Comet Siding Spring (C/SS) at Mars: Risk and Opportunity

National Aeronautics and
Space Administration
Jet Propulsion Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
Pasadena, California
Mars Exploration Program Office
Comet Siding Spring (C/SS) at Mars: Risk and Opportunity Presented by R. Zurek, Mars Program Office (JPL) 29 July, 2014 Comet Siding Spring HST Image: Mar 11, 2014 Mars !
!
National Aeronautics and
Space Administration
Jet Propulsion Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
Pasadena, California
Mars Exploration Mars Exploration Program Office
Operational
Odyssey
2016
2001 - 2014
2018
2020
2022
MRO
ISRO – MOM
Mangalyaan
Mars Express
Collaboration
ESA Trace Gas
Orbiter
(Electra)
Future Planning MAVEN
Curiosity – Mars Science
Laboratory
Opportunity
!
!
ESA ExoMars
Rover (MOMA)
2020
Science Rover
InSIGHT
(Discovery Program)
2
2
National Aeronautics and
Space Administration
Jet Propulsion Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
Pasadena, California
Mars Exploration Mars Exploration Program Office
Operational
Odyssey
2016
2001 - 2014
2018
2020
2022
MRO
ISRO – MOM
Mangalyaan
Mars Express
Collaboration
ESA Trace Gas
Orbiter
(Electra)
Future Planning MAVEN
Curiosity – Mars Science
Laboratory
Opportunity
!
!
ESA ExoMars
Rover (MOMA)
2020
Science Rover
InSIGHT
(Discovery Program)
3
3
National Aeronautics and
Space Administration
Jet Propulsion Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
Pasadena, California
Comet /2013 A1 Siding Spring Mars Exploration Program Office
Close&up)of)Encounter)
Geometry)
vref = 2.0 m/s
vref = 2.5 m/s
normalized flux
0
0.5
1
vref = 1.5 m/s
0
1
2
3
Ame)from)c/a)[hr])
Siding Spring
C/A:)Closest)
Approach)
•
132,000&km&
Mars
View from the Sun
!
!
1
2
3 0
1
time from c/a [hr]
2
• 
3
current recommendation:!
HST obs point to bulk grain velocities below threshold
threshold for Mars impact, so the timing of the v_ref 1
Peak)flux)seGling)in)at)90&100)
one most closely representing the flux of grains, if any
minutes)a@er)closest)approach)
•
28,000&km&
Orbit)Planes)Crossing)
~95)min)a@er)C/A)
0
4 National Aeronautics and
Space Administration
Jet Propulsion Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
Pasadena, California
Comet Modeling Mars Exploration Program Office
Ø  Model the comet-­‐produced dust distribuFon as a funcFon of Fme –  In fall of 2013, two modeling groups were selected through the MEP Cri@cal Data Products program to help with this: •  Pasquale Tricarico, Nalin H. Samarasinha, Mark Sykes, PSI •  Tony Farnham, Mike S. P. Kelley, Dennis Bodewits, U. Maryland –  Also par@cipa@ng, providing @me-­‐of-­‐arrival of comet nucleus and debris: •  Davide Farnocchia, Paul Chodas, Steven Chesley, JPL Solar System Dynamics Group –  Reports have been or will soon be submiGed for publica@on •  P. Tricarico et al., Astrophysical Journal LeTers, 787, L35, 2014 •  Farnocchia et al., in press, Astrophysical Journal •  Farnham et al., in prepara@on –  Original reports and overview available on hGp://mepag.jpl.nasa.gov/cdp.cfm Ø  Results of the modeling acFvity –  Modeling results were constrained using available observa@ons of the comet. –  Provided arrival @ming & dura@on of the comet-­‐associated par@cle flux at Mars. –  Characterized the comet-­‐derived par@cles in terms of size and number density. !
!
