Explosion Welding in the Energy Industry

Explosion Welding in the Energy Industry
Warren Salt
February 06, 2014
© 2013 NobleClad. All rights reserved.
A DMC Company
NobelClad (a DMC Company)
Warren Salt
Director of Business Development
5405 Spine Road
Boulder, CO 80301
[email protected]
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
WHAT IS EXPLOSION WELDING?
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
WHAT IS EXPLOSION WELDING?
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
WHAT IS EXPLOSION WELDING?
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
INTRODUCTION
•
Started operation in 1965
•
Headquarters – Boulder, CO
•
Public Company
•
Traded on NASDAQ – BOOM
•
~480 employees
•
2012 Revenue ‐ $202M
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
BRAND RELATIONSHIPS | NEW LOGOS
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
3 Manufacturing Locations
US – Mt. Braddock, PA
France – Rivesaltes
Germany – Burbach
220 employees
Structured for 70,000 sqm of capacity
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
The Process
Explosion Welding
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
PROCESS DEFINITION/CLASSIFICATION
• Filler metal: • None
• Heat Input: • V=0/I=0
• Travel Speed: • Really fast (2000‐3000 m/s)
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
THE PROCESS
Key Process Elements
• Good Quality Materials
• Explosion Bonding Parameters
• Standoff Distance
• Explosive Load
• Explosive Burn Rate
• Final Inspection
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
BONDZONE – HOW DOES IT WORK?
Many National Laboratories, Research Institutes and Universities have performed high magnification nano‐scale studies of explosion welds in recent years
Consensus: Solid State Welding Process
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
•
No intermetallic formation
•
No heat affected zone
 NobelClad.com
BOND STRENGTH
• High shear strength: • Typically >400MPa for stainless and nickel alloys
• Lower strength CRA’s (Cu alloys, Ti, Zr): ≈ 200 Mpa
• Virtually impossible to separate during forming and fabrication
• Internal attachments can safely be welded to clad surface
Shear test – SSteel/Csteel
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
The Process
Capabilities
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
Clad plates for reactors
(9m x 2m x 140 mm)
CAPABILITIES
50 t
13 m
5m
Large clad tubesheets
(dia 2,3 m x 400 mm)
Cladder : 0.25 to 50 mm
Base: 0.25 to 1000 mm
Flat plates and Concentric Cylinders
Limits:
• Cannot clad contoured surfaces
• Cannot clad brittle materials • need > 10% elongation
• need > 20 joule impact
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
DETACLAD® EXW RANGE OF ALLOYS
Typical Clad Metals
Typical Base Metals
• A 240 Type 410S
• Carbon steel (A 516, 533, 537,…)
• A 240 Type 304 L, 316L
• Cr‐Mo steel (A 387,…)
• A 240 Type 321/347
• Cr‐Mo‐V steel (A 542)
• A 240 Type 904L
• Stainless steels (316L, DUPLEX)
• Alloy 625, Alloy 825, Alloy 600
• API 5L / DNV pipe grades
• Alloy 59, Alloy C276, C22
• Monel 400
• Duplex 2205, 2207
• Aluminum and Al alloys
• Copper and Cu‐Ni‐alloys
• Titanium, Zirconium, Tantalum
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
DETACLAD EXW FEATURES
• Cold Welding Technology – No Diffusion, Intermetallic formation or Heat Affected Zones
• Metal properties are not altered by Detaclad® operation
• Corrosion resistance
• Mechanical properties
•
Produces a strong, ductile, continuous metallurgical weld over full clad surface
•
Detaclad® will not disbond when fabricated by proper thermal and mechanical procedures
•
Virtually any metal combination with good fracture toughness can be welded
•
•
Dissimilar alloys, such as Ti or Al to Steel
•
Similar alloys, such as Stainless Steel to Steel
Low cost and high value for many metal types and thicknesses
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
DETACLAD® EXW VS. WELD OVERLAY
•
