綾 チ ノZr¿Zシッ e ネサZ¿|ニ X ハタフ諺Zm ネク : ノチZ¯Yチ カク ネクyY|» チ { Zナ |タヒ

 ! 62 - 43 ,- 1390 (
) *+! $ %&' $ "#
: *
$(/$ 5
***
$ 8 **+ (/$ (&/
!"#
" ! !
+ ()" ." &' $ % #
(0$1 2 #/ -- ,&' !
, 26"
,) 0$&5 ,4/!
3 26"
,) 809 :;/ !" ( < :=
7
/ 2A 7BC D " @= 2)>0?
2F+ # % FGH ( ." #E ! ,&' I " &! 2 @= 2FH
( H FGH ( J ." :&A
< 26"
,) @
,) L 3 ,&K$ + " # & FH
O= ,&K$ N#/5 @ M!9 26"
5Q< # D< % -0$ 8I$ (! P/
( < # 5Q< ' 2C
O! )>
2D> % !' M!9 R0$5 2D) 2 !"
.% !' M!9 [email protected] )9 D- D5 *
[email protected] )9
[email protected] (T!K$
D- D5 **
$!) )9 D- B 20" 2!I ***
1390/9/28 :R^H 1390/7/23 :#/ ... : 44
.@= 26"
,) 2)>0? ,&K$ :!$
%&
,&K$ a .# ,&K$ ! % " &`$ <H d &$& b!P cA . # < :C 7 TP0 ! 2%" P/ #&
! e!0 $ ( .% !" "<!5 7
! !> < fP F!' 2- #I< !
H 0< #1 (
0 #M 4 i" OE;
«h:g» "!
") #< #<! + jk
/ D-0' D- f
#< ! 8) 0 C9
( 6% .(223 - 222 :1387 m i97 :1347
< o $" ' JL " 0$ ) 2o 7 :! 7
2&5 0$ 2 #$!
/ ( .#/ 5+ 7 f
"
( .< 0o& ' 2/ ' / !I- T!q ' p
F!' #$C< O! R^H =&LD / 0 C9
(+ 2>
( ( .C ? <H fP !' C 0 2O #$!
#/!` i38 - 37 :1388 ) ! H / O&r # " #>
D< d " < O= 4L ( # O$" .(167 :1380
.< J0 >0 !)g
" % .!= u0$ D ( ! (H 2#!CE t " #!CE
!= 2 8I$ 2D 3 ! F1# 7 O$" D ( !" !5!5 bP 2>0 d mH DG D< 7E 0E
F+ O10 )> 7 P0 2 " !)g
DC< O&r 0' < O= (+ 8 !)g ."
w!$ C0= EL '! "E .< 0$5 % D! A v=< :1328 x) =' 2A "F"/ 2 'Ar%
2#> (312 - 311 /1 :1377 )z i1037 /2 :1380 2< 2' i50 - 49
" ,&$& m{ .! D! A #E : " 1
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* 45 !/& &-!+& ,
a/ 2 (57 :1362 :<) ! 0<^5 !' 2 <H 2 !'
2D0$5 22$"H # ' <H "! 2F+
<H D< D< &>A0/ | HH 2R!< a ( i
5 #& ." !0 / 2A F+ (0<^5#H !'
5Q< , e!|! Q D<&>A0/ 5 0E e!|! ( .0/0 2)>0? @= w10 >0 5Q< < :=
O
@= 8+ #< ! ( / " 8)= }<
f) 2 D< 2)>0? !0$ O&LD 5Q< 2 ! O& 2 )> RB
#& .< ) @ ,&' 2 }< ! 0/5 $&- # !' M!9 R0$5 2 @ :
' ,!0H
8
<!" P ( .< :=
' 2!" D-?! ,A
@ ,&' 2 2 @= 2/ 2F+
.! D< :=
@ ! 4E 26"
,) " " +,# -
' ()* .1
2> 0= (1 ( .!= (< + @= 8+ % 6% ~
'Ar% L O! .#$ 2 @= 70 (0/5D
(50 - 49 :1328 x) < ! w!$ JL )> "
! ' &>A0/ 0' @= 8' % .! }< @=
#& ( % "6 i< O= @= ! #E ( !
