PSP3 Final: TRR Briefing Pack

5° Convegno Nazionale IPMA
Italy
“PROJECT MANAGEMENT:DAL CONTROLLO DI
PROGETTO ALLE PERFORMANCE AZIENDALI”
Milano 27 Giugno 2013
Speaker: Miguel Carruozzo
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
1
Il Project Management nel
Programma „Aircrew
Synthetic Training Aids“ (EF
Training Simulator)
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
2
Contents
 Multi National Programme Organization
 A/C programme main Deliverables
 Mission Support Items
 Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids (ASTA)
 Structure and Organization
 Route to Contract
 Programme & Project Management Process
 Product End to End process
 Continuing Integration and Qualification
 Customer Acceptance and Deliveries
 Monitoring and control
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
3
Eurofighter Typhoon
European Partner Nations (EPNs)
Export Nations
NETMA
Eurofighter Partner Companies
Eurojet Partner Companies
Equipment Suppliers
Equipment Suppliers
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
4
Main Deliverables
Weapon System
Aircraft Ground
Equipment
Aircraft
Programme
Maintenance
Major Support Items
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
5
Major Support Items
 Aircrew Syntetic Trainig Aids (ASTA) –
Cassidian GE
 Ground Support System (GSS) – Cassidian
SP
 Ground Training Aids (GTA) – Alenia
Aermacchi
 International Weapon System Support
System (IWSSS) - BAES
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
6
Aircrew Synthetic
Training Aids
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
7
ASTA Structure – Core Programme
Italy
UK
Spain
Germany
NETMA
Eurofighter GmbH and APO
ALENIA
BAE SYSTEMS
SELEX
GALILEO
THALES
EADS-CASA
INDRA
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
EADS-D
ARGE/CAE-S
ESS
CAE-M
8
ASTA Training System and Solutions
ASTA Top Level Overview
Full Mission Simulators (FMS)
Cockpit Trainer (CT)
Debriefing Facility (DBF)
Instructor Operating Station (IOS)
ASTA – Pilot training, mission rehearsal, tactical doctrine
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
9
ASTA Programme Management Organization
Programme Director
Program
Control
Manager
Contract
Commercial
Manager
Senior
Technical
Manager
OPS
Factor
Manager
PCM Team
CCM Team
Tech. Team
OPS Team
ALN
BAES
EADS-C
EADS-D
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
ILS
Manager
ILS Team
QM
Manager
QM Team
ESS
10
Intercultural team constitute of 55 peoples
Australia
Rumania
Argentina
USA
United
Kingdom
Spain
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
Italian
Germany
Sri Lanka
11
EF ASTA Programme Organisation (APO)
Mission
 The APO is the System Design Authority for the complete
ASTA System:
 Customer Requirements Capture.
 Contract Doc. Preparation and negotiation
 Programme Management
 System Definition and Design.
 System Integration, Test and Qualification.
 Customer Acceptance Test
 Software Production and Delivery
 Integrated Logistic Support
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
12
Initialization Phase
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
13
Tools
 Requirements analysis – DOORS
 Engineering Management – JIRA
 Integration Management – TARANTULA
 Query Management – Own Developed
 Configuration Management – PVCS
 MS Project and Excel
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
14
Customer Requirements Capture & Contract
EF Responses
RFQ
Candidates
GE
IT
NE
PBC
UK
RFP
EF
TDD
System Engineering Process
CP181
SP
FBC
SLTA
CP
Change Proposal
FBC
Final Business Case
PBC
Preliminary Business Case
RFP
Request For Proposal
RFQ
Request For Quotation
TDD
Technical Design Description
SLTA
System Level Technical Assessment
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
Spec. (A1)
A1
B
C
:
E
F
Proposal +
attachments
NE
15
Planning Phase
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
16
Project Management – Process Definition
1
1
WBS Preparation
2
Schedule Preparation
3
Rolling-wave planning concept
4
L3 & Planners level with Jira
5
Reporting to PCM – EV analysis
6
Programme / Projects Review Meetings
7
Visibility monthly report from PCM
2
6
3
7
5
4
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
17
Project Management – Process – WBS Prep.
Inputs
Tools
Outputs
Project Scope Statement
(Spec.)
Decomposition
WBS
Requirements Documentation
(CP 181)
Expert Judgment
WBS Creation Process
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
18
Project Management – Process – WBS (1)
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
19
Project Management – Process – Schedule Prep.
Inputs
Tools
Outputs
Activity List
Activity Duration
Project Scope Statement
Dependencies
Expert Judgment
Apply Lead & Lags
Project Schedule
Milestones
Scheduling Tool
Schedule Creation Process
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
20
Project Management – Process – L3 Level
L3 Tasks get allocated to build cycles or sprints
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
21
Execution Phase
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
22
Product End To End Process
ASTA Partner Companies
ASTA Programme Office
SD Process
Sub-system
Design
Sub-system
Requirements
SWs
PVCS
SW 1
SW 2
SS SW Int. Test
and Qualification
Contract
Spec.
