ȍŊQLđƓ9 ɅŊ˗ǤJみ^ ˒̕ G ȼ= űěĮȠĕƾɛLɹɃ˗Ǥ 1

63
ř Ź á ÿ
Vol.34, 2012 ʵ 3 Ř
ȍŊQLđƓ9
ɅŊ˗ǤJU^˒̕Gȼ=
űěĮȠĕƾɛLɹɃ˗Ǥͥ
Ɛ̟ ̭ 1) *ŇɡǚƢ 1),2)
A Look at Human Body Structure,
Obesity and Thinness in Fine Art (1)
―Figurative Art of Upper Paleolithic Stone Age (I)―
Haruka SASAKI, MD, PhD1) *, Shuzo KUMAGAI, PhD1)2)
( Journal of Health Science, Kyushu University, 34:
*C.\ÛǦF“…”Mǁ˵LɍƜL̯̾Y·
- , 2012))
̛3,4)*3
̖b̡*ƭW^“ȍ”GI]*CHL[+J9E˗
ǤG*+õʶMɨș9?LF)`+ 1,2)ȴŪŲX˶
ƼX̗˄ɟLȩƪȍ͍JGBE“˗Ǥ”Gș0?“ũ
DŽ”LĊJMʲÛSHLĵòȯXɍƜ9I.B?[+
JƯa_^
ȍ͍ȌÙL͒ƪ*1 M-[>̦ 600-700 ̔ʵȱJd’
§lɴÕ˫€ †i€k‘d~¬vˆdLɜɮ
Žɘ(Great Rift Valley).\ʂ̓ʭɉ̄ſbM:WĴʃ
ȴȩG9EL͍ȍÓu•¦¬…ª”y.\ƭTB
?>LűĝLÔ2I^[+IʵŘbŏE(Out of
Africa)*2Ȏ 1
ĴɍGƲ˵._bň]̀9I/\Ŧ
ȍ˜Ÿ¨yĕ̳Iȍ
˜Ÿi©p…gy
Ȏ#d’§li€k‘dJEũșȍLȴȩLÙȠ
Įȍ˜ŸŒf„¨–¨r¬wyJȌÙ34 ̔
˄šb̆:^Nature, 2003, Jun []
ʵ°ƂJ¥ªŽdxdQG÷Ƥ9ʹ̱ȡLɜ
ŊÙGĴJȆșȍ͍Ȇȍ˜Ÿu‘i¬yŢ*
șɍL?WJˢßŔF)B?ȠĕɕȠĕIHY
…
˜Ÿ’c–¨ŷƞ;^ȍ
"Šd¬„
˪ĕʕȻĕIHbȷƞ;^ŷʆF[]˱ơIX
¨~©wypª›ˆk¬ȍQGȆ9*©–¨L
LbC2]@;ĤǤbǙʥ9ǔǤʉIĞ]GĔ*b
ɜȌÙbȒ4?LF)^u‘i¬yL˃˄ȍ͍þ
w¬™¨G9E˝ũ9[]ʩʉIȚȊL˄͔G9?
1) ŀǘɜÿřŹáÿ{¬~ Institute of Health Science, Kyushu University, Kasuga, Japan
2) ŀǘɜÿɜÿÈȍĊćĵÿ˧ Graduate School of Human-Environment Studies, Kyushu University, Kasuga, Japan
*Corresponding author. 1-2-6-1202 Momochihama, Sawaraku, Fukuoka City, 814-0001, Japan.
Tel. & fax: +81 92 822 1735. Email address: [email protected] (H. Sasaki)
ř Ź á ÿ ɝ 34 Ą
64
LF)`+
F)^
Ȏ 2 M˜©’h¨yL­e‡y(Venus of
Hohle Fels)ɃF)^íL[+J„˜¨ž7_?ÛG
X?2T92ș̛͋JÃ_ȶ̐F͋Ķ*’j¨
(Form)LǬȖɃF)`+9.X5LǰɃMǐdzJ
ǖT^ɜ07ILF)^ɯȤIŷł9.ɍƜ9I.
