カサZu dシフォ 翰YぉY ZiM カフクve 〆 テ{Z¨fⅥ Z] ノ チZ険 額] |フキツe ] ノムソY

(
) Journal of Agricultural Economics and Development
Vol. 26, No. 1, Spring 2012, p. 41-46
41-46 .% 1391 #$ 1 !" 26 ! "#$ % &%' ( "' – )
*2
* +% ," -1 " %(
1390/3/17 : 1391/1/19 :
42+45 4 4 - 2) *! +, # .( &'! $%! "# ;4( F4G 4 8+ 2E A ;' – ; <= > 6?? @) +2AB C D . 68'% &'!
64 2*! PQ 2) *! +, # -(1385 E M5 65 EA%) % ;' - ; EA% D% ;H' -
UV'W4X A UV'W4 "4# YM4 ;Z R' . ;( AM +5 <*% T<'5 2+5 CR<S
4X A +5 -\' [ AM +5 [ . "AH' 2+5 - 2) *! +,
. ' +, -]0/06 >2 A ]0/39 -2/85 <>8% 2+5 A -+2 ] 8/07
AM -;'-; EA% - - 2) -*! +, :
Q27 :JEL D*4@ 4c *W4! . ;( 'S AM +5 4 Y484 YZ ;H'4 ;' – ; E 6?? Y
R'48 _4= A R4' 4$ A ;( ;( - 8+ . ;( +2AB
&4'! 4 4 424) 4*! +,4 "4# 8 4cQ 4 Y <*% 'h "] H<'5 "cQ
4 4 4cQ 42YZ .4 ;( -(8) Y*2 A H(
-; E4 h4 4 4 4 e) ( "#
4 2) *! +, YM R' .8'S ;'
#j4 D4 4 4h4 o 4# 42+45 4* 8,2 p84] A 4<>8% -,< X c "q&= p8] 2+5
4cQ R4' .4 2+5 'M 'H 2;AZ 44*! +,44 "44] YM44 ,44 -(9) 44'5 A W44
E4 ;4( D4c Y,4 4 A ;b "] 2)
"q&4= 4*! -1377E4 2*! bW e2
$4( 2S e& 28,2 -] 60/5 Y, Y,4 4 '4A 2S e& 8,2 -] 57/9 Y, ;Sq4 A ] 57/6 Y, h 8,2 sS( A ] 64/4
.4 +, ] 126/8 Y, A QA e& 8,2
1
4 - A 2;$ ;A` &'! 2_= > "b . aQ U$ 2;$ Y8 ,
-U42 .4(4 d A - 2;$ c A 42;4$ D4 ;H'4 Y, D D d -D8?
e& -> . %A UV'W Q PQ
U4$ 4# - *! f A YZ *! Cc c
g&4S ] DU$ .(3) -G' A e&
YZ -Y` PQ &'! 2h A hU*&
,G A 2YZ #Z ' -c% 2YZ % b! 424) 4*! +,4 i4@ 4 .h ! <= A
T4<'5 42+45 PQ D h#j A .4(4 4V D4 <] e2 AM +5 <*% &'!
A 4S 4'h F4G "4cQ Y D*@ V D D8
e& A 2) *! +, Q kS
&4'! +45 '4 A 4( 48( m4 GM4 l4 -2 A 1
Y 82 $( ;>M AM
(Email: [email protected]
:EnW ;8W)
1391 #$ 1!" 26 D e& U$ DU ;*2 AM +5
e&4 .4 ; g&4'SS 4 &'! T<'5 2+5
4 -; M Y< 2/8 46 E +5 D \' [ q ; M Y< 12/2 57 E .4 ;4 4S ;A D4 4] 14/4 E4c (
1/7 A 8/2 l44 4( D4 1368 -75 A 1357 -68 2;A
4 4 75 E4 +45 D e& . ; ]
M4 Y4< 26/8 4 85 E4 4 -; M Y< 30/8
4S 4] 1/98 q \' ( ;A D -;
e& %] < q*') ( +2 D .(6) ;
.4 AM4 6Z 42;4? Y4 {4 4 4% -
AM4 +45 4 e&4 -( x)` [Y*2
4'H 42;AZ4 ;4* +5 . c] A 4! ;H'4 4 S Y8 AM +5 &
,4 +45 D4 &4 {4 U4x *W4! .4 4'h
= 6Z 2;? 6Z z* $% ;H' 2}*A'
'* ] . ; e& gS e& Y8
4$% A 4' g&4'S h e& , +5 D &
;4( e&4 -42X A 2 -25<h ~ YFh
v4 Y48 AM +5 ( x)` .(6) e& ;$
A ,4444 44 44*< ,44 ;'44 – ; E44
D4 4V' >'WA G "cQ , A &'! 28+
YZ 6?4? 4 4( > \b &'! 2c
4Vb[ ,4G 424c A 42+5 c M Fx
4* 4c v4` 4x 8b E D .( 8
"q4c 4*G "4] 2>'WA YZ '
.(5) ( Y QS
4@AH yz4 A Tc W5 <<= <) AA .( Tc "] 2;$ V ' .( '
(1)
;4( 4S S A q ;$ V
c D . S +5 )A v 4 U4$ ,4% A 4 @ AW @V
