Kobe University Repository : Kernel Title アジアの地方分権 : 地方分権は万能薬か? Author(s) 松並, 潤 Citation 国際協力論集, 15(2): 21-31 Issue date 2007-11 Resource Type Departmental Bulletin Paper / 紀要論文 Resource Version publisher URL http://www.lib.kobe-u.ac.jp/handle_kernel/81000021 Create Date: 2015-02-24 ÌÍ !"# $%&'()*+,-./)01 2"342536768689:;7!< =>?-@!7"AB14.CD E1 Î Ï ÐÑ 3!?FG) 6:HI?!? FGJKLHM2NO PQ RSTU2SV>WXP YZ367"[\]^-_PSV ` aPb>?-ca SV>?deef+ghiI 4Jj,3klgm,nopq5 rCs,tu=3)-2vH3w xy;<626=>?-z{|g, -}@!7"ca3"~6- WX,#$gmJ@367>r ,r 1 " 3!? ),-$J3 "-!1"-!23A 42;=34 U_ #$%&'(" ¡¢£¤ `¥¦§¨©ª !"«¬®¯3 °±²)P1³A1 I67 ´µ¶·y;1 ¸?3¹;º»,-¼½367W ÒÓÔiÕiÕÖPQR×ØÙÚ XÛ"ÜÝÙÕÙÕ×ØÞßà×Øá â ãLä#$%&åægmTçè é¼ê×Ø×ØëìíèÎÏÐ>×Ø îÝ1 <XÛïð Hv7"Ù×Þ ×Ø%ñí-¹ò×ØQRí3óôI67= Ù×Þ>v7oõy;H×ØöãL÷ø3 ùôúy;3=¸)i1 vH=3Jû67 Ù×Þ×Ø%ñí-¹ò×ØQRí×Øöü ýþí6H!< X14¾M¹;¿M7!< 4À¸Á`p54#$%&J'( =3"2v7ÂÃJ¨=3"WX >r4#$%&ÄÅ1 3¹;7! ca²>v74Æ%ÇÈy;7 !<ÉÊË>:3M1" Ú ' 'û ÆÇ0c6È ÉÊ !"# ! ËRÌ&(ͯÎYZ $%&'()*+,-./01 yz2 2«!S~ 23456789::$ ]XJZ!ÏB6ÐÑÒÓ5 ';<2=<>?:$'@ Ô4ÕÖ/j×!!Ä%c»( ABCDEFGH<2IJKLMN ÒÓÑØc\ÙJL Ú45c! /O7PQR:$S'T ±²UVV³ yz OUVWXJYZ[\J]^_`a ÛÜWÝ Þ$(ßàGH b% :c!def g$ yz0123`ákUVWâã hijkl ÀÁ 2BäSåº`Òæ `mnRo7pc:Rcqm c01çè#2Bäçè c!$ ȵ%tÏé`êRÒÓÈ\ Sr#& ÙJL Ú`45R:c! Ú stu2vwc!: ÐëS`k:`©ìR$ xc<ryz{| í§k¨23íáã !:/ yzRR} î2áãïð/0123#ÉÊñ #~L]` c òóô!ÉÊ DcÍ ABr`yz ¨õyzc!íUVV³öQ 7J# r#&S#Jc c!û$ `!S ÷ø#ÍSùú.Á üíQ/ 2vÇý J` þöc!$c < yz`2v¡ ·Jc!!a % Ca2vºY ¢£¤`¥# ¦k#$ K\Îrñà! à §k¨ yz<r~ ó¢ Ö`!"`R L]c!2BC`©ªR#¨(« ³!$r `¬]®/¯°L :AC2v` yz±²UVV³´µµ! 23!aC` ¶/¶·¸¹º yz`»¼ R R:½¾¿ÀÁc! c!$2v` $òV ³ yz!Ä%cs«Åu UVV³`67jcM :? þ¢þDEFG DEFG EFG@2DEKLMN =_`B - ¡¢£()#9?@¤r¥ !" #$%&'()*+,-./0123 }r¦§+¨-©3oª« 24567812#9$%-843 ¬®¯-°31V :;<2=>0?@A-BC ®¯3±²³\´7 DEFGHI&J3KLMNODPQ 12#A-3µ RST-U3 ª23F¶·¸¹?ºVwx3 V&JWXYKZ- [\]^&! 