5. つながりのいのち - ゲノムの戦略

<B,ND(D; $ ZacD½û
%&#('"'$ ! )*+',w Ï

ž
- '"(%
Ҁºñ…EH3@B´î[\]c?'O"8PE¶,¿N¯5:KD?EB("¶E8D
ÓC¿N¯4P:ș?'O"Ҁºñ…´î[\]cD¿Ã«EkÔ!Ëù…!Ҁ?'O"
ҀºñE´î[\]c@5>¿N¯4PO2@?GN!ñD<B.R©‰5:"8D¦Œ
Ùu,ºñ…áDÁš÷RÄ5!ÊöBåÙRqäC5:"8PE´î[\]cDà¸Rõ
Cy÷7O2@?ƒ·BñD<B.RÙu5:"4MCE!´îo4PO2@DB([\]
c@ݗ4PO2@?!Øm¸CçI­âBºñ…F@åÙ5:"Ҁºñ…!8PE%
!nã
CýO´î[\]cDÀÎB¦ŒÙu?'O"
ð’?E!´î[\]cD¢Ú+MҀºñ…Dà¸R“›5!4MC!æ´îo[\]c
@DݗD®ø¸RÆ*O"
. /1)*+,$!#&02
("!
*/+&-,!/'$%#.)
ºñ@Ep+"8PE¶DèíDô(+1?'N!¶DѸDGN+M‰™C¡OG?!
8P9PD¤ÍDшC|=(>ŽMP>-:"ºñrxE!³C!2Dô(+1@CÐ~
4P>-:@(*L)%[df#^SgV# "
(
&
"!#
!
!
'!bTYeÉ #
!
!
"!¾Û¼É #
!
!
(!
#
!
"
!&
"Ê/D]W\_?ºñÌDàÕ@5>Ÿ×4PO«B•óE!˜ï‘ÃR£<2@!
vtê¨DͪR”)2@!z‚œ‡FDmÜäü,'O2@!¦Œé»D}äR£<2@!
µo7O2@!BA?'O"
2PMD•óEºñÌD®øBàÕ?'N!ÁC{QN—(R£<"àÖDàÕ,©‰7
O}ä,ÉDàÕD©‰R *O"8DÁD{QN—(RòM+C7O2@+MºñDð¨
úsEqäCBO"˜ïEºñșD²?'N!˜ï‘ÃEºñ}äD©‰}‘?'O"vt
ê¨DͪEºñÌRi£7O}ä?'N!vtê¨+MºñÌE„¹4P!ºñyÞDU`
eX#,¬N¯4PO"G:!z‚œ‡FDmÜEºñ}äD©¨?'O"4MC!¦Œé»
D}ä,ºñșDi£RqäC7O"8PE¦Œ@ß6șRé»7O@C!ìhÌRº
H¯72@KqäB}ä?'O"ìhÌDºÅz‚FDØm,µo@BO"2Dµo,ºñÈ
™D£Çqä¸R–J>(/"
ºñÌDàÕ@4PO2PMD}ä,ÂÌ@5>©‰7O2@!8PEºñșDi£!ñ
D<B.?'O"ñD<B.EºñÌ@5>DlHR<B02@?'O"¦Œ@Eë‹Dș
@5>!¦ŒDlHRj-†0șRšN¯7"2P,ñD<B.D©¨?'O"ҀºñE
ñR<B02@Rð¸@7Oș?'O@Š*L)"ºñÌDàÕ@4PO±°D•óE!2
DñD<B.DàÕR¥7KD?'O"¦Œé»EñD<B.Dö§?'N!˜ïEñDlH
$$
&$
NUCB JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS
AND INFORMATION SCIENCE vol.56 No.1
D°!šñ—ÂEôDrJD©‘†—!ì¨ÊªEôD©ÈRp¤7Oï§!„‰ŸŽGDs
ÝEôDrJD©É@'O"4MC!³tEôD=B/D¼ûA5?mÒé2MPO"
ш¸ô-ôR=B13ARuãC5:50JE±î[\^fA5?DǛC'O"±î[
\^fA5?ÀN­4PO3A@!ш¸ôEôD=B/R©‘5!3PRp¤!äÚ48O
3ARuãC5:"¥»@E±î[\^fA5?Dш¸ôDǛRÅ*O"
)!!
#'(-/$%&(",+.*
ôR=B13ARò¶A7Oш¸ôE쨍,MÀ­4P:"ó†ì¨,MD¸Èì¨D
Œ·"9DŒ·w×R±ît7O3A,M±î[\^fA5?D¸ôE IO" шDx
÷„‰C+2O£˜œ•DÔ@!DNA%_UW[he~&R±î¿¡A5!]lcYR†
ã¿¡A7O[\^f-ú5?(0"9PE…æ±îR…C†ã7O±î[\^f@'O"
…æ±îRÎ)ZbfD±îRä‘7O3A@[\^fE†ã7O"3DZbf±îRÜ*O
3A@[\^f†ãR=B/!4MCE!Zbf±îRít48O3A@[\^f†ãRít!
äÚ48O"ZbfR…æA7O±î[\^f"9D¦“Úz-ш¸ô@'O"±î[\^
fA5?Dш¸ôDÀ­"ôR=B1[\^fEôR=B/ßO[\^fDÀ­CL<?©
‘5:%}͖¡ %
#
#
)&
"3D±ît-쨍C+2OTl`kd#ÁËðÃD…@D¸ôÈ
DŒ·RuãC7O"óÓ¯Bì¨,MDÓ¯'O¸ôȌ·C+2O!êDTl`kd#D
‡¬"
%[gj#_SlV# $
+
'
$!%
#
#
*&
!9Dq„E±îtCL<?ÎQP?(OA’*L
)"
[\^fR—·7O±î¿¡A†ã¿¡A5?!DNA A]lcY-™ÙDì¨@'O,C
=(?E!‘Ð{@õBåÏRn73AEèuã@'O"5,5! ш„‰@D£˜œ
•DÔ@!DNA A]lcYRùø7O3A@ш¸ôE INäÚ5?.:"3D¸ôD
©ºw×D…C‘›D¸ôǛ-'O"9PE‹¾-ç¾A5?†ã5?.:ýÆw×D©º
@'O"
½»@®H:¸ôÈDàÕR±î[\^fD¢Û@Å*Ö73A@!¸ôDò¶ELNõ
CBO"šñEZbf±î[\^fD©È9DKD@'N!ôDrJD°@'O"ì¨ØǛ
@'O¸ôÈDôDrJEì¨R…æA5?©‘7O"|yì¨DʪEç´@'O"«Nâ
P:ì¨EZbf±îC…>(?¸Èì¨Gíƒ4P!¸ôÈRŒ·5!
