sat_room4_1100 MVD general Dunedin

Microvascular decompression surgery
Dirk De Ridder
www.brai²n.be
Microvascular Compression
Signs of microvascular compression (Jannetta, Moller)
Unilateral
Dysfunction of cranial nerve
Paroxysmal and intermittent
Typical evolution: more and longer
Triggers
Responsive to carbamazepine (sensory)
Average age > 50 years
atypical clinic : venous compression (women)
Examples: HFS, TN, DPV, GPN,…
Can be familial
Often bilateral (alternating, never simultaneous)
Multiple nerves
Diagnosis = Clinical picture + MRI
Typical clinical picture
+
Correlation between MRI and
peroperative findings (Leal 2010, n=100)
Sensitivity = 96.7%
Specifity = 100%
MRI in MVC
Rightsided light flashes
Rightsided trigeminal neuralgia
Rightsided hemifacial spasm
MVC more common on right side (Hamlyn 1999)
MVC more in women (except Asia) (Hamlyn 1999)
MRI in MVC
Disabling positional vertigo + tinnitus
Cranial nerves
History
1934: Dandy - Trigeminal neuralgia is
caused by MVC of trigeminal nerve
1959: Gardner – first MVDs for TN and HFS
1967: Jannetta popularizes MVD after
introduction of use of microscope by Kurze
in 1957
Microvascular compression syndromes
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
olfactory nerve: paroxysmal unilateral dysosmia ?
optic nerve: paroxysmal light flashes leading to visual progressive deficit (Colapinto 1996)
oculomotor nerve: oculomotor palsy (Nakagawa 1991)
trochlear nerve: superior oblique myokimia (Scharwey 2000)
trigeminal nerve: trigeminal neuralgia (Gardner 1959, Jannetta 1967)
abducens nerve: abducens spasms (De Ridder 2007)
facial nerve: hemifacial spasm (Gardner 1962, Jannetta 1970)
vestibulocochlear nerve: disabling positional vertigo, tinnitus, geniculate neuralgia
(Jannetta 1980)
9. glossopharyngeal nerve: glossopharyngeal spasm (Jannetta 1980)
10. vagal nerve: hypertension (Jannetta 1980), diabetes type 2 (Jannetta 2010) , atrial fibrillation ?,
angina (De Ridder, unpublished data)
11. accessory nerve: spasmodic torticollis (Freckmann 1981)
12. hypoglossal nerve: hemilingual spasm (De Ridder 2002, Osburn 2010)
Trigeminal neuralgia
Somatotopic organization of trigeminal
nerve
Compression site determines pain
location (Jannetta 1993)
V1: caudal compression
V2: medial or lateral compression
V3: rostral compression
Trigeminal neuralgia
Clinical picture
Unilateral
Very short knife-like stabbing pain
paroxysms (less than second)
Triggered by cold, wind, food, drinks
Typical evolution: Paroxysms become
more frequent and longer lasting
Start in 1 branch but can extend to other
Can develop hypoesthesia
Responsive to carbamazepine
Can become less typical
Ask for how it started
Differential diagnosis
Trigeminal autonomic headaches
Autonomic features, alcohol, night
Eagle syndrome
MVD results
Trigeminal neuralgia
Outcome :
70% pain-free after 10 years (n=1185,
Barker 1996)
74% pain-free after 15 years (n=947,
Sindou 2007, 2008, 2010)
Predictive factors
marked vascular compression at
surgery >90% success rate at 15
years of FU (Sindou 2007)
vessel only in contact, only 60% cure
rate at 15 years
Can be seen with MRI (Leal 2010)
Grade 1: contact
Grade 2: indentation
Grade 3: deviation
MVD results
Predictive factors TN (Sindou 2007)
Severity of compression (p = 0.001)
Amount of arachnoiditis (p = 0.002).