i38 :1328 x i22 :1357 o&$0) " #E D<&>A0/ D< $H - 2 #E (+ TE( .(412 :1380 CA80
"( DG i< fP 2 % RB
a != 0/^H
# D< RB
a ' +5 .!= D<&>A0/ #$1 / @=
/ @= " # % #> (524 /1 :1377 )z) 7=j #<
i) " #!P
5Q< 2 ( ! D<&>A0/ f)+
.(90 :1389 2 CE " ! D0 OP& &A @= O (
2
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* ... : 46
:1348 ($
i367 :1383 &=) #< D) wr > 4L D"
!' 4E ! D<&>A0/ < ? .(199 :1383 !C
i165
(| H JB' + 5#$1 #< " # 095 .#$
< w!$A % 2 D!P 20 (Katuzyan, 2003: 234) != D< T @= "E ( .#$ #1
€
t !' < $H 2' i101 /1 :1377 )z) < w10 2)>0? D<&>A0/ ~ 1213
4E 3 ! D0 &A (213 /2 :1378 i105 /1 :1380 2<
/L (Gaspar Drouville) : z5 ./ 2H F!' 5#$1
:$! D( @= 2
v
@= R
‚+!" | D<H "( &A
i146 :1370 :) #$ !' 4E 3ƒ! 2)> 5 (-' D
.(92 :1362 5
DQ< :$! D0 2- #I< D< (Tancoigne) !C
4E #$ |E Q5» ( T 24 22 5Q< f
< &A
.(199 :1383 !C
) «" c!9
@= R !' #<
! D< $H 0 " 7? @= D0 # ! - ,0 @= /L 0 ‚ i0< DQ< ( F5
(0/5~ < # ( D< (Gardane) 5 .! &A
8r @= D0 " " FH &A 7< =&LD
# $" (
8) &A DQ< :$! i#/
!1 H w10
#A ( ~ @= 8 i" !' „0 8;
( "
# 2: (
!I- (C$ # 0!CE & …Q " ? 8
.(171 - 170 92 :1362 5)
D<&>A0/ "J; 2 D0 : z5 # ( (>
D<&>A0/ ." „0 H w10 < )
@=
: ." (C
b< #!' D0 #$ !' 0$
«H» C #L D<&>A0/ / D0 " $! !' RQ5 ,
:) #95 (1 @= < 2= D<&>A0/ !'
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* 47 !/& &-!+& ,
3>=L # D D< < ~9 T ( a ‚† .(147 :1370
a # < D!C< q " 2< !' (+ #< ~0 !
% 2F1 ' Q : RQ5 + . @C> ; F!' D0 &A 8"# " D!& Q%q= L/
. ~ 0/^H 3B" D<&>A0/ Q
2)>0? a=o @= 2
<!" Q - 2#>! D0
‚† " !0 D< < Q5 D< " 5Q 8 . #
r % . < (0$ 4E @= r 5Q< w! H / #& D< !+ " #L !0 ( &A
(| D0 .«- < " ! D ‚ }P/ F0L 2» :
|E = mH }P/ " " @= ‡ 2 5% fB
D0 < .(315 :1367 2`E i166 :1348 ($
) ! !' 2)>0? R^H
% 8 1
a " ;1< #9" #I< "k
(
(
‡ 5 i199 :1383 !C
i58 :1328 x i140 :1382 (C
) D" k
2/ !
C
2- # (171 - 170 :1362
. !
Q !5 f) $' 0 % ,! " # (Iermolov) J!& ' A0 ‚ O& 2 (6 D0 &A
@ 2‡ T #$C< ('% J!& ." b=
b! 2" 7`Q :;/:E 2 Q
!k ! D" :A
@= D0 @ CQ O! 8 #=$ J!& @= .! 2)>0? 2 #'< 2)>0? @= J!& " 2!5 i<
#=$ D0 ," 5% @ ." RB
D0 &A
!' 2 2 D<&>A0/ d mH " D R
.(235 - 230 :1362 F1=
i541 - 531 /2 :1383 $9 i199 - 200 :1382 (C
) "
" < % # 2 !' 2D "& 2 J!&
> O; ( Or @= # D0 &A 4E #< : mH P9 m&- 20 % F!' #>! 8CA
2 " #$
.(79 - 77 :
G) " /> 2) 25!" ,0$< !' 5
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* ... : 48
.0/ D0 #E !A 2 EL (6 J!&
- #? D<&>A0/ d C L ( 4=L
!0 R0) " T!q !' @= C #$ !5(
&A #E D" 2"k
+ J!& . #1
H < Q< (544 - 541 /2 :1383 $9) " ~J D0
@= #<^5 != F-) d 5 @= O (
2
.< :=
D<A F+ (
2 R 2 " A 15
D0 &A #<^5 .< @= O ! D0 R< 2 e>#A
(
#!' w!<%H # ( ! ' CE 1231 T A
4/! < TQ ' 25 #!' b/ O= + ." D
Q .(80 /1 :1389 &= i32 - 26 /4 :1378 ) % # Q #!CE <
#$ !' 4E ˆ!< 0 D0 &A 2O% 2‚= a 2DH + .#'< 2)>0? @=
:1362 5) 095 (1 F "& 2 ~ !
