Stuart Heath talks to DerivSource

!
!
!
!
!
!!
!!Derivatives Going
Why
Are
Listed
Dividend
!!
!!
!!
!!
Mainstream?
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!
!
February 2016
As listed dividend derivatives become a mainstream liquid asset class, more and more players are using these lowrisk, centrally-cleared instruments to hedge dividend exposure and protect income streams. DerivSource talks to
Stuart Heath, Executive Director and Head of the London Representative Office of Deutsche Börse AG.
Q. Demand in listed dividend derivatives has grown
considerably in recent years. Do you think this asset class is
becoming more mainstream? If so why?
The answer is yes – dividend derivatives have become an asset
class that is identifiable in its own right. There is significant risk in
dividends within financial instruments globally, and particularly in
Europe. There are a lot of structured instruments available in
Europe, and dividends form a risk element of these. The growth in
dividend derivatives has been symptomatic of the growth in
structured products. As listed dividend derivatives become more
liquid, we are seeing additional uses of these products, along the
lines of hedging the dividend exposure or income streams for
asset managers. As the granularity of the instruments themselves,
and the total assets they cover has increased, they have become
of more use to more players.
!
!
Q. Who are the major users of listed dividend derivatives?
What is their motivation for using them?
The usage of listed dividend derivatives has broadened
significantly. The key primary users were structured equity
derivatives desks at European banks, which used them mainly for
hedging. For example, if they are listing or issuing auto-callables,
they have a dividend risk dynamic that changes with the underlying
stock, and they use dividend derivatives to hedge those risks.
!
This initially led to almost a structural imbalance. There were sellside firms trying to hedge dividends—who were generally better
sellers of dividends. The main buyers were those that could
actually wear the risk in the meantime, for example hedge funds,
that understood what the dividends were likely to be at the expiry
of these instruments, and would take on the immediate risk from
the banks.
!
Now that they are priced far more in line with what the market
expects, and more players have come into the market, you are
seeing a broader range of people using the instruments to hedge.
For example, straightforward option traders would now potentially
look at where the dividend values or the dividend index futures are
trading, before pricing up an equity index option.
!
Under the European regime, where dividends themselves have
become less certain and more risky, you now have asset
managers trading individual dividend futures just to lock in the
income streams that they have. With more granularity in the
instruments provided, there is now a wider set of applications for
them and a wider set of users.
!
“Listed Dividend Derivatives are low-volatility instruments, which
enable you to achieve returns, or express your view with regards
to income, potential growth of the company, and therefore
distributions of the company, without necessarily exposing yourself
to the market fluctuations of the underlying stock itself”.
!
!
!
Q. What is the biggest attraction to listed dividend
derivatives?
CCP risk management is a key element. The fact they are centrally
cleared makes the dividend derivatives we list on Eurex low risk.
This is important because a lot of these instruments are fairly longdated. Index dividend futures at Eurex go out to ten years, so you
have the opportunity to manage ten-year exposure to the dividend
payout.
On top of that, you have the simplicity of the instruments
themselves. With index futures, if you look at the price on the
screen, that represents the number of index points that the
dividends are anticipated to achieve in terms of the underlying
index itself. When it comes to individual or single-stock dividend
futures, the price you see on the screen reflects the annual
expected dividend for each of those companies listed.
!
So it’s a combination of both the simplicity of the instrument, which
therefore makes the liquidity and pricing more obvious, and of
course the risk management element that a listed CCP-backed
derivatives product has.
!
!
Q. Is there an advantage to using listed dividend derivatives
that you believe generally investors are not aware of and
should be?
With listed dividend derivatives, we are looking at an annual slice
of the dividends payable for an individual equity, or on top of that,
the constituent equities within an index. It’s clearly a beneficial
instrument for the hedging of income streams.
!
But also, if you are looking at the prospective growth—or in this
case decline—of prospects within the European companies
sphere, listed dividend derivatives are low-volatility instruments,
which enable you to achieve returns, or express your view with
regards to income, potential growth of the company, and therefore
distributions of the company, without necessarily exposing yourself
to the market fluctuations of the underlying stock itself.
!
!
By isolating a particular element, an asset manager may feel he’s
got more of an advantage in terms of achieving alpha.
Q. A key difference between exchange-listed dividend futures
and OTC traded dividend swaps is the counterparty risk. As
the market is more risk-aware, do you expect more investors
to move towards futures?
!
I think what we’ve seen in Europe is probably going to be
symptomatic of what you will see globally. With the benchmark
Eurozone index, EURO STOXX 50 ®, the bulk of the market has
now moved to listed futures and away from the swaps market.
Obviously there are some swaps still trading, but these tend to be
far more bespoke—they are matching exact periods that dividend
futures do not cover because of some specific instrument. We
have also seen overall market volumes increase from their original
OTC volumes.
!
As you add more instruments, and more granularity—Eurex now
lists single stock dividend futures, rather than just the EURO
STOXX 50 ®, as well as constituents of other major European
indices—and given the importance of counterparty risk, particularly
when that risk is for a longer date, I think you will see more of a
move towards futures globally.
!
Europe is the most developed dividend derivatives market at this
point, but other geographic regions are now also starting to move
into that sphere with listed products.
!
!
Q. What do you expect to be the biggest development in this
space in 2016? Is it the launch in other jurisdictions for
instance?
As I mentioned, Europe is the most developed and most
sophisticated dividend derivatives market, but of course the US
has significant dividend players. They don’t tend to be so focused
on the dividend itself—maybe because it is paid quarterly, so the
risks are less annualized. They have also been a bit slower in
listing these products—S&P dividend futures, for example, have
only just been listed in the US, and haven’t seen much pickup yet.
There isn’t the underlying structured product market there to
generate massive demand. But now that they are listed in the US, I
can see demand going up for US dividend derivatives, as well as a
lot of US demand for European dividend derivatives. We weren’t
previously able to tap this demand because dividend products
weren’t regulated in the US and therefore couldn’t be listed.
!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
Stuart Heath is Executive Director and Head
of the UK Representative Office of Deutsche
Börse AG where he focuses on Eurex
Derivatives business. Stuart has been Head
of the Eurex/Deutsche Börse London
representative office since July 2010 having
spent the previous three years working on
product development at Eurex and latterly
designing and managing listed dividend
futures and options products which were
launched in 2008. Prior to joining Eurex Stuart
held positions in credit and fixed income trading, covering both
credit default swaps and corporate bonds at Daiwa SMBC and
previously at Greenwich Natwest/RBS. Stuart also has experience
in the risk management side of the industry with HSBC. Stuart has
over 20 years experience in finance and holds BA (Hons) in
Accountancy and Finance and an MSc in International Banking
and Financial Studies from Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh.
* This feature was originally published by DerivSource.com.
!