8c .( M
"A A
<S
(2)
42
F4* 4*! 4c YM4 ,4 -(4) cQ R' D8t*2
35/6 F4 4G _ $% 2*! PQ 2)
.( ]
;'4 – ; E4 ;H' cQ -(14) A u
A ;44( 44% D,>44% 44244 &44'! 44# 44 44
1
"4# "]&45 4q' 4 U'W4 2c
42YZ cQ R' .8'S ;H' \' A "
4 A;$ b$ A e& " b YM
A &4'! 42e2 (A v 2U'W 424*! A 4# 44GZ .h "] Q= W
A 4 '4( ]&S VV) Z A -bw # v '(
A 48A . +2 x)`! [ e& $
4# ;'4 – ; EA% ;H' cQ , -(12) yz
R4' - ! FS H 2*! _4 -F4S H *! +, ] 20 YM 2YZ cQ
4 A 4 .4( 424*! * PQ +, ] 1/08
4*! +,4 &4'! "4# 4 4 cQ , -(15)
4*! +,4 #j4 42YZ .8'S v, 2)
E4c E4 v4 ;H'4 4 v4, &'! { A D,8
-4*! +,4 4 YM R' o ! *
+24 -Yh88 A 2S \ e& +2 lb
-4 424) D4 ;488e& 2+5 2' +, o$ A Q=W 65 "# +2
22 S YZ M5 Y ( A
+S +2AB , -(13) .h YZ c A %S
M4 4 |@ A e& 2 "# 4248,2 4 G' D8?D A . 'S ;b*
H4 4H 4 ;*2 6? S 2S & 2S 'M ] 20/8 V -88 ;H'
;( FG "cQ A .88 ;H' ( *! ) {
D4VV= 4 424 YM4 2) *! +, 8
4* 48,2 4 4 4*! +,4 ; "b# T<'5
4* PQ4 +,4 -428,2 +, l% A # 2+5
-Yh488 A 42S \4 4 e&4 +2 -2*!
424) D4 ;488e&4 2+5 +2
+,4 o4$ A 4Q=W4 645 "# +2 -
.( A 2'
1 - Catalonia
43
.../;$ ,< $ = >&'* +!, /05 78 &,:
G4 +, .2*! G +, -2 o2*! ;b
D4 4 84 5 2*! PQ 2) *!
A 4( F4G E 5 [ ‚ 2) *! +, "]
.4 ;4( 'h x o( c 2*! ] 20 E 2
(3) EA4% 4 424) *! +, T<'5 28
64 4*! 4 4% 4) 4c 4V 28 . ;( ;AZ
.42 4 YM4 4<S *! c D # A (CR<S
4*! 4] W4 C D,8 *! ] Ew 4 +, ] 66/96 <S *! -h Dc CR<S 6
.
:i +5 2;AZ <S A
(3)
4 4( '4(> > A f' "] "A Y
l8' "A 8 d 8c -) D; "] D
:U (4)
Y D,>% :( U2S (3) (5)
(6)
$ @V 8+ ;H' cQ *W! D 4f UV'WX A UV'W "# ;( ;AZ (3) EA% &4'! T4<'5 42+5 A 2) *!
. ;( 'S
!! "! 0!7 5./!6 ./ 01
8( 9 42;'4 l EA% 8 l@ y 8 % . Y* +5 YZ ;AZ +5 2 $8
.424* 44 ,? +, D "# ; EA% D
A 4 4 q4[ ;4G XZ4 UV'W4 2 Z E)
42;AZ4 S l% S ;( S 2;AZ v2
v48 4@V +, "# *2 *( > W
.Z ;' A ;
EA4% ;4( Y8 '*! 2+M % ' D8
"b= R' ; b= 2) $ @V -(1)
4> 4$ 4@V ;4( d4 A . ;( ;AZ (3) EA% *W4! ;4( Y48 -(7) 4Q ;H' . # 2+5
4*! "f UV'WX A UV'W "# 2
A A 4'S &4'! T<'5 2+5 A 2)
. ;(
-4 424) 4*! +,4 84 R8 R' C l44 &4'! " -UV'WX A UV'W [
44] -0/163 A-0/149 --0/135 --0/121 --0/108 Y,4444
A +,4 -42+5 ~c -2ƒ( D # .2 +2
. ;( ;2M +2 2+5 ~c :W "] (7)
W4 F4 (13-2) 4c "A l@ M : "]
44 I A y44 442;'44 A 442; 44<= e44 D44 ,44% .44 e44c T44n y44 44
M4*2 YZ YA4 A 4bw ;*2 <] Q! C
.(2) 8'W2 H] H8 424) 4$ 4@V YAZ 4 8 ;H' - 2) i D '*! 2+M -4 424) 4@V 48 'h FG "cQ 4x (1) EA4% "4] 4 4 2) '*! 2+M
.( 'h
+! ! !! "! #$!% &'
(#)*
" ,-*
E4X -FS H) x 2) *! +, 4hA {4 -p4 4h -; H -€Ah -H H -D,8 -8
+, -1 : % ! ; A 1 2*! PQ (cb[
1 - Border Prices
1391 #$ 1!" 26 44
+ #$ % &'( )* -1 !"
