2K system - CAREkonkret

Different cross-linking strategies:
Self-crosslinking acrylic for 1K and
2K waterborne woodcoatings
European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings
04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf | Germany
Dr. Eva Tejada, Dr. Maria Almató, Dr. Hans Grablowitz
Agenda/
Content
Introduction
Comparison of different acrylic dispersions
New OH acrylic dispersion
Conclusions
Demands on industrial furniture coatings
Mechanical properties
Scratch resistance
Mar resistance
Chemical properties
Water resistance
Stain resistance
Solvent resistance
Domestic compounds
Appearance properties
Transparency / Wood warmth
Matt / Gloss
✔ Resistance responsible for durability and appearance for attractiveness of the coating
Page 3 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
Demands on industrial furniture coatings
Product & application properties
Storage stability
Easy to apply
Competitive price
Drying & curing time
Stackability
Sandability
Blocking resistance
Laws and regulations
e.g.: SED 1999/13
National regulations
Page 4 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
Types of WB dispersions
PES
PUDPAC
PUD
PESPUD
PAC
Secondary
dispersions
Self-crosslinking
PESPAC
Page 5 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
Core-shell
OH
functional
Primary
dispersions
Si
functional
Types of WB dispersions
Secondary
dispersions
PAC
Self-crosslinking
OH
functional
Primary
dispersions
Page 6 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
Primary vs. secondary dispersions
Emulsion polymerisation:
water + surfactants
Multistep process:
Polymerization in solvent
Neutralization +
Dispersion
Primary dispersion
Strong physical drying
High Mw: ~106
Secondary dispersion
High gloss and
transparency
Low Mw: ~ 104
Primary and secondary PAC to meet all wood coating requirements
Page 7 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
Types of WB dispersions
Secondary
dispersions
PAC
Self-crosslinking
OH
functional
Primary
dispersions
Page 8 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
Self-crosslinking mechanisms
1K system
•
•
•
•
…
Self-condensation of methylolacrylamide
Metal complex (chelates, salts)
Self-condensation of organofunctional silanes
Ketone acid / dihydrazine
Page 9 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
Types of WB dispersions
Secondary
dispersions
PAC
Self-crosslinking
OH
functional
Primary
dispersions
Page 10 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
2K Crosslinking systems
functional polymer dispersion
2K system
•
•
•
•
…
Carboxi group + melamine
Carboxi group + aziridine
Carboxi group + carbodiimide
Polyol + polyisocyanate
X
Pot-life
X
X
X= functional group
Page 11 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
2K Systems Polyurethane
+
+
Polyaddition
(Crosslinking, curing)
Polyol
(Component A)
+
Polyisocyanate
(Component B, PIC)
Polyurethane Polymer
Polyisocyante phase is
dispersed and homogenized
Result:
"Polyisocyanate-in-polyol“ emulsion
The polyisocyanate is mixed into polyol.
Polyolparticle
Polyisocyante
droplet
Page 12 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
The choice of polyisocyanate
•
Hydrophilisation level: easiness of mixing, film appearance, chemical resistance
Low viscosity, hydrophobic
Hydrophillic
0
100
0
100
0
100
Highly hydrophillic
•
Hydrophillisation type: chemical resistance
PET-PIC
External emulsifier
PET modified
Highest chemical resistance
Anionic modified
Page 13 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
An-PIC
Agenda/
Content
Introduction
Comparison of different acrylic dispersions
New OH acrylic dispersion
Conclusions
Types of WB dispersions
Secondary
dispersions
PAC
Self-crosslinking
OH
functional
Primary
dispersions
Page 15 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
Acrylic dispersions
PAC 1
OH PAC 1
Primary
dispersion
OH
funtional
OH PAC 2
PAC 2
Self-Xlinked
Secondary
dispersion
Page 16 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
New OH
PAC
Products comparison
PAC 1
PAC 2
New OH
PAC
OH PAC 1
OH PAC 2
Primary
Primary
Primary
Primary
Secondary
Technology
1K
1K
1K/2K
2K
2K
Self-X-linking
No