¸ô‚ÞDTaiX#
-«N­4PO"ôDrJD©ÉEšñá|,MDŸŽ!9D²ŠCs6:†ãít@'O"
Zbf±îD䑵”-3PRuãC7O"4MC!¦“ë¹EôD=B/Dö§@'N!…
æ±îRÎ)ZbfDë¹AÜÌ-9D©¨@'O"ZbfDë¹-ôD=B/D IN@'
N!9D†—-ôD50JD INABO"I:!¸Ä„‰DítGDÙsãü-B2PFô
D=B/EÆ,B("ÙsãüR¤;ß:KDDJ-¸.žO"3DÙs†ãEZbf±îR
ít48O3A@€ß4PO"³tE¸Ä„‰DítGDÙsw×Dv@'N!9D©¨E
Zbf±îDío!äÚC'O"
& )+!',"#$%*(
¸ôÈE[\^f@'N!9D†ãEôR=B13AC'O"ш¸ôDò¶@'O3D†
ãE!±î[\^fA5?ÀN­4PO3A@©‘5:"¸ôDà¶E±î[\^fD[\^
$&
($
:?,KA'A8 # UflA¿ü
lܸ<H&L"5A„ðB„ã¯í=…àçæAêú!*ID!ý¦AWY_lz@&L"
¯íŸ=…àŸOêú3L0=<5M6MAܸO€+27·“,|à@?K!0MOW
Y_lz3L0=<…àAâظ,˜EL"ð®<B!¯íWY_lAܸ=2;!¯íÞõ
A·“!¯íâA·“!1J@!…àŸAm[^aî£@Õò2!0MJAWY_lܸ
@I9;¥1M7ºñAܸOÈ)L0=@3L"
#!!
%(')"&$
ӇºñA¯íWY_l@*/L„ã¯íBUfl¯í<&L"5MB`X\n¯í<&K!
趱ÍOH:¯íåÂŸAÃF™N4<å1ML"`X\n¯íAܸB5A˜'{•
¸@&L"WY_lA¯íÐqBé¤Ðq@ë1M!5Aé¤Ü¸Où÷3L0=<!¯í
A{•!·“,õr@?1ML"UflA¯íåÂŸB%§A DNA w„O :eSoR]
b<&L"w„Au¡áÿ,Ufl¯í<&K!5A…àÐq,tٟ!1J@À²Ë=?L"
¯íÞõA·“B!w„!tٟ!À²Ë?>AÐq<|à@?L"5M6MAÐq@*/L
¯íÞõA·“,WY_l=2;A~ojn@*/L…àA·“@Ìx3L"ð¾<B!¯í
ÞõA·“A„ð=2;!¯íAè»!ës!iopbO—)L"
é¤<å1ML`X\n¯íA·“¸@*';!¯íåÂŸA‰­¸Bä´A°<&
L"‰­¸,˜EL0=<˜'¯í¨¼Ú,¥3L"Îþ¯íA·“|à¸B¯íWY_l
Aô”¸O˜GLªø?°<&L"ºé›ï@ޜ3L DNA BcfVQZ<&L"ga›
ïB#[^aAUflOH:,!"[^a<&
!yh^aA¯íþO :"0MBœA¯í†
¬@óL¯í¨¼Ú<&L"cfVQZA DNA O„@27ºñAUfl¯íWY_l!5A
óM7¯í¨¼Ú,Êö?¢’Ø}A„ã=?K!%
!yß@"LÄÎ?ӇºñŒO–Ô2;
-7A<&L"
¯íAè»#ñA:?.
é¤<å1ML`X\n¯íB!5Aé¤Ü¸Où÷2;è»1ML"DNA A¯íå
Ðq=?Lw„B!P`dp$A%
!]kp$T%
!TPdp$G%
!WaWp$C%A%§<&
L"0MJAw„B A = T!G = C Aw„ƒ<µÂŽ™O‹¹3L"Á;AӇºé<!5
A„ã¯íOÑ(UflB DNA A#ðš–ÇO 8!#ðAw„šB A = T!G = C Aw„
ÌO‹¹2;'L"uîAšAw„áÿ@Ì2!ÉîB0M@Åì×?w„áÿO?3"©9
;!#ðš=?L0=<¯íþ,Æ)L0=B?'"#ðšB DNA ¯íAè»Oò×=3L
–Ç<&L"DNA#ðšBw„ƒAµÂŽ™O½Ò3L0=<ÝûA"ðš=?L""ðš
A5M6M,֊=?L0=<!A = T!G = C Aw„Ì‹¹O;!#[^aA³7?#ð
š DNA ,K«1ML"DNA ¯í!Ufl¯íAè»<&L"
Ufl,è»1ML0=<›ïê!,¥3L"ê!27#‘A›ïA5M6M@è»1M
7Ufl,ÙÏ1M!5M6MAñAvF,|à@?L"ñA:?.A¥¤BWY_l=2;
A„ã¯íOÑ(UflAè»!ÙÏ<&L"›ïê!BñA:?.AžEK<&K!Ufl
¯íAè»@IL›ïê!…–BñA:?.O¥3L…–<&L"ñO:?.ÛLWY_l
A„ðB DNA ¯íA軅–@&L"0A›ïê!@ILñA:?.,ӇºñŒAžEK
=?L"
›ïê!BñA:?.Aä´Aö£<&L"ê!3L0=,?/MC!›ïAvF,‚ˆë
#$
'#
NUCB JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS
AND INFORMATION SCIENCE vol.56 No.1
s@Ûq1;ÌË1;%+/=Bëtæ<$L"šóî%@I8;Dz17šóˆ<B!5M
6MAšó(€æïsA€vOxâ3L"5AÍû?äÂïiÏAÖ@|…ïs@Ûqtæ?