Preop TN duration doesn’t matter (p = 0.67)
Age doesn’t matter (p = 0.09)
Amount of atrophy doesn’t matter (p = 0.36)
Alternative treatments
Gamma knife vs MVD (Linskey 2008)
MVD is superior in prospective nonrandomized trial (n=80, 36 MVD)
γ-knife older (74 vs 54), longer (7.5 vs 2.6),
higher comorbidity (58.3 vs 2.8%)
Pain-free after 1, 2, 5 years
MVD: 100, 88, 80%
γ-knife: 78, 50, 33%
Alternative treatments
Percutaneous rhizotomy vs MVD (Lee 1997, Tronnier
2001, Tatli 2008)
Pain-free postop and facial dysesthesia
MVD: 96.5% & 0.3%
RFR: 92.3% & 5.7%
Long-term FU
50% recurrence rate > 2 years and 75% >4years
after RFR
64% pain-free after 20 years
Comparison of treatments for TN
Treatment for TN
1.
Medication: carbamazepine,
gabapentin, baclofen
2.
3.
Typical TN in healthy person
1.
MVD
2.
Pc RFR
3.
SRS
Atypical TN or comorbidity
1.
Pc RFR
2.
SRS
Hemifacial spasm
Clinical picture
Unilateral
Twitching of eye (typical, 98%) or
orbicularis oris (atypical, 2%) muscles
Typical evolution: initially superior
part of orbicularis oculi, later, inferior
part, later orbicularis oris
Can lead to hemifacial palsy
Differential diagnosis
Synkinesias: after facial palsy
Treatment
Carbamazepine, Botox, MVD
botox: 3 m,
Typical HFS (eye)
Inferior compression
Atypical HFS (mouth)
Superior compression
MVD results
Hemifacial spasm (Miller 2012)
N= 5685 meta-analysis
Outcome (3 year FU):
Complete resolution: 91.1%
Recurrence in 2.4% and 1.2% repeat MVD
Complications:
Transient complications:
facial palsy (9.5%),
hearing deficit (3.2%)
cerebrospinal fluid leak (1.4%)
Permanent complications:
hearing deficit (2.3%)
facial palsy (0.9%)
stroke (< 0.1%)
death (< 0.1%)
Disabling positional vertigo
Clinical picture
Short spells of vertigo (seconds)
Triggered by optokinetic stimuli
Typical evolution: more frequent and longer
lasting
Associated other MVC symptoms of nVIII-VII
Tinnitus
Geniculate neuralgia
Hearing loss at tinnitus frequency
Hemifacial spasm (cryptogenic !)
ABR changes
Differential diagnosis
Meniere’s Disease
Aura, longer lasting, tinnitus together with
vertigo
Low frequency hearing loss
No ABR
MVD results
Disabling positional vertigo (Jannetta 1996)
N=177
79% markedly improved or cured
11% recurred at 3 year FU
in one study (Ryu 1998) 73% of successful MVDs
had preoperative diagnosis of Ménière’s
Disease
MVD results
Glossopharyngeal neuralgia (Resnick, Ferroli
2009, Kandan 2010)
N= 92 (40,21,31)
Pain-free 79, 90, 90 %
Recurrence: 6% at 7.5 years
Typewriter tinnitus
Typewriter tinnitus (Levine 2006, Nam
2009, Brantberg 2009)
Unilateral
Paroxysms
Intermittent
Trigger
Morse code, machine gun-like,
stacatto or typewriter sound
Very responsive to
carbamazepine
Due to intrameatal loop (Levine
2006) or nerve traction (Nam 2009)
MVD results
MVD for tinnitus
Outcome poor: combined results from
all studies: 30% cured, 30% improved
Study
No cases
Symptoms
Tests
Vessels
found
Results of MVD
Okamura et al, 19
2000
HL 58%
Tinnitus 95%
ABR
100%
44% cured
47% improved
64% improved HL
Ryu et al,
1999
HL 77.5%
Tinnitus 100%
ABR
75%
45% cured
12% improved
Brookes, 1996 9
HL 71%
Tinnitus 100%
ABR, MRI
100%
33% cured
45% improved
Guevara et al,
2007
15
HL
Tinnitus 100%
ABR,MRI
100%
20% cured
33,3% improved
De Ridder et
al, 2009
22
HL
Tinnitus 100%
ABR, MRI
100%
5% cured
45% improved
Moller et al,
1993
72
HL 77%
Tinnitus 100%
ABR
100%
18% cured
33% improved
40
MVD and Tinnitus
Results depend on
1. Tinnitus duration (Moller 1993, Brookes 1996, Jannetta 1997, Ryu 1998, De Ridder 2009)
If tinnitus < 3 year : outcome good
If tinnitus 3-5 year : outcome moderate
If tinnitus > 5 year : outcome poor
2. Hearing level (Ryu 1998)
If serviceable or normal hearing : outcome good
If severely impaired ( 60dB or more) : outcome poor
3. MRI
demonstrates compression 78% good outcome (Brookes 1996, Ko 1997)
4. Gender
If woman better outcome: 55 vs 29% (Moller 1993)
DECOMPRESS AS SOON AS POSSIBLE
MVD complications
Complications (Kalkanis 2003)
N= 277 surgeons
N= 1580 MVDs(1326 TN, 237 HFS, 27 GPN)
Mortality rate: 0.3%,
Discharge other than to home: 3.8%.