M
i! @ 6 @= (981 - 980 432 /2 :1380 2< 2' i171
" =0H #9" ( RH 2u" .(544 /2 : i428 /1 :1383 $9)
L " ! o&$eI< &>$E 2 @= - 2F+ 2 " % .0/ 2)>0? O$" , @ f 2‡
% :M ‰A ( ! @= 2" @ 2‡ !H .!< ‰A=
-
' - /0 .2
?&@ ><= >#; $ <=+ "** 1.2
! D< :=
5Q< #$1 #! # " o< 20 56H 7< ,&K$ < r% Q @ 2‡
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* 49 !/& &-!+& ,
!" @= ‡ 2D) 5Q< o< (+ ." o
@= / fP ‡ T % . !' 7BE
D0 &A & O ." PA
20 7$E ‡
(C
) " !' : @= 0) $ !< D 0/ 5 " ! 2! , @= 2# (6 O 5Q< .(141 :1382
2 :C
2 RB
@ &P 2 F
"
-- (0/}&$
> "-/ RB
!5( =>
7
:1367 2`E i171 :1365 `!Q
!" i173 147 :1370 :) " $9
!"
.Q- | 0 2 #91 0< ; " ( (315
f (0'D ˆ ˆ5Q< " # ( +?
.0< FP @= 2)>0? ˆO; ˆOE;
2 @ 2‡
: P # ... D<&>A0/ Š>| ,oP D" D !' D< /L T! Š1 B ‚ 9" # ,=&r !+ " ! (P&
D< D%
= # =^ `>< ‹/E fB E !' Q D< # fB O^
.(11 :1326 +?) !< D @ 9" # B 0$ " !< |
!< 0" ‡ @= " ! ( ‡ "r% % J ~ )> f 7! % # w!&o T" T 7! i#$C< :A0
.() < a&' 2)> O; 0 f)
< D< Oxr 0/5
2 @ 2‡ (0'D T!K$ @= Q 2D +
&= i366 :1377 o&$0 203 :1382 (C
) !' 2)>0? 8CA
,) jk0 $H D5 :&A
(+ " # % #> i(105 /1 :1389
@ 2‡ #95 !
.#$ 0/^H + !< ` 26"
#$!
‡ ( 2H .#/ 8 ! )
8 @= DQ< 2
#$C< ij Š1 2D5 5Q< 7P0 " 8CA0$ 2)>0?
T i " < O= iI F- <TQQ0 3>=L Q ‡ ( ,I0 FH " #H 095 0= ." H !9
$ % @ 2H " - "r% ( .!= 2!< " Q 1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* ... : 50
(+ ( i< R2)>0? 8CA
2 @= #$!
! :0A
.# :&A
(- 2#$C< ! 2 2$ = @= "E
C ‡ ( ." TQQ0 F0>! ‡ f @ p' :' % 2H @ >0 2#$C< H @=
2- 2F1 J;
@ 2H .<H 8 3B #$ OP
Q5 % 1 " (- #r #!' (
-)) " L'DI p' )> D< #'H D<&>A0/
q
)> !' ~ D< " != > o< (+ .(102 :1327
7=j ! 0/ (+ ~0 Q @= "% DG
( (
!$ ." O& !' 2)> #=$ D< ~ F!' 2-0$<
D- TQQ
i! @= ‚+!" o&$eI< &>$E /
2 o&$eI< 2!HC
.! D 2)> Š @=
2 8I$ 2D != < < ! .# D< )> w10 -0$
8~
f5 (Paskiewitch) †!CH !1 C "E @=
% ." #/ )
' CE o&$eI< =' ! v& 7P
D- !" :`$ @Œ ,&K$ )
&>$E
Sir John ) " 2 (Sir John Mac Neill) :" ." )
@=
» :" !5 (+ )
o&$eI< m&- 01 (Macdonald
( 0' 2 O 2H !' f 7P=L , .< )< j ‚
7I 2 !' 2 ' "!" .! R
2' @z 0/5/ R5 D< ' < fE !+ .0$ !"