Ï(ª3L"ÏµOÇH3/=<|…ïsDAÛqyÿO–FL"5MBùÊëtæ?
»É|…Aïs@Ûq1;%+ø“?»)K¿!<$L"%
!råAՃ|…AïÁAÖ<÷
O9?*Ë-7Ճ»÷!5A÷A9?*A}õû£(šóî%<$L"
°ðAïi#´sAtæ¸
°ðTVYa@&-L}é°ðAïsBTVYa€æOïs04L"/A€æ·‘Aò£B
°ðTVYaA©ü?ã¸<$L"R\a°ðTVYa@&-L}é°ðAïsB DNA p}
ç$Aïs<$L"5MB"p}Ôg'J͵Ap}™Ôg@&LÍû?ïs=?L"/Ap
}ç$Aïs(»÷€æAïsOn)/3"/Ap}ç$ïsBbeXa?äÂïi<$L"
beXa?ïi@I8;/L€æïsAÍ+B»Ì@ëý=?L"1'1!ïi(beXa
<$L/=Bøý?ïiG/KâL/=O¢3"äÂïi@I8;n)/0ML€æïs!
5A³7?€æ(»É|…@ۘ1!»Ì€æO”­04L=)!5AäÂïiÏB»É|…
AÖ<Ø0M;%+"»íA|…DAÛq!|…ïsDAÐq!51;!³7?»í§DA
´sA€•<$L"
R\a°ðAäÂïiAümBÍ~@N7L"šóî%@&-L°ðì¼uÙ<Ap}Љ
¹A’K!ñ¦À¬w!szí¤Ao†?>!»÷{àAÃ;A®<!º¯?p}ç$Aj Oô.Lüm(̛3L"»í(»);%+uÙBR\a°ðïiAuÙ<G$L"/AuÙ
<¡¶ÒDAÝÓR\a(ïiO¨-L=)!¡¶ÒÏA»Ì€æ!»Ìû£(ïs1!»
É|…@ILÞÎ(/L"
R\a°ðAºy?ì¼!j B÷O9?,}õÚ?€æ<$L"1'1!¡¶ÒDAÝÓ
R\a(¶Ò=Ã+ál<ïs3L/=(?-MC!|…ïsDAÛq!´sBëtæ=?
L"R\a@&-LäÂïiA̛(»É|…DAÛqæ"AxâOtæ@3L"ßÂA/=
?(J!5AyÿB‡F;×%"1'1!/A×%yÿA#½(%
!råAՃ»÷ŠA´s!
èÜOtæ@1;)7"R\a°ðAì¼!ÝÓAºy0!/M=„@!R\a°ðAïiA
tæ¸"/A¾öA]beVO¥3L°ðêí¤!°ð·‘€•Aƪ(Ճ»÷ŠA÷
A9?*A}é<$L"
°ðA_de[#Íû¸Aƪ
ZUWc°ðAã¸B°ðÍûsAúh0@$L"í¤<ê0MLZUWc°ðB°ðê
ÔgOÅE˜N4L/=<Íûs0ML"°ð_de[@ILÍû¸Aƪ<$L"R\a
°ðTVYaA}é<$L°ðîž DNA AÍû¸xâB/Aã¸@}:+"DNA p}ç$
B%§Ap}AÅE˜N4@I8;ê0ML"ìµ±ÑO 9ĞAÅE˜N4@ILÍû
¸Aƪ!5MB›A°ð‚«@&-L°ðêAŒþ<G$L"
€æîžWe^QAÍû¸ÆªGá2Œþ@}:+"We^QBP`\œA™±‹˜îž<
$L"Ճ»íAWe^QO•¹3LP`\œBãØA#
!§@ŽØ0M;%L"/A#
!§AP
`\œAÅE˜N4(We^QAP`\œç$=?L"P`\œç$AÍû¸(We^QA•
ÈÍû¸=?K!€æAÍû¸O»Eª3"We^QO•¹3LP`\œB DNA A$9Åp
}<$LkÝf—S[e@I8;ŸØ0ML"/AS[eAç$( DNA AkݞÔg=?L"
#$
&#
;?-JA)A9 % UafAµú
1AH*@3<!ZibSAOea–ÞþB DNA Ao~Þþ@H:<ˆÌ2LK"1LB²
ìu{@+0KYi^gh#_TdA~ë=G(K"
§éÆjA¹E“M6@HKÁó°Aº¤!1AÁóq‰ùB²ìÝAÁó°N²E¤5
>3<î@|ô2L<.8"Áó°AzØBVX]fÝA¢Û°!Ïp°N’FK"
ʂ²ì‡AœŒÒwvÍ!7AÁ/AÈx=Áó°Aº¤B².—Jµú>3<|,2L<
.8"
î°²©B7AЅý=(K"î°²©B¶ªÂA¹E“M6@HK›®ÄUafAÁ
óq=(K"Š®Ä‹Â-G;¶ªÂAá­-gi[f@·CL<²©•êAUaf>?
K"™ðA²©•êAñ“@HK ³øAUaf-›®Ä‹ÂAUaf§é=(K"7LBû
°AŠ®Ä‹Â-š;¶ªÂAá­A¹E“M6>?K"¶ªÂ­-»s5K1>=ßÅ?¹
E“M6-tÝ@?J!7AÁó°-›®Ä‹Â„AUafÁó°N²E¤5"ŸÚ@+0K
UafAÁóqB}ƒèq@Ã5K².—Jµú=(K"UafAÁóq-²ìÝAÁóq
NŠ3!ò¾ätÝ?}ƒèqDAÏpÝüN’FK"
#!!
