Coexistence for wireless medical devices_IEC 60601-1

Compliance & Regulatory Info Sheet Nr. 4 | Wireless Medical Devices & Connected Healthcare Applications | July 2014
Medical device manufacturers are increasingly incorporating radiofrequency (RF) wireless technology into their medical devices. Communication is accomplished using either published IEEE standards or
proprietary protocols, many of which operate at unlicensed frequencies
in the Industrial, Scientific and Medical (ISM) bands or in the Medical
Implant Communication Service (MICS) band. As a result, ensuring
wireless coexistence has become a focused effort for regulatory bodies
all over the world.
In this regards the FDA guidance document “Radio-Frequency Wireless
Technology in Medical Devices,” outlines concerns related to RF wireless devices and asks that suppliers specifically address - among others
- coexistence for their chosen wireless modality. However, test engineers will find that it is extremely difficult to find procedures that apply
to FDA concerns. Although the FDA outlines a limited set of standards
to assist in wireless medical device testing, it is still recommended that
design teams review coexistence test plans with known experts in the
field of product deployment.
To address these concerns the IEEE 802.15.2 guideline for coexistence
can be considered. This guideline recommends interference analysis
criteria for measuring interference between wireless systems. It provides an exhaustive list of coexistence factors in the physical layer and
medium access control layer that should be taken into account. It is
to be noted that there is a clear distinction between EMC testing and
wireless coexistence testing.
Wireless Risks
IEC 60601-1-2 is the general safety standard for medical electrical
equipment and the primary standard used for EMC testing of non-implanted and non-in-vitro diagnostic electrical medical devices.
Until recently the major limitation of the IEC 60601-1-2 standard was
that RF receivers are exempt from immunity testing in the exclusion
band. In other words, a medical device with RF wireless technology operating in the 2.4 GHz ISM band was not required by IEC 60601-1-2 to
maintain wireless communication when subjected to RF signals in its
passband.
To fill this gap, the IEC published early this year IEC 60601-1-2: 4th
Edition which reshapes the environment for Medical EMC while implementing considerably increased levels for radiated immunity.
In addition the compliance criteria are no longer defined but depend
highly on the risk management of the manufacturer. As a result, compliance according to IEC 60601-1-2: 4th Edition requires a close coordination process between the manufacturer and the test laboratory. Find the
key changes as follows:
•
•
EM Sources
•
Naturel (lightning, ESD)
Non-Communicating (RF, Inductive charging...)
Communications (Cell phones, Wireless data...)
Receptors
IEC 60601-1-2: 4th Edition (2014) reshapes
the medical environment
TRADITIONAL EMC
WIRELESS
COEXISTANCE
Unintended (Hearing Aids, Medical Devices...)
•
•
•
Communications (Cell phones, Wireless data, RFID...)
At present, device manufacturers and test facilities use very different
methods of coexistence testing. Until recently the medical device EMC
standards did not require test procedures to assess the performance of
systems containing RF receivers in the presence of in-band transmitters. Here, test engineers can find answers in „IEEE 1900.2: Recommended Practice for Interference and Coexistence Analysis“ including
an extensive overview of coexistence factors to consider during testing
and recommends interference analysis criteria for measuring interference between radio systems.
Early this year the IEC 60601-1-2:2014 (4th Edition) has been published,
implying dramatical changes for the medical industry, in particular the
EMC approach for coexistence testing. For more details consult the
summary in the right column on this page. CETECOM is ready to support
you!
Apart from this, various regulatory interest groups are currently elaborating test methods to evaluate wireless coexistence. The IEEE 802.19
Wireless Coexistence Working Group assessing each 802 standard to
determine scenarios in which interference may occur. Parallel to this,
the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) C63, subcommittee 8
formed a working group to seek solutions, known as C63.27. CETECOM
is an active member of this working group.
The environment is divided into 3 areas:
−Professional healthcare facility environment
−Home Healthcare Environment including logistics
−Special Environment /military areas
The manufacturer must state the suitable environment(s) for use,
and design the MEE for emission and immunity accordingly.
The radiated immunity has increased the testing frequencies to match
the reasonably foreseeable max. level found in the environment
Immunity levels are harmonized with IEC 60601-1-11
Immunity testing now follows the same port-by-port convention of
IEC 61000-6 of the Generic EMC standards
Immunity to proximity fields from RF wireless communications
equipment is based on a minimum separation distance of 30 cm
Introduction dates
•
•
•
In Europe, CENELEC has recognized the 4th edition. The withdrawal date for the 3rd Edition is to be expected in 2017-2018.
In the U.S. the FDA will decide on the 4th Edition in July, probably with a 3-year transition period. Unless changes are made that
affect its compliance retesting of legacy products is not required.
Canada will only review the 4th Edition in 2015, meaning that it will
not be adopted before 2015/2016.
Questions? Contact CETECOM!
We are ready for IEC 60601-1-2: 4th Edition!
Coexistence Evaluation
Test Planning Analysis
Conducted Testing
Radiated Testing
Consequential Chain Mapping
Extrapolation to Field Performance
Field Measurements & Monitoring
© CETECOM Group 2014 | Contact: [email protected] | www.cetecom.com