B?ȩƪƾɛ(prehistory)J..^ũɛ˗ǤG9EXɑ
ȁLI*ɹɃbƞ]ǻ4^ŦƭȍLȹɃ͋Gɭʉʸ͋
JMĺɣ;^ɒMI*
Ȏ 3˜©’h¨yʣņ
ʫȝ†f‚g¨[] 20km Lw¢§p§¬r
¬SchelklingenL Ach Valleyq¦­ei…
›†©‰ěLɮȸ[]I^
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hohle-Fels)
Ȏ 2 M˭ťɃF)^/̈džȖɤȶʵɛ̊ (newly
calibrated radiocarbon timescale)őŴţ˖˵ȟJ[BE
5_TFƖXŭ*ȍŊɹɃG7_E*?­e©¬†
Ȏ 2“˜©’h¨yL­e‡y”Ƀ
¨’­e‡y(Venus of Willendorf 1908Ȏ 5)[
BC 35000-40000 ,›¬ŸyLçȜƃ7 6cm
]źJ 7 ȪʵĿ2ŭ*Ġťȱ 3 ̔ 5 Ȫʵ.\ 4 ̔ʵȱ
†f‚€¢¬r¬ɜÿɄ
LXLGȐʄ7_?ƒŠ͚MŔɏ9E*^/ˮ
˶ŝ 4,5Nature 459, 2009 []
Ÿ*ŠÆ0ʇTB?˰˫·ȎʉJŰɸ7_?İɜ
Iʰ̌GỤ̑MĩƢùŋJɜ02ÉȄTF§d¨J˝
2009 ʵ5 Ř 14 ʯƄLNature
459 Ą 248, 2009
ũ7_E*^­e©¬†¨’L­e‡yɃG͍
5)
ƸǻJ†f‚€¢¬r¬ɜÿLžŭÿljˆs¦
ƻ9E*^/ʝ˫MɍƜ9I*V9`ʝ˫JȽʗ
ys‡†Nicholas CornardMȍ͍ƖŭLȍŊ
;^˫²M͌৬qǾǾbǀ9ƨ̳7_?Ə
b˝;ɹɃb˄š9?Gɶ̠;R0͗˶b˄˝9?
ȣbʴW^5G[]Šp©yǓǿ]F)B?
ɻʯȆ˷2009, Apr. 15bM:WȳƈƳ~fz
GXž,\_^ȋɖbǿ^5GMʗƾ.\ȍĊL̸
Caveman with passion for carving turned tusk into
īLÂCF)B?T?ʰ̌bĎVĸ˫.\˰˫ʿ
ªyd¬xh¨y~f
world’s earliest pornography
˫J.3EʀɥLÖɁ;^ƆȯMʗƾL»˯.
zVenus figurine sheds light on origins of art by early
Û.ȋɖb˲+XLF)B?L@`+.ŭɛo§w
humansIH{¬{fw¤‡¨I˝ɞFŸ2̆:\
LȍŊ“l‹¬(canon)”*4 JMʆÔ*”ªšw¤¬
_”NatureLancetƸJXɓ2Lsž¬…/ė
FØƴMɥ2ːúʉˡnj˔ɗǶȖJ˝ũ7_͚M
=\_?
6-8, 14)
ʰ̌LØJʍ,\_ǐưX 5 I*9 4 ̒GMB0]
ʫȝ†f‚Lg¨UlmĿƀL˜©’h¨
GƆU5T_E*^
yʣņȎ 3FʱŶ.\̦ 20 mɮØ 3m Lw¨
ʠ½ȣL˄ŅɾƔM 1990 ʵ°̻ũƜI-ŐɌ7_
…ʷʓǃLɮȸ.\ʀ*ʵŘLĊJɲăȁJ˼
E-]ĿȥLy«¬d(Swabia)½ȣbĎW^Gȕ
ȁ96 ŬJ˵ë7_?ǾəF˄š7_?LF)^
òƖŭL’¨…̲LƊȜĀĕ›¬ŸyȜˬȿˠ
›¬ŸyLçJɹƆ7_?XLG9EXƖŭL“ʟƥ
˕͡ɴLʁȎ 4A
…‡lfʣŕқ¬ŸyI
*4
ŒǤ( portable/mobile art” JɊ;^ƃ7 6cm LǰƟɃ
HǒLʟ˴Ɗ˽JÞ,¦fk¬L[+Iʝ˫b̮
ȍŊQLđƓ9ɅŊ˗ǤJU^“˒̕”G“ȼ=”(1)
;^͞ȍˇȍˇ͞¦fk¬ȍĊLɃȎ 4BI
HɓȔL½˴/˄š7_E*^
9)
65
ƻ Kostienki-Willendorf Culture10)ʗƾL˅Ŋ.ɀ
9.95Lʵɛ
ǿȖLʝľ)^*M–¨[+LXLb˓BE-]
°ȱJMMB0]G9?ȍŊɹƆɃM˄š7_E-\
ʪW*?Ŧƭ̢̲bƯa=^˝ũF)]ƃ*ŒǤȖ
<ĮȠĕűěǧ옟u‘i¬yŠd¬„¨
ʗƾL˶ÙʉIəʒYy~f¨b˝ũ9?ßʸȖ
~¨ȍ
k§dp˶ÙJɊ;^XLGž,\_