&)($"'%
àŠ¯Ž@HKnEAŠ
§éVX]fB~â§éN~@Ý5K"~â§é-?0LCVX]fBÝ3?)"3,
3!§éBàŠ2LK1>=rÉNš;"3,G!ãõ@p4<àŠ2LK1>=ë÷ArÉ
Nà€5K"àŠ¯Ž@HKVX]fÝA¯Ž!7LB§éVX]fA£õ?îÙ°=(
K"§éAàŠ´Ì!àŠ¥¦A¯Ž@HJ!×mA~â§éNš;VX]f-k?KÝN
Š5K"7LB}ƒèq@pÕ5KnENtÝ@5KVX]fÝ=(K"1AVX]fÙ
°N|,51>=ìAnEBî@Ý3š¿3<)/"
²å•êAUaf§é@+0KàŠ¯ŽA~ëB§éӞÈx=A¯Ž=(K"7A~ë
BUafAÙÌjË=Aq{Î!åùΡ¨@HK"7LB²ÀA~끐!².KnEN
tÝ@5K>3<zØ2L8"
Á•ê²å@+0KÝæÇ
§éàŠA¯ŽtÝ°!1AVX]fÙ°Nî@|,51>=Á•ê²åDA«qBŠ
38"Á•ê²åN±5K•êB‰½>3<×mAUafNš;"y•êBæq•ê>3<
ÙÌAÝNš9!1LI-֎2LK1>=‹Â¸Â>3<AÝ-tÝ@?K"æq•ê
=AÙ́ÝAŠ@B!7AÝ@ãõ?lԘAàŠ¼«!2I@B!äãõ?lԘA
àŠö¯-£õ@?K"•êUafAylԘ@Ã5Kãõ@p48àŠ¯Ž@H:<!y•
êBÙ́ÝNš;æq•ê>3<Ý5K"1A§éàŠA¯ŽBæq•ê@p4<k?K"
‹çAæq•ê@Ã5K§éàŠA¯Ž!2I@B¸•êA‹Â>3<A֎-ã¬>?K"
1LIAÝNŠ5KAzØ-Á•ê²åDA«qNŠ38"
Á•ê²å@+0K ³ø•ê,IA‹Âà²vÍB•êæqAvÍ=(K"1AvÍ=y
•êA§éàŠ¯Ž-«Ò5K"¸Ý°Nš; ³øUaf=B¸<AlԘAàŠ-tÝ=
(K"•êæÿ@HKà²vÍ@p4<!UafB¡¨N 0!lԘAàŠ¯Ž-«‘5K"
1AÑÎ?Uaf¡¨&RcWQ`]P\Sèq'
&”$íïÜ "
!
!
$!"
!
!
%'AvÍ!lÔ
˜AàŠ¯ŽAvÍ-Á•ê²åA‹Â†±vÍ=(K"
%#
%%
NUCB JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS
AND INFORMATION SCIENCE vol.56 No.1
Q#W#¯îPQTY
Ŗð»èA‹ÆL‘º3Jéh–ðB!5K6K+OVYLxâ¯î=3J¯îPQTY
<'J"/KHL؍3JŖð»èBQ#W#¯îPQTY=1;^Ïæ.HKJ"Ŗð
»èBÚcOVYL9–ð¤Ì<'JÆ*H¶h17"ÆL‘º3J–ðvAzàéË!
5KHL¸3JؔPQTY+Ŗð»è<'J"/A¶hkÒLx@!Ŗð»è@).
Jp–ðA¸z‘!0H@B!‹Æ½ÆA؍z‘Bmá0K7"
Q#W#¯îPQTY<'JŖð»èAxâ¯îB¢¼û–ð@ė3JOVYLˆ‚=
3J"5KB–ðé"@G8;éh–ð@d,…+K;(-"¢¼û–ðAOVYB‹Æƒº
A¶’==F@£±L¢.!5K6KAéh–ð@Üh0K7ኸL9OVY=?J"
/AÜh0K7¯îáŠ+éh–ðAÜÑzàLŸŠ3J"/Aéh–ðLwE!‹ÆL‘º
3J½–ðAOVYA¿Æ+Ŗð»èL؍3Jxâ¯î=?J"5KB¢¼û–ð@ˆ‚
=1;ė17OVY*HAáÔ<'J"
¸öžAÅö¹
Ŗð»èA‹Æƒº@)(;!OVY¯îáŠA¸öžB»è¡@G8;È,-`?J"
»è¡+9xñzà!5Aėöž@g27ኸ+?0KJ"fùöžA`?JÙè=
²èBÇ®Ó?¸öžLF9%oʏ› #
!
"
!&
"Ùè@).JOVY£±B!¶h„Ø!¶
hÍn@g2;`?J"“Ö?eÙzàL9Cß!?>A“×Ùè<B!~Œ?OVY£±
+?0K!5A£±Bõ_@Bì0K?("/A†j!éh–ð@).Jb՛áŠAú¸
Bl¬0K4!ÉéhB€œ0KJ"/A‰§@uü0K7¸öž+т‘ÀA‹Æƒº!
5AaLià@3J"¥ÃfùöžAÙè<B!“Ö?eÙzàAqÛB»ÄAä·°‡<
'J"тA‹Æ‘À+pç^L‹ë@¸3JeÙzàLŸŠ3J"/A‰§?Ééhú¸
Ll¬1!•X\NZYh3J{©+ƖðM\#]#!iPS –ð?>A{©%™Ð´ó #
!
!
%&
<'J"
cï!²èAOVY£±Bìià<'I!b՛AኸB¦Þ<'J"ƖðBˆÁ
=1;Ééhià<'I!½à¹La3J"/A¦Þ?¸öž+¦Þ?‹Æ‘ÀAƒºL
ià@3J"ÝþfùöžA²èBeÙzàLäø=1?("»Ât}@g27¦Þ?‹Æ‘
À+²èA»ÄàÿL“EJ"¦Þ?¯îáŠA¸öž+!–ðéh!‹Æ‘À!»³öž
@).J¦Þ?²èAėöžLF7H3"
'!!
(,+)"&#$%-*
xâ¯î=zàçåAéý
zàçåAš( ;!9DI![RSUïžB¯îPQTYAôŽÜ¹<'J"5AxñB
¯îPQTY@).Jxâ¯î=zàçåAéý@'J"xâ¯î@x:(;zàçåL˜I
¨1!PQTY=1;AzàLŸŠ3J"ãê17zàçåBªé1!xâ¯îLx@µ7?
zàçåL˜º3J"PQTYzàBµ7?zàçå@…­0K;(-"[RSUïžBPQ
TYzàAŽjÓ?aïž<'I!xâ¯îAríLx@ôŽ@zà3JPQTYܹ<'
J"
/A[RSUïžAPQTYܹB!OVY¯îPQTY=1;¾I¨0K7Î|»ò@)
(;ôŽ@s÷0K;,7%oʏ› #
!