" C<% !' < !' D< .# D0/ 7I 2 2 " % 2
5" .# 2H 2 =0H 2 ' , $H ( " % /
2 / " D% 095 ! 0/5 R5 Dz / :=
2 ^- "% z$ # |E " #95 C<% Q DQ< .«z$
.(638 /2 :1383 $9) = T!H
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* 51 !/& &-!+& ,
2% R!< w!" !' " #9" " o&$eI<
3B= (490 - 478 449 - 442 /1 :1380 2< 2') ! 0<^5 F '
! D) )
R!xE .! f w!=A 0;1< )
CE
D< 0 " ! + D< Q &>$E D- .! D< "! )<
fI #o& Šg 1 #/ o& #10H 0$
25 O=
.(123 :1383 !C
i 83 :1387 2< i215 :1364 Q/) ' ,09<% e| 1 2 1232 T A mH @ " !" % 8~ #P/! Po % ! #$!
< :$5 %
F' #< ; ! D 2- #9' ,) P> ,0% .C F+ @= 2)>0? D- ,A
)
e| ! D" DC< )
F0>! @ @= #$C<
D< Q F09" T{ )
@= 91 .! )> C<%
o&$O» D< " % #A&; 0$ ,0$< ) ; " o&$eI< 2 «/ TQ> 05 !)P "
:1377 )z) Q5 2)>0? ! D" f #C& % " @
#91 " ' # 2» -) ,0<! .(19 :1326 +? i391 /1
!' «o&$OE» o&$eI< «! D" # o&$O
.(103 - 102 :1327 -)) ( 7?'
!' jk
#A
2 8"# D<&>A0/ " # % "E RQ5
" D< $9 > ,0<! .! 0/5 ! D5 5Q< o&$eI<
2 ! D< (-' $ % }< R^H @ )> <8&$
:1383 $9) 2)>0? o&$eI< (- 7)>
/
0/ D< +? ." k
Q - a 4PA ( 2 .(649 /2
(+ D< @= 2 2!0A :&A
)> | D< 2$
:1326 +?) # «0< [] )> ( ;» r% D< " 0/5 I0
!5( o&$eI< ! @= / -) # .(20 - 19
20) ,) !0 < !< D o&$eI< « H» 5 " " P D<
2)>0? O; E 2 &>$E #E % .#' P> @
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* ... : 52
i102 :1327 -)) 0$ O 0) @= #o& fP T!=
D< #! F5 @= #$ #>! .(28 - 27 :1369 B?<
!' , :" .!< D)/ " :" , o&$eI< ˆ2)>
#'H @= 5 #95 !' !' Q D< FH +» :# 0<!
!' H - 2DQ< F$H " 20!' !' % '% "
CE H )> „! z < f? " q&= : T" " "
:#<! !' RQ5 , :" .«! IM%
@= 2 2 - " 095 C<% ' 5Q< (
+ 8" ! 80/ ( .# &>$E # D< 0' " # D
.(640 - 639 /2 :1383 $9) # # 0C ( 01 " 80$
C$' T " ! 0/5 7! 2E )
o&$eI< 2)>0? ,&K$
" :E (P v& 7"^ fI 2 )
†!CH 0/ (Dall Xeski)
( .# D< w10 fP ( o&$eI< TQ 2)>0? @= "
:1377 )z) eBL ! !1 TQ " †!CH 2 ='
M Q a ' o&$eI< 2)>0? =' w
.(392 - 391 /1
=' ( F" !1 m&I p
@ f % $&-
0$ >< '! ' " o&$eI< 2)>0? " .# D! >< ‚ F (139 /1 :)
6% 2' @ # Q=
J;
H D<&>A0/ 7! - " &" !
&>$E ! 0<^5 !1 m&I (0<f0E 5Q< % o&$O #=$ ! 908"»
7"^ " D< .(103 - 102 :1327 -)) «!/ &>$E
P
A / ! p' (- 7)>
:A
v&
o&$eI< DQ< D < 2C )z '($EfBr o&$f$E
:1377 )z) !< @ CH % P0$ (Q " #"E )
wr - z P0 =' Q 7"A
( .(75 - 74 :1372 0/ i390 /1
#&) @= H .< †!CH F" - O! wr T<
#IE f
( mH †!CH .(103 :1327 -)) " (< v& Š&C
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* 53 !/& &-!+& ,
#10H 2! # C 7! #/ )> P Q=
$ @= 2 Q=
Tq< IM% @ ~ !xE ." "C
)< ( 2;0 ~ @= Q=
.! D"-
- 2Q "( 8r )< ( i! #10H #1 O 7I
5 2I
7= DG /q #>! O= ! D 2 O%
($
i125 :1363 ) #/ !' #>! # ' 2!"
