｢｡､｣ｦ･ｨｧ｢ｩ ff ｣ｦ･ "! #$ &%`｣ｦ･( ｦ｣､%) ｧ｢ｩ 0213 "! ｢｡､｣ｦ･(46587¤1 9A

! "$#&%
')(+*-,.0/21430(+56(879(:3;(+3=<>0?05(+/(+301@(:3;A BDCEF3 <G6C+14H8(+A IJ(:51)KL(+M4(+*-51N,.03;(:3;O P(+30Q7RISUT(:G6VWA
xexedY8_~Zyxex-\-zWvh\gzWah\@\9xed~df}6ancea$Åce_h\h\EÚxetWdd`^xeceYWd~a$}c-Zan°Wa_`aht[Y8^W_f]at[vhaDdjzW\gja$ceb}saUZv$_faht!\9Z]d`t·ce6Zyxe_f\9t[ªZ]ÛDZy_`cgxexeZ]z8d_`t
Abstract
X0tY[xeZ]a$\cetW^8a$_`x^ba$cd6^[cedfzW^b\gdZ]\gtWah\jd~i0}6kfa$lncemf_ho;pfqWt[rsa$_`x4tudf_`cecesvw\hYWZyxeahv$}6xeanzcncea0d{|d`c0ah^[ced~^b}sdDZ[Z]a$tWce \ Ã9ceZ}f_`xeaÌa$x4dfceb
xexe Y[Y[ZyahcwZycv$^8zW_~\@cgxex4dL^anceced~\}z[Z\ga$Zt[ce\xexeduYWadftWand`cxeZ]ahdt[t&Y8df_f{t[vh_&aDepftWWanm@x4p0|d`lgce L]\gpfa$¡ece¡}sZ]kDvh¢|ahmw\£[xe¤d ^[ced~}s{!Z[v$a$dcz[vDce_`\gtuafr[xeahYWZ]\dftWZ[\@xgahcw__`xeZ]aU\gt:aht[Ü xY8_`zWtW\ga$vh{¥aDzW!j\gzWancetW}]ahZ]vh\ga$\\hsxeY[X0aJYWZ]xe\YW^WZycw_f^ba$^Wc_`[cgx4an
an¢¥°[^b¦Jance§Z¨0a$tW©ªvhaD©+&«n;LX0Y[xeYWaJa±¨0d~©f}6ªa$ce©¬_h_`Wxg\@cwxg_`cw²_fvnvxe³:Zdft®}a$bcndzWdtWL[\!zW\gxea$Y[\aZ]xdfxe\gd´\@¯^cw_`cexedfa \gtWv$ancex4Z]0bd`ah\UceJ_vD\@_`t\@xeahZ]t8F[a$vhaD_fÆ] aD^[ced~i}skfZ[lnamfoUwp`lnq±mnxe¤fYW¢¥_`x;Ýh\gpfY[mwÞ·d~U¡\dfxe{Y8_`x0d_fbt¶9Úd~}6ta$ceZ!_h
}s]dfZ\g[\a!_`[\gZy\gz[a$cwce_`ahtWtvhxeahZ\h_frW9_fcwtW_`¶xea!a$_ft8]_fd[vD]ah_`\;xeZ]a$d°t[^W\h]rEZ vh\@Zyxwxg_~¯xecwZ_`\@xexeaZ]vDvh_`dftWWf_faht8\@xesZ]UdtZv$xedYµt_fxgcet8d ^bvwY8df_fcgxwt[_`tahx\_fxe\gdu^bxeahY[v$a·xd`[{_`xw_u}6dfa$cncv$d6dutxgZ]ce\;dExeY8^[_~xU_ftWZ]xa$\dfd{ah\UxeYWtWa dfxUÃuce_`dft8z[[xe_`a$xecea!\¤`bWanÒ
x4a$cg´ahah_`txUxeY[}6ajancn}6da$¶cnt[dds[ahtW\hdsrWZ]tWah\h\@xeaD_fL^W_fvhZ]t[´_`]:xeYWa± d6´u_fvwYWZ]t[
_`]dfceZyxeY[\h
Ê¸v$dY[tahxgt±cedbdd~}6a$Z\9c0^Z]xece\d~}^8Z_fvwaD6)a$x_`x9WzxeYWa a$ce \0Ã_`t8_h!a$xecDYWrfa_ft dz[ ÃLxe^[cez[dfxz[]xeZa$t[c9YW8_f_`\Et8xed`
w
x
f
_
b

1. X0Y[a$Introduction
xe^Y[cead[^W_fa$ce\@ajx[Y8df{;a$_fvD\a$_tWbY8aha_`ahWt&tWvhah_Z]}6t[anf´cwce_fdDxe8UYWcea·Z]ahtW\gb´aDah_~[\@cexga$vnuYa$_fa$dft8cgdfx)cg{¥\gxedfa$\;cceYW}s _~Z]tvh}xea!aa$ce_ftWWdsanxceaha$9\gd6\gxeaDd¶d`^xe}ceY[dfa$ac U]_fdtZ\g\gxeahYÂ\;}6r`dfa$_ftcnt8xed6YWvDJaU_`zWtjtWtWds[[Zycea$aahceyv$vhxedfZ]ytstW)xg \gcevwdfYWÃJ]\!aD^WtWzW_`ahxe]ZyaYÂxeY[xeY[a$ßc·ahdD\gxe0a-Y[cea$aah}6\ga$8dcD_`zr8t8ce¢ Ý9vhsahUaD\h_`ZÅ vns Yxet)YvhdftW}6tsd`a$xgc!cncw_`xe\@d6YWxD a r
}xeszZ[ceaha\» ¼sd6r½`rU¾¯ceahX0\gz[YW]a$xe\gZ]t[ar0¸_`Zt8txedfYWxea Y[a$ ctsxe^[\gceandfce}^bd_`\e_`t82\{¥¹dfcZy\gta$cexe}ºa$cet[_~a$cex¶vnY[Zyxed6ahv$ r ce_`dxz\gxeda$cUY8a±_`{|t8_fZyc)a$cw\_`xe_)a·à8_fdDv$2cedf_f\g\)ff xeceY[aha´_`kDxe¢|amwrW£[xgcw¤_f-tW ¢|\g¦Zyxg§|xexeZ]YWtWa±jzWxet8YWaa$_fcey`Zcet[ah6_~xeÃ a
YW_`]_Dd}6tWa´xN_0d^8_~6xeYLa$xed¶ceaDZ]¿zW^[Zyceaha$ahahttxex\hÀÁWd6ce\@xDr0ahxevwY[Y8a$_ft[Z]ce\gaD¿\Uz[Z]{¥ cedfac¤\gvw|-YWahce[dzzWxe]Z a$tWce \ xe^8YW_~axeYbce«a$\gv$ddz[tWcet[v$ahahv$\xeZ]_DtW}fj_fZ]x4_fWd]axe}6d!a$cnxeYWad6àWdDceUdfz[\jxeá-a$ce¢|\h¥Ïsr¢¥xeYWa$xet´YWa)ZyxU_fvDf_`ftceah_`_`]dxea±vD_~s xea
Zxe]_`t[Y[t8vhahLah\gtaU[xe{|z[Z]zW}6t[aha$\uv$cxe{|Z]udfdct[_f\htW _ftÄfxea$ahtce{|t[dfaha$cgtxxez[xDr8t8a$_`_~cet8xe}sahZ]yvh\ga&ra$xevhÃ9YWdcea$tWd~\gÂaU}r8ZxNxe0a$Y[dcea$\µ´ceaD§ ce¿ ah[zW¿sÃ-Zyz[ce\wahZyce«axea$xedJtsYWxeaah\-t8ceYW_`Z]_~W}Y]aax vh^[dfcetsdfÊ¸^bxgceY[dfdfcgZ]]xea&Z]Z]t[dxetW!YW_fxeZ]:\LYW\gaY8_`]cw_`_~cedDxeZ]Ut[ah\L\[r[d`àWZ]{9xd~aDU_`\´dvnahYU\UàWZ]tWxedDY[d`xUZ]t^[dfcet_`d~t2}sxeYWZÅ_faa}`_fceZycgtahxe6´zW_~_f_fxeÂaJ\g\gZ]zxet[dcw_ft[_fvhvwahYW\Z]ahd}6t a
ced`Wa${¥_fxe\g\gahaDZ]tµ_`v)cebvwxeY:z[ahce\@rbxgtWxeahY[a$a dfdf cgtsz[xUxexan\gcexeantWd´ce}a$bZ]xvhaa)_`[ceZyf²dsahyvh&ahz[yvhxdtxedxeZ]tszWahaha$\xDxerÂd¶_`t8^µced~}[Zah\gaj^[Z]dfxea·tWy·LzWxeY[vwY a U_f[vwa$YWYW}6Z]Z]ahvwah]Y}daD^ahtWxe\gYWcwz_~ajcexeahtWah\)\d`xexedfZ]Y8dc¶_`t&x±ddf[_`{0\g\·a$_ce]}6det[aDpf&[]_fmgdp\±\g¥\xeleY[ cwau_`xe]_fpfa$f¡e\h¡)f0cekDX+ah¢|dJmw_`£[xe_a´¤[9cwce_~¢|ahxe\ga¶¦\[§xe¨0dYWah©Z]\±\hªr-tW©+0df«nax r
_a$`Z]\!xeY[_`a$}tc·a$c_`xeydxexedYWa$cea·vht8z[^8_~·_fxeZ\@}bxa¶a${¥cea${¥\gdfRdfc!Z]a!taDxg_~xececedµds\hr:[z[d~ah}6vh^WZ]antW]cedD&ÅÆ_htWZ]tantW=anxex4YW{¥0zWaud`tWz[cevnst8xe\Z[dfanY8t8ce_D_`]}6Zya·Z]xNtWÆa$ xeY8a$Ãº_~cex·Z]aDt[Z] \ à8a$f°cedDa$vhâ6ah_`ah_`xe¸a·`_ÆZce\ahvh6}a$_~a$cgxecgxwa&_fZ]t®xg\gcwu_D}f}6_f_f]an]cezWÂ\gaÇ9Zt[r°[Jxe^bYWdf_&a\gZ]}s]tWdZy´cg\gxe\´z8xeY[_fcwa!_`;xe]¨0a&Z tW©fdª[©Z]\g\ua$ce_f_&}6WaD\@^bxgdDcw0_`v$a$xecgZ]{¥dxezWYWtUa&dxed_ft[`a_
{Ådfcw[_fxw\@_`xgZcetuz[v$_~xexz[xeceY[aarUd`Ãµc´]xeahYW}_`ahx¶sceÇ-aD°[¿_`zWZyceah^W\´]ahZ\-tdf{|d`{ced~u}6a$_`cexeZ]_hd!t¸t[xea$Y8x4_~xdfceZ]s\´\Y8Zt[_` cwvh]z8xeda ÊÆ[ZyxeaZ]d_`tWce_ff-zWaU\gvwxeYWYWaDZ]\zW]Z tW\gJY[dD§afU Zt[]rÂjxeYWahZ]_`xYZyxex;aD&vD_f{tu_fZybcja¿vhzWda$±zWZ]WtWZ]6tW«ah±_ftWUZyxe[Y¶z[xgcwa$_~c
t[}f_`^W_`a$xex4^[ah¶Z]dfvDce_~Z]stxe\hZ]d^Wr:t[_`_fcgtWxU_h& a$ce!c)ahxe\g±Z]Y[ Z]azWahyt^bxex)Z]dvD\gd~_fZy}6xe\@Z]xa$}6cea»È_hce&r+ahÉ~\gtW¾¯z[rÂa$yxNxeÊJ0\;dfahdf&ce{Esxevh\!Y[dah§tË\gxeaaht_fÌx)^[^[\w«jceZ]d\@»yxg_fÍ$ce¾¯vwZ+YW[Îahz[\0xedfZ]{¥dxedfZyt c u}s_f^[Z[_f^[tWa0ce_fdD\gfa$°ahceZ]u}sZ]vh_`ahaUxetax9\@\gZ]xwvw_~YWanxeceahZ]ah\@txeZahxevhZÅ\9_f_~cexe8z[Z]_`dtW\gt:tW\gfz[Z]t[ÊÆcw_`a;tW_`vh_`x-ah]\g\9xedY[Ua\gY[YWahdDt·}6a$z[cnxe\gY8aD_`djx-)Z]Zyt±tWx-dsvhvDd_`t`t!ahã@\9zW^[xet[cedd~v$}s^[xeZ]Zced[d`t a
\gt[^ba$a$x4vhZydfÁ8cevU¶tWvDa$_fxNtL0d`[ced±·xe\gY[a$ace}s\eZ]_fvhah\harf0{¥dfaUc \gahtahxeja$cexet[da$Zxts}6a$d\@xebZ_`xeaUZy{Â_ftd~}6a$ce_h UvD_`ZytxeYJ^b_fa$WceZ]_`ds^[xeZZ]vh}6_fa±]y_[cea$tWZ]\gah\gfZ]ddftxeZ_`vhxedfa¶tsxgxeceYWdfah-Zyc!\gvnxgY[cwah_`tW\gah\·Z]§\gaf\g Z]d]trÂUcw_`Y[xea$ahce\wa±«nràW_`dDUt8 \
_~cedsvnX:Y[dZyahxeah v$d`xetLxez[Z]}cexeaf_~Y[rxeZa-vh\dfUtWY\gdsZ[[_fanaht)crÂxed~_Y[}6aa$^[ce{|cedfd~_h]}sdDZ [Ua$Z]Z]ctWYWx:z¥Ïs[ah¢¥\_mg tWÐ]anxeÑx4d¤f0mw_Ud`Ò^ceceoUd_fpfv$qvhZ]\gahÑWZ]\gtWmg\pfkD{¥ce¢¯df 6dln m ah[tWZ]\gvh¯z[xe\gdf\!ahYWtWdD¶ävhdf_JtWf¨0ah©\@ªxeZ]d©t_`vhWdf\@tsxgxgcwce_`dfv$+xeZ]_`d]tdfahcet8Zyxe_`Y[W]ah\h\! t[a$äa$°^[Z]vhZyxg¯cw_`xea
\ga$d}6ua$cw_`_fZst[xg\h cwE_X0Y[ZyxeahZdf\gat8_`tW ds [ahÃ-\\-{|_fd`t8ceÓ)^W_ftÆ_`vhahd~\-}6a$tWceds_hah\9tWZ]a$t!xN0[Zyd`cea$cerÂa$tsUx+YWceZ]dvwYµz[xexeZ]t[Y[a
Z]ce\a±\gÍ~ah«nv$xeZ]ÚºdtkD¢|mnah£[\gArchitecture
v$¤ceZ]b ¢|ahs\U¦;xeZ]YW\ajxeY[aU}6zWa$t8cna$d6ce´ytWZt[anx40d`ÃÆce^8_~_~xeceYvnY[vhZydxet[ahv$tWxeahz[vncexga
xeY[Zycw^8_~cgx4´^[ced~}sZÅa$czW\gah\Uxeddfancaht[Y8_`tWvhaDLt[a$x4dfce¶\ga$ce}sZ]vha 2.§¯åEX0Z]YWzOverQoS