"
!&
"Î|»òA«yÍnA–ð@)(;!xâ¯î
$$
!$
:@,LB(B8 $ S]_BÊ=
O)¦4Mº*%£S]_>›,~ùOâ)~ù%£Wc^RCTUZ_l2N7"~ù%£
Wc^RBaVY[+ªO¯LøNM1>=!åƒÈ.Bº*TUZ_C©ìqO¢HM"
ý&37Wc^RO¸/25!S]_º*O{AÆ2NM½7@Wc^R=›,~ùOh¦
3<(/"1B+ªCכ,È$ãrOzH7›,h¦~—B{-='L!2KA!›,B½
èÛ®AJMŽÙh¦~—>3<úì4M"F7!×u—ÐO¦:¾uá›,È$Bãr=C!
iéB›,%AB‘!ÜuS]_C¸/3!·uS]_+K½7@ÜuS]_,Lµ2NM
%™14¿ #
!
!
&&
"6NC{üº*>3<B·uS]_Bw)!1NA{;/ÜuS]_Ba
VY[+ª='M"
ò$ŽÙ².DBúì
1BÜuS]_BaVY[+ª,E÷ò$@?B™ïò$A*0MŽÙ².B8ªAúì4
M%sà–£ #
!
"
!&
"³Ôk:È$='Mò$BÈÖAþÂ>@M"f'ĒBjò~ù"1
B~ùOmùA4M7HBŒt@酎ٗÐB†Æ!h¦"1B­AJ9<6‚@/2N
MŽÙ².Bñ;"6BËÞOmùA4Mȼ›,‡@BS]_AJM§ÃÛÈ "1NKB
ËÞÀlBðš,ŽÙ².!:FL!ȼ}‘Bٛ,‡@B¸/TUZ_='M"6NCò
$ŽÙBaVY[+ª='M"ȼ›,‡@BS]_O{üº*>3<w)4M1>AJL!
~ù"ÿ>3<Bò$ŽÙOaVY[3!TUZ_~ùB”në@h¦O­4M"ò$BŽ
Ù².C.B:@.Ow­A4MÈÖÊ=B€ˆ='M"
ò$BŽÙ².CS]_º*B©ìq‡>3<BÈ$֜,ÎLµ37Š¥@TUZ_=
'M"6NCº*TUZ_>3<BôÅOðš37ÈÖÊ=B8ª='M"S]_º*B#É!
íßAJM.B:@.+ª!{üº*BúÄ’AJM3”@ŽÙ†Æ+ª!
~ù"ÿBaVY
[+ª!1NKBôÅOðš4M1>AJ9<­37B,ò$ŽÙ².BTUZ_='M"
2KA!1Bò$ÀlB+•,ÁBäÅÀlD>úì3<(/"1B½7@+ªB©ìq
º*TUZ_!ÁB䫺*TUZ_CÝd¹=¨4"
& ,)-'"#$%!*+(
'!!
*),("-+#$%&
$¬‡O{ü>3<ÎLµ2N7È.‡B©ìqC$¬‡B‹<AÑ9<À˜4M"º*
TUZ_='MÈ.‡B©ìqCS]_(gAJ9<ò4M"`cX_@õÌ(gBæA
ÈÖù?A2N7(gÙ,ÈFN<I!6BÍ<BÈÖ,mù>@MIB=C@("õÌ(g
Ù,È-¡M»‰CÈڇA*0Meé@ÈÒåfBvó='M"ÈڇC×8@È$°,Ï
9Op3<ÈÒ4MTUZ_='M"1BÈڇ,½7@(gÙOîØ4M"îØB­¬
CÈڇB¦ÕmùÅ='L!6BûéC$¬‡B‹<AÑM"¦ÕmùÅOûé4M$¬‡
B‹<C!eé@$¬¶x!eé@P\bQ#>Bw)='M"ÈڇCS]_õÌ(g>$
¬‡‹<BçÇTUZ_>3<~ù4M%sà–£ #
!
!
%&
"
ÈڇB†ÆoêCº*l2N<(@("`cX_@S]_(gAJ9<µ4MõÌ(g
ÙB†¬C5Ó!mù='M"5Ó!mù@½°C|ÖBÈڇBæA5Ó!mù@ϐy„
OLµ4"1B¤GBÍ<O±07N!eélO0ž4Moê,¤˜Ÿ“+ªBÈڇ†Æ
oê='M"º*l2N<(@(´ö@TUZ_†ÆB+ª,×8@õÌ(g!×8@ϐy
$$
"$
NUCB JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS
AND INFORMATION SCIENCE vol.56 No.1
yP·¥4!â,A«½{PÃ0"2C«½{Câ,3-Áw«ä{CäC;A/PmšB4
=.9C>'M%k¿ˆ• "
!
!
$&
"
%!!
($#"+/&
«½{DS#W#£ßRSUX>'M"7C‰ªé²?AM£ßRSUXD{ÐB«¸5M
»çA«Üœ>'M"2C«ÜœpBzª3NM¶„èČRSUX-«½{>'L!7
NDØ£ßeRSUX>'M"`à!® CJ)B!»á«ÜD£ßRSUX>'M"7C
‰ªé²>'MápC¶„èD£ße3N=(M"‰ªé²pC¶„èB+1M£ße
?Ø£ße"2Cí›C_(DRSUXCzªgÈB]º5M"3KB!2C_(-zª3N
9RSUXCtÔΩPÇH!RSUXC\ÂÚ1P|Ç4=(0"
S#W#£ßRSUXC‰ªé²>'M£ßRSUXD!7N8N-£ßÞ^BJ:=—ƒ
ÊhPu25"2NKC—ƒÊhD‰ªé²pC¶„èPÞ*!S#W#RSUXCtÔI
ÞeP1M"‰ªé²C—ƒÊh-YZTXBÕ«5M?.!7C‰ªé²pC¶„èB
+1MÞeDے?AL!¤9A¶„èČBD‹ËAtÔ!7Ct‰-év3NM"¶
„èCØ£ßeD‰ªé²C—ƒÊhP·¥4!¶„èC£ßeD2NPê¨5M2?B
AM"«½{D®›C¢Œ>'L!»á«ÜD…›C¢Œ>'M"
%!"
