The planners guide to CommunityViz : the essential tool for a new

THE
PLANNERS
GUIDE
TO
COMMUNITYWIZ
THE
ESSENTIAL TOOL
FOR A NEW GENERATION OF PLANNING
Doug WaIker and
Daniels
Tom
An Orton
Family Foundation
American Planning Association
Planners Press
Making Great Communities Happen
Chicago
|
Washington, D.C.
Book
CONTENTS
Preface: The New Generation of Planning
xiii
Introduction:
xvi
Computers
Communities, Planning, and CommunityViz
and
Planning
Planning
What CommunityViz Does
CommunityViz Roots and Development
CommunityViz and All Kinds of Planning
The Orton Family Foundation's Heart & Soul Planning Philosophy
Practical Benefits of New Generation Planning
A New Generation of
How to Use This Book
Special
xvi
xvii
xvii
xviii
xviii
xxi
xxi
xxii
Terms
xxiv
An Overview
CommunityViz:
xxv
Scenario 360
xxv
Common
xxvii
Applications
with ArcGIS
Integration
xxvii
3-D Visualization within Scenario 360
xxvii
Scenario 3D
xxvii
Scenario 3D
Exporter
and Viewer
xxvii
FOUNDATIONS
Chapter
Create
an
Identify
Getting Started
i:
Define Your
Study
4
Area
4
Area Profile
5
Problems and Forces of
Identify Key People
and
Change
Organizations
6
7
Describe Decisions That Need
The
to Be Made and Questions to Answer
CommunityViz Project Framework for Decision Making
The Difference Between Decisions and Information
Describe Goals
Chapter
2:
Technical Needs and
Computing Resources
CommunityViz
n
and Technical Staff
11
Data Resources
12
Data Best Practices and Ethics
Experts, Specialized Models,
3:
12
and Crowds
Planning Study Design
13
Guidelines
About Scenario
Planning
How Scenario Planning Principles Influence Project Design
Geodesign and Making Decisions without Scenarios
Project
Practicalities
Time and
8
10
10
Data Resources for
Chapter
8
Analysis Design
Iterative Design
Design for Transparency
15
18
18
19
Budget
Trade-Offs and Limitation of Feasible Planning
15
19
Projects
20
21
23
23
Multimedia
Design
24
Visualization Priorities
Technology
Communication
for
Design
26
Design
26
Living Comprehensive
a
Chapter
25
Selection
Plan
Impact Models
4: Custom
26
and
Analysis
Why and When
Types
of
Impact
Rate-Based
28
Models and How
Impact
to
Create Them
Models
Spatially Dependent Impact
30
Models
31
External Models
How to Choose
31
a
Custom
a
Model
31
Analysis
32
Technical Section: Dynamic Analysis in Scenario
Dynamic
28
29
Coefficient-Based Impact Models
Creating
28
360
Attributes
32
32
Indicators
33
Assumptions
34
Scenarios
34
Tools
Setup
35
5: Three-Dimensional Scenes
Chapter
and When
Why
Choosing
36
3-D Platform
a
36
How 3-D Works
Partly
37
Transparent Textures
Shadows and
38
Lighting
38
Active Materials
How
a
Creating
36
39
3-D Scene Is Built
39
a 3-D Scene
40
Get Data
41
Create
a
Base Model
Model
Development Proposals
42
or
Scenarios
43
Create Presentation Aids
44
Special Considerations for Metro and Regional Models
44
Teaching Example
Chapter
6:
45
Getting the Most from 3-D
The Art of Making Effective 3-D Scenes
Providing Good
Information
the Computer-to-Real-World Connection