Ôa$uÇ©+_fÇ_fbZ]¨; d`\hcwÀÂ_`Ö~xe¹d`_`ahcg^Wµ_`d`cgafxe{r Z]\@¨xeahddftZxDvhr_^[r z[Äcw_fxetWa$tWZ]c}6an8ce×!vh\gZ]Z]ahØxNt[vhvh\hadf r+b{·a$ÎL¨0ce6_f_fah\g]Zy]\e{|a$_`d`vnceYstWaDz[Z_\gz a$xg_~xexL\ ÕtWan\@cexe6Zyahxe]za$xea r Z]vD]tW¤f_~ÒjcgcebZxNa$0pD\! dlnxg[cwd~_`}6ÚR²a$ceè$v¶£s_hµb{¥ce dtWælds[Z]\_fa$t\hxeYWEalnÚFW\@xg}smwceZyÒaDcg_`xepfz8Fkf_`lndfmn{+]]Z¤ftW_fÒ^[^WbZ]]pD\)Z vD zW_`l±xetWZ]xeZdfdtZ]ce_`[a$t¬v$_`xexwZ]lg_)dçft8¢|^8j_`_f0vwp`6kf_`a$lnt8xem$ \Ð

d`Ù {X+ahvwYWt[d]d`rWYW_`ceZÅØ]vh\h Z]xD aDz
{¥vD_fce_~tWdfcgéceZah·µah\@z[xe_`Z]]v$t8xeceZ]_`d^[xe\gZ]a)\dftWxexgY[cw\h_f a·t[}s\g^bZycgdfxecgz8xg_f+_hZ]t[a$c³à8ZydDxUxN\)^W_`Z]v$vDce_fd]\gy\±[Z]tWZyv$a$zWce[ahtah\x^8\gdf_fz[vw6cevha$a$xe\\
_xefYWtWZ] \t_&^Wf_fah]^btWdfa$\gan\!cDcw_f «!cw_`rÂX0xe_ajYW}aë+Zycg;vDxe_f§|zWÊÆ^W_f_f+a´vh]ZyZ x4[tWdft:ê¶ZÜ \x·ceahvn{¥dYW^[vh_`cezWa$cw\g_`\·ahv$tdxea$xet\!ceZ][ÛhxeaDahYWa_hu_`_~\g_°\gZz[vD±cw_`_fzW^8t[é_fvhv$ahZ]cwxN\_`xeZ]t aê
}xes_`Y8xZycg_~xeUxLz8YW_f_ÆZ]:vwY&]^WZt[_fxevwbY[6r[a±a$Ux¶a$Y[tsZ]Z\Lxg]cga)sxeceYWda^W}6^ba$]dcnah\g\d6cwd_`txetWaUxedsY[ëL[a&a)ceah}vD^Zy_`cgcet&xeahzW\g\gah_fahtt8xeL]\;Z tWxexgYWcw_`a)[²!^[z[v±ceaLdfd~8xe}6d_fa$[cvhZ]xedZyYWxNt a
8a$_`\@\gxeaDZ!dft:d t \gtdf^[cwa0_`{v$_`xeZ]Z]cevht[aahr\g\00v$a&ceZya$xe°a$^bceZ]ahdfv$tx¶dfêc0xedfdÆ[xwb_`Zat[aDa$·Z]xeY[{¥cea$dfcì[_a$xevha$dcetxgZ]cwt[_faDvn x
Virtual link
(IP path between OverQoS routers)
AS
AS
IP
IP
IP
IP
AS
AS
AS
AS
bå9a$Çc)¨_d`^f{ÚceËa$xg¬cw_`tW\gdf\gzxeZ]\gZ]d\gZ]t:d tW\h tJahvnxeZdft]\ ¼r:a!^[cea$\gahtxj_´Y[ceZ
Zce]tah^X0xeceY[YWaha·\gaahxg[tcwzWxe_`\¶t8²xev;]Y[a!ba_fa$_fxNtW0&ahdcea$z[aht±t[x4x´zWtWd`dW{d~_`ce}6tWaDa$v$[ce´z[_hxgt8jcw[_`tW_f²dstWv·vnah{¥\-dfcevhc)aDd¿]t[dz[\g\gZ]Z\ce\@ahxece\-ahv$d`xed`{8d}xea$YW_fcgavwYWàW Z]dD ah{2U}6`a\
Z]df_JtÆ{xwxexe_`YWYWcea´aufa$W¨0x´z[©t8ªdf\g©¸\@a¯cw\g_`Z]a$\ xeceaa}sbdZv$Zcâa´rxeêfYW§@dsaÍ e ¤fahk`ÀX`6¤f«n¢|f]E¤6¡uX0èh]YWlµp`Z])\·èegJ¤f]aD8¤f_f f¡[á-\±¥¢¯Ï[ fxelL¥dLÏµ¤fxe{|mnY[d`mwa¶c¢|k`[¤xeYW0a$ÁWaLm@tW¤fàWNZyxelLdDZ]Udp@t \Ý
¥]pfÏW¡elL¡jè$mg£s¤fbNlu ¤6l$mg¤fp`¡w¥¡±Ï[¥lLÏWl·lnWkD¢|mwmwÒµ£W8¤fpD lL¢¥¦¶ 6p~á-ln¡¢|+88pf±pflgç6lgç6wlwwlglw5 lgi b Z ¥Ï[á-l±¢|¥ÑÏL¤6Ïsw¦68¢ g~lnÏ
h
Ñ8m@p6èe¤6è$¢ ¢|Ò
j
h
fa$_ Á[fX0fxe\hceYWÀ`aha´åE_`Z]¨0cexe\@a©xDrfªr~cwxe©¸_`Y[xeaY[_fa$ah[cEt\@xgxgxecgcwY8_f_`v$t±t[xedsZ]dfd[t·ta_Y8^^b_fced`\0a$}scgw¯Zp`à8[Wa$dD\jmgpfxeWDY[_fd`a\g}Z]a$\g\ha$c9fceX0YW}sdDYWZv$ÆZ]a¶\9xeY8dfY[_`ta\Ece_Lx4a$0\gWddz[z[bt8ceahv$[tah]a\
dfZ]tL{9xexeY[YWaa_f[fzWft8ceah]a_`bxesa±ah_`vhcedfa)t8ÂZr8\@_fxgce^[Z]^W[yz[xeZaDt[´u_få9Çd¨t[·{|d`xecYW]ad\gZ\@tW[vhZ]df}stZxg[cez8d_`EÂdfàWt&dDU_ft \
_fffceah_`xeaÆZ]\´dfcea&a$²vhZ]ahtx´xeY8_ft¸dft®_^ba$cg¯à8dD W_f\gZ]\hX0YWa
_Z]`t[f·ceahtWa$anx40ahtd`xcebU8Z]xeYt[axeYW;a_hu_f[d`{9^[Z]tWceZ]d~\@}sxgZcw[_~Z]xetWdf)ce\{_`§ Z] cet[Ãah\g\w\«·Zd`\0{xed±xeYW\ga´a$xUzWêtW[Wa$_fce\gyaDs ]dD_`0cefa$a$cc)xexeYWYWaa!å9tsÇzW¨¸±bd`a$}ca$cedfYW{;aD^W_fµ_fvw»y6'Í a$k~xe¾¯\ UZyxeYWZ]tÆ_`txeZajUZ]t8[dDrÂxeYWa
df_tW_f_`t8tFsNµUZÐPORxeYÆQS¬UYWÑ8Z]¢ vwÑ[Yl!Z_`\W\@N xgcw_fxevnZ]xeZdfaht:\)xeYWX0auYWZ]xe\Y[ce_`dfWzW\@fxgcwYW_`^Wv$zxexjZ]dtdf{^_&ced~\g}Z]t[Zah]a\ []auX0YW_~xjaxNa$0tsdxgcg]ah}6t[a$ds[\)ad`{Ua$°fa$cwcg_fxets\)z[vhÅ_~dfcetsZyxgx4cedfÀEdfdftJtJxexeYWYWa!a![xgzWcwtW_~²[]vaZ]_ftJ\±xe_´YWaUY[[dzW]t[a r
XbUan¨0x40Ãa$ahvhtµdt[xetWY[ahauv$xeZ]df}6tÆa$cndtd6xe&YWa!^ce}sd`Zy}scgZxe[z8an_`cj_f]Z t8tW&bxeYWN a u[_hÃ-&\hrÂbdfa!cjtWbaha!fdf^WxeZ]Zvw_`6xeahaD ]_fahtW}6ah]\hdfrtxeYW_µa^ba$a$tscgxg¯cgà8udDFt[ds[8a_f\gvhZ]_f\!tUv$ZydxeYWtZ]xgtcedxeÂYWaha´ZyxeYWWa$zWc;tWxe[Y[]aa-\gÚ0ahtWx·[bZ]tWdfjxeYcw_`xexeYWaahd`\gac
xed·X0bYacexeahYWa·av$tsdtWzW\@±xgcwb_`a$Z]c;tsxed`\{Euà8dD_fU6\Ua)Z]xetYWa±xeYW[aah[\gZ]zWftWtµ[d`]a!{xe§ Y[\gaha±ajsahahv$vwxeY8Z]_`dtWtZ]\g½«n \_~x xe]Z YWtWabÜ \±df\gz[\¶t8[cw_~anxecea]Z]tWX0YWaL^8_`ahcwt_`xgcga$xetWa$ceds\hr:aêuÁW_fcetW\@x¶ë+a$:xeÌa$cea$°sxDZ]tWr:a$Z]\!x±xeYWa$axea$}sceZycgxeZ]tWz8ah_`\
xeY[ajÍf}6a$}6cna$cnd6ud6ut[dst[[dsah[\Uah\0vwY8U_fZ]] +aht[z[\gZ]z8tW_`yÀ ¶\g^8_`tLZ]anceahtx0cedzxeZt[!df xe]dYW\ga\@¯]cwah_`}6xeaha sdfZu{[_fceaDtW[&z[a$t8\@[xe_fZutWvn_~lxeah`;\cexeaDY[¿ajzWZycecea$aD\gzWyxexedZ]tW_`¶vnY[_DZ}a$_`}6Za0 _`_Wvh]a·a$cgWxw_f_fZ]t8tjsxwU_`ZcexeanY x
bf0X0YWa&ahtxgcgtWdsa&xeY[aht¸Z\@xgceZ][z[xeah\xeYWa[zWtW[]aÜ \¶_~}f_fZ]_f[]a
¼UutWX0a$YW_fv$aZ]xet[aD\U¶}6_fxet8a$d±cnxeYWÚdavhÜ \htWdf dstWaha$\\@xeUaDZ] ]Z tWzWs\gzW\h_f]ytWdfxba[Zyceahv$xeyvhdft[ xg8cw_`_`t8²!svUZÅZ]s\!xeYm_`ceb´fa$_fc!xedfY8tW_`&It xebfYWr9a´xeYWZtWa¶[a$Z]}s°sZxg[cwz8_L_`xg0cw_`à8²dDUv´\hZ] \ {cexedfYW^Wa^bt[aDa$x!_~Z]x!t[^WxeYWz[ax
½s vh tudftWfaha$tW\@a$xecwaD_`¸rW\gZ]t[df\¶a±df§{)d`c;xeY[a d\@xnÃF«d`^W{:_`xexeY[Y¸abxga$cwxN_~0²ahvahtxgcw_Dx40}6a$dce\gd~Z]t[}6ja$cexeY[_h a xeahYWtaxgcgWzWt[tWds[[]aa_f_`t8vhvhdfcwxeYWZ]atW]!d\gxe\gd·ah\UxeY[_~ahceZyacU\ga$Z\@cexg}sceZZ]v$[ajz[xe\gaD^bua$vh_fZyÁ8vncevDd_~\gxe\0ZdfxetWYW\haU à8dDU\;Z]t
t!xeY[aUtWa$°sx\gahv$xeZ]dtÂr60a^[ced~}sZ[aU\gdadf{xeYWaU^bd`xeahtxeZÅ_`8baht
Úxgcw_~²\;v´tW_j_fdscet8a$µah\gzW\;tWyUxDa$r[Z]xN0:df}6tWcea$d`µcnxvhbd6dautW^8[t[_`ZyahxecgaDZ]xd[t[d`\ {E\jxexed±xeYWYWYWa)_`_fx±t8Z]}x±a$]acnY8_`xeZ]\±dut[a$dW}zWvh_~tWdcg[t]Zxgat[cedf)0v$d~ced}6\ga$\@cD r a$dÁ[^[xe^b\·d\gxeaDdJ_`xetda$ã4zWt8\@xz[zW\g\ga$Z]c·tW!{¥dfxecuY[a zW\gZ]tt[xeJa$ce_`tWta$xD8}6a$anv$cnxeZ]ddtA\u_`ce[vwZ]YW\gvhZyxez[ah\gv$\gxeahz\ceaLY[dD_` \
_`t8´}6a$a$cnxUahdtWLYW_fZ]\t[vh8a_`\gxeaDYWµa\gdfa$tce}sxNZ0v$a±d´¿{¥zWzWtW_fW]Zyx4_f¶dfa${Etsxwxe_`Y[9a[Wa$z[\gt8ZftJaf^ ceZt[vhZ]^W]ah\hÀ YW_µdD¨0©xeªYW©¸a¨0vD_`©tª©ba¶_f[Z]\@xgcw^W_f]ahv$xeZ]dfaht¶txevhaD_ftu-bsaahv$z[xeZ]\gdaDt·xeÈd)^[Z]ce}6d~ah}s\±Z[a$°[aU_fahtWYW^W_f]aht[\±vhaDdf {
\ga$ce}sZ]vhah\h
a$\g_^bt8«)a$_f]v$[dfxe]\gZ]ah\±}6\a±vhdfd`t}{xga$xececnY[da±³9d}f¶b_`«cgxed·_`Z]tWd`u[cexwaht[_`6a$Z]_~tx4xea´_!dfceceah\gZ]tWdfv$z[dZ]·t8cevhz[auZyFxevhZdfdf\gtWtsa$\hcexgÂ}scedfZ]Õvhaj9©:¿_fdfz8\g_f`\±]ceZyahx4v$6´d_~tZyxexgcgZ]cecetWda$
àWZ]tdDUZ]\\@xgZ]tceZxe[dz[_·xeZ]tW[!zWtWxe[Y[]aarW_D}_`}6Z]Åa$_`cnW]a)d6uceahvD\g_`dtLzcea$vh°aha$\jcevh§8Z]\g_fatWvhdfUZ^Wxe]YÂa$xerWa]dfv$\gd\wt«;xg{¥cedfdc 3.Q¤f ti0Why
xeYWkfZ]ln\)m`oU\gahpfv$Use
xeZ]dÑWtÂmgpfrEOverQoS?
0¢¯ 6a!lxglncgsÏ[xe¤fdbw_`lgtW \@¡h0lnanmwc±kD¢¯xewY[lUa!p{|d¤f]|dDbUi0Z]kftWlnmfo;¿pfzWqoah\@n;xeZ]pfdá-tÂ¡ À