-0","*).'
«½{Cr×Dܙ¡n{B'M"7NDܙ{C~ìBr<0¡n{>'L!£ße3N
9RSUX>DA("2Cܙ{CÄB!Áw«äDܙ¡nP[Ç36M{?4=´LŸ3
N9"Ø£ßeRSUX>'MÁwܙ{-´LŸ49£ßeRSUX!Áw«ä{"7C«
ä{PqH9ÁwܙC¡n{-Áw«½{>'M"}ë!7ND£ße3NM2?CA(R
SUX>'M"® CJ)B!«½{CtÔDl«ÜœC»sBðM—ƒÊh!Ï°Þ^PŽ
¾B1æN!œC»çeP§M2?B'M"£ße3N=(A(žÑARSUXzªCà
˜-å‡Aà‘?AM"
`à!£ße3N9S#W#RSUX!»á«Ü‚¼DäC;A/Cš¼>'M"x¼,
KC»á«ÜEC¥eDQVXCÏ°Þ^,K”FL!7Cî¬-»á«ÜP«GŸ5"
Þ^Pî¬49QVX-»á«Ü‚¼CQVX?AM"7NDäCš¼-u25QVXÞ^
>'L!ápC¶„è£ßPqH=î¬4=(0"¤9A¶„è£ßC´ŸD»á«
ÜC¥e7CIC>'M"»á«Ü>D!‰ªáC—ƒÊhD‚¼±{CÄ>oì3NM"
‚¼QVXCrBÝeá-̆3NM2?>!»á«ÜCäC;A/Dš€5M"
»á«Ü>Cáp¶„èD£ße3N!«½{>C«Üœp¶„èD£ße3NM
2?DA,:9"7NDS#W#RSUXCiµB+1M“çC_(>'M"2C“ç-Ž¯
>'M,@),D¦CÖÀPa*MIC>'O)"7CÖÇD…CÁw«ä{CÊh-d5
2?BAM"4,4!±=Ciµ>£ße3N9RSUX>D!Áw«ä{CäC;A/DÙ
fÔ>':9?Š*KNM"RSUX±{C£ßeDRSUXCžÑ©PÆd36M"£ße
3NA({P³GÒNM2?>!RSUXÐjCÞÍECžÑAÉb-fÔBAM"2CžÑ
©-RSUX±{C–¹©P‹H=(0"Áw«ä{B+1M£ßeRSUX?Ø£ßeRS
UX!7C­ãCÅï-#
!cÓBðMäC;A/PfÔB49C>'M"
$#
"$
;@.JB)B9 % NW[B¶ú
& )!*'(+"#$%
¯BǟªéPQT[!7LCÈ{´î.¹J¦48¬8@êžBˆÐnªéPQT[
>(K&pŎ— #
!
!
&'
"¯BDz®hCÕåB®hkÎMvà?5K"ªé߅B±‹!2
BPQT[زMs-52?>ÕåB’Ó@gÕwÜCq×3L8"ƒ¥@ªé߅±‹.Í
€B‡Á½M½J!Ê°­‚ÔBßÄ.‡ÁBãa籋gÕMjÜA48"2BÊ°­
‚ÔBßÐMvA¯BDzC¡…48&pŎ— #
!
"
!'
"ì¨>C!¯BDzAHKǟª
éPQT[MªéPQT[زBšÑ>¾+K"
%!!
&*$(#"+),'
¯BǟªéPQT[A,1KvàªéCXU‡ÁÝÚBǟªé!,HD!oãÞÁAH
Kǟªé>(K"7Bªé߅C¯¢l¸ÁAþK"ǟªéPQT[BˆÐnC¯¢
lBb˜Av<)=yÕ5K"¯¢lBb˜.vàªéMèd36!7Bèd.ªé߅>
(K¯¢lMè+K"
2BˆÐnBêžCNW[ªéPQT[?Ã/0d@K"NW[ªéPQT[A,)=C
NW[BÙ·èd.ˆÐnMyÕ5K"]_S[@Ù·èdAHKNW[ªéBèdA¤:
=!ªé߅>(K‡ÁBwÜCèh5K"2B±‹Cfê>(J!ªé߅>(K‡
ÁA±‹3L=vàªéNW[.èd5K2?C@)"ªéPQT[BˆÐn!7BÐnê
žBe).ǟªéPQT[BزM”J¦5"7LCvàªé?ªé߅B»‰”ôAv
<0Ðn"•¼5K¥ºÏ@ˆÐnBñJó>(K"
ªéÚòB±‹#IT z§EB®Ð
XUBÝÚǟªéCǟªéPQT[>BvàªéB„>(K"ÝÚªéMÆ*­‚mü
Bw!7BwÜCXUEB®hkÎ>¹J¦3L8"¯æïßÐBû–?3LK“~B"í
Ûu>!7BwBÃ/@®hCy2I@-:8?3LK"Ã/0®h!ßÐ48BCoãÞ
ÁAHKǟªéBw>(K"¯CæïBßÐkÎ>!Àó@ÞÁ!£ëMǟªéBxý!
ÒÄA÷ô4=/8"7LCǟªéA,1KÚò±‹BزMœ5GB>G(K"7Bز
M}dÏA®Ð368B.…ÂBªéz§>(K" IT z§Bnß! ßÐAHKO_Y\$R!