53=_`BS0 V»¼ ½6¾WXYKZ[\& Ga-FGb012&43=_`B-H 4=_`BHc3=_`BHc&4 c&! 2!A8d3ef3 ¿ÀÁÂ-UÃ]^ÄÅÆÇ -È0 WXYKZ35=_`Bghij 12-CQRÉFÊ6VDEF ]VklmnZo3A-pq GHI&JGa-T6VDE rs0$%#8Vt9#5 ËÌÍ]@V¾3ÎÏr a4543ÒrÓ¿vª 8duv#5wx358d GÐÑ yd]VAz1Jwx3 ÔE3ËÌÃ9@V¾:DE<KL {|$%23KL} =_`B~z MN =_`B - ¡¢£()012Õ @DE}xb8V Ör×0ªÓ¿#93 43MN =_`B"& DPQRSTUÃ#ª3"2 #5JDE&J ØÙ&!QR3ÚµÛÜÝÞß ]V&!J23"& à#53:á<5:â< .]b8V40{|$% &KLMN'()*+,°9ãJ &JDEFGHIA 2!12-äå0?@V V´7 -12#92:<]V40 DEFGæ«3çÎèé¶êJ 3@HI2 Ê6´32]V®¯ëì $]V2 ´-311#Híî0#5 3:DEFGHI&J3KLMN ODPQRST-U3 V&JW XYKZ-[\]^&! 53=_` BS0Ga-FGb012&43= ï4ð3±²³\D _`B-Hc&! <2!3 EFG-æ0ñò25óV -11#21! DPQR3A WXYKZ [\3=_`BHc -#3D ôÎ3DEFG Rb#543 îï ~ á â = ) kãäå kæç *+zptuI¤m¥¦§¨>© ! "# Ici+ª«¬%Id` $%&'()*+ a1®I¯°A&"89+, , *-./0+12 :;,m1bA#B ,34-.-567+89: CDEFGHIm)bc ;,,<=>?@A *+,<:;,OPQR &#BCDEFGHI) SI¤*+J1,m1:;, "89J1+:;,K1 7 1±Aj f{+#&j LMN *,<:;,O `ad1efIj²¢A&" PQRS+:;,$=$T1 k³*+$'(A&+ ,U> VWXYZ[\/0 A&`a ":;I´ ]9^_I`a*+# µK*+¶PI$·¸¹º>+:; )bc*+d1 , *xK»¼MNf9, efIghcij " 12]{½¾A&>+x&*¿Àfj kl*+mIno(C&+ Á$·¸¹ºÂÃ1|Äf9j* A&`a "m I":;,7LMN4 * '(A&`a*+:;, ,1·¸¹º½¾RÅ+ÆÇÈC ,<mpq2rs7Otuv +$I`a(C#12 w"x&8:;,>yzA& +:;,7LMN+ *, {9zp1|f{,>yz}j >ÁªÉ12Êi$·¸¹º 1f+ *~pf{:;> ½¾#>+xf{~Ë´ÌÍ f{9j1C 89 {Î8f+$ *p `C +xf{s7 )*)À"$) 1 {j2jIO *+)4m) ,1C>+m'( :1*+ÏÐ2IÑÒhÓ A&`a "m ÔªIj>Õ8&{q+89+ )1*+mO:;,1:f `a*+ Ö8×Ø$Z[\ {#>+1{inIp@ Ù½f{ÚÛj +Ü(1 $%+mA{>+ f(C&I`a ÝÞ ,1O+#&> " fmjA& inI¡ ¢£> "##*+`a ß1+#&à $%& '()1|²¢8C{q#" çîç H «¬y5«¬C®#f !"# ¯p°Nw $%&'()*+,-. (AAB3O)P /01)201345678$9%: ±²³8´wM)8$*µ¶ ;5<'(=>=?@9+(AAB «¬·«¸\¹º»5(AO¼&¤ CD-;8EF-GHI K JK*+L"&+%: M)8$N Á(AAB5«¬.