Quinn

Building a Sustainable Data Management
Program in the Upstream Oil and Gas
Industry
September 11, 2014
Jessica Quinn, Nicole Sullivan, Ramesh Narasimhan (ERM)
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
The New Air Regulatory Regime for Upstream O&G
Upstream Oil and Gas has seen an
unprecedented increase in regulatory
focus over the last few years..
GHGRP
Subpart W
Internal/
Corporate
Reporting
NSPS
Subpart
OOOO
Fugitives/
Leak
Detection
NESHAP
Subpart
HH
http://latebloomergrads.files.wordpress.com/2012/03/cartoon-pulling-hair-and-questionmarks1.jpg
2
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
NESHAP
Subpart
ZZZZ
Air
Permitting
Similar/ Overlapping Data Parameters
Source/ Inventory
Type
NSPS
Subpart
OOOO
Internal/
Permits
GHGRP
Subpart W
GHG Emissions
Inventories
X
X
Stationary
Engines
X
X
Heaters
X
X
Storage Vessels
X
X
Dehydration
Units
X
X
Pneumatic
Devices
X
X
X
Fugitive
Component Leaks
X
X
X
Venting /
Blowdowns
X
X
X
Well Completions
X
X
X
3
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
X
(Indirectly for
Compressors)
NESHAP
Subpart
ZZZZ
X
NESHAP
Subpart HH
X
(For Major Source
Applicability)
X
(Reboilers)
X
X
X
X
Assuring Compliance and Data Management
Goals and Objectives:
1. Permit/ Regulatory Compliance
2. Voluntary Obligations
3. Business Performance
Reactive
4
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Proactive
Case Studies- Challenges and Successes
Explore successes and challenges in gathering and management of data
across the lifecycle of operations
Case 1- Data Management Challenges
Reactive
Case 2- Successful Data Management
and Compliance Assurance
Proactive
5
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
http://futureofcio.blogspot.com/2013/11/top-five-data-integration-challenges.html
http://www.freevectors.net/details/Free+Colorful+Puzzle+Pieces
Case 1- Stakeholder Communication Challenges
Environmental
6
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Case 1- Management of Change
Personnel Changes
Equipment
Changes
Changes in
data collection
forms and
templates
https://www.aiche.org/resources/chemeondemand/webinars/managing-process-safety-risksduring-organizational-change
Operational
Changes
7
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
What’s the End Goal?
A sustainable program
that will take you from
minimizing value erosion
today to maximizing value
creation tomorrow
8
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Potential Roadblocks
No reason to change
Operations does not like change
Costs
Level of effort
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
9
Case 2- Successful Stakeholder Engagement
Management
Operations
Contractors
Environmental
Legal
Investors
Drilling and
Completions
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
10
Case 2- Sustainable Data Management
Equipment
Data
Management
Management
of Change
Contractor
Management
Activity Data
Management
Compliance
Assurance
Program
EMIS
Reporting
Stakeholder
Engagement
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
QA/QC
Records
11
Discussion– Value of a Sustainable System
Value Identification
Identify
Assess
Investing in a holistic
approach minimizes risk
and increases value
Value Realization
Select
Define
Execute
Working with stakeholders throughout the
scoping and development of an EMIS
system delivers sustainable results
Operate
A
B
Project NPV
C
D
TIME
Project Lifecycle Time
Graphic adapted from :
The influence of front-end development on the value of a project. (Hutchinson and Wabeke, 2006)
12
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Good scope
definition and
execution
Reactionary,
business as
usual
Questions?
Ramesh Narasimhan
Environmental Resources Management
T| +1 504-846-9215
E| [email protected]
Jessica Quinn
Environmental Resources Management
T| +1 504-846-9232
E| [email protected]
Nicole Sullivan
Environmental Resources Management
T| +1 504-846-9268
E| [email protected]
13
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Reality Check - Where you are.. where you need to go..
If all elements do not work together, the system will eventually break down.