Ì«z§CªéÚòBi!ÒÄMòcA48"ªéÚòBäµ!èd!Z^_VCªéi
Bvì>(J!ªéÒÄCPQT[ԋB¥ö@ft>(K"IT z§CªéÚòB±‹jÜ
²BزM©Ë5KGB>(J!…ÂB’Óªéh¢lC7BزMs-52?>É-L8¢
l>(K"
ªéz§B®ÐCǟªéPQT[Bز>(K"NW[ªéPQT[>C!¸=B´å‡
ÁC DNA MNW[ªéBâ…ÞÁ?5K"È{´îB¹³kÎ>C!Àó@å .â…ÞÁ
?4=›FIL8?‘+ILK.!DNA Mvà?5KPQT[BrùŠC!¬8@â…ÞÁ
.`Í4=wÜ5K2?C@-:8"DNA M|ÌBâ…ÞÁ?4=!È{´îBNW[ª
éPQT[CˆÐnM¿1=/8B>(K"
fê!¯BǟªéPQT[C!ÝÚªéAi+=!oãÞÁAHKªéMvàªé?5K
2?>áðÏAßÐ4=/8"†õBq×??GA!ñŒ@ÞÁ!£ëBnßCÝÚªéBŒ
øÏ@®ÐMÖ0"7B®Ð.3IAñŒ@ªéz§BnßA;@.K"…ÂBªéz§A™
%%
$%
NUCB JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS
AND INFORMATION SCIENCE vol.56 No.1
Om×¥ßvlÔC›†Ël!3PQpå59Î¥ßgŸkFC›†Ël"3C›†Ël
Q§I>/9CD¨ŸkC^–?(O"8PDæݬC)m×¥ßvFC§ËQzIO¨
ŸkC^–?(O"
3C¥ßx£ClÔBHMPOL*B!ĝ¥ßSTW[C›†ËlD¨ŸkC^–BL;
>wÐ7O"8CËlD¨ŸkC^–Bu=1—‹¬Q™:!4MBD!Æ°4P9ĝ¥ß
Cpå.›†ËlCŠç¬QIO"3C—‹¬!Šç¬.ĝ¥ßSTW[›†ËlCѬ
?(O"8PD«‰hÓA›†ËlSTW[?(O&nŒ• "
!
!
$'
"
¥ßԄC«‰#¨ŸkCÔË
ĝ¥ßSTW[CuÖ¥ß!8CԄ.¨ŸkQ¸N¢7"Ԅ4PO¥ßBe6>¨Ÿ
kC”äDƒÉ4PO"¨ŸkB,2OvÓSTW[D½äA˜ÍBu=1Ã]?­4P!
8PM.’·5!¡µÊB¶ˆs}Q™<"8Cϐ€.¨Ÿk!<GN!ĝ¥ßSTW[
C¥ßԄ€?(O"8PD’·7O¡µ€@5>~­4P9T$Z$STW[?J(O"
¨ŸkC”äQƒÉ7OԄ¥ßD¨ŸkC^–Bu=)>±Á4PO"¨ŸkC^–.›
MCŸkCâNäQƒÉ7O"ĝ¥ßSTW[B,)>D!uÖ¥ßCÒ㫉!Ԅ«‰
D¨ŸkC^–Bu=)>§Ž7O"8C›†ËlDĝ¥ß@¨ŸkC¶ˆ‘å!<GN!
uÖ¥ß@¥ßԄ€C¶ˆ‘åBLOËl?(O"3C^–BLO«‰hÓ¬.¨Ä¥ß
STW[CyºAÔËQ¹5!¨C®¼ÓèQ|_ÊBI!¨ŸkCÕdQÅ)>/9"
\UVXàœ#¨ŸkCܲ
¥ßSTW[CѬ@5>C\UVXàœD!vÓ´•!¥ßԄ€C\UVX?(O"Ä
¥ßSTW[B,2OvÓ´•!¥ßԄ€D¨Ÿk?(O"’·7O¡µÊA¶ˆ‘å?
~­4PO¨ŸkD!®Ø…¾CL*AáoA…ÛÃ]Q™9A)"¨ŸkC\UVXD!½
äASTW[Ã]Cϐ@5>!ڎÊ!é»ÊA`ŽCÇ?§Ž7O"8PD¨ŸkCܲ
C�(O"
RY[¥ßSTW[B,2O\UVXv@Ca)D!¨ŸkC^–.STW[C›†Ël
Qc/w35!¨ŸkC\UVX!8CܲQ«‰7O3@B(O"d‡¯©D¨ŸkC¤?
(O"8PDrK-B§Ž7O3@J(PE!y‚AÌq@AO3@J(O"8C§ËC”ä
D¨ŸkC^–.ƒIO"
G9!¥ßSTW[B,2O¥ßԄ€C\UVXDuÖ¥ßCÞ³CfB§Ž7O"¨Ÿ
kCܲB,)>J!uÖ¥ß?(Oĝ¥ß€Dšª¿C¨ŸkB 2.P>)1"¨Ÿ
kDj{CŸk.Å)9ÙáQÄCb“@5>c/0!3PQuB¦9AÙáCËlQ§I
O"8PD¨ŸkC<A0?(N!¨ÙáC<A0?(O"
¨Cĝ¥ßSTW[C›†ËlDuÖ¥ß@¥ßԄ€C¶ˆ‘åBLOËl?(O"¥
ßԄ€?(O¨Ÿk!3C¨ŸkC^–.›†ËlQ«‰7O"¥ßÒãC«‰!¥ßԄ
C«‰!4MBD!Ԅ€C\UVXQtI>!¨ŸkC^–Bu=)>›†ËlD§Ë7O"
8C—‹¬!Šç¬.ĝ¥ßSTW[B,2O¥ßSTW[Ѭ?(N!3CѬ.¨Ÿk
CyºAÔËQž„5!4MBD!¦9AiÀQJ9M7"STW[C›†Ël.¨ŸkC^
–BLO«‰QÈ+O@/!8PD¦9A›†ËlSTW[FCÔËiÀ@AO"
%#
#%
:?*JA%A8 # PWYA¥Þ
#!!
