Supplementary Capital Instruments available to

Fintelligence 06 (dated 30 October 2014). Contact us at [email protected]
st
In the previous newsletter dated 01 Oct. 2014, we presented the monthly regulatory update covering RBI, SEBI
and other relevant legislations pertinent to HFCs. In this letter we look at alternative capital raising options for
NBFCs and HFCs. While only equity is considered as core capital, RBI has allowed NBFCs to raise
supplementary capital through instruments which carry “equity-like” features such as subordination in terms of
payment of coupon and redemption of principal, mandatory lock-in and non-availability of security. These are
designed to ensure such capital instruments have the capability to absorb loss in case of stress and provide
protection to senior debt holders.
Supplementary capital:
All financial institutions, including NBFCs and HFCs are required to maintain a minimum capital adequacy ratio of
15% or 12%, as the case may be. In addition to core capital, which comprises of equity and accumulated
reserves, institutions are also allowed to raise supplementary capital to the extent permitted by RBI / NHB.
Supplementary capital also provides protection to senior debt holders, but to a lower extent compared to core
capital.
Considering that equity is quite rare and the most expensive form of capital, supplementary capital allows the
entity to increase its financial leverage while meeting minimum capital adequacy norms. Supplementary capital
instrumental have characteristics of both debt and equity instruments. These instruments are subordinated to
senior debt holders for repayment of interest and principal. As these instruments carry higher credit risk
compared to senior investors, investors typically expect higher returns on these instruments.
According to prudential norms, instruments must satisfy the following norms to be considered as supplementary
capital:
Fully paid up
"Instruments"
only
Discounting in
the years
leading to
maturity
Unsecured
Supplementary
Capital
Subordination
to senior
creditors
No Put Option
No restrictive
clauses
Fintelligence 06 (dated 30 October 2014). Contact us at [email protected]
Types of Supplementary Capital:
NBFCs and HFCs are allowed to raise supplementary capital via the instruments mentioned below. The
classification of these instruments under Tier I / Tier II capital depends on the level of protection that each
instrument offers to senior lenders.
Instrument
Available to
Classification
Compulsorily Convertible Preference Shares
(CCPS)
Perpetual Debt (PD)
NBFC & HFC
Tier I without limit
NBFC
Hybrid Tier II Bonds (Hybrid)
Redeemable Preference Shares (RPS)
Subordinated Debt (Sub Debt)
HFC
NBFC & HFC
NBFC & HFC
Tier I upto 15% of total Tier I capital; balance
can be classified as Tier II without limit
Tier II
Tier II without limit
Tier II upto 50% of Tier I
Key features of various forms of supplementary capital:
The regulators have defined the various key features of the different forms of supplementary capital instruments
that are available to NBFCs & HFCs. These are tabulated below:
Seniority:
Feature
Seniority
CCPS
RPS
RBI Norms applicable to
NBFCs
PD
Sub Debt
Senior only to
Equity
Senior to Tier I
capital
CCPS
RPS
RBI Norms applicable to
NBFCs
PD
Sub Debt
Tier I
Tier II
Tier I / Tier II
Tier II
Tier II
Tier II
100%
100%
Upto 15% of
Tier I; balance
in Tier II
100%
subject to
progressiv
e Discount
in last 5
Years
100%
subject to
progressive
Discount in
last 5 Years
100%
subject to
progressive
Discount in
last 5 Years
Not mandatory
if on private
placement
basis and not
listed
Not mandatory
if on private
placement
basis and not
listed
Not
mandatory
if on
private
placement
basis and
not listed
Minimum
"adequate
safety" rating
i.e., 'A'
category or
above
Minimum
"adequate
safety" rating
i.e., 'A'
category or
above
Senior only to
Equity and
CCPS
Senior
most
capital
instrument
NHB norms applicable to
HFCs
Hybrid
Sub Debt
Senior to
Equity, PD,
RPS, PD;
Junior to
Lower Tier II
Bonds
Senior most
capital
instrument
Eligibility:
Feature
Classificatio
n
Amount
eligible for
Inclusion
Security
Rating
Unsecured
Not Required
NHB norms applicable to
HFCs
Hybrid
Sub Debt
Fintelligence 06 (dated 30 October 2014). Contact us at [email protected]
Issue Size:
Feature
CCPS
RPS
Minimum
issue size
(per investor)
NA
NA
Rs. 25 lakhs
(multiples of
Rs. 5 lakhs
thereafter) if
private
placement
No Limit
No Limit
No Limit
No Limit
100% of T-I
along with
other T-II
No limit;
Classified as
Tier I upto
15% of Tier I;
balance as
Tier II
Feature
CCPS
RPS
Redeemable
Min Maturity
(years)
No
Perpetual
Yes
NA
Max Maturity
(years)
Put Option
Call Option
Perpetual
Not specified
NA
NA
RBI / NHB
Approval for
Redemption
NA
No
Yes; After 10
Years with
prior RBI
Approval
Required
CCPS
RPS
Maximum
issue size
Maximum
issue size
RBI Norms applicable to
NBFCs
PD
Sub Debt
NHB norms applicable to
HFCs
Hybrid
Sub Debt
Rs. 25
lakhs
(multiples
of Rs. 5
lakhs
thereafter)
if private
placement
No Limit
Rs. 25 lakhs
(multiples of
Rs. 5 lakhs
thereafter) if
private
placement
Rs. 25 lakhs
(multiples of
Rs. 5 lakhs
thereafter) if
private
placement
No Limit
No Limit
50% of
Tier I
100% of T-I
along with
other T-II
50% of Tier I
Redeemablility:
RBI Norms applicable to
NBFCs
PD
Sub Debt
No
Perpetual; call
option allowed
after 10 years
Perpetual
No
Yes; Min 10
Years; Prior
RBI Approval
Required
NHB norms applicable to
HFCs
Hybrid
Sub Debt
Yes
5*
Yes
15
Yes
5*
Not
specified
No
Yes; Min 5
Years;
Prior RBI
Approval
Required
Not specified
Not specified
No
Yes; After 10
Years with
prior NHB
Approval
Required
No
Yes; Min 5
Years; Prior
NHB
Approval
Required
Returns:
Feature
RBI Norms applicable to
NBFCs
PD
Sub Debt
Return Type
Rate of
Interest /
Dividend
Dividend
No Restriction
Dividend
No Restriction
Interest
No Restriction;
maybe fixed or
floating
Step-Up
Option
NA
No
Yes.
Can be
exercised only
Interest
No
Restriction;
maybe
fixed or
floating
No
NHB norms applicable to
HFCs
Hybrid
Sub Debt
Interest
No
Restriction;
maybe fixed
or floating
Interest
No
Restriction;
maybe fixed
or floating
Yes.
Can be
exercised
No
Fintelligence 06 (dated 30 October 2014). Contact us at [email protected]
Feature
CCPS
RPS
RBI Norms applicable to
NBFCs
PD
Sub Debt
once during
the whole life
of the
instrument
after the lapse
of 10 yrs; not
more than 100
bps
NHB norms applicable to
HFCs
Hybrid
Sub Debt
only once
during the
whole life of
the
instrument
after the
lapse of 10
yrs; not more
than 100 bps
Taxation:
Feature
- For issuer
- For Investor
CCPS
Dividend is not
tax deductible;
Dividend
Distribution tax
to be paid by
issuer
Dividend is Tax
free
RPS
Dividend is not
tax deductible;
Dividend
Distribution tax
to be paid by
issuer
Dividend is
Tax free
RBI Norms applicable to
NBFCs
PD
Sub Debt
NHB norms applicable to
HFCs
Hybrid
Sub Debt
Interest tax
deductible
Interest tax
deductible
Interest tax
deductible
Interest tax
deductible
Interest
taxable
Interest
taxable
Interest
taxable
Interest
taxable
Payout / Redemption:
Feature
Interest /
Dividend
CCPS
Only in case of
profits and after
interest /
dividend paid
against other
capital
instruments
RPS
Restricted if
Loss / CRAR
below
minimum
RBI Norms applicable to
NBFCs
PD
Sub Debt
Restricted if
Loss / CRAR
below
minimum
NHB norms applicable to
HFCs
Hybrid
Sub Debt
Restricted
Restricted if
Restricted if
if Loss /
Loss / CRAR Loss / CRAR
CRAR
below
below
below
minimum;
minimum;
minimum;
may be paid
may be paid
may be
with prior
with prior
paid with
approval
approval
prior
from NHB
from NHB
approval
from RBI
Principal
NA
NA; Call option NA; Call option NA; Call
NA; Call
NA; Call
cannot be
cannot be
option
option
option
exercised if
exercised if
cannot be
cannot be
cannot be
CRAR is / will
CRAR is / will
exercised if exercised if
exercised if
be below
be below
CRAR is /
CRAR is /
CRAR is /
regulatory
regulatory
will be
will be below will be below
minimum
minimum
below
regulatory
regulatory
regulatory
minimum
minimum
minimum
* The minimum maturity for subordinated debt instruments is not prescribed by RBI / NHB. However, unsecured
subordinated instruments with an initial tenure of less than five years would be considered as public deposits
Fintelligence 06 (dated 30 October 2014). Contact us at [email protected]



