Science Exemplars 052

We Set the Standards!
EXEMPLARS
Best of
SCIENCE
1997-1999
Exemplars
K-2 Tasks
✏
Exemplars
What Do We Know
About Water?
A Group Brainstorm
We have had the water table out for free
exploration and groups this week. Now, let’s
share with each other what we already know
about water.
Yes, it can be something you know from your
own life, or about something you discovered
in our class.
Later with partners, we will write what we
know about water on a large, blue, paper
water drop.
Exemplars
TM
We Set the Standards!
271 Poker Hill Rd., Underhill, VT 05489
Phone 800-450-4050
What Do We Know About Water?
- Page 3-
Science
Exemplars
Grade Level K-2
What Do We Know About Water? A Group Brainstorm
We have had the water table out for free exploration and groups this week. Now, let’s share
with each other what we already know about water.
Yes, it can be something you know from your own life or about something you discovered in
our class.
Later with partners, we will write what we know about water on a large, blue, paper water
drop.
Big Ideas and Unifying Concept(s)
Cause-Effect
Systems
Interdependence
Physical Science Concept(s)
Properties of matter
Life Science Concept(s)
Populations and ecosystems
Earth and Space Science Concept(s)
Earth structures and systems
Science in Personal and Societal Perspectives Concept(s)
Personal health
Time Required for the Task
Allow ten minutes for whole group brainstorm, with 15-20 minutes for partner writing,
(which could be done the next day).
Exemplars
TM
We Set the Standards!
271 Poker Hill Rd., Underhill, VT 05489
Phone 800-450-4050
What Do We Know About Water? (cont.)
- Page 4-
Science
Exemplars
Context
This is part of a larger water unit, designed to be used throughout the school year. The group
brainstorm is an introductory activity which allows children to share what they already
know about water. During this activity, the teacher can note children’s individual concepts,
knowledge, and preconceptions about water. All children have the opportunity to be heard
and their words are recorded and posted for the class to see and refer to later. All ideas are
important and excepted.
The whole-group water brainstorm begins the focus for our study, “Water Exploration.” Here
is a possible teacher/student conversation to begin this activity:
“Scientists, as we study water, we will be conducting scientific investigations.
Tomorrow, we will each choose one thing we know about water and write it ourselves,
(I mount these on water-drop shaped paper, after they are written on, and cut from,
lined paper). We can use these to begin to decorate the water area and the classroom.
Your homework tonight is to list three things you/family use water for at home.
What the Task Accomplishes
This pre-assessment activity begins the water unit activities across the curriculum. It allows
children the opportunity to share and to see their words in print, gives the teacher an idea of
the children’s background knowledge, and provides many different ideas and directions for
further water study.
How the Student Will Investigate
In a whole-group setting, the teacher asks for the children’s ideas, thoughts, and prior
knowledge about water. The teacher writes the children’s responses on chart paper. The chart
can then be used to hang in the classroom, for children’s (conventional spelling) writing, to
review water information, ideas, and new learning along the way, and/or possible water
investigations later.
Interdisciplinary Links and Extensions
Science
Water table investigation and exploration helps to generate new ideas for further study.
Social Studies
We made links to water-related careers (through speakers, books, and videos, etc.), visited
some local water sites, and looked for water on maps.
Exemplars
TM
We Set the Standards!
271 Poker Hill Rd., Underhill, VT 05489
Phone 800-450-4050
What Do We Know About Water? (cont.)
- Page 5-
Science
Exemplars
Language Arts and Movement
Water words and phrases from the brainstorm can be written in blues and greens to create a
“concrete poem” – that is, using the words to create a shape of a water droplet.
There are also many literacy connections that can be made to the unit of study on water. We
sing water songs, rhymes, and chants. Some children’s books that I use to promote
discussion, questioning, movement activities, and water investigations include: Amy Loves
The Rain, Julia Hoban, Trumpet Club, NY, USA, 1993; The Ballad Of The Pirate Queens, Jane
Yolen, Harcourt Brace & Co. FL, USA, 1995; The Eensy Weensy Spider, Alan Daniel, Wright
Group, WA, USA, 1990 (Big Book song about a spider going up a water spout); Make Way For
Ducklings, Robert McCloskey, Scholastic, NY, USA, 1969; and One Cold Wet Night, Joy Cowley,
Wright Group, CA, USA, 1984.
Mathematics
My students like to do measuring, counting, recording data, 3-D projects, and problem
solving activities that integrate math and science (with water topics).
Creative Arts
I try to incorporate short hand plays, puppets, and art projects – such as water color scenes of
water habitats with our water study.
Teaching Tips and Guiding Questions
Before the brainstorm about water, I gather supplies, including having water-related books all
around the room. The following are not all necessary, but help to get the entire room
prepared for a water unit/study. They include: a large plastic tarp for water area floor, a
water table, clear plastic tubes, plastic bottles, various-size standard and non-standard
measuring devices, and a hanging eye hook or clothes line over the water table for possible
demonstrations, inventions, creative system play. Other good items for future investigations
are: clear tubs, bins, turkey basters, eye droppers, cups, bubble solution, foil, clay, wooden
craft sticks to be used for making boats, clip boards, writing materials, underwater slates,
large Ziploc® plastic bags for children’s investigation questions, and various art supplies.
Some questions to guide students are:
1. What do you already know about water?
2. What do you wonder about?
3. What do you want to learn?
4. What could you do to find out?
5. Does water always look and feel the same?
6. Where have you seen water in your house? school? outside? in books?
7. Can you describe how water feels? smells? looks? sounds? tastes?
Exemplars
TM
We Set the Standards!
271 Poker Hill Rd., Underhill, VT 05489
Phone 800-450-4050
What Do We Know About Water? (cont.)