No
No
Solids (%)
40
43
38
42
40
MFFT (ºC)
60
45
70
70
10
Tg(ºC)
60
50
65
90
50
% OH
0
0
1,5
2
3
Type of disp.
Page 17 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
Products comparison: 1K
PAC 1
PAC 2
New OH
PAC
Primary
Primary
Primary
Technology
1K
1K
1K/2K
Self-X-linking
No


Solids (%)
40
43
38
MFFT (ºC)
60
45
70
Tg(ºC)
60
50
65
% OH
0
0
1,5
Type of disp.
Page 18 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
Performance comparison in 1K
5
4
3
New OH PAC
PAC 1
2
PAC 2
1
0
Stains
Resistance
•
Solvent
Resistance
Fast Drying
Sandability
Blocking
Anfeuerung
Self-X-linking is necessary to improve:
 Resistance against solvent
 Drying and consequently sandability and blocking
Page 19 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
Products comparison: 2K
New OH
PAC
OH PAC 1
OH PAC 2
Type of disp.
Primary
Primary
Secondary
Technology
1K/2K
2K
2K
Self-X-linking

No
No
Solids (%)
38
42
40
MFFT (ºC)
70
70
10
Tg(ºC)
65
90
50
% OH
1,5
2
3
Page 20 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
Performance comparison in 2K
5
4
3
New OH PAC
OH PAC1
2
OH PAC 2
1
0
Stains
Resistance
•
•
•
Fast Drying
Sandability
Stackability
Anfeuerung
Pot-life
Primary dispersions are faster in drying and leads to higher productivity
Secondary dispersions give better appearance on wood
High molecular weight leads to shorter pot-life
Page 21 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
Agenda/
Content
Introduction
Comparison of different acrylic dispersions
New OH acrylic dispersion
Conclusions
New OH PAC properties
Self-crosslinking OH functional PAC dispersion for 1K and 2K WB applications
Product highlights
Suited for clear and pigmented coatings, primers and topcoats
Useful for 1K and 2K applications
VOC content < 130 g/l possible
High chemical resistance
High solvents resistance
Low cost 2K coating formulation possible
Page 23 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
New OH PAC
1K system
OH
X
X
drying, RT
X
OH
OH
X
OH
2K system
OH
OH
OH
NCO
OH
OH
OH
OH
NCO
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
X= functional group
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
Page 24 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
OH
OH
OH
New OH PAC
Coating properties: 1K and 2K
1K clear
1K clear
+10 % AnPIC
2K pigmented
+ 20% AnPIC
50 / 70 / 100”
150”
65 / 85 / 100”
120”
70 / 127 / 145“
150”
Sand dry (T1)
approx. 30’
approx. 30’
approx. 30’
Total dry (T4)
approx. 50’
approx. 80’
approx. 7h
Gloss 20º / 60º / Haze (%)
81 / 91 /30
83 / 90 / 30
70 / 87 / 70
5
5
5
5/3
5/5
5/5
Red wine resistance - 6 h
3
5
5
American mustard resistance - 6 h
5
5
5
Ethanol 48% resistance - 1 h
5
5
5
Acetone resistance - 1 min
5
5
5
Pendulum hardness (König), 1 / 3 / 7 d at RT
16 h at 50ºC
Water resistance - 16 h
Coffee resistance - 1h / 16 h
Drying measured over glass (200mm wet) at 23ºC and 50% RH.
Chemical resistance evaluated on coated birch panel ( 5=very good; 1= very bad).
Page 25 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
DIN 68861 Test
New OH PAC
Chemical resistance
New OH PAC
 Self-crosslinking OH functional PAC dispersion
New OH
PAC
1K
IKEA R2
2K
Clear
Pigmented
Clear
Pigmented