D< O= IM% ~ # .(76 :1324 B/ i126 :1368 !/ i167 :1348
i(161 :2535 #%) «% < )
D< 8) [0E] )> » !
@ # % J;
! 7 2! )> w
H 2!C )< ( (
@= )
5Q< 7"A
Q=
J;
H .‚&) @= 2
.#$ F!' D- #=u
@ f- ,A; #A&;
v& ,o 0$ F!' ! a| ( , " Q $&- - 2!
D< ( .(19 - 17 :1326 +?) #>| ( , D< <
26"
,) !5( " xE (Q FC o&$eI<
#' r% 26"
,) 5 #o' TE( .#$ 7! .!< 0$ ,&K$ @
?&@ ><= ) DEF + >C
$ A @ BA$ 2.2
.5 ,&$& r% / #' - 2!" ,B
! ,&$& ^5 ˆ " 'Ar% <!< '&x
/ % + .< DH !" % ,C& (
" #E O$" 2
RQ5 " &' ,&K$ 3B !0 @ " ! D
D90 'Ar% 2/ f !6 '&x
0< ~ @ "
'Ar% i" 4!
&E fQ 7! "
)z i129 :1380 CA80) #$ #o& ~0 !0 2 D<&>A0/
.(146 /2 :
8C i60 38 :1382 (C
i426 /2 :1343 mC i47 /1 :1377
( «:;9 ,)» P / - 2!" ,&' 2 (0$1
#/5 :C< 0$&5 ,4/!
:= T‚ f1812/1227 T m&- 1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* ... : 54
m&- # #E ) ( 8 :;/ .(77 :1390 G25)
2!" !" 2)> ‚ " < (6 i< "k
-C 2)>
D< + .(139 /1 :1378 !A) < «0< H 0 0)‚ !)» -
# 0 @= (0< - 0 )> 0 7= (0< )> #E ,&K$ " ) ( 2!0A :&A
! 2
.«# D!= :` m&- 2 =‚ ,&' 4E» D! !0 )
,&K$ Q % % FH !" 2 8 0/ (1812) T #>| !1 . !' P =H 2 2Q0 & D @ D( (< 2D o| != . v& 7"^ b< @= 2)>0? (0'<# > 8&$
< v& 0!' P9 a 22H mH @ " (
@ # /;0 4L @ #"E " b< (
@= 2)>0? 0'< # #o& % 2
>0 ! @= .(168 :1353 P) " #E Š6
, #/ mH ." #P 2)H (+ :P #$!0 m&9
.0/ m&9
6& '($A! v& 0' (Rtishtchof)
% + )> 8) 2E 7"^ ( .< a ( ) 7"^
# ($E " ' !' 2! ,&" 7"^ e< cA " ! (R!'
!5 m&- 9 ,&' ,I0 v& 7"^ .< D F!'
& a/ 0 2 2)
H (+ (0$ " (Sir Gore Ouseley)
!-+ " (185 - 168 :1353 P) #$( #$ R!"
!" | #
#"E 4E R2)>0? 2 x
!= O= @=
.# D F!' ,A; #E 2 u 25:C< f1812/1227 T 7"^
@ ,&' 2 D 0$&5 ,4/!
TE( I @= @ 2‡ T H " 0$&5 ,4/!
.#' ) ‰A
/ :C< " ! ,4/!
(0$1 < P>
:! D% 0$&5 ,4/!
f)+ :;/ ." &'
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* 55 !/& &-!+& ,
... 7xA& #=$ !' A
0 )g 2 ... !
z ... 7xA&
f~ / ‚ " f~ )> „! !' ... & # 2 # €0A D5 5 (>
2)> "
#C& J;
:' !0 $" €' #Px <
:1380 2< 2') 5 8CA P0$ # @ # # .(177 - 176 /1 :1378 !A i243 - 242 /1 :1377 )z i363 /1
2)>0? m&- | #E @ " ~ (+
#E D< D OP $&- " " 5 :;9 ,) @=
‰A $&- !
2 <B
a D< Q5 )> 4/!
