hs5 RFB 15-04 Park Village Elementary School Chiller Replacement rItlnl-1\ INDrPrNrrNt .!krr.r'rt t)t-irRr[r lro se Proposed Pricr (l(X) Poinfst Make/Pricing I EER, 95oF 1or Option #2 -236 Ton Air Cooled Sorew-Tlpe Chiller, 9 EER, 105"F (or better) with a complete 5 year warranty Option 13 -236 Ton Magnetic Bearing Chiller,0.83-1.35 (or better) with a complete 5 vear warranty kWton, l05oF Altemate #l Temporary Chiller Unit (Weekly Rate) of (lrxxlsiScrriccs- York s194,100 York Arctic Cool Ternporary Chiller - Installation, Start-Up and Rernotal 2l llrnr.rir.ncr. lnrlRt.trulatiorr-()u:rlih icine Make Option #l - 236 Ton Air Cooled Screrv-Ty,pe Chiller, I better) with a complete 5 year warranty Make icrne Prici Pricing Make $171,000 York No Bid Arctic Cool York $185,050 $188,242 Trane $190,960 York s283,204 Arctic Cool s343,456 N/A $187,200 Carrier $245,000 Arctic Cool Pricing $195,567 $190,562 s155,440 Make York Trane Trane Make Make Make Trane $I $192,839 York $195,352 s287,567 Arctic Cool $288,631 84,341 Trane s180,790 Trane $180,790 Arctic Cool $300,410 Smardt s29l -155 N/A No Bid Carrier $198,370 Arctic Cool 9297,700 l s.s71 sl5,67l $7.s00 Not Indicated $4.02s s2.940 $2.s75 $6.300 s4,200 PASS PASS PASS PASS PASS PASS PASS PASS PASS PASS FAIL PASS $1,200 $3,573 $3.1 25 $2"070 Not Indicated $1.800 $2.877 PASS PASS PASS PASS $ Flfc. tPASSor[',\l[,1 Does the vendor meet the expectations and qualifications as indicated in ttre Bid Documents conceming Experience and Reputation, Quality of Goods/Services, Safety Record, Proposed Personnel, Financial Capability for the Size and Scope of Project and ability to comply with project timelines. Re uuircme ntr {PASS or F'Al Lt Did the vendor submit all required documentation at time of bid 3t Subnrittal submittal (bid bondrng documents, disclosure forms, acceptance forms, etc.) I have reviewed the submittals for this offering and recommend the following vendor(s) for award TDlndustries. Inc. to provide Ontion #3 which specifies a 236 ton Maenetic Bearins Chiller Michael L. Ashmore, MBA, CPPO, Director of Purchasing Daniel Kershner, Executive Director of Operations /o.2-/r U /]I1