Neurological complications: 1.7%
Hematomas: 0.5%
Facial palsies: 0.6%
Ventriculostomy: 0.4%
Postoperative ventilation: 0.7%
Is it just the compression ?
Arguments against MVD (Monstad 2007)
1. MRA studies indicate that vascular contact
with the trigeminal nerve is present in most
healthy individuals (Peker 2009) and as
common on the non affected side (Anderson
2006)
2. Treatment results of MVD in multiple
sclerosis patients with TGN are almost as
good (at least in the short term, they
relapse more often) as in idiopathic cases
(Broggi 2000, 2004)
3. MVD is reported to provide pain relief even
in TGN patients without visible
neurovascular contact (Revuelta-Gutierrez 2006)
Pathophysiology of microvascular compression syndromes
www.brai²n.be
Pathophysiology
MVC
Ephaptic transmission (cross-talk)
Chronic
Ectopic excitation (in axon)
Paroxysmal hyperactivity
Focal demyelination
Vascular compression
Hypofunction
Demyelination
Moller 1999
Only compression ?
DTI evaluates microstructure of nerve via
FA, fractional anisotropy; RD, radial
diffusivity; MD, mean diffusivity; AD, axial
diffusivity.
Asymptomatic patients have normal
microstructure, thus no demyelination, no
axonal damage, no inflammation, no edema
(Lin 2014)
Symptomatic TN have disturbed
microstructure suggesting inflammation
and edema not visible on gross imaging
(DeSouza 2014)
And only on symptomatic side (Fujiwara 2011)
Histopathology
Endoneurial fibrosis
Chronic compression
Day 0
Congestion of nerve
Bloodvessel
Stasis of endothelial capillaries
Secretion of protein-rich edema
fluid in endoneurial space
Fluid organizes
Endoneurial fibrosis
Nerve root
Day 30
Extravasation
(Evans blue albumine)
Day 300
MVC
of
Vestibulocochlear nerve
www.brai²n.be
Anatomy of the Vestibulocochlear Nerve Complex
Vestibular Nerve
Superior Vestibular Nerve
18000 fibers (gray)
10500 fibers
Utricular Nerve
3500 fibers
Horizontal & Superior Ampullary N
3500 fibers each
Inferior Vestibular Nerve
7500 fibers
Saccular Nerve
3000 fibers
Posterior Ampullary Nerve
3500 fibers
Cochlear Nerve
Facial Nerve
31000 fibers (white)
7000 fibers
Intermediate Nerve
3000 fibers
Symptoms of MVC n VIII-VII
Symptoms associated with MVC n VIII – (VII)
(Mollers and Jannetta)
Intermittent paroxysmal spells of unilateral
typewriter tinnitus lasting only seconds
2. Associated ipsilateral symptoms
Facial nerve: cryptogenic or overt HFS
Intermediate nerve: otalgia with or without
deep prosopalgesia (geniculate
neuralgia) or feeling of pressure in the
ear
Vestibular nerve: vertiginous spells : short
lasting, optokineticly induced
Cochlear nerve: frequency specific hearing loss
3. Typical evolution: spells more frequent,
intermittent periods shorter, finally
constant
Anatomy of the Vestibulocochlear Nerve
Functional Histology
Peripheral part : Schwann cells in
myelin (wave I in BAEP)
REZ : at internal acoustic meatus
Vestibular more distal
Cochlear more proximal
Central part : oligodendroglia
without epinerium but with
pia mater (wave II in BAEP)
peripheral
REZ
REZ
central
REZ
REZ
Peripheral Segment
Nervous tissue
PNS nerve fiber = axon + Schwann cell
Each fiber undulates
Provides elasticity and protection from traction
form bundles = funiculi
divide and branch
Funicular plexus
Peripheral Segment
Supporting tissue
