Characterization of Current-Mode CMOS R-2R Ladder Digital

SURE: Shizuoka University REpository
http://ir.lib.shizuoka.ac.jp/
Title
Author(s)
Citation
Issue Date
URL
Version
Characterization of Current-Mode CMOS R-2R Ladder Digital
-to-Analog Converters
Watanabe, Kenzo; Wang, Lei; Fukatsu, Yasunori
IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement.
50(6), p. 1781-1786
2001-12
http://hdl.handle.net/10297/3527
publisher
Rights
This document is downloaded at: 2016-02-25T12:26:03Z
IEEETRANSACTIONSONINSTRUMENTTWIONANDMEASUREMENTVOL.50,NO.6,DECEMBER2001
1781
CharaCterizationofCurrent−ModeCMOSR_2R
LadderDigltal−tO−AnalogConverters
LeiⅥねng,ⅥsunoriFukatsu,andKenzoWatanabe,FbllowlLEEE
AbstTVCトーA digital−tO・analog(D/A)converter based on the
R−2Rladderis丘rstaTlalyzedintermsofthepowerconsumption,
topointoutthatthectlrrent・mOdeisthelowestpowerdissipation
COunterpartOfthevoItage・mOde・Theintegralnonlinearity(INL)
analysesandthecharacterizationmethodsofthecurrent.mode
I)仏converterarethenpresentedtoidenti付theerrorsources.The
methodsareappliedtoan8−biHⅣAconverterhbricateduslng
O・6FLm CMOSprocess・MeasuredresultscomparedwithINL
analysesindicatethatthedominanterrorsourceofaprototype
COnVerteristheresistanceofthemetalinterconnectbetweenthe
ladderandthebondingpad,andtheINLoftheladderitselfisl.2
LSB.
Ln血7bms−CMOSintegrated circuit,Current−mOde)dig−
ital−analogconversion,lowpower,reSistiveladder.
ThispapernrstreviewstheR−2RladderD/Aconvertertopolnt
Outthatthecurrent−Orinverse−mOdeconngurationisbestsuited
fbrlow−POWerOPeration・Then,methodstocharacterizethecur−
rent−mOdeconverterarePreSented.Perfbrmancesofan8−bitD/A
COnVerterfabricateduslngtheO・6FLmCMOSprocessarennally
PreSentedtodemonstratethecharaCterizationmethods.
II.R−2RLADDERD/ACoNVERTERS
Fig・1showsacircuitdiagramofaconventionalvoltage−mOde
R−2RladderD/Aconverter∴隼isthereftrencevoltageand
di(i=1,2,‥・,n)isthen−bitbinarynumbertobeconverted
intotheanalogvoltage・AssumlngnOWthatallresistorsare
exactlymatchedandtheswitchesareideal,thentheimpedance
I.INTRODUCTTON
T慧 CMOSprocessiscommonlyusedfbrmixedanalog
digitalsystemintegration,because the advancein
Seenfromthenode①totherightiS字Randtherefbrencevoltage
SWitchedbydiisattenuatedby2 ̄ttoreachthenode①.The
OutPuttも。tOftheD/AconverteristhusglVenby
nne−line technologymakesitpossible tointegrate alarge
SyStemOntOaSmallsiliconarea・Oneoftheissuesaccompa−
叱ut=(d12 ̄1+d22 ̄2+‥・+dm2−m)×隼=宗佑(1)
nylngSuChahigh−densltylntegrationisthepowerdissipation,
andlow−VOltage andlow−POWer designs are highly recom−
か=d12m−1+d22m−2+‥・+dm・ (2)
mendedl1],【2]・Thisisespeciallytruefbrananalogcircuit,
andapromlSlngCandidateisacurrent−mOdecircuitthathas
the potentialcapabilities of wideband and wide dynamic
Slgnalprocesslngunderthelowsupplyvoltage・Current−mOde
analog−tO−digital(AD)anddigital−tO−analog(D/A)converters
ThecurrentflowlngthrougheachleglSglVenby
dl佐一叱tlt
71=
(3)
2月 ,
Will,thereR)re,bekeycomponentsinmixedanaloganddigital
ASICs[3】.
