Special Feeds in Children - Tropical Paediatrics Congress 2014

Ready to Use Foods –
Challenges for improved infant feeding
M.B. Krawinkel & I. Jordan, Institute of Nutritional Sciences,
JLU Gießen, Germany
Classification of acute childhood malnutrition
Steve Collins, Lancet, 2003
Severe complicated
malnutrition
Severe uncomplicated
malnutrition
Moderate uncomplicated
malnutrition
<70% W/H (<-3 SD Score)
or
bilateral pitting oedema
or
MUAC <110 mm
and
one of the following:
- Anorexia
- Lower respiratory tract
infection
- high fever
- severe dehydration
- severe anemia
- not alert
<70& W/H (<-3 SD Score)
or
Bilateral pitting oedema
or
MUAC <110 mm
and:
- Appetite
- clinically well
- alert
70-80% W/H
(<-3 to <-2 SD Score)
and
no oedema
or
MUAC 110-125 mm
and:
- Appetite
- Clinically well
- alert
2
Inpatient
Outpatient
Outpatient
stabilisation care
therapeutic care
supplementary feeding
RUF = Ready to use foods
breast milk
banana apple etc.
baby food (industry-made)



But also

RUTF: ready to use therapeutic food

RUSF: ready to use supplementary food
3
ICTP2014 - Michael Krawinkel - RUF
Examples of Complementary porridges
4
ICTP2014 - Michael Krawinkel - RUF
RUTF
Ready to use therapeutic
food (RUTF)
z.B. Plumpy‘nut ® von
Nutriset SA


92 g sachet, 500 kcal
ingredients: groundnuts/
peanuts, milk powder,
vegetable oil, sugar,
vitamines and mineral mix
Treatment of severe
malnutrition
No water needed


5
RUSF/ LNS
Ready to use supplemental

food (RUSF)
Lipid Based Nutrient

Supplement (LNS)
For treatment/ prevention of

moderate acute malnutrition:
[WAZ ≤3SD until -2SD ]
6
ICTP2014 - Michael Krawinkel - RUF
7
8
UNICEF Supply Division – Prices for RUTF
9
http://www.unicef.org/supply/files/RUTF_Pricing_Data.pdf
WHO Recommendations on IYCF
≤ 6 mos
Exclusive Breastfeeding
up to two years breastfeeding
at 6 mos
2-3 CF meals per day
(2-3 tablespoons = 1 meal)
6-8 mos
2-3 CF meals per day + 1 snack
(½ a “cup” = 1 meal)
9-11 mos
3-4 meals per day + 1 or 2 snacks
≥12 mos:
(½ to ¾ “cup” = 1 meal)
3-4 meals per day + 1 or 2 snacks
(¾ to 1 ¼ “cup” = 1 meal)
(1 cup = 250ml)
10
ICTP2014 - Michael Krawinkel - RUF
Expenditure for food security and nutrition
eduction / beneficiary ?

Nutrition education:

Community based growth promotion with supple-mentary
feeding:
2,50 USD/person (1985)*
11,00 – 18,00 USD/person (2001 – 2003)*

Breastfeeding promotion:
0.30-0.40 USD/person (1996)*

Trials of Improved Practices:
(about 50 persons) =
8,000 – 30,000USD (1997)*
RUTF:

about 60 USD/ person
(2 mo‘s treatment / child)
* source: World Bank 2006. Repositioning Nutrition as Central to D
evelopment
11
ICTP2014 - Michael Krawinkel - RUF
Challenges in handling RUTF
Patent law

Quality insurance


Aflatoxine (case Haiti)


Codex Alimentarius
60 USD for 2 mo‘s treat-ment
Breast feeding and RUTF –
per child/360 USD/yr)


nutrition education ?



Code for marketing of RUTFs ?
Taste of peanuts ./. anorexia of
severely malnoutrished
RUTF doesn‘t contain water –
children
safe drinking water is needed

Locally produced „RUTFs“ are
displaced from the market
No guidlines for usage and
implementation of RUTF
Costs (6 US-Cents/sachet =

RUTFs for children below 6
months only as an exception
12
ICTP2014 - Michael Krawinkel - RUF
Conclusion


RUF/RUTF/RUSF are usefull innovations to support
community-based management of malnutrition and
humanitarian aid in emergencies
Points of consideration:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Costs and logistics
Replacement of natural foods
Replacement of breastmilk
Taste / Sugar content
Lack of acknowledged general guidelines for use and
marketing
RUF/RUTF/RUSF are no magic bullett for the fight
against malnutrition.
13
ICTP2014 - Michael Krawinkel - RUF
Thank you for listening
No dependency nor interest to be presented.