Endoneurium
Collagen rich connective tissue
Surrounds axon and Schwann cell
Fills funiculi = fasciculi
Perineurium
Thin sheath
Compartimentalizes funiculi
Imparts tensile strenghth
Epineurium
Loose areolar tissue
Surrounds funiculi
Forms nerve trunk
Central Segment
Nervous tissue
CNS nerve fiber = axon + oligodendrocyte
Collected in bundle
Travel more parallel
No funicular plexus
Supporting tissue
No endoneurium
No perineurium
No epineurium
Pia mater surrounds white matter bundle
More susceptible to injury
Less vascularized
Anatomy of vestibulocochlear Nerve
MVC has to be at REZ to be
symptomatic (Jannetta 1979)
CNS segment is sensitive to MVC, PNS
segment less (Leclercq 1980, Moller
Anti-oligo AL
1994, Ryu 1999, De Ridder 2002)
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
8
6
4
2
so
ph
ar
yn
ge
al
glo
s
fac
ial
ina
l
0
n. VIII
Ménière: 15/100,000
1/3=MVC ?
incidence
10
ge
m
REZ
12
tri
co
ch
lea
ris
distance to REZ
Incidence is related to length of CNS
segment (De Ridder 2002)
Brainstem Evoked Auditory Potentials
I
Brainstem Auditory Evoked Potentials
II
III
= result of a synchronized firing pattern as a
reaction to an auditory stimulus (Moller 2000)
The more synchrony the higher the peak
Neural generators of BAEP (Moller)
I : peripheral cochlear nerve
II : central cochlear nerve
III : cochlear nucleus
IV : superior olivary complex
V : lateral lemniscus
VI : inferior colliculus
IV
V
VI
Brainstem Evoked Auditory Potentials
Vascular compression
Criteria for MVC (M Moller 1990)
II amplitude < 33%
I
II
III
Ipsi I-III IPL > 2.3 ms
Contra III-V IPL > 2.2 ms
Focal demyelination
I-III difference > 0.2 ms
III-V difference > 0.2 ms
I-III difference > 0.16 ms if low or absent II
III-V difference > 0.16 ms if low or absent II
Aβ
Aα
Aδ
myelinated
Unmyelinated C-fibers
Tests in CVCS
BAEP (Schwaber 1992)
Wave I-III interval difference > 0,2 ms
Wave I-III interval difference > 0,16 ms if low or absent wave II
Wave II amplitude < 33 % contralateral side
Contralateral wave III-V interval difference > 0,2 ms
Contralateral wave III-V interval difference > 0,16 ms if low or absent wave II
Ipsilateral wave I-III absolute interval > 2,3 ms
Contralateral wave III-V absolute interval > 2,2 ms
Audiogram (Schwaber 1992)
High frequency hearing loss
Mid frequency notch hearing loss
Low frequency hearing loss
Flat hearing loss
65 %
27 %
8%
--
(12 %)
(29 %)
(11%)
(50%)
66 %
57 %
30 %
24 %
2%
MVC and preop BAEP changes
Vascular compression
First two years no significant
BAEP changes (Pearson p=0.490)
After two years peak II decreases
ipsilateral to the symptomatic
compression (p=0.012, Chi Square)
Dyssynchronized firing
IPL I –III prolongs if peak II absent
(definite: t=2.702,
Student T)
df=21, p=0.013,
Demyelination related slowing
The longer the compression the
worse the damage (IPL I-III)
(probable: n=16, r=0.501, Pearson P=0.048)
De Ridder, 2007
De Ridder 2007
MVC and Symptoms
Vascular compression
Induces frequency specific
hearing loss (De Ridder 2005) due to
the tonotopic structure of the
auditory nerve (De Ridder 2004)
Low frequency hearing loss in
hemifacial spasm (Moller 1985)
De Ridder 2005
MVC and Symptoms
Vascular compression symptoms…
Induces frequency specific hearing
loss (De Ridder 2005)
The more hearing loss at tinnitus