q
D
k
xeY[aWz[t8[]a_fdt[\@xUxeYWaZtW[Z]}sZ[z8_`ÂàWdDU\h
0á-a¢|Î¥Ï[dfpfdce£sz[aRÅ´^pl Y8ceg6ah_D¤fvh}6Z]¢|a\gkfahl$_·yÒ´\@r´xgr¤ ceqdftWa¬lg$;¢|vD) _`_`g¶ts\gax®¥Ï[{|d`l±xedäcèez[¤6sw\gt[Z¦ t[gfd~umg p`£8U}6 ´a$Y[cna$xemgYWt¤d6sa$c¸ uxeY[ a$w{ cevNaRah_`y\ cexa r
}sxgZcw[_faUv$xebZ]da$tÂxgxer0a$Link
cepfxe[Y8_`mgtp¥(CLVL)
bleah f\@ÐNxg]pfa$¡e¡dfkDcg¢|xmw\g£[a$cg¤ }6a$cnd6¶\gdfzxeZ]dtW\UxeY8_~xU\e_`xeZ]\@{¥´xeYWa{¥d] dDUZt[uvhdt[\@xgcw_fZ]txe\hÀ
2.1X:dja$t8Controlled-Loss
}s ¢¥Z]vh<¦ ah\hTUrÂQ0VX_fa·W[^[V]aceYDdr8^bxe}6dfdan\gaucnvwY8_´_`dcwjt[_`a$v$xeìxed)a$ce^[_fZ]ce[Ûhd~aj\@Virtual
Í;zWÚ\gtZ]tW¶xe}6YWa$a)cnbahd6\@uxgz[a$\ga$d`cUcgx\gYWdftzWxea$´cetWfa$a$xDxb_±xe\gYWancea$}cgUZ]vhZ]a\ga±tWd±_zWdf\ga$cec\ga0xedYWtÂ_fÜt x
e
x
W
Y
)
a
g
\
$
a
e
c
s
}
]
Z
h
v

