Outcomes, quality of life, scoring systems

ICU-acquired weakness and
recovery from critical illness
What doesn’t kill you makes you weaker
Sandra Oeyen
Intensieve Zorg
UZ Gent
“Surviving Intensive Care: a report from the 2002
Brussels Roundtable.” Angus et al. Intensive Care
Med 2003; 29: 368-377

The traditional goal of intensive care has been to decrease
short-term mortality. While worthy and extremely
important, this goal fails to address the issue of what it
means to survive intensive care. Key questions include
 whether ICU survivors have optimal long-term outcomes
 whether ICU care decisions would change if we knew
more about these outcomes
Co-morbidity = underlying health status:
important for long-term outcome
always obtain a thorough history!

co-morbidity
LOOK AND THINK OUTSIDE THE BOX….

How will the patient survive the chronic phase?

patients and families measure success by return to pre-ICU facilities
 independent living
 return to work
 no suffering
HEALTH RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE
HRQOL
QOL
persoonsgebonden voldoening of tevredenheid in de
verschillende domeinen (fysiek – mentaal – sociaal) van
het leven en hoe dit beïnvloed wordt door de gezondheid
van een persoon
How to measure quality of life?

Specific instruments


focus on aspects specific to conditions (disease, population, …)
Generic instruments (which can be used for every patient)

Short-Form 36 (SF 36)




36 questions
physical health: physical functioning - physical limitations - pain - general health
mental health: vitality - social functioning - emotional limitations - mental health
EuroQol-5D or EuroQol-6D (EQ-5D, EQ-6D)


5 domains : mobility; self-care; usual activities; pain; anxiety-depression
6 domains: + cognition
Oeyen S et al. Quality of life after intensive care:
A systematic review of the literature.
Crit Care Med 2010; 38: 2380-400

worst long-term QOL:





severe ARDS
prolonged mechanical ventilation
severe trauma
severe sepsis
influence?






severity of illness
comorbidity
preadmission QOL
age
gender
acquired complications
Physical dysfunction is common
Intensive care unit acquired weakness = ICU-AW

long-standing consequences have large effects on recovery
ICU-AW = CIM and/or CIP

CIM= critical illness myopathy (primary myopathy)
muscle fibre atrophy – muscle necrosis

CIP = critical illness polyneuropathy
distal axonopathy
ICU-acquired weakness: long-term consequences

muscle wasting and weakness

fatigue

pain – painful joints

poor appetite, dysphagia, cachexia, weight loss

voice and taste changes

skin and nail changes, hair loss

sexual dysfunction

pruritis
Mental dysfunction is common

poor QOL physically (younger patients!)

fear of death - anxiety – depression

PTSD (>> benzodiazepines during ICU – NOT severity of illness!)

disturbed sleep - insomnia

lack of confidence

lack of libido

guilt - social isolation

previous psychiatric history

familial consequences – marital difficulties - financial difficulties
Cognitive impairment is common

90% at hospital discharge



decreased to 25-78% within 1-2 years
higher in ARDS
clinically underappreciated!!

decreased QOL

inability to work

poor concentration – poor memory

associated with ICU delirium
What can we better do to improve patient outcomes?
PICS

Recognise and be aware of PICS



Family and GP may have little understanding of ICU and the problems
patients faced
Family members may also suffer from this critical care event (PICS-F)
knowledge/ information: information brochure, videos, social media
What can we better do to improve patient outcomes?
PICS
Critical Care Medicine 2014

examined in 11 studies – including 2 RCT

>> diary usage in Scandinavia (40-76% ICUs) and UK

Aim?
to fill the memory gaps
to promote psychological recovery
Diaries for patients may, with further research, be shown to be very
effective. However, the provision of diaries to ICU patients and its
study are in their infancy, with more questions than answers.
So….PICS….and now?!

Few proven specific therapies for PICS but….
the PICS concept is new and research just started recently

Often post-ICU patients do not have access to certain interventions because they
do not qualify for these interventions as they have not a certain diagnosis;
for example stroke, AMI, post CABG revalidation, respiratory revalidation,…

We can not change a lot of things in the post-ICU phase:






families
co-morbidity
rehabilitation
social interplays
quality and continuum of care from ICU – home environment
How much of the morbidity we see in ICU survivors is actually caused by the
acute illness?
ABCDE + FGH already during ICU admission :
PREVENT PICS!!
ABCDE + FGH to prevent PICS






ABC: Awakening and Breathing Coordination (agitation and
sedation):
reduce use of sedatives - allow patients to be more alert
D: delirium assessment/monitoring
E: early exercise, early mobilisation (starts in the ICU!)
F: family inclusion, follow up referrals
G: good hand-off communication, family communication
H: hand family written information, diary
Critical Care Medicine 2014

prospective cohort before-after study

624-bed tertiary center

5 adult ICUs, 1 step-down unit, 1 onco-hemato special care unit

prebundle: feb-oct 2011; 146 pts

SAT and SBT conform individual ICU physican’s practice (safety? success? failure?)

no delirium or management policies in place

patients were not routinely assisted out of bed

postbundle: oct 2011- april 2012; 150 pts

ABCDE bundle applied to every patient (regardless ventilation) unless order NOT to apply the
bundle (opt-out method)
Pre-ABCDE
bundle
Post-ABCDE
bundle
Unadjusted P
Ventilator free days; median
(IQR)
21 (0-25)
24 (7-26)
0.04
Delirium anytime, N (%)
91 (62.3)
73 (48.7)
0.02
% ICU days spent delirious;
median (IQR)
50 (30-64.3)
33.3 (18.8-50)
0.003
Out of bed mobilization, N
(%)
70 (48)
99 (66)
Hospital mortality, N (%)
29 (19.9)
ICU mortality, N (%)
ICU-LOS (days); median (IQR)
Hospital LOS; median (IQR)
Adjusted
odds ratio
Adjusted P
0.55 (0.33-0.93)
0.03
0.002
2.11 (1.30-3.45)
0.003
17 (11.3)
0.04
0.56 (0.28-1.10)
0.09
24 (16.4)
14 (9.3)
0.07
5 (3-8)
4 (3-5)
0.21
13 (9-15)
11 (9-13)
0.99
Potential barriers to implementation
of early rehabilitation in the ICU

gaps in knowledge of benefits of early mobilisation




improvement of muscle strength
improvement of functionality
improvement of QOL
reduced costs due to reduced ICU- and hospital LOS

deep sedation

limited ICU staffing…