&%($")'
œgA\ˆ!˜Aw œgA\ˆBœgO‚ 3K|œAd·lA¬\=$K"/Ad·l*¸Ž–ÕQRU
YAŒ}¿hOsÂ1!ZSTVOoF<–ÕÉ{x=$KœgOž€3K"0I@B!/
AŒ}¿hAf½BœgAd·l@H9<Îd0L!6AÎd@p;%<!‹CAŒ}¿h
Aց*y¼0L<%-"¸Ž–ÕQRUYAŒ}¿hBœgAd·l*ž€3K¿h=$
K"
œAd·lBœA˜*¢E”3"˜B£š®„A_k=$J!6Aw B–Õc0L<B%
?%"¸Ž!×È!61<!¯‘>AnNJ@p;-jÂ!/LIA£šiÂAÁƒ*˜A`
EO¢E”3"|œA¢+Kkv!¢+<+7f½!6A¬±*œA˜OÔE”3"6Aw BrȾ@QRUYc0LK/>B?-!¯‘OoF7°Ú?Ü©m@(.K°Ú?nNJƒ
%Aº=ÔE”0LK"–Õc0LK/>?-w 0LK˜!/A˜*œAd·lO¢E”3"
œgAd·lBgO‚ 3K|œAd·lA«~…Û!6AÁƒ)Iw 0LK"–Õ
c0LK/>A?%˜Op@w 0LKœgAd·lB°Ú=$K"gA®„kv!g
Ó§A߆!Ñc!/LIA°q@N7K°Ú?Ü©*œgAd·lOw 1<%-"6A
°Ú?d·l@ž€0L<!°Ú?œgAÙJÚBÉ{0LK"
Œ}¿hA‰­eȟ
¸Ž–ÕQRUYAŒ}¿h!6A–ÕÉ{x=$Kœg!6A°Ú?ÙJÚ!6AÎd!
˼!61<“¡"/LIB!¨<!œgAd·l@p;%<›¿3K"/Ad·lB|œ
@[®1!g@b2<]?J!Š´>>G@Óc3K"6LB¹^Oa'!Š´Oa'<»
Û3K¤²¾?zÝ=B?%"/Ad·l@p;-Œ}¿hAÎdBœg@(.KÆÏÎd
@f,4!QRUYAº=Ò2<%K"¸Ž–ÕQRUYAŒ}¿hBd·lOGoF7Œ}
¿h=$K"
¸Ž–ÕQRUYAŒ}¿h!6A¿hA‰­eȟBœgAº=B˼0LÄ?%"œ
gB/LO˼3Kr‚O‰7?%"6A˼BœgA®„pÌ=$K¢³x@H9<?
0LK¯?%"˼Ap•BPWY–ÕQRUYAŒ}¿h>Ã2=$J!6AzÝBЏx
AzÝ=$K"œA¸Ž–ÕQRUYBXV®„OpÌ>3K"6LBXV!œCA›cOo
F<!PWY–ÕQRUY*ªJ”17Œ}¿hA_k=$K"
œAd·lB¸ŸAÉ¿@Ê9<Óc3K"œA¸Ÿ*¢ØxŒ}¿hAp×zÝ!œg
A{—Oǎ3K>+!™7?d·lBœgA‰­eȟ!XV¢Ð’AØA:?,O¦µ
3K/>@?M&"6LBœg@tFILK‹CAŒ}¿h>?K"6AŒ}¿hAÍ!
/LO˶3KAGœgAd·l=$K"/A˶OGoF<!œA¸Ž–ÕQRUYBŒ
}¿hO­.K"
% !$#"
¹u¢ØxAŒ}¿hBPWY–ÕQRUY>1<ªJ”0LK/>=‡D97"PWYO
À'K/>=ØO:?,!PWYOÓ'K/>=›c17"–ÕQRUY>1<AşOi)
3/>=!¹u¢ØxBØA:?,AڍOÉ¿05!Œ}¿hO›F<+7"6LBPWY
#!
"#
NUCB JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS
AND INFORMATION SCIENCE vol.56 No.1
C²î!ZaeQƒÒ¦Ø@7>ìé8M²î?,M"5CZaeC²îCÀ?!¯¹ˆ0„
Î7!¬C¾›¦Ø[]^e0µLŸ6N:"9ND%
!oÌBñMZae¦Ø[]^eCšŒ
Äv²î?,M"
Zae¦Ø[]^e@7>C¿…¯à!Ó¦Øq[]^e?,M¯¹ˆ!6KB!¬C¾›
¦Ø[]^e"¦Øq[]^e@Ó¦Øq[]^eCšŒÄv!9C±ÞC€PL-CÀB
¬D¯1M"¬C¨D5CtÂCÀ?µŸ6N:"¨C‡®0¦Øq6NA/<:5@DŽ?,M"¦Øq6NM5@CA-¨?!¦Øq6N>-A-¯Q¯1M"9N0¬C¯1è?
,M"šKCZaeB‘GN:%
!oÌCàC=A2!9CƒB¯GN!¬@7>¯1!àQ=
A4"xœAZaeCƒÒCI@B!ZaeB‘GNM5@CA-šKC¨QÖHŸ7!šK
C¯QÛ2Ÿ8"9ND¬C¯C~E?,O."9C¯CnHCÀB!ê/AMàC=A2Q
˛8M@1!¬DmÁC¨Qœ}7!9CÀB×GN>-3C?,O./"
#"$!
³Ç°!’‚¥£!¢‰ç™
#
!!
*$*Šº¯Õsy'¼"{
ZaesyCƒ´+‚Ï Å
#
!"
!$*Šº¯Õsy'¼#{
ZaesyCÄv+‚Ï Å
w½— #
!!
($*=A0LC-C;'Zae¦Ø[]^eCšŒÄv+
ߋp¡s»yðž Vol#
&
"'#
w½— #
!!
*$*=A0LC-C;'¾C²î+
ߋp¡s»yðž Vol#
&
$'#
w½— #
!"
!$*=A0LC-C;'àC²î+
ߋp¡s»yðž Vol#
&
%'"
“%áåÍ #
!!&*Ub\T`^RW]Êâ+‚Ï Å
#
!!**ZaeCÆzé²î'Ub\T`^RW]+
*Šº¯Õsy'¼"{
ZaesyCƒ´+¼%¤
‚Ï Å
[fi&_RkV& "
*&
"(©Ñ#
!
!
))$*¯à@Dr/'ÕíÃBH:¯•Ú+‚Ï Å
áäª #
!!
*$*àð+ÉÜÙ¶ŸÑ†u
dSYh· #
!!"$*¯à@Dr/
9N/KC&
!Ì'ÝëC¯àsyFC˜«+Ðԁ
–À§ã #
!!
*$*”cjXgeqBJM¸Î­|•ÚCæÈ+
*Šº¯Õsy'¼({
”¯lï¯Õy+¼$¤
'%
''
‚Ï Å