Making
Enhancing Subjective
Solutions
to Common
Feel
Challenges
50
50
50
50
51
52
Soft Features
52
Numerous Features
52
Large
Areas
53
Uneven Terrain
54
Choosing Accessories
54
Conclusion
CASE
STUDIES:
54
Klamath River, California and Oregon;
55
Manchester, Vermont
57
II
COMMUNITY
VISIONING, VALUES,
AND
GROWTH
Chapter
7:
Why
PROJECTIONS
63
Visioning
and When
Beginning
Scenario
63
Visioning Project
64
Current Situation
64
the
Assessing the
Building
Low-Tech
65
65
Visioning
Scenarios Created
by the Public
66
Scenarios Created
Internally
Best Practices for Creating Scenarios
Selecting a Preferred Scenario
67
Implementation Plan
68
Teaching Example
68
CASE
Res DU
by Zone
spatial buildout results
STUDY:
Chapter
Land Use
Metropolitan Boston,
8: Growth
67
67
Massachusetts
Projections
Build-Out
Rea„DU_MDR
*;
Re6_DU_ForCon
a;
R<wj)U_OFA
72
75
75
Designer
Build-Out Wizard
2:
6l
76
78
Steps
Density Rules
79
Commercial
79
Buildings
79
Keeping Perspective
TimeScope
80
Allocator
81
External Models
81
Combining Growth-Planning
Decision Tools
82
Data Needs and Sources
82
Teaching Example
83
CASE
STUDY:
Middlebury,Vermont
Chapter 9: Value Mapping and Special Places
87
90
Mapping
Why and When
Articulating Core Values
Value Mapping Steps
Making a Value Tree
90
Value Elements
92
Value Drivers
92
Physical Form
93
CommunityViz Value Indexes
93
Using Value
Mapping
94
Places
94
Value
Mapping Special
case
studies:
90
90
90
91
Allegheny County, Pennsylvania;
Exeter,
Rhode Island
95
viit
III.
MAKING
Chapter
Why
io:
PLANS
Local Comprehensive Plans
and When
104
Current Conditions
Describing
Creating Scenarios
Modeling Impacts
Engaging the Public
Teaching Example
STUDIES:
Why
107
108
109
Durango,Colorado;
115
Mooresville, North Carolina
118
11:
121
Tools
CommunityViz
Analysis Templates
Scale-Changing Formula
123
123
Functions
Sketch Tools
Linking
Analysis Grids
Teaching Example
STUDIES:
II
TB^
,1
127
Greater
Nashville, Tennessee;
Site Selection and Assessment
Why and When
Suitability Concepts
CommunityViz Tools for Suitability Analysis
Suitability Wizard
Nested Suitability
Categories
Assumptions
Symbology Tools
135
136
137
137
138
138
138
139
Scoring Systems for Centers and Neighborhoods
139
Teaching Example
141
CASE
OH wurc«a
133
138
and Charts
Irom
131
135
Alerts
Projoclod Water Use
125
125
Washington County, Utah
12:
123
125
to External Models
Chapter
12T
121
and When
Data Needs
CASE
106
106
Regional Land-Use and
Transportation Plans
Chapter
104
104
Data Needs
case
lOl
STUDIES:
Chapter
Squamish, British Columbia, Canada;
144
Calumet County, Wisconsin
147
13: Resource Plans
Data Needs and Sources
Working with Raster Data
Valuing
Resources
Conditions and
Targets
Assessing Implementation Strategies
149
149
150
151
151
152
CommunityViz Tools
Scientific Modeling
152
Evaluation of BMPs
153
152
Optimizer
LandFrag Wizard
Teaching Example
CASE
153
154
154
158
Topsham,Maine;
STUDIES:
Delmarva Peninsula, Delaware, Maryland, and
IV.
REVIEWING
i^m¥^
WiSte?
I \
Chapter
1
;-'.ig.
:
„
£:i;:."'