a
e
c
h
a
h
v
h
a
]
Z
6
}
D
a

!
_
W

W
z
t

Y8_D}6a_`ts¶Z]tWv$ahtxeZ}axed! zW\gaj}a$cndb
txe[Y[]dsaa![9ahWÄ\hz[r\gt8_jZ]t[¨0a±©ªd~}6ah©a$vncjYW^[_fce_t[d~}sZvh\ganZÅcgxwah\_f\Z]Z]tÆ_jb^[^bdfa$a$zWceZ]t8dsahµtr[xed`ZsaD{0rJdxet!Z]_~x±xea·Y[xeaY[ceaha¶]dfa$\g_`\tscw[xgcwcg]_`µahxe\ga\)_`\gt8d`ahÆ{;ahtuYWa$°dDZy x
xeX0Y[Y[aa·z[Z[t8ah[_¶anceZ]]\Z]xetWYW_`x8__`t8¨0s©UªZÅs©®xeY¢¥¡$ê´pf]¤f_fNtWln¡;xe]dfYW\gaj\u]dcw_~\g\gxeaha·\ëa$°}^b_~a$cgceZ]ahZt[tvhaDxeZ]a ¼sUa$}6dfa$cgcnxn«;dxgcw_`²\gYWvdf zW [aD_`t[]dfxurW^b0aha)tW_f0]dZ Ûhz[axeYW]ZaL6a±W_f_uvwb`a$ce\@dxgNz[ant8dfcgx§bàWa$dD\@xg
xeYWd)dD2cea$vhuahZ]_f}6taUucedfdxezWY[fa$YWc;y!à8dDxeY[Ua\)\e§|_`xeY8_~axUxe\gYY8ce_`dcez[axeYWY[^[az[x\e_fZycgceaha\gv$^bdahtWv$xefZ]ah}6\@axeaDdf {
xeÃY[a´t[[a$x4zWtWdf[ce]ua{¥^8ce_~dxe Y: xeYWa¶]d\g\@¯cw_`xeaL}f_`ceZ_~xeZdftW\!Z]txeYWauz[t8[ance]Z]tW
_`Z]xet[Z]W}6a«;zWZ]tW\gvha±a$tsxe}6Z]}6ancna$\;tWddfxUWX0xed±YWZ]\g\zW^W;^b_hd`cgr8x_`t}6 a$cnÃ0ddft:xgÜcwx_`²YW_Dvf}6 a)tWah`
zWtWWt[_fat[;v$µ_h¶^8xe_fd!vw6vha$dfxets\)xgcexedfdLÂxexeYWY[aua[}sZyzWcgt8xez8_f]aÂ9]Z åWtWd`¶cg;df_~\gcw\cw_~anxecgacedfZ]c!\Uxev$d!dfcg_ceahWv$uxeZ]cedfa$t
xexe§¯d¶YWå9_fÇt¨;d!«)å9xeYWÇ_fZ]t8¨\hµWrÊ¸Ú_fzY[ËxeZ]dajuÚu_`xeË_hZ]v!Æ cet[YWahah^b_faDah\_`_!xjcedDdfaDce¿aua$zWcahxe\@ZWxu_fa¶t8§¯ÚsxeUËdZcea$«xevhY_`d~ce}6cea!aDa$¿cux4z[Z]cedaha$^b;aht8_hahts\x dvhdfz[tW\gx-yuZ]a$\-\@\exetW_`aDxed`!Z]x-\@{¥]Z]Zut[bb`d`aDÊJxe[Y¶Za;_`v$vhxeda$dtW]t[j\@\gxgZcwvh[_`]aDa$Z]ts_~c-c-xex4\hxeWY8d¨_`\gx-dfvhtWZyahx\gtWZZ][_`\-cea$^bZ]Rc ddz\h\gr8\gà8Z]§¯W_6dD]«9Ua;_f\xe]dxgcwzu\g_DZ]}6·à8a$dDz[ceU\gyxwZ]\t[_ftW_`·cean_a
Z]t[µdftxeY[a´ËX;XFbanx40a$ahtxeYWa¶d`}a$ce_DÆtWds[a$\_ftWxeY[a´tsz[! bah\@xga$d`cgxDr~_ftW·§b«{¬à8dDU\+ba$dftW;xedU_¨0©ª©-r~_ftWxeYWa9ceah\@x+df{
OverQoS routers
"! #%$&$'
(
)*
)&+-,/.102)
,4357689$:!;!<=,=-$&#
> '?)#$&@')A)5
'#BCB--,=DE='-,F';=,=.)'G
B1-,IHKJML=#"'=(
2.2 Aggregate Resource Control
~tW_ ce_`e aceZ]XU{äd¨0§¯à8_6Ã-dD«0\hUxe\0YWÊÆa5_~a;ceORavhQ_fb]SUa$W\@Ð4xexgl YWN$£ana;¢¥xedfk`Ycg¤cexDdlnszWWÚf;\gYW\g¥^[ÏszWz[m@pfx£a0_fg~vwxeÏ~Y8YWÑ8Z]_~£sahx0}69_`ahd`]·{9bbxeY8!ah\@_`_xgxUàWa$àWd~d~dfcg8xZ]tX0à8\gdDYWvhUaha$t \
v$\gY[dtWdz[\@xgÅcwº_`Z]_ftsvwxLYWZ]§ah¼}6«±aÆvD_`t[tdb]aha´\g\cea$xe;Y8ce_`ZytºxgxeahZytxe\_fXU\hÀ¨0aDÃ-_`vnaDY¿zWWZ]_f}fvw_f]ah`tcedx&z[xet8Y[Æcedfà8zWdDUY\
^[Y[z[a$cexa)t[Zydx{|udf]_~dDxgUxea$\cxeY[YWd~_`RxxeuYW_`ajt_fLffà8cedDahU_`\xeba!ahW]d_ft[tW´Uxed¶ZxexeYWYLad`¨0{©f_´ª¨0©©f+ªå[©cedfr8 êfr
\g^[Y[z[dxez[\ÅdfL{+t[xeY[dfxa a${ °vhàWahd~aDU¶\0xeYWxeYWa_`\gxzWbâah]d`d{tW)xeY[xea)d)XUxeYW¨0aÃ-¨0aD©¿ªz[©-Z}f[_fß]ahdDt0xahxe}6Y[ancecDdfrzWxeYWYZ]\
Z]ah¿sz[^[Z]}Z]ah_`\±a$xetsY8x_`xex!Y[ceZ]{dfzW_µfYW¨0^W©zªxD©¸r[xeY[à8a$dDceâa)Z]_`\vnY[_~xZa$}6]aDah_f\!\@x_fd`t[cedfa´xeYWxeY8anc_`t¨0©Z]xeª\!©JXUà8¨0dDÃ-
xexeYWY[Z]_`\x_`_`^Wvn^8Y[_~Za$ce}6ahaht\;xey]Lah\g}s\;Z]dxeY8_`_`xet´ah\Zyxevh\UdXUt[\@¨0xgcwÃ9_fNZ]aht¿sx·z[§@Z]}ÍD«U_`\ga$Z]tst[x;vhaxeYxeceYWda)z[zWYW\ga$^[cz[xDUYWÕdfz\gax
àWfa$dDx¬_±_`bvnY[anxgZa$xe}6a$cUah\\ga$]ahce}s\g\UZ]vhxeaY8_`ut\@ZyUxe\ZyxeXUvnY[¨0ZÃ9t[·aDxe¿d±zWZ]xe}Y[_`a]ahbtahx\@xgxeYa$cedd`z[cgx YW^[tz[xexa$ceut[a$_hx
_}s`bZ]vhå[d~aLdf}6cgajcexeahzW_`v$cetWahZ]_`}6z[xeaDahyahrEtxxeY[Z]\UZ]_J\·xezWZ]Y8\!\g_~anxtWc¶d`Ux·a±ZyxexeYWY[Y_~a´}xevDaY[_`aZ\gaxe^[Y[X0]ceZdfv$YWzWZ]xea¶yY[^[^WceaDdfz¿Wxuz8]_`ahdfxe {)ahYWU Z]xe\Z]YWxeà8Ya)dD\gUxea$Y[cg\ha
xexeßYYdDcece0dahaLz[ah}6a$anYW°[cD^[_`rEz[_Lx-^Wd`z[]{bah\ga$\aDcj_fZ]vwtZY!\)Ud`t[{dfY[YWx±ZvwZ]Y¸\9_fyà8;dD_hU}a$\h\jcnZÊJtdxea0a$ceZ]a$^[]\@z[cexed~\@aDxg}sµcwZ_`[Z]xetÆaha;\dfxeahYW^[t[Z]xe\-Y8Z]_`^btWdZ]ÛhvhZ]tZ]aDtWx-U\gxeZ]a$Y[xecgY a
}sZ]vhah\;xed!z[\ga$ce\;UYWZ] a)\@xeZ]:\e_`xeZ]\@{¥Z]tW!xeY[a_fbd~åW}6dfacjvh\gdfdtW\@xga·cw_`zWZt\ga$xece\h\) Zyx
Z]\LZ]RÛhZ]
t[d`#Jce.=aµxe-,YWZ]a ^bxed`Ycgce
xwd_fz[tx´YW^[xedz[L=x_`vnd`Y[{Za$xeYW}6aaJahZyBc_'àWK]d~dDGrUé%#"\h0]dåW\g df\cucw_~Z]t[xe\@axw_fxetWYWv$_fat®r0uZy{_`xe°Y[Zya
z[XU\\g¨0Z]tWÃ9[aD_^W¿\}6zWdZ]_f}fZ]\vh_fan]Nahdfd~ttW}6x0¶anxecg_fY[ \ ceÃ&dfxezWYW_ffa)^WYW^[]^Wd]Zz\gvh\x_`xecwd`Z]_~{Edxet·_a±à8Z]\dDd]z[ahÅ\gj\a$bxeceaY8a±_fYWÍt_fk^Wk\e^_h< Wxeksd^W]Í \h¶ra$_jx-Âdfz[X0tW\gY[a$y ac
cez[ah\g_fZ]tW\gd)t^ba${|d`cg¯c!à8z[dD\gZt[å9µÇ¨ }6a$cnZ]\dxeY8_`ZxtÆ^bxea$Y[cgNZ]_f\·fvDf_`ce\gaha _`xeaZ]tWå9\@ÇxeaD¨_fY8_fdf\{_\gZ]]d~^Wa$y c
d~}6anceYWaD_fZ]t´xea$ce\;d`{9ceaD[z[t8W_`tx0xgcw_`²vxeYW_ft´^bZa$}cgah¯tRà8dD_¸vnå9Y[ÇdZ]¨vha r
xg0ucw_f_~_`:t²tL=xv#xed)'zW1åW\g#Z]a$dfB cec&\!^[=ceZ]t[d~#}6\@d,=xwa;zW._fxetW> Y[v$aa].Z rxe6'Ya_cedxezWdJzW
\gfa$Y8YW.=c_D^[-}6xez[aYWx%_`v$dfx&d={:tYWYWxg_fZ]'ce\ \dvN,·Z]d z[t^byxedfxeZcgYW^[xwah]_faµZytc´Uxà8_fxdDfUà8fdD\&ceUahu\;_`_hxe_~ax
xeYWY[_fa\;a$x4°^bd·ahà8t[dD\gaU\Udf{EZ]t´xeY[xedY[\gaa\e]_fah\g\ a)vNZ¨0©f^bªd`©µcgxwU_ftY[xUa$x[ceWa¨xedfYWtWa\gXUZ[¨0a$cÃ9_·aD¿z[zW\ga$Z]}fc;_fxe]Y8aht_~xx
xebYa¶ced_`z[W]aYW^[xez[dxÂcedfaD{[[_0Z]\@à8xgcedDZ]JWzZxe\ akxeÈYWÎa!xeWdf^[xw\h_` td`{jxeY[Í´Z]\:ÎvD_`[\g^Wa\jrDxe_fYWa-dfz[tW\gLa$c+Zy\gxeY[\)dx4z[Åd
àW¶dDUzW\;\gZ]_ft[\0!Y[YWaZ]a$UcwZ]_~\gceY[vnahY[\hZ[vh_fX0EYW]Z]Z \tW¶{|z[\gtWY8v$_~xeceZ]dfZt[t8L_f]Zy»yx4Í !\`¾vD8_fÌt¶dfbxeaaxeahYW_f_`\gZ]xUy¶Z]t_fvwxeYWdsZ][ah_D}6aDÜ \
UdfttÆZ]xe +a$xeceYWt[tWadfa$xUxDdfr6cez[ah_xe\gzWz[df\g]Z]xa$tWcZ]&tvD_f]Z]Zt[t[t[v$tWbcedfr:aDx0_fceaD_f\gahvwYWzWZ]vhahxeZ]Y[}6t[aUceLdxez[xeYWYWZ]Y[\ha!³^Wxez[z[Y[tWxce]dfah{|dfzW\gc\fYWxexeYW^WYWaUzax)vhdfdxedft[YW{andcaht[\@àWxea!Z]dDdfUà8t´dD\hZ] \
0d_fRtÂt"x·Ü x! xeZ]dL7ce^8aD
_f#vnzWBx´vhaxe=Y[xe#aY[,=a¶v$. dv$> d-^W.]^W'a$]xea$Z]xedfZ]t
dftÆxe.=Zxe-Za$%\´a$ \±d`{·d`{']d\gt[Y[,Xdf cgxjà8Ú dDà8UdD\hzWU\g\·a$cZyz[{vnuxeYYW_hZ]_ \
ce{¥\ga$anZ]ah cet[}vhZ][vha!_`axw\gv$Z]_LtWdv$^WzWa±_f&vwxe6YW\ga$ajZ]xe\¶tWuZy» ÁW_DDã@vD¾¯df-_fcetX+ZyxNxed&yZ]df Z{z[\@^xgahcecw&d~_`}6xexgaua±cw_fxexetWYWY[\@aa±{¥a$0{|ceah\a$_fJ\gvhZ]dfW[tWZ]ce \gZydDx4Z]U\@x\gZ]d`dtW{t[y\g&z[a$°vndfYÆ^b{a$__
Uxg\gcwanZy_`cexe}tWY´Z]\@vh{¥_afa$cer8\±vh_fdtW&¼ t[k\gkUZÅZa$cxe:YurÂxeY[d`_`a){t8Ía$°[Î{|_fdzWc^[^W\]\ga)YWZ]\0d`Z]t&cg\gxY8åE_~à8Z]cedDaDUz[ce\a!xe!¼·Y8d_~Z]t[t&xaxgUcw]d_`Y[t[tWZ]vn\@Y&{|anà8c!_¶dD%È ¨0k ©xeY8ª_~© x
àWah\g^b_fdDvwa$UY:v$\xesZ]\@X0}6xwahY[_`ycgax]dfxeåEYWtWZ]ahZyz[cà8cexgdDacw_f¼t[§¯\@_\@xw«{|_`a$cg\gcexeYW\\dD_`xeUxYW\0a0xeZ]xexgY[cwa_faht[\ vD\@_`ks{|\g)ra$ac0kU]_`Íx-Y[r xeahksZ]t¶¼s_frsao]_`8kt8à8ri dDUUkY[ \½Z]cea\gahah\gv$vUYWahd`Z]ce}6cga$ax
xe_`_`Y[tLt8aUaDvD¿_f_fz8]\g0_`a;àWU\gd~Y8YWU_`a$\·t!ceazWxed`\gYWa´{EaUxexeahYWY[taauxgcg¨0j\e_f©tWªds©-a¶[Üa;vh\dce8t[z[_`tWt8ah\s\@_xeUZ]d\gZÅZstxeY:vh^[d[]aUtX0xgå YWcedfZ]\åE;¸_f\gv$vnvhY[\gvwdahYWz[aDtsa¶xezW\;_f]{¥t8a$dfcD c r
xeZyxeY[\ja·xgYWcw_f_~tW}aj\@{¥a$xec!Y[a·Z]It \e_fks \&aj\gËahvfX;rEXUÂYWÚZ] \aL__`ceah\g\gYWz[df]xDcgrxjxeà8Y[dDa±U]d\±t[vh´dàWd~^[ºanxeÁ8autWxeZ]\gY[Y[ahahZyc\
xgUcwY[_`tWahtÆ\@{¥a$xec)YWa·Z];t ahtkxg]Í·cgJ\gaht[vds [ a!tcevhzWdt[t\jxgcw_L_`\@^bxDr+a$cgåE¯à8Z]fdDz[ìceau\gvn¼sY[§aDb[«z[\gY[Z]t[d~U\_f]xeY[d`a·ceZyxevDYW_`\ga
z
long flow
short flow
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4 sec
0.3
0.4 sec
1 Mbps
(a)
0
0.1
0.2
(b)
H! L=
, '
> $:! L B1, ' !a"(
# E
A#,=. B, > EL B-A#BB@'I#)"#-B#
=B
=#,=. > -.'X( > i)I l' #)"#-B#
=B
=#,=. > -.'X( ;$&:! L B)'1,?'-! ; '%! > .)G
$
)#w#"$( "% %E'$ &' $&:! L B)'1, ' ! ' B,
>
"! #,=i=,=$%#,.X(
^%\
ik k
xe_Y8ce_~ahx-\gz[]Z]xD}6rahaD\9_fxevwY[Ya;\g\gYWYWd`dfcgcgxx9àWàWdDdDU\vhdf½ ^Wd`]a${bxexeahYW\9a;xeY[_D}fa0_fxgZ]cw_f_fWtW]\@aU{¥a$8c0_`Z]t8t!sdfUtWZÅys xesY: fÚ\
\g[ahdva$:\X0t[Y[dfa!x_`Z]ah^bvndfxcgxexwY[_fa0tx]d^btWdZ]tàWxdDxed³xet[YWdfa;xea·]dfZ]tW\xeà8YWdD_`xxe\@Y[xeZ]Z\[Zvhd^ce^[d~]}6a$ahxeah\-ahZytxe\x
xgcw_faht[txÂ\@{|xea$YWcZ]\+Zt \ga$kce}s\´Z]vh\gaahUvÂZ]xeÚ Y[d\gzvnx9Y[aD^[[cez[Z]df]cEZt[t[dD_`U]dfahce[ZyxeY[a df{[xexeY8YW_~a-xà8vDdD_`Ætµ]ahZ]t[f^Wxe]Y[a$\
Z]\U^[t´ceah\g\gzWahtxeuaD¶_~cgZ]tÆr[»yÍÍ$}6¾¯a$ cnduvD_ftZtW[ahah´^[ced~}sZ[aba$xgxeanc\gance}Z]vha$\
xedjåEZ]xeZ]\t8_`zW\gya$cer\tWUd`Z]xexeaµY[dxezYWx;_`xzWtWZ]tº[zW^y·cw_f_`v$xeZ]ahvhvnaµxeZt[xeYWja$xeceY[aJa_`Wce_faÆvwsvDf_`ce\gdahz[\t8Z]!txgUcw_`Y[²!ZvwvY
ZyxuÃuu_f6_ha$\vw\gYWahtWd\gdfa\ga±xedJxed¶}_fZ]df] Åd_~vDxe_`axea·vhdt[\@dfxgcecwa)_fZ]8t_`x&t8§¼U«nZ sxetYL^8xed´_~cg_´xeZv$zW}6_`a$cncDr0_fd6t
^[_f\)ced~xe}sYWZ[Z]\ja$c¶Z]\_~ã@xz[\@xexeYWZyÁ8aLaDanJ°[^ba$tWxe\gYWaLad`^{cexeZYWv$a¶aL\@Wxg_fcez[vwsv$fxez[cedcez[aut8d`{;xexgYWcw_`au²bv&ah\@_`xg\ua$dfdftWcg x
xece_fYWaDtWaµzW[vhxeahZ]YWtWv$a¶ceahxe_fY[\g}aa;a$cnZ]^[t´ceZ]dxevhY[&a;a^b\gxea$a$Y[cec}sceWdfZv$ZyzWx-ahf\h{|YW9d`^WcåWzxed`xeY[cj\0Z]\Zdft[xg{+\@cwxwxe_~_fYW²t[avhvWar_fr9_`vwt8_`t±`cece da$z[vhÃdt8z[vD^·_`à8tÆxedDYWUdfa\U[\gsZyan{Å x
{|xeanYWceaahtWvh}6a¶a$cndvh&dfcg^[ceahce\gd~^b}sdfZ[t8a$cDZ t[tyxez[^cecetÂZv$rÂZt[xeY[La¶xeYWau}6a$8cn_`t8d6s&UZÅ^scexed`YÆ}sZzW[\ganahc)ÆvD_fst
\g_fa$\gce}sZyZ]xevh\9avhz[\@xeda$ce\:xed^W_D _YWZ]fYWa$c9^ceZ]vhaZ]tja$°vnYW_ftWfa{¥dfc-ba$xgxea$c
(
1 Mbps
0U¨ YW©X0ªZ]vwYWY®©:Z]\¸\hZÀ\\g_ah_vn^[xevhz[Zdfdcet ±aWå9Z]Çaht8\g_~¨v$xeceZZ]8dfbt¸_`ah\g\aDdf{±xN0å9\gddäÇ]z[¨ xeZ]Zyd_fttWa$ce¸ah_fttWÚxË0_&±_DY0[\¸Ëahced`vDZ{Æ_`]W\gdfz[xe]Z]Y8z[Å_~xexLZ]Z]dtWt_
¨0©ª© ë+_fWs\@Z]xgtWcwvh_`aµv$xeZ]Wdz[t2ce\@_fxeZ]Z]t[ah\\g\Lxeddf{±bv$dcez[dft8\g\@xgxecwY[_~a²vÆWz[Z]t8\L[z[]a\gz8]_fd]\gy\u®cwzW_`t[xea^[cexea$d
Z
]df[dcwZ]\gv$\)xwa$_`ccwW_`df]xea{9aurÂ\gd0a$vh[aud\gtWa$ce[a$}6Á8\waD«nt[ a d~ZL}6a$_`cj\±\g_´d\@xwa_`xeZ]_`\@cexefZ]vDa$_fc±^bba$dcezWZ]dstWJµdfdf{;tJxeZ]xeYWaaL_D§df}6tJancw_fxeYWaa
xeZ]\dJÚcev$ahd^b^[tWahz[\@_`cexgxeahceaDyz[v$]xDÚ Ëce a$txgcw__f8t[_`ce\g\gahaD]Zu_fZ]xg[\gxe]dahaLL]z[xgxezWcwZ]t_fdxetWtLZ]\g:{¥dfxeYWcZ]\gaj\gWZ]z[\gdahZttW[§Zt[a$Z cuc ce¨0ahvh©k6ahª«nZ]r}6©:a$_\\Z^8_f\U_ftaDvw_`6_f\@a$vn x
stWtWdft[dDUÛh]a$aDce[dufxw_`ahcetfx±a$xj{Åce]ddÓ\g\cwxe_`YWxeauafr ceahZsvhrÂahZyZ]x}6anZ]cD\ ah tWtdfzWvhdfYtxgxecwd¶_f\@cexDanr9xgxecwd&_ftW_f\gvwYWZyZ]x)ah}_`at_