′/′l二.−
Anydataconverter,AD,OrD/Aconverter,requlreSthequan−
J′=
tizedreftrence・Astraightfbrwardwayofproducingthequan−
tizedrefbrencesistheresistorstnngortappedresistor.This
2月
(宜=2,3,・‥,れ+1)
(4)
architectureisexclusivelyusedfbrhigh−SPeedflashAノDcon−
VerterS,butisseldomappliedtoaD/Aconverterbecausethe
Wheredn+1=0.
SWitchtreetomultiplexthequantizedreftrencesdependingon
Ifdi=1,thecurrentIiissuppliedbythereftrencesource.
adigitalinputtakesalongtimetosettlel4],[5].Anothersimple
Ifdi=0,0ntheotherhand,IiSinkstotheground・Sinceno
arChitectureistheR−2Rladder・Itoperatesasahigh−SPeedcur−
Currentflowsoutoftheterminal①,thetotalsourcecurrentis
rentdividerl6],andthesmalldevicecountisquiteattractive
equaltothetotalsinkcurrent
toanASICinwhichalargenumberofD/Aconvertersarere−
quiredl7],[8].ThemainerrorsourcesoftheR−2RladderD/A
∑鵜=−∑扁沃一左石 (5)
COnVerteraremismatchesoftheswitchon−reSistances,butthe
advancesinCMOS伽e−linetechnologyhavegreatlyimproved
thematchingaccurac)Ofswitches・Basedonthesetechnolog−
icalaspects,theR−2Rladderisrevisited.
andthepowersuppliedbythereftrencesourceisalldissipated
intheladder・Thepowerdissipationisthus
P=∑帖佐・ (6)
ManuscnptreceivedDecember13,2000;revisedSeptember30,2001.
TheauthorsareWiththeResearChInstituteofElectronics,ShizuokaUniver_
Slty,Hamamatsu,Japan.
PublisherItemIdentinerS0018−9456(Ol)10978−2.
Fig・2plotsthepowerdissIPationofthe4−bitD/Aconverteras
afunctionoftheinputcode・ExceptfbratrivialcasewhenD=
0018−9456/01$10.00◎2001IEEE
1782
IEEETRANSACTIONSONINSTRUMENTATIONANDMEASUREMENT,VOL・50,NO・6,DECEMBER2001
Fig.4.D/Aconverterunderresistancemeasurement.
Fig.1.Ⅵ)ltage−mOdeR−2RladderD/Aconverter.
WhereRriistheresistancelookingtowardtheright−handend
5 2 5 1 5 0
2 1 0
%川
Oftheladder.Thecurrentflowlngthrougheachlegisthenex−
PreSSedasfollows
壷一1
ん
圭=芸(1−ど宣)n(1+どた),(戌=1,2,…,可・(10)
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101112131415
Introducingtheweightingfactor
DigitalinputD(decimalnotation)
W1=拍一己1)
Fig.2.Normalizedpowerdissipationofa4−bitR−2RladderD/Aconverteras
i−1
afunctionofthedigitalinput.
1′
Wi=妄(1−El)H(1+どた)
WeCanreWrite(11)inthematrixfbm
VG:VertualGround
dn
70
Ⅰ。ut(VG)
L
r
i。ut(VG)
L
r
0 0 ・ ・ l
盟
In.
1
0 0 ・ ・ 0
1
R p(
n
0 1 ・ ・ 0
Ⅰ
。
1 0 ・ ・ 0
R叩
ん. (13)
The matrix representation(13)indicates that the weighting
factor,and thereby the mismatch Ei,Can be determined by
Fig.3.Current−mOdeR−2RladderD/Aconverter.
SettlngOnlydi=1andmeasunngI。。t.
0,theplotsare.symmetricalarOundD/2n=0・5,Wherethe
Thecurrentmeasurementdescribedaboveprovidesndata
fbrtheresistanceratio.Ann−bitR−2RladderD/Aconverterin−
dissIPationismlnlmum.ThisholdstrueOfanyR−2RladderD/A
Cludes2nresistors.Tbknoweachresistancevalue,nadditional
COnVerter.ThecurrentflOwlngthrougheachlegattheminimum
dataarerequired・Suchdatacanbeobtainedbyapplyingacon−
POWerdissipationisglVenby
StantCurrentIintOtheI。。tteminalandmeasunngthevoltage
atthereftrenceterminal,aSShowninFig.4.Thevoltagetl
WhenonlydlissettolandtheotherbitsareSettOOisglVenby
l:・
(7)
ム=元
坑=凡11Jin. (14)
ム=一占ム(ま=2,3,・‥,叫1)・(8)
Eq.(8)indicatesthatifZlisreplacedbythereftrencecurrent,
thesamearChitectureresultsinthecurrent−mOdeD/Aconverter
ShowninFig.3.Thisconngurationisthusinterpretedasthe
lowestpowerdissipationcounterpartoftheR−2RladderD/A
COnVerterS.
