Kobe
University Repository : Kernel
Title
アジアの地方分権 : 地方分権は万能薬か?
Author(s)
松並, 潤
Citation
国際協力論集, 15(2): 21-31
Issue date
2007-11
Resource Type
Departmental Bulletin Paper / 紀要論文
Resource Version
publisher
URL
http://www.lib.kobe-u.ac.jp/handle_kernel/81000021
Create Date: 2015-02-24
ÌÍ
!"#
$%&'()*+,-./)01
2"342536768689:;7!<
=>?-@!7"AB14.CD
E1
Î
Ï
ÐÑ
3!?FG)
6:HI?!?
FGJKLHM2NO
PQ
RSTU2SV>WXP
YZ367"[\]^-_PSV
`
aPb>?-ca
SV>?deef+ghiI
4Jj,3klgm,nopq5
rCs,tu=3)-2vH3w
xy;<626=>?-z{|g,
-}@!7"ca3"~6-
WX,#$gmJ@367>r
,r
1
"
3!?
),-$J3
"-!1"-!23A
42;=34 U_ #$%&'(" ¡¢£¤
`¥¦§¨©ª
!"«¬®¯3
°±²)P1³A1
I67
´µ¶·y;1
¸?3¹;º»,-¼½367W
ÒÓÔiÕiÕÖPQRרÙÚ
XÛ"ÜÝÙÕÙÕרÞßàרá
â
ãLä#$%&åægmTçè
é¼êררëìíèÎÏÐ>ר
îÝ1 <XÛïð Hv7"Ù×Þ
ר%ñí-¹òרQRí3óôI67=
Ù×Þ>v7oõy;HרöãL÷ø3
ùôúy;3=¸)i1 vH=3Jû67
Ù×Þר%ñí-¹òרQRíרöü
ýþí6H!<
X14¾M¹;¿M7!<
4À¸Á`p54#$%&J'(
=3"2v7ÂÃJ¨=3"WX
>r4#$%&ÄÅ1
3¹;7!
ca²>v74Æ%ÇÈy;7
!<ÉÊË>:3M1"
Ú
' 'û
ÆÇ0c6È
ÉÊ
!"#
!
ËRÌ&(ͯÎYZ
$%&'()*+,-./01
yz2
2«!S~
23456789::$
]XJZ!ÏB6ÐÑÒÓ5
';<2=<>?:$'@
Ô4ÕÖ/j×!!Ä%c»(
ABCDEFGH<2IJKLMN
ÒÓÑØc\ÙJL
Ú45c!
/O7PQR:$S'T
±²UVV³
yz
OUVWXJYZ[\J]^_`a
ÛÜWÝ Þ$(ßàGH
b%
:c!def g$
yz0123`ákUVWâã
hijkl
ÀÁ
2BäSåº`Òæ
`mnRo7pc:Rcqm
c01çè#2Bäçè
c!$
ȵ%tÏé`êRÒÓÈ\
Sr#& ÙJL
Ú`45R:c!
Ú
stu2vwc!:
ÐëS`k:`©ìR$
xc<ryz{|
í§k¨23íáã
!:/
yzRR}
î2áãïð/0123#ÉÊñ
#~L]`
c
òóô!ÉÊ
DcÍ
ABr`yz
¨õyzc!íUVV³öQ
7J#
r#&S#Jc
c!û$
`!S
÷ø#ÍSùú.Á
üíQ/ 2vÇý
J`
þöc!$c
< yz`2v¡
·Jc!!a
%
Ca2vºY
¢£¤`¥#
¦k#$
K\Îrñà!
à
§k¨
yz<r~
ó¢
Ö`!"`R
L]c!2BC`©ªR#¨(«
³!$r
`¬]®/¯°L
:AC2v`
yz±²UVV³´µµ!
