 www.facebook.com/ PesticideActionNetworkUK 15 Can you help support the vital work of PAN UK? Donate online You can donate to PAN UK online at: www.justgiving.com/pesticideactionnetworkuk Donate by Standing Order To: Bank/Building Society___________________________ Address_______________________________________________________ Account No___________________________ Sort Code___________________________ Commencing on the__________________ Please pay the sum of _______ and repeat this each month/quarter/year to : PAN UK, Ac/No.6501 0734 00, Sort Code: 08 02 28. Name: ___________________________ Address: ____________________________________________________________ Postcode: __________ Donate by Cheque Please make cheques payable to Pesticides Action Network UK and send them to: Pesticides Action Network UK, The Brighthelm Centre, North Road, Brighton, BN1 1YD Gift aid declaration Please treat as Gift Aid donations all qualifying gifts of money made □ today □ in the future Please tick all boxes you wish to apply. I confirm I have paid or will pay an amount of Income Tax and/or Capital Gains Tax for each tax year (6 April to 5 April) that is at least equal to the amount of tax that all the charities or Community Amateur Sports Clubs that I donate to will reclaim on my gifts for that tax year. I understand that other taxes such as VAT and Council Tax do not qualify. I understand the charity will reclaim 25p of tax on every £1 that I give. Name: ___________________________ Address: ____________________________________________________________ Postcode: __________ Signature___________________________ Date ________________ Please notify PAN UK if you: Want to cancel this declaration Change your name or home address No longer pay sufficient tax on your income and/or capital gains. If you pay Income Tax at the higher or additional rate and want to receive the additional tax relief due to you, you must include all your Gift Aid donations on your Self Assessment tax return or ask HM Revenue and Customs to adjust your tax code. 16 PAN UK | ANNUAL REVIEW 2013
© Copyright 2024 ExpyDoc