The current−mOde R−2RladderD/A convertercanbe char−
From11andEl,WeCanknowRplandR,1・Next,thevoltage
VBwhenonlyd2issettolisglVenby
ヰ+監言語監日記月品(15)
SinceR,1glVenby
acterizedbythefbllowingproceduresl9],[10】.LetEibethe
み1=凡1鴫21デ (16)
resistancemismatchatthenode①
isalreadyknown,WeCanObtainRslandRp2by(15)and(16)・
月pi一月γ壱
どi=
月p豆+月ri
(9)
Repeatlngthisprocessntimes,OneCanmeaSurealltheresis−
tancevalues.
WANGetal.:CHARACTERIZATIONOFCURRENT−MODECMOSR−2RLADDERDIGITAL−TO−ANALOGCONVERTERS
n(1+どた)=1+∑どた
(17)
L,。t=Iid。al+△I
=∑2 ̄id詰+△J
■ヽ
■
仰「 ̄
_
_
「〆 .
.
W 50 100
l ■
∩
■
3
20町
長
150 2 4 6
0 0 0
WeCanObtaintheoutputcurrent
6 4 2
0 0 0
Approximatlng
︵斡SJ︶合で空白弓〇三d払む召H
Once the resistance mismatchesareknown,theintegral
nonlinearity(INL)ofthe convertercanbeeasily estimated.
1783
_
_
了
W
(18)
壱=1
andisglVenby
筈=一号(d1− 差2一(叫dた)
22
(d2−墓2−…斗‥・一打19)
5 0
0.
g2
︵西SJ︶合でd呂叫召昌扇払3月
where△Iis the errorcurrent due to the resistance mismatch
The丘rst−Orderrepresentation(19)oftheerrorcurrentindicates
thatINLassumeslocalmaximaatminorcamiesandmaximum
2−(n+1)Ir・Therefbre,E<2−nisrequiredfbrn−bitresolution・
The other error sourcesare On−reSistances of switches and
Wireresistancesfromtheladdertotheoutputterminals.The
INLsduetotheseerrorsourcesarealsoshowninFig.5,Where
an8−bitD/AconverterwiththenominalresistanceR=Rs=
Rp/2=2030andtheresistan?emismatchofO・4%isassumed・
0 0 0 0
3 2 1
to LSB,the maximum error current should be smaller than
︵再∽d合でd呂弓呂l邑首ヨ
atthem亘iorcarry,aSShowninFig.5(a)・Themaximumerror
currentis2−1EIZr.FortheD/Aconversiontobeaccuratedown
. .l l
l■
−
半丁
−
■
’. \
‥
仁
l ▲.
−
_
l
50
1 0 0 150
3
’
▼
r ▼
’
Fig.5(a)showsINLduetoresIStanCemismatch.Thepromeis
asymmetricalwithrespecttothemqorcarry.TheINLpronle
Whenthemismatchofon−reSistanceispresentinadditiontothe
resistancemismatchisshowninFig.5(b).Theon−reSistances
Ron,dOfthoseswitcheswhicharedrivenbythedigitalinput
≠
(C)
Fig.5.INLpronlesduetomismatchesin(a)resistance,(b)on−reSistanceof
SWitch,and(C)wireresistance.
diareaSSumedtobellnwhilethoseRon,百drivenbydiare
Cenl Cem2
assumedtobeO.Itcanbe seenthatINLduetoon−reSistances
issymmetricalwithrespecttothemqOrCarryandassumesthe
COnCaVe−uPPrOfile・IfRon,d<Ron,百,thenINLassumesthe
COnCaVe−downpro丘Ie.Fig.5(C)showstheefftctofthewirere−
Sistance.ThewireresistanceR。utfromtheladdertoI。utter−
minalisassumedtobe300,WhilethatofR元首tOZolltterminal
isassumedtobeO.Theresistanceofthewireinterconnectloses
エ
M⊥
3
壷 ⅥM 2
 ̄
 ̄
謂
○
Ⅰ
。
ut
Ml
Ⅰ
。
u
t
0
thesymmetryinFig.5(a)and(b),andshiftsthemaximum’INL
towardLSBifRout>R757I盲andviceversa・Thesepropertiesof
INLpronlescanbeusedtoidentifytheerrorsources.