Patches
SWs
Development
Cust. Req. Capt.
SW 3
ASTA
SW
Load
Integ.
&
Test
SPRs
ASTA
SW
Load
Creation
SW 4
ASTA
SW Load
Delivery
Qual.
Accep.
SWs Del.
SW n
APCs Internal
Process
SPRs
Integration Agile
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
Process
Qualification
Acceptance & TAP
23
Integration at Joint
Integration Facility
(JIF)
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
24
AGILE Principles
 Working software is delivered frequently (weeks rather than
months)
 Working software is the principal measure of progress
 Welcome changing requirements, even late in development
 Close, daily co-operation between business people and
developers
 Face-to-face conversation is the best form of communication
(co-location)
 Simplicity
 Self-organizing teams
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
25
Scrum Diagram
Daily Scrum
Meeting
24 hours
Product
backlog
Sprint
2-4 weeks
Sprint
backlog
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
Potentially shippable
product increment
26
Test and Integration Level
•Baseline
•Pedigree
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
•SPR Status
27
Test and Integration Level
There is three main “level” of integration at the
Joint Integration Facility (JIF)
 Functional Test
 Smoke Tests
 Full System Tests
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
28
Scrum and SCM
Mainline
Validation
Daily Scrum
Meeting
24 hours
Label
09-21
Continuous
Integration
Mainline
Time
SCR 1
SCR 2
Mainline
Validation
Sprint
2-4 weeks
SCR 3
Label
09-22
Mainline
Validation
Label
09-23
´
Regression
Test
´
SCR = Software Change Request
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
29
Qualification &
Acceptance
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
30
Qualification & Acceptance Process
Design Baseline /
RFAs
Qualification
Tests at the
Joint Integration
Facility
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
Type
Acceptance
Checkout
Individual
Acceptance
at MOBs
31
Quality Gate Concept
time
Phase 1
Inputs
Phase 2
Type
Acceptance
QG
Entry
Device 1
Device n
Engineering
Baseline
Build-up
Maturity
Test
Stability /
stress Test
SW Rel.
gold
ATMs Run
MOB Like
Operation
MOBs
QG
Conclusion
Test Doc.
SW Doc.
Potential Minor Modification
Formal Configuration + Formal Doc.
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
32
Monitoring and Control
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
33
Single Project Key Performance Indicator
Project Name
E2E Project Stage
Pre-concept
stage
Concept stage
Development
Stage
Embodiment
Stage
Utilization &
support stage
Schedule Variance
Schedule Performance Index
Cost Variance
Cost Performance Index
Risk Assessment indicator
N° of issues
Issues validation
measurement
Issues Closing Adherence
Requirement Tech.
Compliances
ATM Testing pass rate
Device Availability versus
planned
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
34
Project Management – Process – Reporting to
PCM
L3 Task progress is reported back to PCM via a Burndown chart of the current cycle
or sprint
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
35
Single Projects S curves
S curves
Value (€)
5.000.000
4.000.000
3.000.000
EV
2.000.000
PV
AC
1.000.000
RW
0
Months
1
2
3
4
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
36
Single Project SPI / CPI Graphic
M3
SPI
1,40
1,00
0,60
0,60
1,00
1,40
CPI
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
37
Sigle Project Dashboard (sample)
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
38
ASTA - Overall Integrated Dash-Board
Project 1
KPI
E2E Pro c ess Stage
Pre - Concept
Concept
Development
Embodiment
Utilisation & Support
Schedule Variance
Risk Indicators
Resource Issues
Product Content
Concurrency Indicator
Project 2
KPI
E2E Pro c ess Stage
Pre - Co ncept
Concept
Pre - Concept
Concept
Development
Embodiment
Utilisation & Support
Schedule Variance
Risk Indicators
Resource Issues
Product Content
Concurrency Indicator
Project 3
KPI
E2E Pro c ess Stage
Development
Emb odiment
Utilisation & Support
Schedule Variance
Risk Indicators
Resource Issues
Product Content
Concurrency Indicator
Project 4
KPI
E2E Pro c ess Stage
Pre - Concept
Concept
Development
Embodiment
Utilisation & Support
Schedule Variance
Risk Indicators
Resource Issues
Product Content
Concurrency Indicator
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
39
Projects Monitoring and control
CPI
2
1,8
1,6
GE Req
1,4
P1E
HMSS
1,2
SPI
1
0
0,2
0,4
0,6
0,8
1
1,2
1,4
1,6
1,8
2
0,8
Vis Obs
0,6
T1EP1
0,4
0,2
0
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
40
Execution Follow-up (Sample)
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
41
Aircrew Synthetic Training Aids
42