NCO Rank Boards Feedback and Discussion

NCO Rank Boards
2013
--Feedback & Discussion--
For Training Use Only
Updated Jan 2014
Honor – Duty – Respect
1
Purpose
• Share observations on cadet performance
during Regimental NCO Rank Boards, 2013
• Discuss potential priorities & initiatives with
rising Corps leaders
Honor – Duty – Respect
Flow
• Board President’s Charge
• Keys to Success
– Preparation
– Interview
• General & Specific Feedback
• Decision Making Approach
• Take-Aways
Honor – Duty – Respect
3
Reminder:
Board President’s Charge
• Welcome & congratulations
• We hold you in high regard for reaching regimental board level
• Thank you for being willing to lead
• Two purposes for board
• Gain insight into your leadership & judgment
• Help board make good decision about who leads the Corps
• Flow: three-to-four questions & final “opportunity”
NOTE: board process is about interview “experience” too
Honor – Duty – Respect
Keys to Success (1)
• Preparation:
– Identify your objective - never sell yourself short
– Develop “themes”
• Desire, capability/confidence, vision
• Think big, inclusive, important, personal strengths &
weaknesses
– Don’t take “guess the question” approach
– Consider “the board” perspective: credibility,
judgment, comm skills, presence, priorities,
leadership views
Honor – Duty – Respect
5
Keys to Success (2)
• Interview
– Only one first impression…
• Appearance, posture, gestures, eye contact, what you say
–
–
–
–
–
–
Do like your Mom taught you…
Know your themes (desire, capability, vision)…
Be positive…
Chair fly (practice) what you can…
Grace under fire…
Be yourself…
Honor – Duty – Respect
6
Regimental Boards
--More Interview Resources1-Cadets selected for Regimental Boards are highly
encouraged to use campus resources to practice for
their rank board. Specifically, cadets wanting to
maximize their interview prep should follow the two-step
process below:
•
•
1
Step 1: Use interview stream for rank boards preparation:
http://www.citadel.edu/root/images/Career_Center/interviewstream.pdf .
Interview stream provides sample rank board questions.
Step 2: E-mail interview stream link to Gervais Hagerty
([email protected]) in the Oral Communications Lab to secure an
appointment for advanced preparation. Advanced preparation consists
of a one-on-one, 25-minute session to improve interviewing skills.
Appointments are limited to the first seven cadets per battalion to
contact the OCL, who have already completed the interview stream.
See “Letter of Instrcution for Cadets” at http://www.citadel.edu/root/promotion-boards
Honor – Duty – Respect
Other Basics
• No CQB = no opportunity
• Stack the deck
• Teach rules to knobs &
sophomores
Honor – Duty – Respect
Note: point values change
periodically; always
consult most recent
“Promotion Board
Memorandum” on
Commandant’s webpage
General Observations (1)
--Interview Feedback--
In stronger interviews:
•There was evident passion as demonstrated by:
• Enthusiasm and/or…
• Twinkle in the eye and/or…
Genuine
• Preparation and/or…
• Intensity
•Cadet was confident-humble-respectful-inclusive
•Cadet was too “tight” (or too casual)
Honor – Duty – Respect
Mindset
Practiced
General Observations (2)
--Interview Feedback--
In stronger interviews, cadets:
•Were sharp, professional, and engaged with “the audience”
•Stepped up to higher responsibility (seeking 1SGs or higher)
•Were willing to leave company or battalion
•“Knew” board president & audience
•Had “themes” to emphasize
•Had “thoughtful” priorities for next year
•Knew how they might approach new responsibility
Honor – Duty – Respect
Themes-Priorities-Approach
Themes:
•Bring love for company AND the Corps to job (appreciate standards)
•Will stay in step with CO (command team is huge)
•Committed to developing ALL cadets (EVERYONE is in our care)
Priorities:
•Discipline with chain of command, to include communication
•Academics
•Everyone a leader for personal appearance & professionalism
Approach:
•Be the example & be positive
•Communicate, communicate, communicate
•Sync: Emphasize routine commander/1SG sync AND 1SG/NCO sync meetings
•Be visible: “75% of leadership is doing what you don’t have to do”
Honor – Duty – Respect
Homeruns - Keeper Quotes (1)
• “Peer leadership is key, working with upperclassmen – set clear
expectations, lead by example, positively reinforce…”
• “Challenge more than rank holders…privates essential”
• “The Citadel is amazing place…key is helping all remember WOW
factor…why came here in the first place”
• “CO & 1SG set tone for unit—objective (fair), positive, professional”
• “Balance is key—keep academics #1 but challenge in other areas”
• “Diversity is a strength”
Honor – Duty – Respect
Homeruns - Keeper Quotes (2)
• “We need to break down some stereotypes…as an athlete I felt
branded”
• “No stereotypes, I would just asked to be judged on the merits”
• “Negativity holds us back”
• “We…”
• “A leader needs to be visible and communicate directly”
• “1SG has responsibility to the commander and cadets, all cadets”
• A TAC or C/SGM who says “can police own classmates”
Honor – Duty – Respect
“Caught Looking”
• Reporting In – not crisp or with gusto
• UOD – not squared away
• Desire – no answer to “anything you want to leave
us with regarding your leadership & next year?”
• Body language – too “comfortable” at board
Honor – Duty – Respect
14
Decision Making Approach
• ID criteria first versus personalizing first
– Improves objectivity; facilitates decision making
Scoresheet
– Personal Appearance
– Oral Expression & Conversational Skills
– Leadership Potential
– Specific Board Member Questions
Honor – Duty – Respect
15
Take-Aways
• Leadership is precious privilege
– Don’t say “no”
• Preparation time is fleeting
– Don’t squander it
• Great leaders:
–
–
–
–
Are willing to lead
Are the example
Set expectations & priorities
Are relentless in execution
Honor – Duty – Respect
16