PROPOSALS
163
Analyzing Zoning Regulations
166
jl$!0Mk
and When
166
Data Needs
^%
:r
„-_!—
Why
*
14:
166
Zoning Development Capacity Analysis Using
,
—
Zoning Development Capacity
Estimating Capacity
«.„„
the Build-Out Wizard
Calculations Outside the Build-Out Wizard
Utilization
*
y?f*
j
~~~
-jmi
Capital
''
m^m\M^m\
171
15: Cost-of-Services Analyses,
Improvements, and Pro Formas
Setting
Using
a
up
a
Cost-of-Services Analysis
II
!
v
179
L--<j\..Jl
jfiHt^
Aw^^O^^V
vSHt'
'
\
h
/
*t?V'
'
-^V
^AXwMnJSR
W
Regulations
179
Pro Forma Analyses
180
Teaching Example
180
Chapter
~
176
177
Cost-of-Services Analysis
Analyzing Subdivision and Land-Development
V
170
Chapter
sgj^
i v
166
171
Teaching Example
j
160
REGULATIONS AND
DEVELOPMENT
%. "f&S"^7^^..
Virginia
16:
Design
About 3-D
Review and
for
Form-Based Codes
Reviews and Form-Based Codes
Modeling
Design
Using 3-D for Design Review
Modeling Proposals for Design Review
Displaying the Scene
Using 3-D for Drafting and Applying Form-Based Codes
Indicators for Design Review and Form-Based Codes
Site-Specific
Indicators
Comparative Community
study:
185
187
187
187
188
189
189
Indicators
189
190
Teaching Example
CASE
185
Westminster,Colorado
194
AND
COMMUNICATING
Chapter
17: Public
INTERACTING
Meetings, Presentations,
and Charrettes
197
198
and When
198
Public Meetings
199
Why
199
Charrettes
Presentation Techniques
and Best Practices
202
Designing the Analysis
202
Understanding the
202
Designing
Speaking
the
with
Venue and
Presenting
Keypads
Display
203
CommunityViz
204
Logistics
205
3-D Scenes
and Online
CommunityViz
in
Introducing
206
Polling
207
Workgroups
209
Workgroup Learning
Curves
Interactive
Best Practices for
CASE
Audience
209
Capabilities
to
Workgroups
STUDIES:
Rocky
Mountains, Idaho, Montana,
and Alberta and British Columbia, Canada
Chapter 18: Reports, Displays, and Websites
Reporting
Display
Reporting and Display
Images of 3-D
210
Fort Lupton, Colorado;
Northern
and
210
Using CommunityViz with Workgroups
212
Wyoming,
214
216
Features
216
Best Practices
216
Scenes
218
Website
Project
Web-Ready Reports
218
218
Website Images and Data
218
WebShots Wizard
220
3-D Scenes on
the Web
Sharing Complete Analysis
More Web Options
a
220
on
the Web
Chapter 19: Beyond Planning Projects
Anticipating Planning Problems
Connecting Plans to Day-to-Day Processes
Supporting Other Departments
221
222
223
223
224
225
xi
228
APPENDICES
Appendix
i:
When and How to Get
Help
228
228
Readiness Self-Assessment
CommunityViz Skills
228
Technical Environment
228
Organizational Readiness
228
Partners and Collaborators
228
Modeling
Staffing for CommunityViz
229
Working with Consultants
229
Resources
230
Skills and Resources
CommunityViz
Appendix
2: Data
229
Management
Data
Management
Best Practices for
Data
Management
Best Practices for 3-D Visualization
Using
Data from
Multiple
Analysis
231
231
232
232
Sources
Appendix 3: Performance
234
Analysis Performance
234
3-D Performance
235
Appendix
4: Data Sources
Appendix
5:
CommunityViz
238
Features
Integration
243
243
Scenario 360 Features
243
with ArcGIS
3-D Visualization
243
Dynamic Charts
243
Scenarios
243
Decision Tools
244
Modeling
245
Engagement
247
Interactive Analysis and
Communication and
Scenario 3D Features
248
Scenario 3D Exporter
249
Scenario 3D Viewer
250
Contacts
251
References
253
Glossary
254
Acknowledgments
263
Index
264