Cbck Cご
ldl
d2也
d3d3  ̄
 ̄d7d7 d8b Reght
er
ⅠⅠⅠ.CMOSLADDERD/ACoNVERTER
I t l The characterization methods ofthe R−2RladderD/Acon−
l l
dt も d3 d7 血
d蜘血hput
Verterdescribedintheprevioussectionhavebeenappliedtoan
8−bitD/AconverterfabricateduslngtheO.6IJmCMOSprocess・
ThecircuitdiagramoftheD/AconverterisshowninFig.6.The
resistorRinFig.3isreplacedbytheunitnMOStransistoroper−
Fig・6・Circuitdiagramofan8−bitD/AconverterfabricatedbyO・6ItmCMOS
atlnglnthelinearreg10n,andthefburunittransistorsfbrmthe
thedigitalinputdianddiOPeratealsoasswitches・Therefer−
unitce11fbrl−bitconversion.Thoseunittransistorsdrivenby
encecurrentwasassumedtobe256pA.
1784
IEEETRANSACTIONSONINSTRUMENTATIONANDMEASUREMENT,VOL・50,NO・6・DECEMBER2001
25
ノ
20
/
/
ノ了
S15
∈
ヽ J
主10
5
0
/
。
i。
=
2。
2.
… )
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
tr(lA)
Fig.8.CurrentversusvoltagecharacteriSticsatthereferencenode.
Fig.7.Microphotographoftheprototypechip.
Wheretheusualnotationsareusedfbrtransistorparameters・The
22
0
500
克=〃晶(筈)(侮一佐一等)侮,
︵望む呂召莞巴ぢdj
ThedraincurrentIDOfannMOStransistoroperatlnginthe
linearreg10nisglVenby
/
3
2.
4
1.
2
linearoperationislimitedto
tbS≦l七5−1㌢.
(21)
0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5
ChannellengthofthenMOStransistor(pm)
Themaximumdraincurrentisthus
(t七g一作)2
Jpmax=〃mG諾
(22)
Fig.9.TheequlValentresistanceversusthegatelengthofannMOStransistor.
300
TheunittransistorsintheMSBcellcarrythecurrentZr/2=
250
128PAandthiscurrentshouldbesmallerthanIDmax.This
200
COnditionspeciBestheaspectratioasfbllows:
Inderiving(23),theprocessparametersFJnC。X=40IJAⅣ2,
1与=0・8Vandthebiasvoltagelち=2・5Vareassumed・
A muchlarger aspect ratio than that speci丘edby(23)is
PreferabletolowertheequlValentresistance,therebythepower
dissipation,andalsotoreducetheharmOnicdistortionwhenthe
D/Aconverterisappliedtoanattenuatorandamultiplier・With
thislowpowerandlowdistortioninmind,threeaspectratios
W几=200FLm/3.FLm,200ILm/2.4pm,and200〃′m/1.2pm
苛きちdち○
(筈)≧2・2・ (23)
150
100
50
0
−50
−100
−150
−200
−250
−300
DigitalinputD(decimalnotation)
areChosenfbrprototypechips.
Fig.7showsamicrophotographoftheprototypechipwith
(W几)=200FLm/3FLm.Inthecentralpart33unittransistors
Fig・10・ThnsfercharaCteristicsoftheprototypeD/Aconverter:W几=200
〃m/3〃m.
arrangedintwocolumnscanbeseenfbrmlngtheladderstage.