23!aC`
¶/¶·¸¹º
yz`»¼
R
R:½¾¿ÀÁc!Â
c!$2v`
$òV
³
yz!Ä%cs«Åu
UVV³`67jcM
:?
þ¢þDEFG
DEFG
EFG@2DEKLMN
=_`B
- ¡¢£()#9?@¤r¥
!"
#$%&'()*+,-./0123
}r¦§+¨-©3oª«
24567812#9$%-843
¬®¯-°31V
:;<2=>0?@A-BC
®¯3±²³\´7
DEFGHI&J3KLMNODPQ
12#A-3µ
RST-U3
ª23F¶·¸¹?ºVwx3
V&JWXYKZ-
[\]^&!
53=_`BS0
V»¼
½6¾WXYKZ[\&
Ga-FGb012&43=_`B-H
4=_`BHc3=_`BHc&4
c&!
2!A8d3ef3
¿ÀÁÂ-UÃ]^ÄÅÆÇ
-È0
WXYKZ35=_`Bghij
12-CQRÉFÊ6VDEF
]VklmnZo3A-pq
GHI&JGa-T6VDE
rs0$%#8Vt9#5
ËÌÍ]@V¾3ÎÏr
a4543ÒrÓ¿vª
8duv#5wx358d
GÐÑ
yd]VAz1Jwx3
ÔE3ËÌÃ9@V¾:DE<KL
{|$%23KL}
=_`B~z
MN
=_`B
- ¡¢£()012Õ
@DE}xb8V
Ör×0ªÓ¿#93
43MN
=_`B"&
DPQRSTUÃ#ª3"2
#5JDE&J
ØÙ&!QR3ÚµÛÜÝÞß
]V&!J23"&
à#53:á<5:â<
.]b8V40{|$%
&KLMN'()*+,°9ãJ
&JDEFGHIA
2!12-äå0?@V
V´7
-12#92:<]V40
DEFGæ«3çÎèé¶êJ
3@HI2
Ê6´32]V®¯ëì
$]V2
´-311#Híî0#5
3:DEFGHI&J3KLMN
ODPQRST-U3
V&JW
XYKZ-[\]^&!
53=_`
BS0Ga-FGb012&43=
ï4ð3±²³\D
_`B-Hc&!
<2!3
EFG-æ0ñò25óV
-11#21!
DPQR3A
WXYKZ
[\3=_`BHc
-#3D
ôÎ3DEFG Rb#543
îï
~
á
â
=
)
kãäå kæç
*+zptuI¤m¥¦§¨>©
!
"#
Ici+ª«¬%Id`
$%&'()*+
a1®I¯°A&"89+,
,
*-./0+12
:;,m1bA#B
,34-.-567+89:
CDEFGHIm)bc
;,,<=>?@A
*+,<:;,OPQR
&#BCDEFGHI)
SI¤*+J1,m1:;,
"89J1+:;,K1
7
1±Aj
f{+#&j
LMN
*,<:;,O
`ad1efIj²¢A&"
PQRS+:;,$=$T1
k³*+$'(A&+
,U>
VWXYZ[\/0
A&`a
":;I´
]9^_I`a*+#
µK*+¶PI$·¸¹º>+:;
)bc*+d1
,
*xK»¼MNf9,
efIghcij
"
12]{½¾A&>+x&*¿Àfj
kl*+mIno(C&+
Á$·¸¹ºÂÃ1|Äf9j*
A&`a
"m
I":;,7LMN4
*
'(A&`a*+:;,
,1·¸¹º½¾RÅ+ÆÇÈC
,<mpq2rs7Otuv
+$I`a(C#12
w"x&8:;,>yzA&
+:;,7LMN+
*,
{9zp1|f{,>yz}j
>ÁªÉ12Êi$·¸¹º
1f+
*~pf{:;>
½¾#>+xf{~Ë´ÌÍ
f{9j1C
89
{Î8f+$
*p
`C
+xf{s7
)*)À"$)
1
{j2jIO
*+)4m)
,1C>+m'(
:1*+ÏÐ2IÑÒhÓ
A&`a
"m
ÔªIj>Õ8&{q+89+
)1*+mO:;,1:f
`a*+
Ö8ר$Z[\
{#>+1{inIp@
Ù½f{ÚÛj
+Ü(1
$%+mA{>+
f(C&I`a
ÝÞ
,1O+#&>
"
fmjA& inI¡
¢£>
"##*+`a
ß1+#&à
$%&
'()1|²¢8C{q#"
çîç
H
«¬y5«¬C®#f
!"#
¯p°Nw
$%&'()*+,-.