xexe]dYWd!\@a!x±b_~df^8}zW_`a$t8vncw6d _fanfZx·a _~x·df\g\jdfcw_~\@xxead~}6c a$cxe]YWda·ZZ¶txexea$Z]ce}f_fah-\hr+d~}6Ua$Y[ca$Ucea Y[ëJZ]vnYJceah^[cea!a$\g;ah_`ttsxe\x
4. Implementing CLVLs
*)
,+
0/
.-
U\gZY[ a$a$tc±cea&_`_ftt®_å9UlnÇm@Z]¤f¨tW¡e[£8dDmg_` l\gaDeZpD\¶ _`_l^W\g^[zWzWcetWvwdZyYÆxu_fvw_`d`Y:\j{rËaht[aahvhaDds[s[Z]4}sZ]tWZd[[]adf^fxeZ]ahdvht:dsarÂ[Z]Z]vwtst[Y8xe[d)_~cwU_fÊJv$Z]t8xeaLa$ced~vhZ]ÛhUdfaht[\h r
a$tsxgcg§ z t[ds«n[rbaUYWz[ancecea Z]tW¶Z]xe\YWxea·YWUajZ]tst8zW±dDbr9a$c_ftWdf{^8§ _fz vw6a$xe\«_`cecga$ce^[Z]}sceahZt[\gaht_~xe\xxexeY[Y[aa
{|xets_fanz[v$ce·xed`bZcDt[a$r Z]ctW`mdf{c _LceaD§ z zWZ]tWtWe WZ]±_ftzW« x
z9^8_`UceaDvnX0a$zWYWxetWa\W_få9_fWÇt[v$¨âaD&Â^{_`ce¹v$dxea$WdfÁ8e]cDaht[r a0`sxerEceYWaD\ga;z[cezWvnaDYµvha$zWxe\¶Y8t8xe_`[dx)_ft[xeY[v$a$ a
xw_~ceX0Y[a$xZ]\;]d^[\gce\Ud[cw]_`ahxeäalZjZ]\UZ]\vnYW_`_fvn]Y[ahZ]ahtW}6faDZt[! bahvD_`zW\ga^W_fvw6a$x;]df\g\gah\_~ceazWt
^Z]t&ceaD][dZ]\gv$\xw_`cw_~Wxe]aa·rW_`_ft8tWuvhxedfY[cgacea$_fÅ]_~xed`aDce&Zyxe^8YW_fvw6·a$xz[\@]dx0\gYW\gah_f\ht8+]aZ]t[vhcwaj_`\@xexeY[Za±v}fvnYW_f]_fz[tWa±fahd`\{
ceZa$a±vhuahuZ]_h}6µ_ha$¶cUb_`tWa´bd`dfxdtWzbaux;ajWdf_`c±zWcex4]\@ax4dxedu]d`d_`cw\g[\ga$a$df\;cecw\·Zt´dfxe{_d!uU0Z_f_ftWZyfx[tWdD{¥Zyxedfz8c{|Úa¶ahaD]\g\gdu8r_`_`xevn]Y[uanac·{¥xeceZ]xedfY8 _`atxe^bY[ë+a$a r
ce{¥ahZ]dsaD8df_f{+vw_±W{ÅcezdceR\@xxeuYWa;_h±ceahbvhaa$Zv$}da$cDs^8s_~d[cwr6_fcw[_~xea;YWxea$dcxexeYWY8a;_`t·xeZ]xgcga;Z{|t[d`c0xeddxw^[_fceZ]aDtWZ]Z]t[v$ x
xev$Y[dtWaU\gdanvhcevh}z[_~cgxeceZ}a$tWavh_fa^[_f^[tWce·d6_`uvnYÂ_fÀ:ftWÊJZyxea·z8vhdfa;df{^WzxeYWxea!a;t[_a$\@°sxwx_~WxeZz[\@cexe\@Z]vDxD_`r`0baUdf{|zWdft8]dD&dt_
xedfY[t!a^8{Å_`cw\@_fx-v$xeYWZ]Z]d\@t´xedfdfcg{+±^8_`_ft8vw±6a$\gxean\x]xedY[\@axUceZ]aDt_zWt8U[Z]t8_ft[v$d~2{_`v$zWxeaUdfc-xed±xed[xez[Y[ceZ\@\9xe\0bWdfzW_f\gtWaDÂ
xevhÚZ]_fdf]Wtvhz[zWdfce_~\@{;x-xe^WaZ]tW_fxevw[YW6zWZ]a$\v$xeahb\)\-d]zWzWdt[tW\@x±ce!a$dvh\gz[d~zW}6xevwtsa$Y!cwz[xe_f·Y8[b_~]a;xa$cxedfY[xe\gaY[\gaha!t[\a$ceZx0aDt![]df_z[\gt8U\gah[Z]\0t8_ftW[vD_`vndDzW\g{aDZy_f{bvnxexeYWdf·acDE{Å\gcwz[ÊJ_fvnv$Y a
[z[Îce\@xed`\UceaZ]\U^cea$ah\gvh\Z]\gxeahYWy_fr65t ]a$Zsx +§yë«9[aht[dfxea;xeYWaÃ-¹å&df{xeYWa;]d\g\cw_`xea-ë+r
UUY[Z]tWa$[cedDaaD_f;vwX0Y)Y[}ah_`t:z[ra-{|dfdfc´{`ë)_ÆZ\:fZ}aDah_ft\gzxwce_~aDcea$d~x´}6a$]dc+\g_f\utcwah_`t[xevh<a ds[ZZ]rt[0 ^fat[ahvhahdsaDZt[xed
v$d^WzxeaxeYWa\gu_f] ah\@ox `·\gzWvwY´xeYW_`xDÀ
ë +§yë« Dë Z
§@ÍD«
+an°[§yëbZy¨x¶«ndf tW dst^Wz^aLxecwZ_f{|t[d`v$AcLxeZ]vh`L_Æarce[aDzW¿at8zWZyahce]\@ahaLxe\)Z]uvhxedYW_~xea¶a ^[sz[+tWxe§ydDëahU\!«-]_fxeaDY[\[af{|da´]]dd`dD\gU{\u\hxecwY[8_`aX0xeauY[aëZ]\@xg{|ced`}Z[ca$z[cnaDxe_`Z]ddvnYt
Ua$tsZ]xgtWcg[±dDtWds_`a;t8ÆzW\g\gahah\9tWxe[Y[\·ah\gZyaUx±\e8_f_`vn^W]xeahd&\9xexedY[auv$dahtWt\@xgxgcgceJz[v$t[xds_[YWaZ]\@xetJd`xecwz[_fceLtÂr6r+_fxet8Y[ a
xet[Y[dsah[tazWvhd\ga$\^[xez[YWxeZ]\ah\ YW`0Z]\@{|xed`dcE`xecwYW_fìatWxeand°xÂah\@UxeZ]Z]ut8_`d~xeJa +8§y_`ë\g«naDjåEdfZ]tt8_`xe]YWa-rahxe\@YWxeZ]aUuah_`txexgaDcg
+§yëbxU«n xez[cetW\Udfz[xxeY8_`xdfz[c_f]d`ceZ]xeY[ ceah¿sz[Zyceah\¼ %Z]df\g\\e_f^[]ah\
xev$dd _`^Wvhvhzzxecwa_`xexeYWahyaY[a$Z\@\@xexedfZufcw_~_`xe<a `µdftW{|yd`cLz[_Æ\gZ]tWf!Z]}6xeahYWt¸a}f_f_`]\@zWxa¼ %d`Z!{ \eZ_`;^WZ]tW]ahvh\haLrWaa
ce\gahY[¿sdfz[cgxUZycexeajZ]xeY[aaj^b\@a$xwce_~Z]xedsZ][dt8\j_~§cgdf{+xe^[YWceadf^bd`a$cwcg[x4a$´cxedfdu{EYWdZtsLzdfxeahtW\wy«n d~}6a$cceah_`xeZ]}6ahy
¶ZfYJ\gdd~]z[}6xea$Z]CLVL
dY[t´aD_Z]\0&ceUahYW_`construction
xeahZ]t}6ahxeyYW¶a!aD_f]df\@\gu\)xecwd±_~xeZaëJ^[]a$Z]\
4.2ÊYWZ] FEC+ARQ
[z[a$cets\@xDxN´rZya§xjafxevD YW_`]atJr6Uå9Z]tWYWÇvhah¨zt cjW+_´_f§yë\gY[aDbased
e
c
Yxe[Y[aDa_^[rceah}saZ]ddfz[z[\Uxe]å9Z tWÇa¨¸_Y\gd][z«+cexeZZ]Z·\dft:Y[å9 aDÇ_D_¨}ss^f¯Úxw_fËZ]2aDW_`«n^W6^X+cedd6_fceaDvw[Y·z[xevhYWa0_`xexYWa$Z]°s\-xed~ah}6t8a$cg\
tsZ]tz[xe¹·d&zWbUaa$Zc:xetWddf[{[dDceUaha$xg\u_Dcw´_f_ft[tWvh\gdftW_f\@Z\gxgW\gcwZ]_fdfZ]tWt_xe\9\UcexeaDd{|[df_~z[cx9t8]dW\g_`d\UtW\@v$cexEahµdvhtWd~{_`}6afv$a$`xecgÊJdfcura0d`{waZ]}`ceZa$\@axg{¥cedf^8Zcu_`vnxvnaD_`xea$Y[vnxeY a\
Ut[dZ]tWt[cedDa$vhd~Z]}6ta$xecwYW_f[a-]ÁWacer6\@xexÂYWcea;da$z[tst8xgÂcg± tWtdsxeYWa;a-ce\ga$ahxgv$cwd_ft8t[\gcedfZ]zWxe\-t8xeYWrha;Zy{W]_;df\@Ux0Z]tW^8[_`vndDÆa$xeZ]\\
UZyÊJxeYa_jt[ceahaDaD[z[xet8d±Wah_`\@tWxev$Z]u{|_~_fxev$axed`xeYWcCa` f^8 _~cw_fa$xea$ce\h)r ` _ft8i ` Ú\0Z]t¶xeY[a
^Z]t&ceah_}sZ]dZ]zW}6\¶a$tLvD_`U\gZatWr;[]dDa$x +X0§yëY[«!ajan°[ds^b[a$ahv$xeaDxeYWaL^W_f{¥cwvw_`6v$a$xexZ]ddft®\g\df{jcw_~^Wxea·_fvw_~6{¥a$xexea$\ucx4]d\@d x
cedfzWtW[\UZ]\ah¿szW_fxed ·§ ` « ·§ ` D«UYWa$ceaÀ
4.1 FEC-based CLVL construction
30
25
Overhead(%)
Overhead: FEC vs FEC+ARQ
35
20
Pure FEC
FEC+ARQ
Pure ARQ
15
10
5
−2
10
ê ¸ê4ë¼ ®êNë
−1
0
10
10
`
: )%ic )#.$ %l 3"! aJl
# (
HK', k $ 7
% $&# $ (%
#,=. ' 7B,$&D B-,=D 1
'
m
'
#
&
B
'
!]-B1# =#$&D:
=,=. #*)I$(
>
Target loss−rate(q) in %
Í ®êNë
·§ `«7c ë +§yë« Dë
§¼«
X0anYWxX0Z]\-]YWda±\gZ\Ua$a$Å°cw_`^b\xeaha xev$Y[xeZsaDa0r8&{|dfd~a$]xe}6dDa$a$UceceY[Z]tWaDZ]jtW_adr ^xe·Y[xeZar:ceZ]Z]\aDÛD_~\gzWxeZ]Z]t8d[t^W_fy^[At[cev$`dfuW{]ah_fLvn·xedfÀ § ce` \CZ]}6«$` §@ahÍt_`_t85xw` _~` cg«n
xe` Y8h«n_~rx\gz[Z]t[ã4ahZv$xZ]Ûhxea0d)xexeY[Y[aUa;a$xw°_`^bceahanv$x0xeaD]·d\gd~\0}6v$andcetWYW\@aDxg_fcwÂ_`rZ]tsxDÀ c ·`§ ` « ··§ ` § ` « nu« §@Í Zs
^[` cw_`åWcv$d`xecgZ]xevhkzWat8r±X0_~xexeYWYWahZ]ya\r\gdfd^[{|d`]xez[cZ]xeuZ]udf_ftu_ftZ]\g¬d]^Wz]df]xeZ \gZahdf\\!tFxe[Y8{|Z]\@d`_~xgcxuceZ]Z]WxexuY[z[Z]xeZ]\\Z]dfb^[tWa$ce\Jdxgxe[xeanYW]cuah_` xÆtWdfdx·Z]\v$vhxez[dÆUcY[zWahZ]\gtt a
xgå9cwÇ_fåEt[¨ Z]\gzZ]tceZyxga xexeaDYW´½ a^WÁ[vh_fcedvw\@6x!a$^Wcexed\h_`z[ceaht8\ Ârxe_`YWt8a d~z[}6\ga$aceYWå9ahÇ_¨ dfvntWYWy_`cw_`xev$dJxea$^ceZ]ce\@dfxexeZ]ahvhv$\x{|ced`anc
^[dfå9{¶ceÇd¨xe_fYWvwaYWÚahå9\hËÇÊÆ¨ a&UÚuZyxeËY_f 6a^W_fz[xN]0ceand`d4ceå9Z]dxeÇ[Y[¨\ga$ce}f_`Z]_`\Æt8xe Z]·dt[z[^W\hvnz[YºceåEan\g4Z]uceÚ\@xDË_fr]a$xecÆYWa&Wxe_fY8d~\g_`}6aDta$ ceYWxeahY8_f_^_` x
df_f{±^[^Wxe]YWZ ahaµ\µ^Wå9z[Çcean¨Ó4å9dÇtW¨ y2_`xefddfcexeZyYWxeYWaÆLcea$xgX0cw_`Y[tWZ\g\Z]\ZyxgxebaDah2vh_f^8zW_f\gvwaf6ra$xeå9\hÇr¨ _ftWÚËxeYW a
xetså9dfzWÇxw±_`¨ uba$tÚcz[Ëdf·{Rbcea$a$_fcµxg]cwdf_fd`{´t[ce\gZ]xe^8Y[_`Z]vnxgxea$ahcexeah\h[·^WzW_fv$vwahah6\vha$dfxexet8d!\)xeZ]r\jY[ajU±YW^[zWahz[vwt ceY&a$N\gZ ÚuË_f¬] a$c)_fë ]xeY8d`_fceZ]trxeY[xexeLYWYWaa r
U^8_`YWvnancea$a xU` Z]\Ucec9anxgcw` _ftW\gc ZyksxgxeaDX0¶YWdZ]\·t[]Z]´\!dbt[ahvhvha_f³zWxe\gYWa¶Z]\UZ]tÆZ]\xea$YWtWZ]\·dz[vh_fY\gaxed!ah_f_fvwvwYYWZ]]ahdf}6\@ax
_±xwÊ¸_~ceY[Za$]xa]då9\g\@Ç¯cw¨ _`xea ÚË ë Z]\= dfceaâa$²vhZ]ahtx=xeY8_ft ^[z[cea$Nå9Ç¨r
^UWå9zÇYWcean¨ a$ceNa å9ÚÇË¨ Z]_`\u]uxedfYW_hcea&Zyxe]Y[ceahLaDtW¿`rzWxeY¸ZyxeceY[aµaµZt0xed`d`Z]cecea\@axgxevDZ]d`_f{j\ga&axeY[xeceadahvhahced~tWa$}6v$vhandsd~cg}6[¸a$Z]tWcDxe[;Z^fÊ¸[aJa$ZyvhxeZY¸ds\ [xeZ]RtWYWa r
Uxw_fZ]t8a d~ t´vhdftxgcw_f\@xDErsxeUZ]ZyxeaY¶xexedUY[ceaahvhå9d~Ç}6¨ a$cE{ÅceÚdË¬]df_`\g]\gahdf\hcerfZyUxeY[Y[ a$cea Z]x0u_D
Z]_f\;tWxe YWacedfzW_ftWtW ¯xgceZ]^¶¶xe_~Z]cea¶axebY[ana´x40\gZ]a$Ûhaha$t´\!xedfY[{UaxeYWahtauxgcgU¶Z]t8_ftWd~¶Uxe\±Y[vhadfa$cg°cea$Zyx;\g^btWddst8sa r
Z]åEtWZ]uzxeced¶auce½dfrÂzWxetWYW[a!\·}fÍ·_f]_fzWtWa$µ\j¼d`{:åWdfc)xeY[r a±\gZ]±_ftWzW _`xeZ]dt&_`ceceaha\gz[\g]a$xex\xe\gdJY[dDÍ Uktµk`Z]t \
xeaD]daD_`\gLvn\@YÂ¯^Wcw6_`_fX0xevwaY[6a$a0anxe°[}\U^b_`Z]]ant&zWceaZ_·a$d`tWU{ vhZaDtWu[dD[º!ah^bxeUYWahaY[tWZ][Uvn\EYZ]t8dfZ]t±[tLdDxeìxeY[z[a0ce§|tts0zWd`Z·\ce\@[bxga$anvD^bcE_fahdf\gt8{[aÀcea$ahxgtcwx__ft[dfc tL\gxeZyYWxga r
_D}6a$cw_`a$vD_`\gaÀ cÆë
«n
+
-, /.
,
0. 23
.
1
.
.
.
.
4
57698
.
5:6;8
.
.
'<
=<
>@??
B<
.
<
<=
>A?A?
.
.
C<D
>@??
-<
+<
E<
F<= G<
<
H<
57698
Wx4Y dD^b tah\)¨0xed`YW©f{Z]ª\µ\g©:an\gce\a$}v$vhZ]xevh_fZ]a$dt\jt:br{¥dfac!zWaa$\gt8ah[Z]¯\gxevhd`zWN\ga$\t8xe}6Y[anàWcecndDahUad\hJvh-dfX0xetWdµYWv$cea^ancexexed~aY[}ceZana$°WaaL_`a$[°[Zy^W_f]a$ahce\^Wa$]tsahdfx\{
0avhdftW\gZ[a$c_`ceafÀ^ba$cg¯à8dD8_ftWUZxeYuZya$ceahtxeZ_`xeZ]dtÂr\@xw_`xeZ]\@xeZy
5. Examples of Using CLVLs
Differentiating Flows in a bundle
Providing Guaranteed Bandwidth and Protection
2
1
Flow 1
Flow 2
Flow 3
0.9
1.6
0.8
1.4
0.7
Throughput(Mbps)
Throughput(Mbps)
1.8
1.2
1
0.8
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.6
0.3
0.4
0.2
0.2
0.1
0
250
300
350
TCP Flow
Misbehaving Flow−3 Mbps
Guaranteed Flow−0.5 Mbps
0
250
400
Í Às¼±À6½
vhf_fahb\@xe8Z]d_`tut8svhUdftsZÅsxgcexedfYb_fzW]f_`dfcwce_fZytxexeYWaha$\h\hrs_fÚt8]![xeanYW°[a$^[\g]aZv$anZ]°Wxg¯_`cw_~xe^Wa]ahah\9tWceah¯^xedfceahah\gtWaht·x0vhdfZyt[{¥
{¥_Da$}fce_fahZ]t_fx)[;a)_hW\±_ft8Z]tsUUZYWxeZ]vnY:Yµrb`xerbYW_faahdfttWxgcgjxetWYWdsavhaudf[Z]^b\@xga$cexeZ]Z]WtWz[·xeàWa$\)dDUxeY[\hau¨0©ª©
xgZ]cetZ]W_zxe^ZAllocation
t[d5 ^bbdfcg_`xeZ]dft8d_ft[]¶yÆxeY[{|_fa·Zyc!à8dDuU_`\)tWtWZ]\ancDxe:dÊJ_fya
5.1Úì\gZ]
]vhd_fvDtj_~xeZa´^[Differential
xeY[]^Waha]a±8ah0_fttWxE_D_UU¹d`Z{UZyxe[Y\gZ]a$\@Rate
e
c
àW_`dDUd\t[±Z]txexeYWd!a[ZyZya$cea$ahceahttx;xUvhvh_f_f\gce\g\g}a$\g\a$]Z\h_`t8aåE¶\gZ]a$^[cez[}scecedZ]alvh^ba\·d`cg[xeZ]ahd\gt8a$^8df_`tW_`] cw\@_~xgcwxe[_~Z]Z]tWxe\@ahxgce\0Z]Wxe}YWza$Z]xe\UcnZ]tW\ga$dcg b
}st¶Z]vhxeaY[{¥Z]df\c9\gxeZ]Y·cez[aha;Å_~[xeZ]Zydt:a$rscea$xetsY[xEavh[_fzW\gt8\gah\-]adfW{W_fxgt8cw_`s²UvZ_fxev$YucedfZ]\U\g\_f_] d\gZ]vDtW_`xe]aDa¶¨0Z]t¶©ªxeY[©a
cw _~ajxeZ]_fd\g\gÍjzWÀ[¼a)À[_½!Í z[ku\gZÎt[¶W^[_!\¹]Z ËtWbËr8\g_fvnt8Y[aD[_ z[]Zt[Î¶W[^[Z]\\gvh\gZ]a$^W]]{Z tW\ga¶Z]»yÍ~Z]¼~_`¾¯c8ß_fa$vwcea r
`^cecedahz[\gaht8t[vha)xgcwdf_`{²_!v}_~X0cgY[ZZt[\!!cw_~Wxez[Z]t8dJZ]\a\@Wxg_fcetWZ]v$xeUyZ^[xeceYLah\gêa$ce§¯}_`aD\a$\@a$xe}6Zuaht_~xeZ]aDtLxeY[ a
^[t[N ]dsa¶[xeahZ]Z]\h]zWr~ah\@\xga0cwxe_~vDYWxe_fa±aht±\±cwaD_`xe_fxeY[\gauauZ]ydfj[{Zya$_°sa$xece\gahahZ]t8t[txeZ]xea_`YWxeaZ]XUd\e¨0t_fÃ2_`v$aà8ceddD\gds\·«n[:_LahÊs^8_`_`YWv$Z]Z]cecj daud`\g\9{xeY[xeYWZ]\j}aa$anahcn°Wt_`xe!Zydcea
^W_`xeYLZ]t¶xeYWad~}6a$ce_h´tWa$xN0dfceb
_`cwah_~[xeZa!_·Assurances
_`t8ah]Z}]a$dcg\g\) _f\g\gzcw_ft[vhah\
5.2}a$cnStatistical
xeYW_`{xxeuY[_haLudtWbLa$axvDzW_`_`tcg\gcea$Z]{¥^}zWce_`d~{|}Rate
d`cwZc_~xea±\@axg\@cexw_`ah_~and
_fxuxeZxe\@Y[Z]xetWZ]avD!Loss