Itcanalsobeseenthattheunittransistorisfbrmedbythepar−
(L=−256FLA)reftrencesareSymmetrical,Whichprovesthat
allelconnectionof4transistorswithW几=50FLm/3〃m.The
theladderD/Aconverterisavailablealsofbranattenuatorand
rightmostpartisthereglStertOStOrethedigitalinput.
amultiplier.Fig.1lshowstheINLobtainedfromthemeasured
Fig・8showsthecurrentversusvoltagecharacteristicsatthe
reftrencenode.Thisresultindicatesthattheunittransistoroper−
atesasalinearresistorof23200Verthewidereftrencecurrent
transftr charaCteristics.Companng the profiles with those
ShowninFig.5,itcanbefbundthatthedominanterrorsource
isthewireresistance.Thebest一員tsimulationuslngSpicehas
range.Fig.9showstheequivalentresistanceasafunctionof
estimatedthatthewireresistancesfromtheladdertotheI。ut
thegatelength.Thelinearrelationcon丘rmSthattheaspectratio
Fig.10shows the measured transftr characteristics.The
andI。。tPadsare8.80and12.80,reSPeCtively.Thesevalues
arequltereaSOnableinviewofthe丘ne−lineCMOSprocess.
PerfbrmancesoftheCMOSladderitselfareevaluatedbyex−
transftrcharacteristicsfbrthesource(I,=256pA)andsink
Cludingtheeffbctofthewireresistances・ThbleIlistsequivalent
linearlyscalestheequivalentresistance.
WGetal・‥CHARACTERIZATIONOFCURRENT−MODECMOSR−2RLADDERDIGITAL−TO−ANALOGCONVERTERS
1785
4 2 0 8 6 4 2 0 2 4 6
︵閂SJ︶卓雇呂弓喜一空訝盲Ⅰ
PrOfi1ewiththatshowninFig.5(b),itisclearthatthemismatch
inswitchon−reSistancealsodegradesINLtol.2LSB.
IV.CoNCLUSION
CurrentandvoltagemeasurementstocharaCterizetheR−2R
0
150 200 250
ladderandtheINLpronlestoidentifytheerrorsourcesofthe
ladder−basedD/Aconverterweredescribed・Thesetechniques
︵斡Sd丘で望月召0日︻d払む盲i
WereapPliedtothe8−bitCMOSladderD/Aconverterfabri_
4 2 0 8 6 4 2 0 2 4 6
CateduslngtheO・6pmCMOSprocess・Themeasuredresults
haveindicatedthatthedominanterrorsourceoftheprototype
COnVerteristhewireresistancefromtheCMOSladderstageto
thepondingpad,andtheINLoftheCMOSladderisl.2LSB.
Theprototypeconverterwasfabricatedbyfullydigital−COm−
Patibleprocess・Thecircuitconfigurationissimple,andthe
0
50 100 150 200 250
(b)
Fig・11・IntegralnonlinearityoftheprototypeD/Aconverter:(a)Ir
256IJA;(b)Z,=−256IJA.W/L=200FJm/3FLm.
device countis small・The analog bandwidth extends up
tolOO MHz,and the totalharmOnic distortionisless than
O・1%・Owingtothesedistinctftatures,theCMOSladderD/A
COnVerterdescribedhereinisqulteuSefulfbrhigh−SPeedD/A
COnVerSionandvideoslgnalprocesslnglnamixedanalogand
digitalASIC・ImprovlngINLbylowenngthewireresistances
isafuturework.
5
REFERENCES
1
l1]A・Chandrakasan and R.Brodersen,Eds.,LDW−上もwer C材OS De_
l
■
−
軒
Slgn・NewYbrk:IEEEPress,1998,Pt・Iandpt・II・
J
[2]C・Tbumazou,J・B・Hughes,andN.C.Battersby,Eds.,Switched−Cur−
し
.
_
O
▼
l
100 150 200
250 3
0 旬
TmtSanAnalogueTbchniquejbrDigital花chnology.London,U.K.:
PeterPeregnnus,1993,Ch.1.
5
︵斡SJ︶合−h雷雲tヨ三雲ぎ召H
Ir =2 56 1止
[3]C・Tbumazou,FT・Lidey,andD・Haigh,Eds・,AnalogueICDesign:The
Curlmt−ModeAppTDaCh・London,U・K・:PeterPeregrlnuS,1990,Ch.
1.
[4]A・B・Grebene,B¢olarandMOSAnalogIntegnlted CilruitDe−
DigitalInputD(decimalnotation)
Slgn・NewYork:Wiley,1984,Ch.14and15.
[5]R・S・Soin,EMaloberti,andJ・Franca,Eds.,Analogue−DigitalASICb;
Fig・12・IntegralnonlineantyOftheCMOSladder・W几=200FJm/3FLm.
CiTruitZbchniques,DesignIboIsandApplications・London,U.K.:
PeterPeregrlnuS,1991,Ch.6.