frequency the worse the tinnitus is
perceived (TQ) (definite n=16,
corr=0.750, p= 0.001)
… correlate with neurophysiology
The longer the compression the more
damage (probable: n=16, r=0.501, Pearson
P=0.048)
The more damage (IPL I-III) to the
auditory nerve the worse the
tinnitus (TQ) (probable: n=17, ρ=0.782,
p<0.001; definite: n=9, ρ=0.811, p=0.008)
De Ridder 2007
MVC and Symptoms
The longer one has tinnitus
associated with MVD the louder it
is perceived (De Ridder 2010)
De Ridder 2010
Tinnitus and peak II
Tinnitus is related to dyssynchronized
firing in n VIII
And not to nerve damage and
deafferentation
Cfr TMS 2/15 only vs nl 50%
20,00
Pre/postop tinnitus intensity difference (dB)
Tinnitus improvement correlates with
postoperative peak II improvement
Tinnitus improvement is not correlated
to IPL I-III improvement
10,00
0,00
-10,00
-20,00
0,00
2,00
4,00
6,00
8,00
Pre/postop peak II ratio
Relation between pre/postop peak II ratio
and pre/postop tinnitus intensity difference (dB)
n=9; rs=-0.714; p=0.031 (Spearman)
De Ridder 2007
Hearing loss and IPL I-III
Hearing loss at tinnitus frequency is result
from nerve damage and not from
dyssynchronized signal transmission
40,00
Pre/postop hearing loss difference (dB)
Hearing loss improvement correlates with
postoperative IPL I-III improvement
Hearing loss improvement correlates not
with peak II recurrence
30,00
20,00
10,00
0,00
-10,00
-20,00
-30,00
-0,05
0,00
0,05
0,10
0,15
0,20
0,25
Pre/postop IPL I-III difference (ms)
Relation between pre/postop IPL I-III difference
and pre/postop hearing loss difference (dB)
n=9; rs=0.857; p=0,003 (Spearman)
De Ridder 2007
Microvascular decompressions (De Ridder 2007)
MVC causes initial dyssynchronized firing resulting in
tinnitus (peak II decreases)
Followed by nerve damage resulting in hearing loss
at tinnitus frequency (IPL I-III prolongs)
The longer the compression lasts the more damage
and the more hearing loss (at tinnitus
frequency)
The more damage and hearing loss the worse the
tinnitus is subjectively perceived
So in MVC the tinnitus initially is likely due to
dyssynchronized firing pattern transmitted to
auditory cortex
Later on it might due to deafferentation
Microvascular
compression
Peak II amplitude
decrease
Dysfunction
focal
demyelination
Tinnitus
prolongation
IPL I-IIIi
Hearing loss at
tinnitus frequency
Ephaptic
transmission
Compensation
Chronic ectopic
excitation
Reorganisation
cochlear nucleus
Colliculus inferior
Verlenging
IPL III-Vc
Improved
symmetrical signal
transmission
De Ridder 2007
What about contralateral IPL III-V ?
Hypothesis
Contralateral IPL III-V
prolongation is compensation for
slowing in ipsilateral I-III segment
Compensation cannot by slowing
contralateral I-III (no cell bodies)
Could theoretically by speeding
up ipsilateral III-V
Slow down
De Ridder 2012
Compensation in brainstem
IPL I-III
IPL I-III+ PEAK II
IPL I-V
IPL III-V
M
SD
M
SD
M
SD
M
SD
Preoperative
Ipsilateral
Contralateral
2.58
2.11
.32
.11
3.58
3.03
.31
.27
4.44
4.36
.15
.34
1.80
2.05
.18
.14
Post-operative
Ipsilateral
Contralateral
2.47
2.11
.06
.13
3.13
3.35
.51
.34
4.39
4.07
.12
.09
1.91
1.90
.17
.09
Preop ipsilateral peak II decreases and IPL I-III prolongs
Preop contralateral IPLIII-V longer (as a compensation ?)