#Âà @9+% ÄÅÆÇ/2ÈÉ-~M)#«¬ -(AAB3O)PQRSTU ÊË V N $:WXYZ[)*+%- ½¾¿À#$ ÌÍÎË´M) 5 Ï *5\QRST]^_*+ GHI8`a#bN cde #!" ÐÑ)*+ 6*+efgh.ij @P58$Ò+b%#$P klm5nopqrst9+j NeÓ[%Ô#ÕµÖ @klm5nopqrsuvw ´+*+×ÕØÙÚÃÛw *$jxyz{ ÕÍÎqÜÝδ+M# |}-~ *5M)JK5* /vÔM8! K*+)#b@PN'(@: " )M#?F K %N nop É#Þß5àÑ)*+$Ò+b lm)PlmI áâã¹RäåÛwæ $F8&+ ¿À)çèTºéÔ*%êëá #$N%efgh@9+ )*+ìí-M)$îïÃð>ñà %-8$l »òåó ôêëõ e!"867 öå÷¸\øùúåûüøç)ã¹Räå *-5qq( Ϻ¶æÛw¿À) 8$l5#+% çèTºéýþ6)*%êë#$: 67O*$.i öå÷¸\øùý ¡O Ûwe¿À)æÆÇÈÉ M) $M)8`a# bN c¢ £d¤)¥¦#§¨5©ª Ô#æ Ý´b8#b5 9%M)8 } + ó ôN* *êë 6 ¹ Y Ö 4DL4C !" A! ¡¢6=¶M!^_ #$%&'()*+,-./0 "I`·¸¹=º?S'» 123456789:9 ¼B¨B½B!"¾¿ ;<=>?!@ABC À!ÁÂ+,-.=/08D &'(+,-./0!234 DÃÄÅÆfg=ÇÈ%! DEFGHI4 ¿À4ÉÊË`fg=h JK6LMNO7L DfY=¸7L?PP DPLIJKQR9ST ÌÍ`2ÎUÏ·4i4 UVWPX9=YZ[Y IÏ·lÐ+Ñ 4LX\]&'()*^ 4Ò¹-.ÓÔ=ÕD!3ÎÖ =× _`&'$a!+,-.=/0 Ø%!ÙK ÚÛ LÐ DGb4Lcd!()*eX +,!ÜÝÞØ)ß!2à4L fg=hDfY=h?9 Ú wx{| P=i+,-./0j$k ?9á`6á`U!â &'()*4lV! ã4lD 4mn!o\]=pqrs `äå=ºPÙEæçè` `l4`tuv:KV`? ?wxYC!" wxyz{|}~!YI ¢6$a6éäåp23! 7!PXVD` 2344 4Lwx{|?Y @B+ S' ,!2 äå=l! DC +,- A=i[Y=L9`4 ./0234"Ö 5'@B á`êë7`L? +,-./0D`AC= ìíîéï£Ê£ ? ¡¢6£¤ ðñ ¥ òóôõö÷øùD =ú $¦%§Kv$¨A¥©ª 0Ðæû`üg23ýþ=l v>C`A«¬L % v% Y%` ®2=¯ 4 ÐÚ¾ úÙ °±`23!LP=¯wx =jDO ¡4LÚÐ {| ?P²$¦% `ÜÝ_ !©!^ j! `A³´AC 1`Y¾`£A4 µ!®2v PQP¿Mà ¿Mæ z ÇÈ Ue ¸ ·uÉ{cB>6Ge !"# ©ª7²³ $%&!'() *% +,-&./01#2 3 4567 89:,.%;<=> z67 ÊËtd ÌÄe£Í ?&:,.%@A7B>CDEF θ>XG ¿Méª GHI;<=> ?&:,.%@A Ä&¿ 7JGCDEKGHILM 6G¿Méª7 zU>6G NO | ÏÍа YZbX ;*PQPRST#%3UVW G XG YZ&[\%]$!1'6^_`7 ÓÔÕ7~>XG zU>6G a6bXc d[e Ö×XG ¯ >Ub fghijkl8mno X¿MéªÑÎ ØÙ® )p>qNOr 7 >q stdp hijkl8mno 7yc z{ l!'( uvwx |}e~>6 ¿MéªÑÎ Å e a¥Ò6 G G udÚÛ6G|Ü ÝÞßeÄÅ4ÆàáXâã>ä å6G}l æ·l¿MÃÑÎdO >q66G7JG~:,.% p çèp¿MÃéêëGXG !'$)G ;Br ~:, }U zU>6G7 .% e íËÄe F6CDEz{- Jcì´ ÏîïXG ²³·ðñ "#%P'$#%-7KG~:,.% X¿Méª7ò¸>XG U q~l9 ¯óôe |X 6E NO} ¿MéªB÷ p>q ; e¡¢£¤7¥5¦e õö°GX ©ªÄÅ4Æ X~ øùúX° ¯| +'§'"+1¨'6©ª7¦e 7 p 6Å «O};¡¬¥5e®6G ¥Ò65GX ¯ z¤¸wxXÝ ©ªNÝvx NO°GX } ±z²³7´o ²³´oYZ ¤X· ¸ #+µ%-¶ !¹,)/6º» ¼½¾#!¹,)/6¿Àe²³· 7>7Áe z ¿Mé ? Gûüýþ ô9Ýv ¯ 6bXG & ¿M éªÄÅ4ÆX~ 6q ¥Ò 6p a6e öz9c ¯ ö ªp 6ÄÅ4Æ6p~> p ÄÅ4Æ6ÄebP ©ª QP|X PQPÄ c¯e!