DIN 68861 1B
Good chemical resistance is achieved as 1K
Higher level achieved by addition of a polyisocyanate
Page 26 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
New OH PAC
Industrial application data
Sandability
Blocking Resistance
5
5
4
4
3
3
1K formulation
2
2K formulation
1
2
1
0
0
0
2
4
Test details:
- Application:
- Drying:
- Stacking:
- Evaluation
6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24
Drying time (h) at 40ºC
g/m 2
120
wet on leneta foil
15’ flash-off at RT before drying at 40ºC
Face to face for 1h at 40ºC, 100 g/cm 2
5: Best, 0: Worse
 No anti-blocking additives/waxes have been used in this test
0
2
Test details:
Application:
Drying:
Sanding:
Evaluation
4
6
8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24
Drying time (h) at RT
120 g/m 2 wet on Sapelly wood
RT
320 grit sand paper
5: Best, 0: Worse
No sanding aids have been used in this test
Page 27 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
New OH PAC
Results on parquet coating
New OH
PAC
1K
New OH PAC
2K
10 % PETPIC
PUD1
1K
PUD1 / New
OH PAC 7:3
1K
30 / 65
100
80 / 100
110
54 / 57
60
67 / 70
73
Sand dry (T1)
approx. 30’
approx. 40’
approx. 40’
approx. 40’
Total dry (T4)
approx. 60’
approx. 80’
approx. 105’
approx. 90’
Gloss 20º / 60º / Haze (%)
80 / 89 / 40
68 / 83 / 40
82 / 89 / 7
84 / 90 / 11
Water resistance - 4 h / 24 h
5/4
5/5
5/5
5/5
Scratch water resistance - 4h / 24 h
5/5
5/5
5/5
5/5
EtOH resistance – 5’ / 30’
5/5
5/5
5/3
5/3
Scratch EtOH resistance - 5’ / 30’
5/4
5/5
5/3
5/3
3
5
3
3
83 / 91
80 / 90
15 / 4
21 / 20
Pendulum hardness (s,König), 1 / 7d at RT
16 h at 50ºC
Black Heel Mar Resistance
Abrasion Taber CS10 / CS17 –
mg lost after 1000 rev (10N load)
Drying and pendulum hardness measured over glass (200mm wet) at 23ºC and 50% RH.
Chemical resistance evaluated on coated oak panel (3 x 120mm wet) ( 5=very good; 1= very bad).
Product not assessed in VOC emission tests
New OH PAC could be used in parquet coating in 1K, 2K or as combination partner with a PUD
Page 28 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
New OH PAC
Results on exterior
100
Gloss at 60º
80
60
40
20
0
0
500
1000
1500
hours QUV A Test
2000
2500
New OH PAC
New OH PAC/PUD 2 1:1
New OH PAC/PUD 2 3:7
PUD 2
New OH PAC
New OH PAC/
PUD 2, 1:1
New OH PAC/
PUD 2, 3:7
PUD 2
Evaluation under UNE_EN 927-6:2007.
Formulation containing HALS
Testing conditions: 24h of condensation / 48 cycles of 3h
consisting of 2,5h UV + 0,5h water spray
Total length of the test: 2016 hours (12 weeks)
Application: 3 x 150g/m2 on massive pinewood
Clear coatings based on New OH PAC passes weathering test according DIN EN ISO 927-6 (QUV-Spray).
It can be used alone or as combination partner for PUDs.
Page 29 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
Summarizing…
 A comparison study has been made for different acrylic dispersions for wood coatings both in 1K
as well in 2K systems.
 Primary dispersions have stronger physical drying resulting in better productivity (faster
sandability and blocking development) both in 1K as well in 2K systems. Transparency and gloss
of the coating will be inferior than with secondary dispersions.
 Crosslinking is necessary to have good solvent resistance.
 Real 2K polyurethane systems are necessary for the formulation of pigmented coatings with high
level of chemical resistance.
 The use of the New OH PAC, allows the formulation of both 1K as well as 2K with a medium-high
performance respectively, giving lot of freedom and versatility to the formulator and end-user to
get the desired level of coating performance: IKEA R2 requirements for 1K clear coatings and
DIN 68861 at level 1B in 2K clear or pigmented. Different applications opportunities are seen for
this new resin.
Page 30 • European Coatings CONFERENCE Parquet and furniture coatings • 04 – 05 February 2014, Düsseldorf
Thank you!