xeb;Y[Zyahxe\gt!ahyxe{:YW}aU_~ahcetZ]ahxg\cg·Z]t!tWxedsZ][aardZ]xah\gut:_hÜ x0·YWt[_Ddf}6xa;_fahxeytd±0xg_Dscgced\0tW^ubdsa;_`ts^baL·dfZ]\g^8\u\g_`Z]Wvna$6]\gaan\uxexe\hxed)YW_D_f}6tZ]tWdfv$ZÅbf a r
]a$dfah\g\gÆah\s_`x9_xeYWaZ]\@ahxgtcexgZ[cgz[xetWZ]dsdtÂar: {auxevDYW_fatÆ}_`a$\@z[xeahZu\Exw_~_fxeauah_t)s}f_f ]zWbia vD_`b t·bar+\gz[dsvnsY
xe_`YW\j_`xex Y[azW§ b tW[a$cebyZ]tWL«±Z]\Z]\@xg\gceuZ[_fz[]xe2Z]db td`{ b!Z]\¶Z]\±_\@\@xwxw_~_`xeWZ]d]at8_~}fcg_f] zWa{ _fb \]dt[Z] \
t[Wd_fttWNÛ$Ua$ceZd[xerYxeYWceaah¿sa$tsz[xgZycecgahut[ahdst[xea\vh\g_fzWtLvwY_f[xeYW_`Zyx;xuà8xeYWdDUa\;t[Ua$x¶ZyxeY8_f^tWcea$U\gZ^bahxevhYZyÁ8ceaDa$
xe¿_`Y[Wz[ah\@Z]ce\gxga$acw_`à8v$ahxedDtZ]Udxut\·Z\¶vDZ]\j_`]t!ah]ah\g^[\g\u\±ced~xexe}sY8YWZ_f_f[Ft ta0xeb b!YWa$U\gZya0xe;Yà8dDZ]YWUtWZ]vh\aLYUxeZy^xeY[ceY!adbWtW_fd`a$Wxex¶Y!Z] _~Zy\@x4cgxwce_`r:Z]xe}xeZ]_`\@YWxea¶Z]vDcw_`_`¨08xe©a&]ªdd`\g© \{
_`t8&8_`t8UZsxeYfz8_~cw_ftxeahah\hÊÆajcea${|ancxed¶xeY[ah\ga±àWd~U\_f\LoUpfq
n;p`á¡e{[vhdzce\garD0atWahaDj_ftj_f[Z]\g\gZ]dtjvhdtxgceddszW]a_`xExeY[a
xexea$Y[Y[tsa!auxgcgu^ba$d6d~ce´}6Z]dsanà8ceÅdD_hU{¥udf\hc±t[dsUÚ[YWa\gZ]dvnxeY rbd·xeb_fYW]ahd\ga)vD_`à8Z]xe\±dDaU\@xexw\Y[_faWvD_f]Wa´t&_ft8_fbtWsajJU_ZÁW°xeYdaDZ]xgb xeah§|xNL[^[d_`tWZ]vDy_fd]ytWd`Æ}fa$d`\@cx{
xeY[ad`cw[a$cdf{:Z]tzxeah\w«nr_`t8·àWd~U\u_D±ceahtWa$dfxeZ_~xea_Z]\g\gZdft:
255
260
265
Simulated Time(sec)
5802)
,'1#B:%#" #B-B$#"', '
) $[B1#'
(
> '=-, #
= ,=.Ba-,F'<
#
270
275
280
285
290
295
300
Simulated Time(sec)
Jw
"-.=, #-'-$#B #,=. > -.'A#"
#,:)"
0 > #,=.mL=
$', ;#)"#-B#'
B G
=#,=. > -.'
,(
gxWX0cez[YWZ]Wt8ajzcexeahafaDu´_f_`Z]t[Zdt[t[u\@^8x;_`cgxexYWadf{dfxexeYWYWana±cj_~¤f}fk`_f¤fZ]¢_f]¤6[èh]a·l$ÐN8èe_`¤ft8bs `UáZÅ¢s f¥xeÏ±Y&à8vDdD_fUt&\UbZa!t¶xeZ]YW\@a
x4dsÊÆah[ahaa$tj8Z]x4zW0]z[\gdZ]\@tWxgd~jcw}6_`_a$xecea;\g_hZ]xe±YWa0^Wt[]¨0dsaU[©\gahªZ]\E·©-cezWz[Ü \-tW_~vDt[xe_`ZZdf^8t[t:_`W[_Z]¨ Z]¨0dfxN±tW©\gªxeZd[©¶a$^[Wc0cez[d~_jt8}s}sZ[[Zy]cgaaxez8{|xedfY[_`cWZ\9_U]Z \gtWxwan_`!cece}bZ]vhananax
]X0dYW\g\-acw}s_`Zyxecga0xez8d`_`{ :Zl]Zc tWk xgÍ cw¬_D}6a$dcet±\ga$xe\df^·_±d`b{df_fxgtxe]ahN´tWNa$XUvn¶¨0]ÃµZt[^WuZ]^bdfa{;U'Í k!ZyxeÎiY N9W^W\c¬_`'Í t8ks
xe\gYWa$ceaj}sv$Z]tWcedf\g\e\@_`xgcw_~^W²]ahv·\v$dfd{ bfr8^[xeceY[Z]\gaah\ahtÈ&xgkucg]dt[tWds`[ajZ]}6[ahanxea$XUce¨0ÃZ]tWahàW\ d~Ub \hÂÕcdk È
xeWÎYWz[Wat8^[[\zWa¶\gtWZ]tWvh[dfv$]atWa \gZ]Z]\@xe§ ^Wb\]ahdf{k ahxetY[ÈxeceÎ\0aha¶[xeYW^Wà8a\ndD«¹UZ]\0\hËÀt[Ë2ah§@Í~\g«·]vnZ Y[_µZ]aD[[z[afd]WZÆt[X0uY[à8adD[äZ]ah\gtvhcexgZ]aD^Wcg·¿]Z z[tWtWZ]afcedsbZ][t[X0aJYWdf_a {
8_ftW_`t8´s_¶U§¯ZÅ½6s«xeYXUf¨0z8Ã_`cwà8_`dDtxeah[a)åEdf]d~7{ Uks\ È¼jÎ_f[tW^W´\h½±r:§_`¼ce«;a_!_D}f½_fZ]Î_f[W^W]a$\W¨0_fÕt8Ë2sUà8ZdDxeY r
à8dDåEUZ]\h zceaÈ^[]dfxe\LxeYWaJ_D}6a$cw_ffaÆ8_`t8sUZÅsxeYº_`vnY[Z]ah}6aD®xeYWa
xe_fY[tcexea$aha·ahà8dD8U_`\)t8s_fU\jZÅ_usxe{|YzWt[Uv$xeZyxeZ]Y¸dtµ_Jdf{]dfxe\gZ]\@cwa_~:xea&åE]dfdD{)âdÍ·t[yceF ahvhksa$ Zk6}¼ ahu\UZyxe\jX0YWfZ]z8\u_~cgZ]\
x4df{d&¼ \df\cw[uanbce\!X0YWdf{a)uXU¨0_ffÃtWZyà8xez8dD2a¶Z\]dD^[0ceand`c!xeahxev$Y8xe_`aDtÆ´_fxeYW_fa¶Z]tWtW\@a$xxN0xeYWdfa)ceJ_`dff\gce\·a$\gcw\g_`Z}xeaa
xe½Y8dfÎ_`cetaf[r_·^Wxe\±Y[ceaha¨0fÕXUzWË¨0_`cÃ§XUbà8d`¨0dDxe®ÃYµZ]\gà8t´Z]dDtWUxevhYWa)\jaZyY8xW_Dz[a$}6°t8a!^b[xea$]aY[ceZ]a!ceahahtW\evhvh_faha$Z]\}6a!ah_!\;]dDah0Z]d`anceYcaxn«nahW9tW_fåWt8¯zsxecgUdfxeZYWaha$tWxecgY
à8]ÌddDdf\g\-tWajcw¼0_`dfxwxe{-a_`66xeahåEYW\:Z]Z]\t8__fce]aD}y¿_`zWrtsUZyxwce_`ahY[\ahat±_`dftxe{sY[xeaUYWZ]XU\+d¨0_ft8Ãµuà8z[_`dDvn\gY[ah\:Zt[a$xe°a$Y[cg^ba-La$a$ceZ]°Z]tahvht[ahxevh\gYW\+aha \W__fÃtWxeZ]ceUdz[ahZdxeanxezYÂcexD\ r
dtÆahtxexeY[aDau}sa$Z]°cgxevhzW]zW_f\gZ]}6Z]aht[y³E_`_fx;]xeY[xeaY[a!d`}cea$aDce¿zW_D¶ZyceaDt[µds[{¥zWah\htW vnxeZdft8_`ZyxNÆ Z]\·Z]^W]a$
[\xwt[_`a$Zt[aD·aht8s< xev4d`\@xeahZyxet8Control
vw·YWZ]v$tWdtWfxedah\@xeanZ]xedYWtua$Uc vhx)dfts_xgce\gandf
5.3ÚtjahExplicit-rate
¿_f]zWfahdft[cevhZyxea;YWtWdf{+¯\)¨0xedfU©ªahZyxetW©:YWj\dz^Wahx_`t8xe_`Y·WÃ2]dfahCongestion
\g¨0Z[©a$ªc©xe+YWa;Z]vhtW_fv$\ga±aUxeUYWYWajahahttxg_` cg]8ahcet[t8dfdssz[[¯xexea·a$dfc±saht[\gt8zWd~)^[U^bà8\CdfdDb!cgUxD\-_`+xxgåWcw_fdf_~tc±}a$\gceZ]^b\gaUd^WZ]a$t]°[Z xvh_fZyZ]v$x4t&xeyr:±xevhZddtWtafa r
à8Zyx;dD\evDU_~_`xe\t´Z\@ZÁWtahahxe\·vhY[Z[xeajY[a[a´YWzWdDvhtWdf[tW]xe\@axgd±rbcwah_`_ft[Z]t\gdxez[vD\·ce_`Z]xexetWCaYW!_`bxxeYW_`b _`xdaDtW_ffvw\@<Y xxeb§|Y[xeYWa_`a´vh]zd_`cgcgvDcece_~ahZ]xe}taD_`xe]!xecwdu_`_fxev$àWa´xeZ]dD}6df a {
à8xed!dD aD_`vn«Y´_fà8t8dD _f\;b{|ahahc [8b`_`Âvn´X0YW_fahtWtÂ_fr]dsfdz[^[\ced~xe}sd Z[Z]¨0tWÃ2xe»YWZ]¾¯\r8vhZtd{|dfd`^bcea$ucw_`_`xexeZ]Z]tWdt
ahtWYWdf\@xe\9vD_ft±\gaht8±_`x9cw_`xea_b r6_Ucw_`xea0xeY8_~x9UZ]tWd`x-vD_fz[\ga;dfcea
0
0
(
&
xexeYWY[Z]_f\±txe_´dL\gà8udDU_f]\jxetsY8zW_`±xjbxga$cwc_D}6d`a${Uce\gdauW\g·ancez[}yxe_`ZW^[]]aa]¨0d\g©f\gªah\h©Ü \±st[µavD\ga$_fxgtJxeZ]a$tW°sxeahxet8Y[ a
ce\ga$anxet8z[[ceantWcDahÜ \àW_fd~]df tW!xgcwxe_`YWtWa\gceahZ]}6\g\ga$Z]ced\gta^Wcw_`_`xexea·Y:xed¶xeYWa!Z]tWZ]±zW df{xeY[a b Ü \
6.ÊJa)Discussion
_`t8ah\gZ]\gtÂvhtWÀs_fdDX0_f¬YW[aZ]ZybZ]x4\gahvhtWzWZ]an\g\gÁW\g\zWxe_·ah\-\hdf{| a${Âºd~}6Za$ce^b_hd`cg\hxwr6_fxetYWxaU_f^b\gdD^b0ahvna$xec\dfdf{Â{-vhdfxeY[txga·ced]}aDa$cn]dd\g \
xea$d±vn^bYWd~:_ft[ a$cUah\0xeYWxeZydjcw%Bxe#)YW^Wa _` cg x4ÃuZa$t}6ts{¥a$cwxece_`Zyxe\@_hZ]xgahce\U\·zWdfv$_~xexeceY[zacea$ac;aDb_`xeÎ\@Y8Æ_`d`t´xecedaxgcwZ][_fah[^b^[Zyxe]dfZ]d~cgdJxwt8_`_`vhtsdxey[^WrÃ-xe_`\UY[ceaDa$xed
d`}a$a$ccnahtWdYW_ft[a$vht8aD_f´[]v$ahd\´a$·tsxez[antWce^[Z]vDce_~Z]\gxeahZdf\ut´xedÆ\ganceW}z[Z]vhZ a$\Uxexed·Y[ahvhZyc]Za$dDtsUxe\ht¸8ªZ]ÃÌZ]_`\uceyxed r
^uced~xg}cwZ_aZyxevhZdfdft8_`· z[tWZ]ÃvD\h_`xeZ]dft¶\gance}Z]vha$\0\gzW^ba$ceZ]d`c0xedjxeY[adftWah\dfa$ceaD
X_`W0\@xgY[cw_`av$xea$Z]dt:xe0dU¨0^ce©d`ª}s©ºZ[a9_f]bdDanUxgxe\¶a$cE_f\g^Wa$^[ce}s]ZZ]vhvh_`ahxe\:Z]dZ]tjt[\u}6xeda$cn^[cedd~}sZZ[\Âa´xeYW^baa$¨0cg¯©à8ªdD ©
W^[]_fahtWahUtZxExet[Yja$[Zyvhda$t[cea$tsahxe\@xeZ_~Z]dfxet!Zdft:vhdr~t\@xwxg_~cedfxeZ[\@_`xeZ]]vD_`dfceZycwxe_`Y[xea0_`\E\gU\gz[Z]xecwY[_`dtWzvhx-ar`_f_`tt8±Z]!d
\guz[_`^W6^ba!d`cgZyxjxZ]^btd\gce\gdfZ]z[Wxe]a!a$cexe\hdLÂX0Z]Y[a$^[cea!a$_~ceaha±txxN0xeYWd¶ah^[\ga·ced\g^ba$ancecg}sxeZZv$a$ah\\±dfZ]{0tJ¨0_f©tÆªd~©}6a$xeceY8_h_~ x
t[`cea$ahx46_~dfxeceZ]bdt:ÀbxeYWaj_`WZ] Z]xNxeduvhdtxgced:xeYWajdf\g\cw_`xeafrÂ_ft8Lxgcw_~²v·_`f
cw_~]axeaÜ \·r:xe^b,Y[dfKce%xedfahzWtB-BxeZY[_f.^W]GUyzÆBxD9_~'x)X0 YWxe¨0YWZ]\!a·©ªZ]an\°[©Â^b\;Zya$_ftWvwa$\gYWcea!ahZ]ahtd`}6x±{Ua_´{Åce_dce^[aDceaDzWdfv$xea$xeYWÁ8Z]andt[c!tµaD!\gZ]Z]tµxw_`xeZ]ceÅYW_~a·anc¶x;W]zWddt\g \
^cea$d~vn}YWZ_ftWa¬Z]\g_ \ÁW°§aaD []Wr¹_ft8ZysU\ga$Zce}bxeÜ Y \UÚ_`\gW\g\@z[xgcecwaD_fuvnxeåWZdfd`t cg;[_~cwz[[xZ]tWU±ZyxevhY[_fd\gz[\wx«xe_fY8t_~ x
]v$dfd\gt\xgcedzW] _`aDcw_`ts]dxe\ga$\ah\h_fU[X0\@xgYWcwan_fcev$aµxeZ]d_~tÂcea x40d_f[}f_ftxw_ffah\¶df{)^[ced~}sZ[Z]tWÆ_
xeàWddDåEUxeY[Zy\·cea\@Z]xDtahrt__xgcg±vh\gZ]dxecetzWdxgz[_`cexexedfZ]andc0]taDZ]stuU_fdfY[]\ga$\¶dcevDa´_f_`Wt[xe\@Z]dLt[xgcw!{|_`d`_)v$cexe WZ]dzWtd`tW{[]_fZ]a}6[Üah\-\·ceZ]ah\g\g\gdZ]dfdzcetaucevhvhà8ahdf\;a$t°_`xgZ]WcedZ]d0ZytWx4Z] \
^vh_fcetah\gahvwtYWxDd df \g{a&xeYWxeadJ_D^[}ce_`dfZ xe_`a$Wv$]x a08v4Z]_`t8^bsUdfcgZÅxws_`xetsY·Ux xµahà8v$cedDaDU_`\´\gah\hr~xeYWacedfah^Wt^[xgcgZt[µtWdsxeY[aa
^W\ga$_fahvwtJ6a$xe&\Udf_¶{9WxeY[zWAatW[v4]]a·ah\gZ]\@\Z]Z]tµ^bdfahcgt[xwa$_`cwts_fUx -x·dfz[tWvnahY&\hb]dDah0v$a$dct8xeYWr8_f\gt&Z]tWxev$YWa)a±xeY[dfa\g\)]dZ\gt \
xeanY[°[a&^[]ZzWv$t8Z]xg¯cwa$_~ceyxeaZt[vhÆdt[tWanahx4\@0xeZ]d`dcetbrv$d0ta&xgcevDd_`t¸_f]fdfdfceceZyxeaLYWceaD\_f[{|d`Z]yc±¸àWdDahU^W\)]dDUZyxet[Y[a$Z t
xeY[aWz[t8[]a vD_`Å_`WZ] Zyx4 Z]\ _ft Z]^bdfcgxw_ftxFvhdt[vha$cet Zt
Y[aD}_a$$cnr8#_`Bd# t8buÀE-B-xe01YWPaL7a]tsdzWdf±b_`a$x!c0xed`Y[{a_`}6a$cndzWdtux·Wdf{z[t8\@xw[_`]xeaha\;r-bxea$YWdDa´å9 Ç¨=d~}6a$cg
ce_`aht8¿sXÂ®z[cwZy_ahce[}6aZyahxexetZ]d·dxezWtW^b_f_fa$];cgy{¥®\gdfdfce_äzxe^bZ]danZtW\gcg\g\±Z]àWdfxedDt2d®^v$Wdcez[td~}xgceZandc;a¶uÁWåW_ftWdftWa$cL_ff}6cwa$a$_`cgts¸ahzWtxD_`_`rceceZy\gfx4vnaJJY[aD[\g[a$zWcez[t8}s]ZZ]t[vh]ahah[\\ r
u[zW_`tWZ]ts[xw]a_`Z]utWZ]_htW¶tW_`dft8xbua{¥_faDtW_f_f\gfZ]WZt[]aÆbX+xeYWd!a&\@anxwx_`_~xeaced{¥z[dft8cL´ahxe_fY[vwZY\U^à8cedDd W]ahZ]täxeY[aa
vh_h_fta$cz[xe\gd·aLah\gt[vDY8_`Å_f_`t[Wvh]aaLxetahxevwa$YWcet[tWZÅan¿xDz[Ü \;ah\·xedY8_~rsx!\gz[0vnanY¶ceaL_`\;^[ahcet8dfs^bNdY[\gdaD\@x_`8x_f\gxeahYW´a _f Ã
Z]X0\g\gY[Z]da$tceavhd_`ceta&xgcedx4d» \f ¾¯vhr8dd`c^bsdftWt8ah_ftxe\¶Z]vdf^8{_fxevwYW6aa$xUå9\@Çxw_~¨ xead~§}6¹a$ÃceY[WaD«_»yÍDÀ0½~¾vh df!
±\gvhzW_f]t[ahZ\vh_`0xeZ]ahd]t20U_fZytWxeY¸xe^[YWceadvh[ahzW\g\gtWZ]t[[[]aÜ \±X0cwYW_~axeavh dt±{_`zWv$t[xDZr-vh_`xeYWxeZ]a¶dt¸^ba$d~ce}6vha$ahcetY[xwaD_f_f a
d`vnce{0aDce_faD\gahzW\h+t8X0[_fYWtZ]\xZ]xg\cw_~b²ahvhv_fzW \glgaj$mgxeleYW¤`¡ha±lnt¡z[_f·\bxeYWa$caj d`cw{0_`xe^8a!_`vnd`{a$xexeY[\a!\gahWtz[x)t8[z[]ajceZ]Z]tWt[
xeY[]aa\e_fz[c±a!vhxez[Z]cgcea·a$tsUx±Z]zWt8txedDz[FtWaDZ]tWJvnceZ]aD_f^[\gaha$\)UahZytxexwYÆ_`xexeZ]YWda·tÆcwvh_~_fxetau^[dfce{;dxevhYWa$a·\g\uW¼&zWk&tk
Îd`a$[tsce^Waxw\±rb_~xeZ]dft[Z]{dtLd`å9cwÇz[[\ga$¨ Zct[xg_`cwcg_`^Wce²Z]Z]}^bv¶_`ahE]ZddftWt{aD^8_&r8_`ÉY[vnZfa$Y[xe\Î8Z]ß_`\t8Û¶sahUÃE]yahZÅNst\gxez[xeYLZ]ZyzWxeaDå9 LÇgxe¨gd´ ÚE_`t&åW z[Z¨cgxe\;Y[^[{¥a$]dfa$cgc
ËahaDs4d]dfdtv$ds[ah\h0z[vnYÚ ¨\u_`ceavhdfa$cevhZ_f]y _~}f_fZ]y
'
(
f_ []at»^[cw¾¯_fvnxeZv$ar80a)a$°^bahvnx±zWyxeZ]^W]aj}6a$cnd6´tWa$xN0d`ce\;xeduvhd`
a$¨0°©Z] ª\@xD©:rb\·_`tL\gYWZ]_`ce^bZ]tWdfLcgxwxe_fY[tax¿\e_fzWa$\@auxeZdfvhdfttWvhda$t[\@xevhaDa$Æcet[]\UZt[xebY[9aX0a$YWahZ]\±v$x¿d`zW{-ah\@·xeZ]zWdytÆxeZ]^Wcean]a
xeu\gY8aD_`_f_~Z]xEt[xe\0a$YWd\g2a \g^b]N´&ahtÂNv$XUrdW¨0a$z[°ÃJxZ\@_`dxjWz_`\@cUt8xg^[cw_fcevnah\gxe]Y8Z Zdf_~cet!Z]a±t8_`_`xecg]Y[dDua±U\gW\Z]±_f_ft8tzWs)U_`tsxeZZ]zWd±xetuY&bcedfa$ahc+{\gz[d`_¶]{xev$\;¨0dZ]©tWtWªf[ah©:Z]\@vD\Exe_`aDxexeda
][Z tW]a)bzW \g t!Z]t[_WÌNZyxeXUZdf¨0t:Ãrdf_fz[[c\@xg\gcwZ±_fv$zWxeZ]df_`txeZ]dfZ]t!\_fceah]\g\gdzWy{xe_`\Z]cZ]tWxe[d!Z]vDxe_`YWxeaaUWxeY8_fvw_~x0`_ced[z[zWt8t[
XU¨0Ãxgcw_~²v
»yÍn¾)¹·ËjW8ÎÚt8dfcgcea$Z]ce\h\gbahËt:rah\gßjZ] WZ]ahÕt_fx_f}cea$Z]\gceYW_DtW¶_ft:Ìrba$Îµx4 dfces_f\h_f \gYWtAda$S0mgrWpD_ftW ¥Ï
References