(AAB3O)P
/01)201345678$9%:
±²³8´wM)8$*µ¶
;5<'(=>=?@9+(AAB
«¬·«¸\¹º»5(AO¼&¤
CD-;8EF-GHI
K
JK*+L"&+%: M)8$N
Á(AAB5«¬.#ÂÃ
@9+%
ÄÅÆÇ/2ÈÉ-~M)#«¬
-(AAB3O)PQRSTU
ÊË
V
N
$:WXYZ[)*+%-
½¾¿À#$
ÌÍÎË´M)
5
Ï
*5\QRST]^_*+
GHI8`a#bN
cde
#!"
ÐÑ)*+
6*+efgh.ij
@P58$Ò+b%#$P
klm5nopqrst9+j
NeÓ[%Ô#ÕµÖ
@klm5nopqrsuvw
´+*+×ÕØÙÚÃÛw
*$jxyz{
ÕÍÎqÜÝδ+M#
|}-~
*5M)JK5*
/vÔM8!
K*+)#b@PN'(@:
"
)M#?F
K
%N
nop
É#Þß5àÑ)*+$Ò+b
lm)PlmI
áâã¹RäåÛwæ
$F8&+
¿À)çèTºéÔ*%êëá
#$N%efgh@9+
)*+ìí-M)$îïÃð>ñÃ
%-8$l
»òåó
ôêëõ
e!"867
öå÷¸\øùúåûüøç)ã¹Räå
*-5qq(
Ϻ¶æÛw¿À)
8$l5#+%
çèTºéýþ6)*%êë#$:
67O*$.i
öå÷¸\øùý
¡O
Ûwe¿À)æÆÇÈÉ
M)
$M)8`a#
bN
c¢
£d¤)¥¦#§¨5©ª
Ô#æ
Ý´b8#b5
9%M)8
} + ó
ôN*
*êë
6
¹
Y
Ö
4DL4C
!"
A! ¡¢6=¶M!^_
#$%&'()*+,-./0
"I`·¸¹=º?S'»
123456789:9
¼B¨B½B!"¾¿
;<=>?!@ABC
À!ÁÂ+,-.=/08D
&'(+,-./0!234
DÃÄÅÆfg=ÇÈ%!
DEFGHI4
¿À4ÉÊË`fg=h
JK6LMNO7L
DfY=¸7L?PP
DPLIJKQR9ST
ÌÍ`2ÎUÏ·4i4
UVWPX9=YZ[Y
IÏ·lÐ+Ñ
4LX\]&'()*^
4Ò¹-.ÓÔ=ÕD!3ÎÖ =×
_`&'$a!+,-.=/0
Ø%!ÙK
ÚÛ LÐ
DGb4Lcd!()*eX
+,!ÜÝÞØ)ß!2à4L
fg=hDfY=h?9
Ú wx{|
P=i+,-./0j$k
?9á`6á`U!â
&'()*4lV!
ã4lD
4mn!o\]=pqrs
`äå=ºPÙEæçè`
`l4`tuv:KV`?
?wxYC!"
wxyz{|}~!YI
¢6$a6éäåp23!
7!PXVD`
2344
4Lwx{|?Y
@B+
S'
,!2
äå=l!