.# D" #E )> 20 #E 0$&5 ,4/!
0= .!
0 $ % ,5&' 2= # D= 8 )> ! ' / +
/ #' @ ,B Q # 3>=L # :;9 ,) FH ˆ 2F+ 5% @ " # ( (C
:! .
20 0 v& }< R^H 7! " )/ @= 2
.(168 :1382 (C
) " !' #E D0 &A R
dQ #
.! % 2#!' T!= )> (0< 2 <! @ < (
2 I5 2 @= #!' !' RQ5 , (C
"(
# 095 (1 !' 1# 2 0$&5 ,4/!
D< " " /| (C
TE( .! 0/ )> 9 8+ @ "
F$H - < @= 2)>0? v < #!' "( O=
7! ( ~ ! ( i!= )> f 4/! Q- | .(180 :1382 (C
) " !' #E «D< Q5 (» " < B
,B 26"
,) !< D " ! ( D
!" ( J
C& C !)g )5 D=C / #' @
.! D< ) := % 7P + >C
$ K<FJ <J ?&@ ><= IG DH 3.2
,) 2! 0/0/ )> C< !< #>! < D< " !5
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* ... : 56
D< Q5 )> ˆ2)>0? 0$&5 ,4/!
+ . ! 26"
#95 ‚=
: ( m&- ,o&$O )> 0E < 0'< #
( i!= !;0 !' 2 ,<E ! @= (583 /2 :1383 $9)
(C ~A #< "k
D< Q5 )> C& 1< #P/!
- ( .!< $9
2- / ! 4/!
f)+ :;/ D< 2Œ q
!
2‡ T mH D0 J!& F5 b=
H @=
Q )
91 5Q< 2C<" ‡ f < @
8)= !' 8+ " @= ( ." + %
." (x
k
R 2)>0? 20 #E @ %
. @ 2‡ f 5r% @= O=( 0E 2D
:$! D( o&$0
7 R? R!' @ #!P
#o& "( cA @=
w= #$C< ( < O= ‡ ( #< '($E " ;1<
.(366 :1377 o&$0)
@= " # 8&$ # D< D< T?0 ( FH +
v;
. DG H 2!" k
!' !
O$" "( T :< 9 2 #$!
= @= # 2 !' 2DQ- )> ˆ&' ˆ91 :u 20P # #E
@= ,;' } "( f # 2 E @= RA0 # )> < 2 @ < 8
4L ( @
@= wo| #E f
:# 0<! 5 " !5 .< :=
#1 #>! 0'< # fP @ 5 i! @ O
.(170 :1362 5) < TQQ0
! QI #/ †!CH Q v& 7"^ 2 @= "- (
:#95 5 7"^ ( . F!'
p' " ( 2 ( Q 2D+ C =0H ( D<H 5
$9) 8" m&- 8&$
!' fQ5 "% ... fQ- u
.(627 /2 :1383
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* 57 !/& &-!+& ,
/ 2 @= ,E % <8&$
$&- f 3?0E
.# D! !' #E % "wI @
! (Nesselrod) &$ !0C †!CH " ! rr (+ 2)> 0$&5 ,4/!
f)+ " " "k
,'
@= 2)>0? " < % .#< D- !' 7! @=
.(606 :) # # 0/5 4&>
«RH " PE»
2)>0? " " )>
@ "% mH $ 2!5#95 mH fI
.< 0$ 26"
20 26"
,) # @=
:< "k
!5( ) 809 :;/ @= (
Q !
z D # >) @= w! ‚ D<H !+
< #1
@!& 2Q> w! " " )>
D! O&o ( 4;
.(396 /1 :1377 )z i673 /2 :1380 2< 2') ‚& % PA0? D<H
@= :
26"
,) 9 % (| '!
(- 7!C ( #& 09- 1 R2)> 2 @ #| #/
k< " #< ~0 2 -
!
- :# (<
N= T{ 2x (+ D< #o& fP
@ ,&' :&>#& " 26"
,) 809 :;/ ;;' ( .# D! %" 8I$ (< ! P/ ,&K$
0>! D! <= !' % D5† )> < O=
2)>0? #>! i! D")
)> 2 D! 0E (+ . 7>=
.0/ o' !< 8LB
R!10 #$!
A ‚ .< % @= " ! 2A #>! @ 2‡
,) ,0% R)> D< &>A0/ , 7~A % @= C< #>!