¹,)/6º»¼ >¯e k Á( (¯R)[&'ÃÄ{Å !"# '")[{(],"F,Å(³W´ $%&'()*+,-."/0' µbt(^)ÆÇÈɹ1%<"ʾ &$1(12 Ë1 345651$748565(( [(ÌÍ^'¹1<)hi(Î7)ÏÐ 97):;<=>?@(AB ©*+,-.®<7Ñ R)^% C<$1DE?@($ &< 'ÒÓ&*+,-.®< 1)FGH??@"IJ(KL ÔÕ1¾¿Ö"1565×" $1D%&ML" N ?*+,-.(ØÙ1$7 ¢ (OPQ"/0'&$1"R) ³µ¢$ ')[<RÚ S$TUVWXYZ[&'( r)ÛSr1Ü,Ý(0)*+Þ ")2\]^'/0_`'&$1abc (9ßÞà¹1áâãfgdP 03*+,-.de/0$1( ØÙäB$( ')hi(*+F( 1fghi"%&'(j(kl Î7)åæÔÕ (1 mS$no pq7r1s t%<uv&w)x yz(*+,- .{t|R}Z^7)hi(~( 1 ,ç2 3)èé2 3) êMë2 " 3(ì$$7) d7)*+F "M_ vwíî[(ïðñ(9òó$1 &1ab$)X 2 %3^»7)[& 2 3'(u) 'ôõö÷ø 1$7õù÷ø U5 )èé1$7êMë r&wúû 2 !" 3 $$<%|R2! # "$ 3 $7°(üý"),çþ_&1þ ¡¢£¤2 $ 3(¥¦ t æ)Ñ 1¡(*+,-. §,r1¨©Qª«$12% ø6)øt< &3\]^'¬_&)1$7 %s1 (® ^¯'° "±r²&' Âvw)(*+,-.7Ó< &1ab) 7^)1$7 ^)<$Ú&1%<"1")%&7* %&$( R)³W´µ +,-.[((")H?Q_&9ßÞ <¶·¸S%¹%<"1%(ab) (>(1$7[(9 º$ 7»¼½¹1%<" $ ûþR)F'(ܾ¿Ö $$<%|R¾¿¹107)À N¹1þt _&%<þæ µLµ/012 !"#$%&'()*+,- !" # $ 3 4 ( % ) 2 # % % §¨©ª«¬y®¯°±²³´µLµ¶· ¸V¹º»´¼½º¾5¿6À5 </012=$34>[email protected] 57ÁTL !8<=(* B(CDEFGHI0J( *KLMN<OPQ% STUVGWX%(7"YZ[\] ÂÃÄÅÆ´~ ÇÈÉÊËÌÍÎFG ÌJB˺ÏÐÑÀ ÒÓÔÕÖ×ØÙ²´JÚÛ¢ÜÝË!¥Þß ^_à¦e˺áâãäå6À ^_`abcd#e`f`WXg æZ[«KTç⶷¸V¹"èF»éêë WXhi&jk)>lm( n ìíVîT²´KTç⶷¸V¹ï >>op7qr:$spt( pFp' ^_àP0ðñWXjkºéêëì G>WX$uvw`i&x-WX íVîTÀòó yz%(7"{|}~+P7{ |><op7it( ./01234$56789:; . R /012"¤F " " ôõæö«KTç⶷¸V¹^_à:» éêëìíVîT÷øòó ùú«îû=/012=» üZÙùÖ t(*s Ï°ý²´=¸þ¸cbº 7iP $)* áâãäåÀòó $-*" ZæÖ« Çi&¶ãä¸ 67 ¡$¢£*(*¤ !¥$ V¹»²´!¥FG¶ãä¸V¹BË :;p7( Ñhf`i&˺` hÀòó ! " # $ %& '% ( $ ) ))$ **+++ , *-.)%* !*" / # $%*+$' $0)P¦# 1..2 1 % ¯°±«Ç.Ç$¢,¶·¸V¹ $ 7» ²´µLµ¶·¸V¹º Àòó % &' " ( 5 ' " ! " !# " $% ! % %$ $ ! & $' %$ $ " $" ! ( $ ! % # " $% " $%$ ) $ !* $' ' $ ! ' $ $ !# " $ % ! $' ' $ + % , ! $ %' $% $% $ %$ ! % % % $ " $ ! % " " & "- . "/% $!
© Copyright 2024 ExpyDoc