Postop ipsilateral peak II and IPL I-III normalizes
Postop contralateral IPLIII-V normalizes
De Ridder 2012
Microvascular decompressions (De Ridder 2007)
MVC causes initial dyssynchronized firing resulting in
tinnitus (peak II decreases)
Followed by nerve damage resulting in hearing loss
at tinnitus frequency (IPL I-III prolongs)
The longer the compression lasts the more damage
and the more hearing loss (at tinnitus
frequency)
The more damage and hearing loss the worse the
tinnitus is subjectively perceived
So in MVC the tinnitus initially might be due to
dyssynchronized firing pattern transmitted to
auditory cortex
Later on it is due to deafferentation
Compensation occurs in the brainstem, evidenced
by reversible contralateral IPL III-V prolongation
Microvascular
compression
Peak II amplitude
decrease
Dysfunction
focal
demyelination
Tinnitus
prolongation
IPL I-IIIi
Hearing loss at
tinnitus frequency
Ephaptic
transmission
Compensation
Chronic ectopic
excitation
Reorganisation
cochlear nucleus
Colliculus inferior
Verlenging
IPL III-Vc
Improved
symmetrical signal
transmission
De Ridder 2012
Summary
De Ridder 2012
Conclusion
MVC is clinical diagnosis (unilateral, paroxysmal, hyperactivity,
triggers, carbamazepine, more and longer, hypofunction)
likely exists for all cranial nerves
ABR & MRI for confirmation and delineation of nerve
injury
Treatment results
For TN, HFS, GPN, DPV: ≥ 75% 10 year cure rate
For tinnitus worse:
Between 5 and 45% cured
Between 12 and 45% improved
Few worsened
Easy indication for TN, HFS, GPN, DPV, difficult
indication for tinnitus
www.brai²n.org
Importance of REZ ?
Compression anywhere along cranial
nerve, but especially anywhere
along CNS segment
1.
2.
3.
4.
Histological arguments
Neurophysiological arguments
Epidemiological arguments
Clinical experience
Importance of REZ ?
1. Histological arguments
1.
2.
3.
4.
CNS segment has no endo-,
peri- or epineurium
Nerves do not divide nor
branch, so they do not form a
funicular plexus
Nerves do not undulate, so
have less elasticity
Oligodendroglia form less
lamellae than schwann cells ?
Importance of REZ ?
2. Neurophysiological arguments
1.
BAEP monitoring
traction most dangerous for hearing loss
(Raudzens 1982)
four patients lose all waves after Peak I
2.
Möller’s criteria for CVCS
1.
2.
3.
IPL I-III increase (66%) not specific enough
wave II disappearance (57%) second most
frequent anomaly (Schwaber 1992)
Rat experiments by Möller
I
II III
Importance of REZ ?
3. Epidemiological argument
3
distance to REZ
the longer the CNS segment
the higher the incidence of MVC
5
4,5
4
3,5
3
2,5
2
2,5
2
1,5
1
1,5
1
0,5
incidence
3,5
0,5
0
0
trigeminal
facial
glossopharyngeal
De Ridder 2002
Skinner 1931
Tarlov 1937
8
6
4
2
so
ph
ar
yn
ge
al
glo
s
fac
ial
ina
l
0
* In some series upto 73% of CVCS had a preop diagnosis of Ménière (Ryu, 1998)
incidence
10
ge
m
Ménière has an incidence of
15.3/100.000
i.e. 1/3 of Ménière’s disease might
be CVCS*
12
tri
5-7/100.000 ?
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
co
ch
lea
ris
Expected incidence of CVCS ?
distance to REZ
Importance of REZ ?
Importance of REZ ?
At proximal segment
4. Clinical experience
Decompression along CNS segment results
in good outcome (not only at REZ)
Sometimes even at peripheral segment
REZ
n. VIII
At distal segment
REZ
n. VII
MVC location & clinical picture
www.brai²n.be
MVC location and tinnitus type
Vascular compression
At CNS segment can result in nonpulsatile tinnitus (Moller 1993, De Ridder
2004)
At PNS segment can result in pulsatile
tinnitus (Nowe 2005, De Ridder 2005)
or typewriter tinnitus (Levine 2006)
Intrameatal loop
42
50
40
30
20
10
15
2
4
0
pulsatile tinnitus
non-pulsatile tinnitus
intrameatal loop no loop
P < 0.00001, Fisher’s exact test
Typewriter tinnitus
Typewriter tinnitus (Levine 2006, Nam
2009, Brantberg 2009)
Unilateral
Paroxysms
Intermittent
Trigger
Morse code, machine gun-like,
stacatto or typewriter sound
Very responsive to
carbamazepine
Due to intrameatal loop (Levine
2006) or nerve traction (Nam 2009)
Non-pulsatile tinnitus
www.brai²n.be
Used classification
Classification
Possible CVCS : initially intermittent
unilateral tinnitus spells without
associated symptoms.