DC
+,-
A=i[Y=L9`4
./0234"Ö
5'@B
á`êë7`L?
+,-./0D`AC=
ìíîéï£Ê£
? ¡¢6£¤
ðñ
¥
òóôõö÷øùD
=ú
$¦%§Kv$¨A¥©ª
0Ðæû`üg23ýþ=l
v>C`A«¬L
% v% Y%`
®2=¯
4
ÐÚ¾
úÙ
°±`23!LP=¯wx
=jDO
¡4LÚÐ
{|
?P²$¦%
`ÜÝ_
!©!^
j!
`A³´AC
1`Y¾`£A4
µ!®2v
PQP¿MÃ
¿Mæ
z
ÇÈ
Ue
¸
·uÉ{cB>6Ge
!"#
©ª7²³
$%&!'()
*%
+,-&./01#2
3
4567
89:,.%;<=>
z67
ÊËtd
ÌÄe£Í
?&:,.%@A7B>CDEF
θ>XG
¿Méª
GHI;<=>
?&:,.%@A
Ä&¿
7JGCDEKGHILM
6G¿Méª7
zU>6G
NO
|
ÏÍа
YZbX
;*PQPRST#%3UVW
G
XG
YZ&[\%]$!1'6^_`7
ÓÔÕ7~>XG
zU>6G
a6bXc
d[e
Ö×XG
¯ >Ub
fghijkl8mno
X¿MéªÑÎ
ØÙ®
)p>qNOr
7
>q
stdp
hijkl8mno
7yc
z{
l!'(
uvwx
|}e~>6
¿MéªÑÎ
Å
e
a¥Ò6
G
G
udÚÛ6G|Ü
ÝÞßeÄÅ4ÆàáXâã>ä
å6G}l
æ·l¿MÃÑÎdO
>q66G7JG~:,.%
p
çèp¿MÃéêëGXG
!'$)G
;Br
~:,
}U
zU>6G7
.%
e
íËÄe
F6CDEz{-
Jcì´
ÏîïXG
²³·ðñ
"#%P'$#%-7KG~:,.%
X¿Méª7ò¸>XG
U
q~l9
¯óôe
|X
6E
NO}
¿MéªB÷
p>q
; e¡¢£¤7¥5¦e
õö°GX
©ªÄÅ4Æ
X~
øùúX°
¯|
+'§'"+1¨'6©ª7¦e
7
p
6Å
«O};¡¬¥5e®6G
¥Ò65GX
¯
z¤¸wxXÝ
©ªNÝvx
NO°GX
}
±z²³7´o
²³´oYZ
¤X·
¸
#+µ%-¶
!¹,)/6º»
¼½¾#!¹,)/6¿Àe²³·
7>7Áe
z
¿Mé
?
Gûüýþ
ô9Ýv
¯
6bXG
&
¿M
éªÄÅ4ÆX~
6q
¥Ò
6p
a6e
öz9c
¯
ö
ªp
6ÄÅ4Æ6p~>
p
ÄÅ4Æ6ÄebP
©ª
QP|X
PQPÄ
c¯e!¹,)/6º»¼
>¯e
k
Á(
(¯R)[&'ÃÄ{Å
!"#
'")[{(],"F,Å(³W´
$%&'()*+,-."/0'
µbt(^)ÆÇÈɹ1%<"ʾ
&$1(12
Ë1
345651$748565((
[(ÌÍ^'¹1<)hi(Î7)ÏÐ
97):;<=>?@(AB
©*+,-.®<7Ñ
R)^%
C<$1DE?@($
&<
'ÒÓ&*+,-.®<
1)FGH??@"IJ(KL
ÔÕ1¾¿Ö"1565×"
$1D%&ML"
N
?*+,-.(ØÙ1$7 ¢
(OPQ"/0'&$1"R)
³µ¢$
')[<RÚ
S$TUVWXYZ[&'(
r)ÛSr1Ü,Ý(0)*+Þ
")2\]^'/0_`'&$1abc
(9ßÞà¹1áâãfgdP
03*+,-.de/0$1(
ØÙäB$(
')hi(*+F(
1fghi"%&'(j(kl
Î7)åæÔÕ
(1
mS$no
pq7r1s
t%<uv&w)x
yz(*+,-
.{t|R}Z^7)hi(~(
1
,ç2
3)èé2
3)
êMë2
"
3(ì$$7)Â
d7)*+F
"M_
vwíî[(ïðñ(9òó$1
&1ab$)X
2
%3^»7)[&
2
3'(u)
'ôõö÷ø
1$7õù÷ø
U5
)èé1$7êMë
r&wúû
2 !"