The Regulations specifically mention that subordinated / hybrid / perpetual debt can be raised only in the
form of “instruments”. As such, loans may not be eligible for classification as Tier I or Tier II capital even
if all other conditions as satisfied.
Capital instruments can be issued only in Indian Rupees. HFCs may issue hybrid capital in foreign
currency with prior approval from NHB / RBI.
In case of Subordinated debt and Hybrid Upper Tier II capital, the amount qualifying for Tier II capital is
subject to discounting in the last 5 years to maturity as given below:
Remaining maturity of the instruments
(i) up to one year
(ii) More than one year but upto two years
(iii) More than two years but upto three years
(iv) More than three years but upto four years
(v) More than four years but upto five years


Rate of discount (%)
100
80
60
40
20
Capital instruments are exempt from reserve requirements
Only QIPs or other investors who have given positive consent for subscribing to subordinated debt
1
instruments can invest in such instruments .
Supplementary capital instruments enable finance companies to increase their financial leverage while still
complying with capital adequacy norms. At the minimum prescribed level of capitalisation (15% and 12%,
2
respectively, for NBFCs and HFCs), the leverage is limited to 5.7x for NBFCs and 7.3x for HFCs in case the
capital adequacy requirement is met wholly out of equity. However, except in case of NBFC-MFIs, Tier I capital
requirement is not prescribed by the Regulators. Instead, the regulations place a cap on Tier II capital at 100% of
Tier I and perpetual debt at 15% of total Tier I. Assuming and NBFC / HFC takes full advantage of supplementary
capital limits, the financial leverage can theoretically be as high as 15x.
We hope you found the update useful. We welcome your feedback to us at [email protected] and
would be glad to revert in case you need any further details.
1
2
SEBI (DIP) Guidelines, 2000
Assuming 100% Risk Weight for underlying portfolio.