5 Modeled Par@cle Field National Aeronautics and
Space Administration
Jet Propulsion Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
Pasadena, California
Grain density 1 g/cm3, v_ref = 1 m/s Mars Exploration Program Office
1.5e+05
Fluence is es@mated to be in the 0 to 10-­‐6 counts/m2 [1/km2] range • 
The par@cles, from 1 to 10 mm in diameter, arrive at Mars travelling 56 km/s, 80-­‐110 minutes a[er closest approach of the nucleus. • 
Orbiters can hide behind Mars for 30-­‐40 minutes, by phasing in orbit. • 
Rovers are protected by the Mars atmosphere, thin as it is. [km]
1e+05
• 
50000
0
[km] -1e+05
!
!
-50000
0
50000
[km]
1e+05
1.5e+05
!17
National Aeronautics and
Space Administration
Jet Propulsion Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
Pasadena, California
C/SS Encounter Goals for Mars Assets Mars Exploration Program Office
•  Survive: Low fluence & orbit phasing take care of that •  Science ObjecFves Focus on Two Areas: 1) the comet itself and 2) its potenFal impact on the Mars atmosphere. •  For the comet, the goals are: Ø  First-­‐ever resolu@on of the nucleus of a long-­‐period comet. o  MRO HiRISE: 140 m/pixel on a nucleus ~ 500 to 2500 m across Ø  Characterize C/SS coma & tail: Par@cle size, gas composi@on, ac@vity. o  Warning: The Mars spacecra[ instruments weren’t designed for high-­‐spectral resolu@on gas survey or for imaging diffuse, faint objects (as compared to Mars), but we will see what we can do. o  The best instruments for comet composi@on may well be on MAVEN, which will follow orbit inser@on on Sept. 21 with maneuvers and instrument deployments as they transi@on to their nominal science orbit. •  For Mars, the goals are: Ø  Observe impacts of cometary gas & dust on the Mars atmosphere. !
!
o  Upper Atmospheric hea@ng (>150 km) o  Ionospheric enhancement o  Cloud seeding? 7 National Aeronautics and
Space Administration
Jet Propulsion Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
Pasadena, California
Science ObservaFons* -­‐ Preliminary *Conducted only if safe, posing no spacecraft or instrument issues
Mars Exploration Program Office
NASA Missions Comet Mars Response v v u u u u Comet Nucleus: Size, Shape & Rota@on u Comet Ac@vity: Jets & Variable Brightness u u v v u Comet Coma: Variability, par@cle size, gas composi@on u v u u u u u Comet Tail: Par@cle Size u v v v v u u Mars Upper Atmosphere Composi@on: Neutrals, ions & electrons; meteor trails v v u u u u Mars Lower Atmosphere: Temperature and Clouds v v v v v v 1Conducted
NGIMS,STATIC SWEA,SWIA LPW,MAG, SEP IUVS MastCAM CHEMCAM? PANCAM HEND/NS THEMIS VIS & IR SHARAD MARCI CTX MAVEN1 ROVERS Comet General Features Key: major contribu@on u contribu@on v !
!
ODY MCS Observa@on Objec@ve HiRISE Target CRISM MRO u only if transition to science orbit is nominal
8 National Aeronautics and
Space Administration
Jet Propulsion Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
Pasadena, California
Science ObservaFons* -­‐ MAVEN *Conducted only if safe, posing no spacecraft or instrument issues
C/SS Nucleus Closest Approach
- 2 days
Possible Encounter with C/SS Debris
- 1 day
IUVS Comet Imaging on 5 orbits Mars Exploration Program Office
+ 1 day
All instruments as H/V off
in standard Mars MAG, LPW, SEP on
science on 7 orbits + 2 days
All instruments as in standard Mars science on 10 orbits: •  Charged par@cles, Ne & Te, Ions/neutrals •  MAG, IUVS limb & coronal scans: Mars imaging (lyA, OH, D/H) MAVEN Example
•  Science opera@ons begin 2 days early to observe Mars, interrupted for safety during peak dust @me, resume for 2 days post encounter, then resume nominal transi@on plan. •  Pre-­‐encounter imaging to determine ac@vity level, composi@on, gas/dust, etc. Also view Mars as baseline for post-­‐encounter effects. •  Spacecra[ in safe configura@on during close encounter and dust tail passage, implies safest aqtude and instrument High Voltage (H/V) off. •  Periapsis of 4.5 hr orbit is behind Mars at predicted @me of peak dust flux. !