}=| B?< w0" % (0 " ( D< .# )/ 3B" 26"
27$ " 8)0 «o' }='» )> Q%B5 3B" A # D<
. «» o' «> Or 2#? » > 3/ O`; f
:A
#$C< T!K$ @= D<&>A0/ (
T ! !' !
! D% ... / %» #& (
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* ... : 58
"M !' RQ5 a= B?< .(55 - 54 :1369 B?<) «! !$
5 TE( # D f" RQ5 ( k
2 FGH ( 2!#$ "
D< .# 8) $ !0A :&A
~ " 0 ( #A !0
T ! !' !
! D%» C#E 7! " )>
2 #$!
" )> A #>! C<% #/5 !' «!$ O= @= " ~ o< (+ .< 0< 2!5 2H .# D :
,&K$ #' F91 /
2/ " 2A 70' D< , 5
=0 ! != " ;E E 70' ( . 2" 2)>0?
)> < O= D< 2~A " I 20/ D #< ()"
DG D< 2Š>| ( Q/ . TQQ0 7=j 0>! D!
( ! D" }&$ 2D 4&
-0$= 2 0HT!H
$9 i170 :1362 5) !< 0/5 " | < )> #$!
#'H ‰A †!CH @= 7"^ "+ .(428 /1 :1383
2)>0? C " 2)> @= + D< #r
‰A "FH <!" &( D o&$eI< &>$E
o< (+ ~ .(649 /2 :1383 $9) - !H R (x
2 = D< C
}P/ " I0( @=
#E 2 2- D5C
2!#$ )> < O= ( .#$
.< F!' f" 5Q< < O= , 5 ( DB
0/ < )> 2 0 % . ,0$< (0!'
@ 2‡ f O 5Q< ." D90 F=1
2
> + D< " !" !' #!CE #A
7? 0/
:/!0$ ,0<! .)
!' #$C< " 2 $E D 8 2-:) ( 0$
5" # IM% ! Q o&$O D6 "2!L D! @=
.(50 - 49 /1 :1386 /!0$) #< @0 2- 2 % 2"/
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* 59 !/& &-!+& ,
0E "!' PA
2 " 2!' )> ‚" 0E %
2H !< D ‡ )> &( ! | -- ,=&r .(428 107 /1 :1383 $9) %
!' 0!CE -=1 T 20 #E ˆ5Q< ‚
220 2!A T O&r ,&K$ ( !
@= w10 ! >0 5Q< T .! D"
5Q< ( # .# %" ! != < D!5 2)>0?
(< F F!' 2! )> " ! 2 + @=
!' ( eQ #1
€
2 2 % #95 " wo' !'
Q D< 0E " ! + #91 ( , .(153 - 152 :1370 :) #!'
095 (1 8~ F
#< )> Q%#P/! +
.(74 :1328 x) !
$9 ." Q -- 2H 0E " ! + #!;' ( 0$5
" ! D" )H 0E " # D" « # !'» †!CH T!
RQ5 ( + .(619 - 618 /2 :1383 $9) " 8&$
@ @=
I0 2 †!CH " ! T0E ( # DC k
- a
w! @= < D< :!0 2E (+ 7"^ a
#E 0>! @= :`$ ( e!I ." OP
. (
26"
,) 809 :;/ !' @
4%3)
:`$ (
2 f
Q ,&K$
.! ,&K$ ^H …Q 5 Q D ( .! !" 1
w10 2/ !' A 7 D D< )
5 (
7 "F+ " ) Q - 5Q< 2 C ( C& "
2!" ,&' 2 D (6 5 ( .!< )>
(0$1 2 $&- + ." ,&K$ '
#P= 2!5 @ " =0H @= 2)>0? A!&
7!
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* ... : 60
!" #' 26"
,) DG 0$&5 ,4/!
! %
DB ,&K$ @ ,&' .1 # F!'
! !" " (
8) C M!9 2 % Fo - "%
O= % " !5 5 ( .! Q !E 5
"JL 2 ( .< @= 2)>0? #>! 5C<
. # @ R " < D ! # ( :x> (
M }< ( 2 E 26"
,) 809 :;/ !)g
.#< @=
2 @= #!' ,&K$ @ #' 0) p 2
5 :" D- Q 2- ,= x R2)>0? (0'<#
D< Q5 )> f
2%" #< ! / !" !