Detaclad® has no dilution ‐ alloy chemistry is constant over full thickness
•
All overlay has some dilution
•
Virtually no heat affected zone
•
Explosion cladding has much faster production rate
•
Overlay typically requires 5mm deposition
•
Results in higher weight and cost
•
Internals can be directly attached to Detaclad® •
Cannot be done with overlay
•
Is suitable for virtually all metal types
•
Is lower cost for many alloys and thicknesses
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
DETACLAD® EXW VS. ROLL BOND • Superior shear strength (ie bond strength)
• Typically 200 to 500 mPa dependent upon alloy
• Translates into a guaranteed bond upon subsequent forming with appropriate procedures
• Attachments can weld directly to Detaclad®
• Improved corrosion performance from low temperature process which minimizes sensitization
• Production profile
• Large fix asset that is shared vs. relatively low fix assets that are dedicated
• Translates into more stable pricing and more stable lead times
• Nobelclad maintains 4 week flow for standard product
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
Application
Industries
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
INDUSTRIES
•Armoring
•Shipbuilding
•Railway industry
•Electrochemical processing
•Hydrometallurgy
•Refrigeration
•Steel Mills
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
Energy
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Upstream Oil and Gas
Refineries
Power Generation
Coal Gasification
LNG
Alternative (IWind, solar, OTEC),
• Chemical & Petrochemical Industry
 NobelClad.com
GORGON SLUG CATCHER
• 153 plates – 625 + 5LX65M
•17 @ 37mm x 3,248mm x 12,650mm
•136 @ 37mm x 3,248mm x 12,300mm
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
TMCP + EXW FOR CLAD PIPE, ALLOY 625
Comparative ASTM G28 Method A Corrosion Testing
Alloy 625 Clad, EXW & Hot Roll Bond
1.00
0.90
Corrosion Rate (mm/y)
0.80
0.70
0.60
0.50
0.40
NobelClad EXW:
Sour Service rated, Excellent CVN, CTOD and DWTT
0.30
0.20
Voest TMCP:
No Mechanical Properties Reported, No SPWHT
0.10
0.00
Special Metals Typical
NobelClad EXW As‐Clad
NobelClad Gorgon EXW with PWHT TMCP Clad (Voest ‐ NACE Corrosion
2013)
 NobelClad.com
Application
Co‐Extruded Boiler Tubes
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
COAL FIRED POWER PLANT
• Basic Process
• Burn Coal
• Heat Water/Steam
• Generate Electricity with Steam
Turbine
• Water wall
• Efficiency Improvements
• Staged Combustion
• Reducing Environment
• Accelerated Corrosion
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
COEXTRUDED ALLOY 622 TESTING
•
Baseline Steel Tubes
•
•
•
Massive corrosion
First Step Weld Overlay
•
Significant improvement
•
Still shorter life than desired
•
Weld structure is susceptible to corrosion
Second Step Coextruded
•
Cold welding process
•
Extruded structure
J. N. DuPont, W. Van Geertruyden, A. Caizza and A. Esposito, Paper No. 10201: Corrosion Behavior of Alloy 600 and 622 Coextruded and Weld Overlay Coatings, NACE Corrosion 2010
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
COEXTRUDED BOILER TUBE
Tube Manufacturing
•
Step 1 Clad Billet
• Concentric Clad
• Inside F11
• Outside Alloy C22
• 6” OD x 24” Billet
•
Step 2 Extrude Boiler Tube
• 2.25” OD
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
Other Applications
Oil and Gas Industry
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
DMC CLAD REFINERY COLUMN
Base Metal SA‐516‐70
Cladding changes with height: 304L, 317L, 625
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
COKE DRUM
SA 516 G70 + 410S or 316 L (40+3mm)
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
REFINERY COLUMN
Cr‐Mo steel + Stainless 321 (102 mm + 3 mm )
5 m diam x 35 meters long
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
CLAD CRUDE VACUUM TOWER
Explosion Welding for the Energy Industry
 NobelClad.com
Thank you
Warren Salt
5405 Spine Road
Boulder, CO [email protected]
[email protected]
© 2013 NobleClad. All rights reserved.
A DMC Company