Pro-Rata Long Service Leave - Office of Industrial Relations

Pro–Rata Long Service Leave
Presented by NSW Industrial Relations
Pro–Rata Long Service Leave
Topics
∗
∗
∗
∗
∗
∗
Long Service Leave Act 1955
Pro Rata Long Service Leave
Case Law and Examples
Resolving Long Service Leave Issues
Important Information
Useful Contacts and Links
2
Pro–Rata Long Service Leave
Long Service Leave Act 1955
A TRANSITIONAL ARRANGEMENT DERIVED FROM A PRE MODERN
AWARD. If no award entitlement in NSW:
 Long Service Leave Act 1955
∗ Applies to most employees in New South Wales – full time, part time
and casual
∗ Entitlement – 2 months (8.67weeks) at 10 years of continuous service
∗ 1 month (4.33 weeks) after each additional 5 years
∗ Must be taken as soon as practicable as leave or paid on termination of
employment
∗ Certain interruptions will not break service (parental leave)
3
Pro–Rata Long Service Leave
Long Service Leave Act 1955
In the case of a worker who has completed at least 5 years service
but less than 10 years service and whose service was terminated for
reasons other than serious and wilful misconduct:
∗ a proportionate amount (pro rata) for each completed year, month,
week and day
The above also applies if worker leaves on account of:
∗ illness, incapacity or domestic or other pressing necessity, or
∗ Death of the worker
4
Pro–Rata Long Service Leave
Long Service Leave Act 1955
Illness, incapacity or domestic or other pressing necessity
The act does not define illness, incapacity or domestic or
other pressing necessity
∗ Worker may have entitlement if resignation is on account of the
above
5
Pro–Rata Long Service Leave
Long Service Leave Act 1955
Illness, incapacity or domestic or other pressing necessity
Test applied by courts:
∗
∗
∗
∗
Was the reason claimed for termination one of the above
Was such reason genuinely held by the employee
Was the reason a real or motivating reason
Would a reasonable person, in the circumstances be compelled to
terminate their employment
6
Pro–Rata Long Service Leave
Long Service Leave Act 1955
Illness, incapacity or domestic or other pressing necessity
Reasonable Evidence
∗ Claimant is required to provide evidence to enable the
questions posed to be answered to the affirmative.
∗ In answering the questions, that the court could determine
what the true facts were at the relevant time, in light of what
was said and done, and of the circumstances in which those
things were said and done.
7
Pro–Rata Long Service Leave
Long Service Leave Act 1955
Illness, incapacity or domestic or other pressing necessity
Illness or Incapacity
∗ Did the illness or incapacity necessitate the termination
 Was the evidence sufficient for a reasonable inference that had
it not been for the illness or incapacity that termination would
not have occurred.
8
Pro–Rata Long Service Leave
Long Service Leave Act 1955
Illness, incapacity or domestic or other pressing necessity
What is it?
∗ The courts have deemed the test for the above is a subjective
one
 This means that the court views each situation on its own
merits and facts. Each situation is considered different
although the courts may refer to previous case law.
9
Pro–Rata Long Service Leave
Long Service Leave Act 1955
Illness, incapacity or domestic or other pressing necessity
Test Case
British Motor Corporation v Chance (1965) AR (NSW) 364
∗ Employee was suffering a chronic mental disability that resulted in a
recurrent anxiety state
∗ NSW Chief Industrial Magistrate held the illness was the cause of the
workers termination
∗ Employer appealed this decision to a full bench of the NSW IRC which
upheld the original decision by Chief Industrial Magistrate that the worker
was entitled to pro-rata long service leave payment
10
Pro–Rata Long Service Leave
Long Service Leave Act 1955
Illness, incapacity or domestic or other pressing necessity
Test Case
Westbus Pty Ltd v Bartush (2000) NSWIRComm 26
∗ Employee claimed loss of income, change in working conditions and the
inability to collect his children from school as “domestic or pressing
necessity”
∗ Commission found in favour of employer as family friend assisted in
picking up children and employee unable to prove that the loss of
income amounted to “domestic or pressing necessity”
11
Pro–Rata Long Service Leave
Long Service Leave Act 1955
Illness, incapacity or domestic or other pressing necessity
Test Case
Donnelly v South Maitland Railways Pty Ltd 1964
∗ “home duties” given as the domestic circumstance, the pregnant
employee successfully arguing that this was a “domestic or pressing
necessity”
Franks v Kembla Equipment Co. Pty Ltd 1969
∗ Employee was required to leave work to care for sick wife and assist
with children
12
Pro–Rata Long Service Leave
Resolving a dispute for Pro-Rata LSL
Step 1
∗ The employee should try and discuss the issue with the employer in
the first instance
∗ If the employer disputes payment or refuses to make payment
 Recommend that parties seek advice regarding merits of case
∗ If not resolved the employee should serve a letter of demand on
the employer:
 setting out the reasons for the demand and the amount in dispute
with a reasonable timeframe for the employer to respond
∗ At any time contact can be made to NSW Industrial Relations on 131628
to speak with a NSW IR Officer regarding the process to resolve the
situation
13
Pro–Rata Long Service Leave
Lodging a Complaint with NSW IR re Pro-Rata LSL
Step 2
If an employee believes they have a legitimate unresolved complaint, then they should visit
the NSW IR website, www.industrialrelations.nsw.gov.au and print out the complaint form
listed in the contact us area of the NSW IR website.
Step 3
The complaint form is sent to NSW IR (Employee should attach evidence supporting their
complaint and a copy of the letter of demand).
Step 4
The complaint is registered and a 28 day pre investigation process takes place during which
time a NSW IR Investigator will assist the parties to resolve the issue.
Step 5
If issue is not resolved the matter may be referred for an investigation by NSW IR where a
determination will be made on the evidence provided by the employer and the employee.
14
Pro–Rata Long Service Leave
Lodging a Complaint with NSW IR re Pro-Rata LSL
Step 6
Depending on outcome of investigation then NSW IR may:
∗ Refer the matter to Chief Industrial Magistrates court or;
∗ Recommend that the employee take their own legal action
 Small claim or;
 Civil claim
15
Useful Information and Contacts
NSW IR Contacts and Services
∗ NSW IR is working with NSW businesses to help them better understand
their rights and responsibilities as an employer. Through a
comprehensive workshop and webinar program NSW IR are providing
employers with information and tools to deal with Industrial Relations
issues and Human Resource issues.
∗ Face to Face IR and HR Workshops include:
Industrial Relations:
∗
∗
∗
Rights and Responsibilities
Workplace issues for Bookkeeper and Payroll
Various Modern Awards workshops including:
 Health Professionals
 Children’s Services
Human Resources:
∗
∗
∗
∗
Managing Employees
Writing Workplace Policies
Bullying in the Workplace
Workplace Negotiations
16
Useful Contact & Links
NSW Industrial Relations - 13 16 28
∗
∗
∗
∗
∗
∗
∗
∗
∗
Employment Records and Payslips webinar
National Employment Standards (NES) webinar plus many other hot topics
Transitional Arrangements in Modern Awards
Workshop Program
Long Service Leave
Public Holidays
Entertainment Industry
Taxi Industry
www.industrialrelations.nsw.gov.au
Fair Work Ombudsman - 13 13 94
∗
∗
∗
∗
∗
RSS alerts – Really Simple Syndication
Modern Award Finder / Pay and Conditions Guides
Fact Sheets, templates, pay tools and other resources for employers
Guidance Note – Transitional Arrangements
www.fairwork.gov.au
17