» ¼D¾±_ff t8WQ uÕÊ¬_f6q+ai0ÊÆr[q ¹·ahS;Z]W\grsÕ\h^Wb_f_fÚfvwahtb\rb_~ÍDÎµce½svnÍbY[Zy¨0xeÍ ah_`\v$ceÈxe]rb\gz[dÕ0cetÂa_`rbt[{¥Ç;df9cWr[[¹¨0Zy_D_`}st8a$Z]ce_ahah[\htr_xer[Z_`xeÊahv$jxD_`[tW%¼ [kksr Í
» ½~¾)\gËj\ga$a$[cece}s}sÕZZv$cwv$_fahah\h\U[rahZt´tÂr8v$xe¹·xDYWa WÍ ¨tsxe_`ÉsancecebtW rbta$_`xxet8a$_~cecet[vna$Y[xU8Z]xe¹a$YWv$cwa$xe_~z[tW{¥xDce6 aa$ÀWcDÚ t´txed~ah}6fa$cwce_~}sxeZ]aDa$ r

» \`¾jß±©zWW t[Õa·ceYWahÍ _f\gt[_f[\[zÂW rbÇ Ç;tWt[xe[a$Ê¬^bcedtWZ]antxUxtWË_Z]å+fYs¨xeZy\gÍ\grWZ]½fdf½t8 vhY[dftsahtWxgcedfa$cDÀbr Ú 8cevwsYWxeZydfxeZahvhvn_xerbz[_`cwt8_f
Zq \g\gz[ahQ;\i _ft8¶^ba$cg{|rd`^Wceu_f_fa$t[\vhÈa At S0rbmgspDxe dvwp@Ý Y[df ]LQ rWsaD[ahtÂr
j