[6]B・Razavi,Princ¢lesQftheDataConverterSystemDesign.NewYbrk:
IEEEPress,1995,Ch.5.
TABLEI
[7]L・BultandG・J・G・Geelen,“AninherentlylinearandcompactMOST
RESISTANCESANDRESISTANCEMISMATCHESOFTHEFIRSTFoURMSBCELLS
OFTHEPROTGrYPECoNVERTER・W几=200FLm/3IJm
Onlycurrentdivisiontechnique,MIEEEJ・Solid−StateCilruits,VOl.24,
pp.672−680,June1989.
[8]K・Watanabe,L・Wang,H・−W・Cha,andS.Ogawa,“Acurrent−mOde
approachtoCMOSneuralnetworkimplementation,’’inPTVC.Int.CoTU
C ell
R esistance (
0 )
M ism atch
AJgor地肌∫A′℃肋ecr〟作∫助mJJeJPmcg∫∫・,1997,pp・625−637.
[9]M・PKennedy,“OntherobustnessofR−2RladderDAC,S,”1MThns.
N o.
Rp
Rs
1
438.
6
442.
6
−
0.
45
2
447.
4
455.
6
−
0.
91
3
4 13.
5
429.
4
−
1.
9
4
344 .
9
3 71
−
3.
6
E(
%)
CiTruitsSyst・,VOl.47,pP.109−116,Feb.2000.
[10]B・V訂ghaandI・Zaltan,“Calibrationalgorithmforcurrent−OutPutR−2R
ladders,”inPn,C・LEEEInstrum・Meas・Tbchnol・CoTf,May2000,PP.
753−758.
resistancesandmismatchesinthe丘rstfburMSBcellsevalu_
atedbythecurrentandvoltagemeasurementsdescribedinthe
PreVioussection・Rpincludestheresistanceoftheswitchtran−
Sistor・Thedeviationoftheequivalentresistancefromthenom−
inalvalue,andthemismatchincreasewiththelattercell.This
isduetotheaccumulateduncertaintylnthewireresistances.
TheO・4%resistancemismatchinthefirstcell,Whichdominates
INLoftheCMOSladder,SuggeStSthatINLbelLSB・Fig・12
ShowsthepracticalINLoftheCMOSladder・Companngthe
Lei Wang was bomin Shanghai,China,On
November14,1970・HereceivedtheM・S・degree
in1997andthePh・D・degreeinenglneenngfrom
theUniversltyOfShizuoka,Hamamatsu,Japan,in
2001,Onthesu叫ectofR−2Rladderdigital−tO−analog
HeiscurrentlywiththeMeiyoElectricCo.,Ltd.,
Shizuoka,Japan.
1786
IEEETRANSACTIONSONINSTRUMENTATIONANDMEASUREMENT,VOL.50,NO.6,DECEMBER2001
YasunoriFukatsu was borninIzumo,Japan,
in1978・He received the B・E.degreein system
englneenngfromShizuokaUniverslty,Hamamatsq,
Japan,in2001・HeiscurrentlypursulngtheM・E・de−
greeintheGraduateSchoolofShizuokaUniversIty・
Hiscurrentresearchinterestsareinthecircuitde−
KenzoWatanabe(M’74−SM’86−F’93)receivedthe
B・E・andM・E・degreesinenglneeringfromShizuoka
University,Hamamatsu,Japan,in1962and1966,re−
SPeCtively,andtheDr・Eng・degreefromKyotoUni−
VerSity,Kyoto,Japan,in1976.
HeisaProfessorattheResearchInstituteofElec_
Slgnandmeasurementofthedigita1−tO−analogcon−
tronics,Shizuoka,Universlty・・HewasattheUniver−
Verter.
SltyOfCalifomia,LosAngeles,aSaVisitingPro一
hssor丘・Om1982to1983.
Dr.Watanabe received the Andrew R.ChiBest
PaperAwardandtheI&MSocietyAwardfromIEEE
IMSocietyin1984and1999,reSPeCtively,andtheSaitoAwardfromtheChion
Institutein1990andtheThkayanagiMemorialAwardin1994.Hehasalso
beendesignatedanEmeritusProftssorofXidianUniverslty,Xi,an,China,in
1997.HeisanAsSociateEditorofIEEETRANSACTIONSONINSTRUMENmrION
ANDMEASUREMENT.