89
7; 67
5 67
&4 02
3+
#/02
-0/16
-0/12
-0/12
-0/04
-0/15
-0/12
-0/22
-0/24
-0/24
-0/22
0/54
-
0/48
0/88
0/12
0/68
2/08
0/99
0/13
0/21
-0/29
,+.
"; '*! +M
-0/14
0/54
1/59
"8< '*! +M
"; Z +M
"8< Z +M
.>12 @ A >5 @ ->1@ :Sj
(AB) + #$ 6'( )9= >? 5; -2 !"
5 5;
4 5;
3 5;
2 5;
1 5;
#4 AB100)
#4 AB80)
#4 AB60)
#4 AB40)
#4 AB20)
(6'(
334/81
(6'(
266/85
(6'(
200/89
(6'(
133/93
(6'(
66/96
2318/55
1854/84
1391/13
927/42
463/71
2349/09
2401/91
1428/05
547/91
752/21
1879/27
1921/52
1142/54
438/32
580/17
1409/46
1441/14
856/83
328/74
435/13
939/64
960/76
571/22
219/16
290/08
469/81
480/38
258/62
109/58
145/04
#$
D,8
-H H -FSH
8WX
€Ah
; H
p h
{
cb[ h
mV= 2' :Sj
(! L5) >? 5; B + #$ &K % &)J -3 !"
55;
29163287
2950930
6679308
13293220
12550845
10859944
26111311
45;
29206568
2967820
6724734
13455854
12575691
10886445
26203815
35; 25;
29249850 29293131
2984710 3001601
6770161 6815588
13618489 13781124
12600537 12625383
10912945 10939446
2629319 26388823
mV= 2' :Sj
A ] 0/42 Y' A '2 -h "S -] 1/83 \'
. ;( ;2M +, ] 0/04 V A *)
4*! +,4 # ( s5M (4) EA% % #j4' 42+45 4 +4 42) S - 2)
E4X -4(4 l% 2) *! +, .( 82S
. +, +5 D A ;( 2) D DM% 8
15;
29336413
3018491
6861015
13943758
12650229
10965946
26481327
,+.
D,8
H H
€Ah
; H
p h
{
cb[ h
4*! +,4 -UV'W4X A UV'W "# R' (4) EA% T4<'5 42+5 8 R8 [ 2)
+24 D'M4 -42ƒ4( D4 # . ;( &'!
;2M4 -4] 27/98 \4' D,8 +5 A 4] 4/80 \4' AM 2+5 YZ y . ;(
+24 D'M4 -4] 3/05 \4' 4 ; A ; H +5
4 Y4c A p84] 42+5 A . ;( ;2M 45
.../;$ ,< $ = >&'* +!, /05 78 &,:
(AB) 5; T7 BU( >? )? S5 0 + + #$ 6'( )9= MNO+P NO Q+R -4!"
5 5;
4 5;
3 5;
2 5;
-0/7199
-0/1903
-0/1810
-0/1716
7/4853
7/4901
7/4994
7/4997
-28/1287
-27/0546
-27/9805
-27/9063
-2/6624
-1/9436
-5/0586
-0/9480
-0/2968
-1/4235
-4/7997
1/8192
-0/0491
0/4075
0/0300
-0/1092
-2/1364
-1/6411
-4/0529
-0/7565
-0/2002
-1/1359
-4/7994
1/8227
-0/0482
0/4119
0/0349
-0/1049
-1/6103
-1/3385
-3/0473
-0/5650
-0/1037
-0/8483
-4/7992
1/8262
-0/0472
0/4163
0/0398
-0/1006
-1/0843
-1/0359
-2/0416
-0/3735
-0/0072
-0/5607
-4/7990
1/8297
-0/0463
0/4208
0/0446
-0/0962
1 5;
-0/1623
)?
cb[ h A FS H
7/5045
-27/8322
8 EX
-0/5582
-0/7334
-1/0350
-0/1820
0/08894
-0/2731
-4/7988
1/8331
-0/0454
0/4252
0/0495
-0/0919
H H
€Ah
; A ; H
p h
„ "S A {
cb[ h p
A AM
Yc A p8]
Y*'S A 6Z
Y' A '2 -h "S
V A *)
"S mV= 2' :Sj
D,8
(AB) 5; T7 0* >? )? S5 0 + + #$ 6'( )9= MNO+P NO Q+R -5!"
