development of low transformation temperature (ltt)

DEVELOPMENT OF LOW TRANSFORMATION TEMPERATURE (LTT)
WELDING CONSUMABLES
Tariq Alghamdi, Stephen Liu, and Faisal Alabbas
Colorado School of Mines
ABSTRACT
Fatigue resistance of welded steel joints has grown to be one of the most important
concerns of structural integrity. Undesirable tensile residual stress is observed in low carbon
structural steel weld joints upon completion of solidification and after the weld is cooled to room
temperature. This harmful stress makes the welded joints more prone to fatigue failure. Thus, the
presence of compressive residual stress, instead of the typical tensile residual stress, improves
the fatigue properties of the structural welded joint and makes the nucleation and propagation of
the crack more difficult. Thermal post weld heat treatment (PWHT) and mechanical shot peening
processes are known to reduce the tensile residual stress and possibly induce a compressive
stress. However, both approaches are cost and time consuming methods.
Considerable effort was made to create welding consumables that can induce
compressive residual stresses near the weld toe regions via phase transformations. This
compressive residual stress can be significantly bigger than the one generated by mechanical or
thermal rework of weldment. Martensite transformation start (Ms) and finish (Mf) temperatures
are essential parameters in structural steel welding because of their influences on residual stress
development in the weld. It is preferred that the martensite transformation initiates at a
temperature as low as possible and finish just above the final temperature to which the weldment
is expected to cool. It is well established that alloy compositions affect significantly the
temperatures of phase transformations. Yet the exact nature and extent of the effects of chemical
composition on the metallurgically-induced compressive residual stresses has never been clearly
evaluated. This work presents and compares several methods of calculating martensitic start
temperature (Ms) reported in the literature. The key aspect of this research is to distinguish
between newly developed Low Transformation Temperature (LTT) welding wires to specify
leaner and more economical alloyed consumables. By means of leaner chromium, nickel and
manganese additions, the new experimental wires can achieve high fatigue properties as the
10Cr-10Ni wire proposed close to a decade ago to mitigate tensile residual stresses in weld toes.