Basic
Data Collection
and Assurance
1
Regulatory
Reporting
Recordkeeping
and Data
Management
Management
Of Change
Performance
Reporting/ Metrics
14
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Reactionary
2
Functional
3
Proactive
4
Resilient
5
Example Data Mapping Table
Data Need
FVp - Flowback Volume
Value
What is the process used to
What is the documentation/
What QA/QC procedures are
Who is the owner
obtain this information from
source for this data and where in place to ensure accuracy of (responsible person) for
source/ documentation (in
is it stored?
this data in the
the background
case some processing of data
(electronic/hardcopy)
documentation/ source?
documentation/ source?
is required)?
Volume
Nwo - Number of Workovers
Count
Fuel usage at Completions,
Workovers, and Interventions
Volume
Total number of internal
combustion engines with heat
capacity equal to or less than 1
mmBTU/hr
Count
15
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Example Data Mapping - FVp
Company
Company
Company
16
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Case 2- “Cradle to Grave” Data Mapping
Data
-
Data Collection
and Assurance
-
Where does this data originate?
Does this data relate to a specific equipmenttype?
Who collects this data?
How often is this data collected?
Who reviews this data before it is entered in IS?
Information
Systems
(EMIS)
-
How does this data get into IS?
Where does this data reside in IS?
How does this data relate to other data in IS?
Management
Of Change
-
Does this data expire?
How often is this data reviewed at source?
How often is this data updated in IS?
Does change in equipment (to which this data
relates) trigger an MOC action?
Does that MOC action update this data as
well?
Performance
Reporting/
Metrics
17
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
-
Does this data get reported?
If yes, to what level does this data get rolled
up?
If no, what function does this data serve?
Case 2- Why a Holistic Approach makes sense..
• Build from what you already have – why start from scratch?!
• Data WILL change! Save time & money by streamlining update process.
Reduce compliance risk by mapping the change across all elements of
the data management system.
Sustainable Data Management Strategy
How often
to check for
changes?
Which data
changes are harder
to identify?
Data Collection
and Assurance
How often is
the data
collected?
Who collects the
data, and so who
would know of the
change?
Can we categorize the
change as high,
medium, or low impact
on reporting?
18
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Are there existing
systems and
processes that can
be tapped into?
What’s a
trigger for
check?
How would the
change ripple
through the
system?
Is there a
log of
changes?
Performance
Reporting/
Metrics
Information
Systems
(EMIS)
Case 2- Defining Scope Boundaries
• Identify what aspects of the Air and Climate Change world
you want to capture through the Process
• Do you want to start small and grow big, or conquer big in one sweep?
• Do you want to start first with only regulatory drivers?
It is important that Senior Management
understands and approves the scope!
• If set-up correctly, as sustainable
approach to data management for
AQCC would significantly simplify
the scaling up process in the future
to include more scope.
Sustainability
Drivers
(CSR, CDP)
Permit
Compliance, other
regulatory aspects
Core
Regulatory
Drivers
NSPS OOOO,
Subpart W
19
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Fugitive Emissions
Component Count
Onshore
Production
Optical Imaging/
Method 21/IR Laser
Both
Facility Components
Onshore
Processing
Facility Components
Transmission
Compression
Facility Components
Underground
Storage
Facility
Components
LNG Storage
Facility
Components
LNG Import &
Export
Facility
Components
Distribution
Below Ground
Stations; Services &
Mains
Above Ground Stations
Note: See Subpart W for specific descriptions of components, which vary considerably
between industry types
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Discussion-Data Management Tools Progression
Initial Level:
•
•
•
•
•
Manual data
collection
Separate
spreadsheets
Single person
accountability
Annual or quarterly
reporting
Intermediate Level:
•
Manual data collection
•
•
Stand-alone or niche
system(s)
Automation used for
data gathering
•
Manual and infrequent
data transfer
Integrated single
system – Env Mgmt
•
Annual or quarterly
reporting
Frequent data
collection and transfer
•
Daily or weekly
reporting
•
Proactive alerts
•
•
•
Reactive processes
Reactive processes
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Advanced Level:
21