!
9 National Aeronautics and
Space Administration
Science ObservaFons* -­‐ MRO Jet Propulsion Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
Pasadena, California
*Conducted only if safe, posing no spacecraft or instrument issues
C/SS Nucleus Closest Approach
- 2 days
Mars Exploration Program Office
Possible Encounter with C/SS Debris
+ 1 day
- 1 day
Periodic C/SS Observa@ons each 2hr orbit + 2 days
Periodic C/SS Observa@ons on each 2hr orbit C/A
C/A – 1 orbit: 2 CRISM + 13 HiRISE scans Various line @mes to provide different exposures; CTX R/A C/A orbit: 2 CRISM + 10 HiRISE scans + CTX R/A Shortest line @mes for best resolu@on; MCS obs of coma (TBD) Key: C/A = Closest Approach; R/A = Ride-­‐Along !
!
Center @me for C/SS par@cle encounter with Mars: 20:07 ± 10 min UT 20:46:49 19:43:51 C/SS C/A 18:31 UT 19:01:52 18:12:16 17:39:30 16:38:26 MRO Example
C/A + 1 orbit: 2 CRISM + 13 HiRISE scans Various line @mes to provide different exposures, CTX R/A Nadir observa@ons C/SS observa@ons 10 National Aeronautics and
Space Administration
Jet Propulsion Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
Pasadena, California
Science ObservaFons* -­‐ Mars ODY Mars Exploration Program Office
• 
ObjecFve: –  Emphasis on the unique contribu@ons to be made by THEMIS: moderate resolu@on infrared spectral imaging. • 
THEMIS: 3 proposed, prioriFzed observaFons: –  Obtain highest possible spa@al resolu@on images over as much of the coma as possible during one observing period (±26 hr?). •  Image coma as close to closest approach to Mars as possible. –  Obtain complete coverage of the coma and tail at moderate spa@al resolu@on. –  Obtain an image of the enVre coma and tail above the Mars limb to provide context of the coma rela@ve to the known temperature and gas and dust opacity of the Mars atmosphere. • 
!
!
11 Neutron Spectrometer and HEND: –  Nominal observa@ons while in nadir-­‐point aqtude to monitor effects on neutral and charged par@cle fluxes. National Aeronautics and
Space Administration
Science ObservaFons* -­‐ Opportunity & Curiosity Jet Propulsion Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
Pasadena, California
Mars Exploration Program Office
!
!
12 • 
When the comet is at closest approach, the local @mes at Opportunity and Curiosity will be early morning and late a[ernoon, respec@vely, so the comet would be viewed thru the dayside sky. –  It is also mid-­‐southern spring, a @me when extensive dust storms may occur, further reducing visibility. • 
Best viewing will be pre-­‐dawn and post-­‐dusk on the encounter sol, but several hours before and a[er closest approach. National Aeronautics and
Space Administration
Jet Propulsion Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
Pasadena, California
Next Steps Mars Exploration Program Office
• 
Phasing Maneuvers
Ø 
Ø 
Ø 
Ø 
• 
• 
July 2
August 5
August 27
October 9
MRO 1st of 2 phasing maneuvers (OTM 37)
ODY phasing maneuver, if required
MRO 2nd of 2 phasing maneuvers (OTM 38)
MAVEN will combine with 3rd period reduction maneuver (PRM-3) during
transition to science orbit
Get Comet Encounter Observation Sequences finalized
Interactions with Comet Science Community
Ø  Ongoing: Participation in Coordinated Investigations of Comets (CIOC) forum
Ø  August 11: Workshop involving Mars Projects and other Comet Observers
o  Give status on Mars spacecraft comet observing plans; seek comment from community.
o  Review latest observations and observation plans.
Ø  September 19: Virtual Meeting between Mars Projects and Comet Scientists
o  Give status on final science observing plans by Mars Projects.
o  Review latest observations.
!
!
• 
September 19: Provide update on mitigation status and observation planning
• 
October 19: Closest Approach of Comet Siding Spring to Mars
Ø  Prime observing campaign ±2.5 days around nucleus closest approach
13