5 5;
-8/0727
0/3901
0/0567
2/8479
4 5;
-8/0726
0/3903
0/0569
2/8503
3 5;
-8/0724
0/3905
0/0572
2/8527
4 424) 4*! "f -AM 2+5 42+45 D4 .4 4' +24 +5 D " 42;4$ 4 424) U$ <>8% +5 AM
4 4 424) 4*! +, D8 . U YZ AA
2+5 . H8 #j +5 D " 42YZ AA 42;4$ 2) U$ , >2 A
+,4 D48 -4 ƒ X A +5 bW
. H8 # 2+5 D 2) *!
4 4X 4 4 AM +5 < +V % l48 42UW4 X +2 h<%
4Q 4 4 A Ew Y8 .( *) +5 D "
8 f 8 AM +5 "b'
AZ4 …4H) 4 A 428,2 +2 $% e& +2
. U2 +5
2 5;
-8/0722
0/3907
0/0575
2/8551
1 5;
-8/0720
0/3909
0/0577
2/8574
S5 )?
X A >2
<>8%
mV= 2' :Sj
4 s&45 4f _4 2) *! +,
4 4A 2+5 * 2;$ ( _ A ( "4 4(4 _ D 8 . 'M 2YZ AZ
A Y' A '2 -h "S - Yc A p8] 8 2+5
.( ;A, VA*)
4*! +,4 -UV'W4X A UV'W "# R' (5) EA% AM4 +45 4 4 8 R8 [ 2)
4 \' [ -2ƒ( D # . ;( . +2 -] 8/07 X A +5
>24 A ]0/39 -] 2/85 <>8% 2+5
. +, -] 0/06
A 4 +45 -4(4 ;2M4 (5) EA4% 4 % "'bW U$ , A AA 2;$ 8,2 l < X
4 bW4 Q4A 428,2 i*G 2) q
1391 #$ 1!" 26 46
V
A ;H'4 4 Y4 AM4 +5 Ef'( A -F 2) 8*2 #Z A <= .1389 . *) -1
.AM &'! +5 -Y 82 $( ;>M -( 8( Y .;' – ;
.Y$ -` 6`V Z "M' -, A 8+ -+G8 YZ 2 A Y ;' -; <= .1371 .e -m -2
-E [ Y) <S sS A Ef'( - e& †< Q .1386 .; F`q* A .i *( -.F Z ] 8W) -3
.16-31 -24 -*'% A W F< +2AB .(1350-1384 2
.117-148 -34h +2AB .Y 2*! aQ 2) *! +, #Z A .1384 . -4
.Y*2 -U< M -EA u? ;' – ; <= .1384 .i -5
&4'! 48 E4 4h;$ +5 D "8< @V AM +5 A8 b$ #j .1386 .ƒ <$ -6
.45-60-69;*( -15 E -c AA AM &'! .MEDEE-S
.159-194 :17 (i) {] F ;>M M2AB <G . @V 2E VbQ .1388 .ƒ <$ -7
.119-91:8 &'! +2AB .Y 2) e) ( "# .1387 .i *! A .F !] -.i H( -8
-; +4*2 D4 .4 ;'4 - ; EA4% 4 2) *! +, "cb A #Z .1388 .F '5 A .k W -9
.Y$ €b[b[ ` ;>M .;'
M4 .*'W4 > &'! Y` 2sS( UV'W S # .1384 .i V] A .k -.e ! -10
.527-537 -48 ;M
-11 ;*4( -3 E4 &4'! "4cQ & .D,8 e& Y, '*! T<'5 28 # .1385 .F >< A .a A -11
.63-83
12-Berument H. and Talpcy H. 2000. Inflationary Effect of Crude Oil Prices in Turkey Department of
Economics, Bilkent University, Turkey,316: 568-580.
13-Dubo I. 2003. Impact of Energy Subsidies on Energy Consumption and Supply in Zimbabwe: Do the
Urban Poor Really Benefit? Energy Policy, 31: 1635- 1645.
14-Llop M. and Pie L. 2008. Input–output analysis of alternative policies implemented on the energy
activities: An application for Catalonia, 36: 1642-1648.
15- Uri N. D. and Boyd R. 1997. An Evaluation of the Economic Effects of Higher Energy Prices in Mexico.
Energy Policy, 25: 205-215.