Probable CVCS : possible CVCS with
associated symptoms (otalgia,
vertigo or hemifacial spasms) or
MRI demonstrating vascular
compression of cochleovestibular
nerve (using high resolution
heavily T2 weighted CISS images)
or abnormal ABR
Definite CVCS : probable CVCS with
associated symptoms and/or
abnormal ABR and/or abnormal
MRI
Certain CVCS : definite CVCS which is
surgically proven
De Ridder 2007
Why is this so ?
Tinnitus intensity and tinnitus distress
Poor correlation between tinnitus
matched sound intensity and tinnitus
related distress (Moller 1994)
Correlation between VAS and TQ is
nonlinear (unpublished Vanneste)
INTRAMEATAL VASCULAR COMPRESSION
1. Typewriter tinnitus
www.brai²n.be
INTRAMEATAL VASCULAR COMPRESSION
2. Pulsatile tinnitus
www.brai²n.be
Pulsatile tinnitus
15% unknown
Vascular loop in internal auditory canal ?
Hypothesis
Vascular loop induces turbulent
flow in internal auditory canal
Transmitted to apex of cave
where cochlea is located
Via bone conduction to cochlea
What about surgery ?
Surgical Results (De Ridder 2005)
4 patients operated
4 free of pulsations
2 recurrences
De Ridder 2005
If this is correct
Why do we not hear our carotids ?
Because of the pericarotid venous plexus
De Ridder 2005
Is that really so ?
Hyperdynamic flow in
Hypertension
Sports
Basilar artery hypoplasia / stenosis
Venous plexus dampens insufficiently
De Ridder 2005
Secundary cochleovestibular compression syndrome
1. Isolated compression
2. Induced compression
1. Overcrowding fossa posterior and/or
Chiari (Sindou, De Ridder 2007)
2. Space occupying lesions (De Ridder 2008)
Tinnitus and Chiari (Wiggs 1996)
Pulsatile tinnitus
Venous humm
Cause = ICP / Hydrocephalus
Worse on bending over
Disappears on ipsilateral
jugular vene compression
Hearing improves on jugular
vene compression
(masking)
No BAEP changes
Non-Pulsatile tinnitus
Intermittent
Cause = 1. MVC ? (crowding
posterior fossa)
2. brainstem traction ?
BAEP changes in 75 %
100 % III-V prolongation
36 % I-III prolongation
June 13-16, 2012
BRUGES
http://www.brai2n.com/tri2012
Anatomy of Cranial Nerve
Cranial nerve consists of two
kinds of tissue
Nervous tissue
Supporting tissue
different for central and
peripheral segments
Peripheral Segment
Nervous tissue
PNS nerve fiber = axon +
Schwann cell
Each fiber undulates
Provides elasticity and
protection from traction
form bundles = funiculi
divide and branch
Funicular plexus
perineurium
endoneurium
Surgical results
Patient
Age
Gender
Tinnitus
Duration
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
48
49
56
63
48
64
63
64
46
45
55
72
40
44
62
48
60
65
48
40
F
M
F
M
F
F
M
M
M
F
M
M
F
F
F
M
F
F
M
F
15
3
9
2
2
4
4
3
14
7
2
11
2
5
4
5
2
3
1
11
VAS
Preoperative
8
8
7
9
7
7
9
5
9
10
8
10
7
7
8
10
7
8
4
8
TQ
Postoperative
8
7
10
8
7
4
9
6
7
10
3
10
1
5
7
10
7
4
4
6
Preoperative
29
63
52
46
71
73
29
33
63
59
77
77
44
37
49
Postoperative
36
54
73
59
58
69
70
35
25
57
55
63
11
63
54
66
63
16
De Ridder 2010
5% cured, 45% improved
No improvement after 4 years !
Tinnitus intensity improves little
Tinnitus distress not