h
a
^
D
x
8

%kk&k
¼
» ÈD¾ ·vhdWt¨{|a$Yscez:aht[r[vhZ]tW u_`^WË^W_f]d[Z vDr8_~xeZWdfstWah\\gY8d_`t¶t:xer[YW_fa tW¶txeßja$cet[a$Y8x;_`z[tW\gZWt[Ç-t8_f_`t W]Z tW
d`q }a$ceQ;_D´i ·z[yxeZvh_f\@xr8_`[ce_`vwtLYWZyxe¹ahZ]vnahxez[dcera¨0 Ú)tE r8S;Úm@zWpD[Wp@%¼ Ý kkf ÍfQ
» ¾jÚ[}f_ft[vhaDuß_~cw;_~cea)Ú cevwYWZyxeahv$xezceah\h j
» D¾jtWÚja$[xN0åWahdfce[su\_`_ftW\UtÂvDrW_`Ú)\gvDW_¨ah \hÀ Z]tsb}6a$ahcg\@xDxerbZ]6_`_~t8xe¶Zt[Êº·xe[YWÊ¸aZ]± ]ZzWtWyxeZyan{¥cDcw8_`v$¹xw_~_fxw _
t8q _`xezQ;ceai df{-Z]txea$cet[a$x;r[ª;_`_`tWtvhxgdfcwzW_`}6²ancDvfr8 ¨0 tA_`t8S0_fmgWpD_ r8Úp@Ý z[f[ÂQ Í É
» É~¾ __f_f\gtWY[t[ddfahbxgxerbZr8_`t8¹± b ±Ü ZyX+ddfdfcwafrÂ[}6a$©ce vD_`d\@xDY[ÀWtWËj\gdfaht:]Zr_f[Îµa Wå
·qzWyxeZ]vD_`\@xeZt[i0·q UZyxerWY[_`_ftLt´¹d~}6Z]aha$ced_hr¨0t[Ú)a$x4rbdfv$cexDbW %¼ kAt kksS0 mgpD
» ¾)¹·vhd t[ah_~\@xwxe_fZ]d[tZ¯r8v$Îµdt[xgßced_ftW{|[d`]ca${¥z[r[xe_fz[tWceLa¨YWZ]WËYLdfWY[_fcetW\hUtZxea$xeceYtW4anjx ah_h
^[ceds[z[r8v$ÃxUZyxgahxets\g}s[Zyz[ceced[tWrWÃa$Újtsxer[\hÚ z[ At [8S0¼&mgk&pDk6 ¼s p@CÝ f Q q Q;i
»y'Í k~¾±åWzWWtW©:WZ]tL_f_`t8a$´tsxw¹±_`]b\;¨_ftWdf\@Lxeah_f]^[d^W]Z Ç9vD_`cgcexedfZ]dct[vh\hjd txgAt cedS0ÂmevhlndsW¢Znt[l [À)¤¥ r[Ìa$

`
d
e
c

r
Ì
·
[
r
W
å
h
a
Â

Í
É
s
½

»yÍÍn¾jXzWb^[b^b8dfÇ;cgxeWZ]ÌtW±[r[b¹·ah\@8xgsa$xeahdf^[cgYWxUahxgt[cw\h_~r ² WvsUxedZyxeZ]vDY_s{rb_`_`Z]ct8´\ga$ßjce}s Z]vha)Y8vh_`ztWce}6 a
¹tAahvS0ÂmgÍpD j p@Ý V;i wQ;i rWËZ]da _`tWahZyced[rbÕcw_fÛhZ]r
»yÍ~¼D¾±zWÎµ\gZ]btWsY[ceaha$aDÁ8v$Y8Z]x;_~ccedf_fzWt8tW ¶ced ª[_`Z]t:cef YWtAah\gS0af8mgpDÇ9 ²vhp@Z]Ý ahtf xUQ {_`Z]c¿zWahz[ahZ]tW
farbÎLÚ)j r8ÚzW:Í È
q
Q;i
8
r
0
¨
f
_
±

[

e
c

Z
[

»yÍD½~¾ o08£[s¤xed¢|Z]vDÒu_sp@:Ýq[q¤flnNmwl$kD¢¯lnw¡el)¡ ¢¥Qpf¥meÏWl l fRWNqblnemw¤]ln¤èh8Ãwl Y[f¹¬Ñ6Ñ8xemgYWpDah¤\gwZ]Ï±\hr Ýhpfm
¨0¨;_`ÎcetWÄa$4¨;Z]a±s Îkk~ahe]Ídft Ät[Z}a$ce\gZyx4r[[ahv±Í Ès
»yÍ\`¾ { _f8Zyscxe\gda$Z]cevD}s_sZ]rWvhßjavhz[ceY8}_`atW_f]r8_`d`t8ceZyxeYWX 8{|d`WcÇ;]ZWtWÌ[\gWY8Ú_~ceYWZ]tWZ]a$[cwr[_~ceceaDvn_fY[yZ]¯vDxe_fZ] a
_ft8¶^[rbce¨0Z]df_fcet[ZyxNtWah\h\grWa$ceå[}scwZ]_fvht[avh a rWEt ÚS;z[m@[pDÂ Í p4wÝ sf Q q Q;i
&&
&&
&
"!#!$"%&(')
+
,.-
&
0
"/
&&
**
#
1
32
4
&
65.,
***
&&&
**7
&&
8
&&
**9
j
&&
1

Download Report