- Page 6-
Science
Exemplars
8. Is water ever bad for you? good for you?
9. Who needs water? Why? How do they get it?
Concepts to be Assessed
(Unifying concepts/big ideas and science concepts to be assessed using the Science Exemplars Rubric under the criterion:
Science Concepts and Related Content).
• Earth Science: Earth Structures and Systems – Students explore water as an Earth
material having physical and chemical properties.
• Life Science: Populations and Ecosystems – Students explore water as an environment
for many organisms and begin to understand how an organism’s characteristics and
behaviors are related to the nature of its environment. Human activities have an impact
on natural systems; changing human behaviors can lessen the impact on ecosystems.
• Physical Science: Properties of matter – Students explore characteristics of water and
liquids.
• Science in Personal and Societal Perspectives: Personal health – Students explore how
water is part of personal care (dental hygiene and cleanliness) and nutrition to maintain
and improve health.
Skills to be Developed
(Specific science process skills to be assessed using the Exemplars Science Rubric under the criteria: Scientific
Procedures and Reasoning Strategies and Scientific Communication/Using Data).
Observing, Predicting/Hypothesizing, Drawing conclusions, Communicating findings,
Challenging misconceptions, and Raising new questions
Links to Science (and other) Standards
Scientific Method: Students describe, predict, investigate, and explain phenomena.
Scientific Theory: Students look for evidence that explains why things happen, and modify
explanations when new observations are made.
Physical Science – Properties of Matter: Students describe and sort objects and materials
according to observations of similarities and differences of physical properties.
Earth Science – Earth structures and systems: Earth materials are solids (rocks and soils), liquid
(water), and gases. These materials have physical and chemical properties and are useful
in different ways.
Life Science – Populations and ecosystems: An organism’s characteristics and behaviors are
related to the nature of its environment.
Science in Personal and Societal Perspectives Concept(s) – Personal health: Personal care – dental
hygiene, cleanliness, and exercise – will maintain and improve health. Nutrition is
essential to health. The body needs food and water to work right and remain healthy.
Exemplars
TM
We Set the Standards!
271 Poker Hill Rd., Underhill, VT 05489
Phone 800-450-4050
What Do We Know About Water? (cont.)
- Page 7-
Science
Exemplars
Suggested Materials
For this activity, students only need lined paper, pencils, scissors, paste, and a water drop to
glue words to. Recordings from the group brainstorm were available as a word/idea bank.
Students can either trace and cut their own water drops or they can be prepared ahead of
time.
Possible Solutions
Student writing required that pairs worked together to keep track of what was to be written
and appropriate spacing of words when words were glued onto the water drops. Students
were to write one complete sentence about water.
Rubric and Benchmarks
(Several Samples are Provided for Each level)
Novice
Samples (2) at this level are simplistic, in that they identify basic uses of water. (I drink water.
I use water at the sink.) There is no evidence of understanding why we drink water or how
we use it at the sink.
Apprentice
Samples (3) at this level, identify uses of water that are basic, but more specific. (I jump in the
water. I take a shower. I take a bath.) There is some evidence of understanding how we use
water. Playing in water, drinking water, and washing in water are typical responses at the
Novice and Apprentice levels.
Practitioner
Samples (3) at this level, identify specific, basic uses of water and give reasons (I drink water
because I’m thirsty.); or extend beyond basic needs (I use water to paint.); or extend a basic
function to other things, ( I use water for washing dishes.). There is evidence of
understanding that water is used in ways beyond meeting basic human needs – for pleasure
and for getting work done.
Exemplars
TM
We Set the Standards!
271 Poker Hill Rd., Underhill, VT 05489
Phone 800-450-4050
What Do We Know About Water? (cont.)
- Page 8-
Science
Exemplars
Expert
Samples (4) at this level, show evidence of understanding that water is used by other objects
and organisms to meet needs. Some show evidence of use of prior knowledge and experience
(Speedboats speed in water. I use water for fishing.) Others show evidence of extended
thinking, (I float a pencil. I like to play sink and float in the water.)
Author
Anet Hammett teaches Kindergarten at the Thatcher Brook Primary School in Waterbury,
Vermont.
Exemplars
TM
We Set the Standards!
271 Poker Hill Rd., Underhill, VT 05489
Phone 800-450-4050
What Do We Know About Water? (cont.)
- Page 9-
Science
Exemplars
Novice
Student ideas are basic to
human needs. There is no
evidence of understanding
why we drink water or
how it is used at the sink.
Exemplars
TM
We Set the Standards!
271 Poker Hill Rd., Underhill, VT 05489
Phone 800-450-4050
What Do We Know About Water? (cont.)
- Page 10-
Science
Exemplars
Apprentice
Student responses are still basic, but
are more specific – a bath, a shower,
etc. There is some evidence of
understanding how we use water
and why.
Exemplars
TM
We Set the Standards!
271 Poker Hill Rd., Underhill, VT 05489
Phone 800-450-4050
What Do We Konw About Water? (cont.)
- Page 11-
Science
Exemplars
Practitioner
These samples give
explanations for basic uses
or extend use to other areas
that are not as obvious.
Exemplars
TM
We Set the Standards!
271 Poker Hill Rd., Underhill, VT 05489
Phone 800-450-4050
What Do We Konw About Water? (cont.)
- Page 12-
Science
Exemplars
Expert
These samples extend thinking and draw
on prior knowledge and experiences.
They show understanding that other
objects and organisms use water.
Exemplars
TM
We Set the Standards!
271 Poker Hill Rd., Underhill, VT 05489
Phone 800-450-4050
What Do We Konw About Water? (cont.)
- Page 13-
Science