3
$$<%|R2!
#
"$
3
$7°(üý"),çþ_&1þ
¡¢£¤2
$
3(¥¦
t
æ)Ñ
1¡(*+,-.
§,r1¨©Qª«$12%
ø6)øt<
&3\]^'¬_&)1$7
%s1
(®
^¯'°
"±r²&'
Âvw)(*+,-.7Ó<
&1ab)
7^)1$7
^)<$Ú&1%<"1")%&7*
%&$(
R)³W´µ
+,-.[((")H?Q_&9ßÞ
<¶·¸S%¹%<"1%(ab)
(>(1$7[(9
º$
7»¼½¹1%<"
$
ûþR)F'(ܾ¿Ö
$$<%|R¾¿¹107)À
N¹1þt
_&%<þæ
µLµ/012
!"#$%&'()*+,-
!"
#
$
3
4
(
%
)
2 #
%
%
§¨©ª«¬y®¯°±²³´µLµ¶·
¸V¹º»´¼½º¾5¿6À5
</012=$34>[email protected]
57ÁTL
!8<=(*
B(CDEFGHI0J(
*KLMN<OPQ%
STUVGWX%(7"YZ[\]
ÂÃÄÅÆ´~
ÇÈÉÊËÌÍÎFG
ÌJB˺ÏÐÑÀ
ÒÓÔÕÖ×ØÙ²´JÚÛ¢ÜÝË!¥Þß
^_à¦e˺áâãäå6À
^_`abcd#e`f`WXg
æZ[«KTçâ¶·¸V¹"èF»éêë
WXhi&jk)>lm(
n
ìíVîT²´KTçâ¶·¸V¹ï
>>op7qr:$spt(
pFp'
^_àP0ðñWXjkºéêëì
G>WX$uvw`i&x-WX
íVîTÀòó
yz%(7"{|}~+P7{
|><op7it(
./01234$56789:;
.
R
/012"¤F
" "
ôõæö«KTçâ¶·¸V¹^_à:»
éêëìíVîT÷øòó
ùú«îû=/012=»
üZÙùÖ
t(*s
ϰý²´=¸þ¸cbº
7iP
$)*
áâãäåÀòó
$-*"
ZæÖ«
Çi&¶ãä¸
67 ¡$¢£*(*¤ !¥$
V¹»²´!¥FG¶ãä¸V¹BË
:;p7(
Ñhf`i&˺`
hÀòó
! "
#
$
%&
'%
(
$
)
))$
**+++
,
*-.)%* !*"
/
#
$%*+$'
$0)P¦#
1..2
1
%
¯°±«Ç.Ç$¢,¶·¸V¹
$
7»
²´µLµ¶·¸V¹º
Àòó
%
&'
"
(
5
' "
!
" !#
"
$%
!
%
%$
$
!
&
$'
%$
$
"
$"
!
( $ !
%
#
"
$%
"
$%$
)
$
!*
$'
'
$
!
'
$
$
!#
"
$
%
!
$'
'
$ +
%
,
!
$
%'
$%
$%
$
%$
!
%
%
%
$
"
$
!
%
"
"
&
"-
.
"/%
$!
© Copyright 2026 ExpyDoc