„>
D< 2~A 7;
!; F!' D- )> " #E
2!" 8 % 2D> @= " #< Q % 5Q<
!' 2)>0? #E 0!' ! D" :A
2>/ 2#$C< "
.# 9 FH ( H 4PA
( N!<
2 2H 7jk
26"
,) 809 :;/
@ Q-:k
2#' D<( D<A .#<^5
2 ) :;/ ( 2!0A D + @ " /
< " ! 2!5 ‰A 26"
,) (- , .0$
" 0$ % #A&; )> (>
2 :" 70' (0< 8r !' w10 DG m&- 21
9 ( < :=
" # % - #< 26"
,) 7Q ( . a&o
!< !" ( #91 )5 % w10 = " <
. T{ ! 7 T "!
" % ,< D!C< k< . H , 26"
,) 4 2H !
O
(
/675
wr " 2)< :/ E D" 0 " # !" ~ 8) > 5
.1
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* 61 !/& &-!+& ,
#<^5 :A ( q "C mH D0 . wM :H
.(58 :1328 x)
.# D$! "k
.2
89
Q" :)
f' ($A ,
1780 - 1828 @ } .(1382) :! (C
.-
.!' :)
=" .(2535) / #%
A ,A
vA;
!0 .(1357) '($EA o&$0
.) :)
2
.=" :)
o&$0 7L' , .(1377) '($EA o&$0
. :)
T TE < .(1378) 2) .T= :)
0$&- $/ 2Q
, 2>0 2# .(1362) E F1=
.+ :)
!C
.f .2‘ ,9 .(1383) .f .2‘ !C
.…"< & ="& :)
T= @= f0 ! .(1327) -)
:)
wr 2‘! 5 2 (0$1 .(1367) 2)= 2`E
.="
’+ :)
// vA;
(PM .(1380) h:x/ 2< 2'
.B < ‡/ 7 70
.Q=< :)
A ! ,
9 .(1370) z5 :
.7BL :)
2!; / f0 o& j“ .(1383) ‡= &=
«2 } mk
: ‡/ 0 =» .(1380) 8E #/!`
.14 R f!&
.@/ :)
DQ& hQQ vA;
!080 .(1380) Š% 8<A CA80
7>o «(!N) >o ,) ‡ ,"0 0$&5 ,#P/!» .(1390) ($ABr G25
. 8 R 3@ fB D( & A QH ,
-=1 < .(1387) ( m
.F1H+ :)
.& ="& :)
1/ P
A ,
.(1343) H mC
.L :)
9" f0 i!0 .(1377) ‚&$ P
A )z
.)" :)
; m&- @ M!9 FQ/ :& .(1369) ! B?<
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )* ... : 62
.> D- :)
2< v ,9 .(1387) v 2<
.! :)
! ($E ,
:< 2 7L' .(1362) !!K 2 :<
. :)
1790 - 1815 : ~ # .(1353) ‚' P
.2~ ,1H+ :)
" !" ($E f0 2x .(1328) E x
.-/ 7>o FGH ,${ :)
28 / .(1372) | 0/
.@!
:)
2 )+! ,
0$ 9 J> Q/ ,9 .(1364) & Q Q/
.) FP , : ! ($E ,
B/ ‘ ,9 .(1324) ‘ B/
.w0" 2 :)
0<% T= @= ,
T .(1368) #$
‘ !/
)9 D- 1
2FGH « # A» .(1389) @= 2 .1 R 2 @
. ( :)
fB"! & ,
,&K$ .(1347) :`
€ "
. :)
# !A ,
7/$ .(1365) m! `!Q
!"
.D- :)
T= @= ,
5 T‘ #!k .(1362) 9% #" 5
.2/ !=o D- :)
o&$O @= 2}10 T!E .(1326) 8P! +?
.w0" 2 : (7E ) : ,
.(
) 8C
.T= :)
2B 8! m&- } .(1378) !A !A
.m :)
( 5 < .(1386) h= /!0$
.0' :)
!' <> .(1388) ($E DQ 8C= f0 > 0 .(1383) > $9
.L :)
2 1 €
.9 R 1 @ ) , «@= 2)>0? D » .(
) ($A= G
#$) =" «D<A D<&>A0/ » .(1389) . .% .(5 &=
.w0) :)
2 !
,
(
.=" :)
E ,
.(1348) #5 7 ($
.(! :)
H & ,
T #$ .(1363) Katouzian, Homa (2003). "Legitimacy and Succession in Iranian History", Comparative Studies of
South Asia, Africa and the Middle East, Vol. 23, No. 1-2.
1390 !" #$ %& '( %& )*