10)
?5_\Â͓L½˴L˄šM5LƾěJȍ͍Lƃ
IHLłɖʉIē̎M˞._E*I*Ẩ͇͚M
ƿĜʸ/ÂɪGƃ*©–¨JȌÙ9?5Gbǀ9E*
ˡnjI˂*©§’F͚͌bɳ3E˝ũ7_ɔ*
^s‡†ˁƬM†‡g(Daunbe)ãLǻͅɮÀM
ɜɚJː9͇ĨMɥ2˙ċȧǺôbXƧa=^ 17)
bǀ9E*^Ȏ 56
·ȎʉIXL.đ˘Ŷ
þȆʉI“˗ǤLĢŨ”F)^GGXJĮȠĕƾɛL
˗ǤLƭŦGõʶGbȆ9*ƶʎFƕśʛ;^˚̷Ȗ
/)^G9E*^
Ȏ 5“­e©¬†¨’L­e‡y”Ƀk§ˆ
dpq¦­ei…ě(BC 30000-25000
ky…§dgf¬ƈ̓ǁȲˁ˴ČA:
Ǭ Ȋ L 5 5 ` 2000 B: Medicine All
Illustrated History; 2004 []
Ȏ 4
Aȑʁ(water bird)
Bˇȍˇ͞Ƀ(Felid and man)
(Nature, 2003 bï˼[])
­e©¬†¨’L­e‡yȎ 5Mȩƪƾ
ɛL­e‡yɃG9EMƖX[2ɭ\_đJ;^
ĜêXɓ*ƞˠF)^1908 ʵky…§dL†‡
gãJĿ*­e©¬†¨’½ȣFʠƈLžŭÿlj¥
|’}¬ƒeJ[BE˄š7_?ƃ7 11.1cm
LȠñĒbÐ̽IȠĕFŅB?GƯa_^ǬȖɃF
ȸǭÿʉIëȟ[]k§ˆdp—¨t¨˶Ù
ěBC 25000-20000
ĠťȱL˜Ÿu‘i¬yJ[
^ȷƞGž,\_?˄Ņ7_?ɮÀFMǣʓ9I*
g¦f…IJ̼ȠñĒbȶƝG9Ȣȁkl
–¬m¦FȢăȁJȭW\_E*?5GMʦºI
5GF)]9N9N“ŏŗ”L˝ǹG7_E*^
ʗ
ƾĚJÔý̫ɂ)^*Mų¸Lwyƒ/ɍƜ9E
*?5GbƧa=^ɔ*ɜɚG͢˫ʰ̌Mɷ92
Űɸ7_ͣXɜÉȄXMB0]G˝ũ7_E*^
ʝ˫MɍƜ;^/̹ȮǾL̞̲7 CLȸJIBE
*^F˞._ªwd, Kostienki L­e‡yGX͍
Ȏ 6­e©¬†¨’©”§lɃbö„ž¬x¤
¬.\ɽW^(ǁŤ͎)
ř Ź á ÿ ɝ 34 Ą
66
Űɸ7_ȗǢ9?ȖʉʦɺGːú9Eē̎ƫƴ
>LXLL˝ũMɒLɹɃbĎWːúʉĈ̈́Ù7_
E*^
1-3, 10)
!1ɓɮÀȌÙȨGd’§lĠŨȨ/)]ɓ2Lȍ
©”§lɃbö„ž¬x¤¬.\ĉEU
͍ÙȠL˄š'(&ëȟŖâ[]űljLȨ
^G[]Ķɾ7_^˫²/ºIBE-]ÉÍb˞
/̮͋F)^ȍ͍ŎʙǕJC*EMȆ9*
18)
LɅƞ
ÙȠL˄šʵɛɈʄ̊LȌ̄½ʏƮëȟI
F)^5G/̾ëF0^Ȏ 6
ŪŲ>LXL/̗˄
HJ[]ʯȆ9*ƺDŽÚȨ/ʅǯ7_E*
ɟF)B?5GJÞ,Ŭ˻ʉIǸɃG9EL·̖M
^(Nature 423(Jun.12)742,2003.Science 331(Jan.
I2ĴʠɖLÂȍb̋ͤɓƥȃĻƮɎLˋÎ
28): 329, 2011 etc)T?Ƌʵ201111 Ř 3 ʯ
̅ŎLjêLʀ)^*Mɮ̅ȊǬȊb˝ǹG9?
ʑƮˊ Nature ƸJ 45,000 ʵȱũșȍ͍MŠd
0̓ɖȖÔĿ̊TFXǏ]ʱ_?ɓɴȅȖ
XLF)`+
2,12)
Â˫J˜Ÿu‘i¬yLȖʉI
ń·bXB?Đłsexual toyiª€pIƞˠ
¬„¨~¨ȍLĴɍ/̆Ƈkpy’j†
ɜÿ7_?
erotica)^*MŭɛLɅŋʉš¨‹q¦’e
șȀĕȓʼ 10,12)ʳ˥˵̂ʂűLłɖɃ 7,8)IHbȐ
!2ǧěȍ͍/d’§lbɠǣ9£¦wdɜ́öɮ
ʄ;^ÿljX*^/˜©’h¨yLǰɃbĎW
JǝUC0ȌÙ9?ɠǣLʵɛYŦÅJC*
Ȗɺ/Ķɾ7_E*^GM*,ǎĉʉIƯ͆JŔ3
EXǫȨ/^d’§lĢŨȨ
^šëF)^
7,13-15)
DZI2GXƙ͠Yģ͐°óLʤł
G9ELŵ͂ʉĜʸʉIXLG9EɅƞFMI*5
!3pª›ˆk¬ŦȍM¥ªŽFșT_?ȆȍF
GMʠ½ȣJ̑HɢÂɖG9E9.ǣʓ9E*I
)^G7_E*?/ƖĿFXª¬†¬ɜÿL
*5G.I]LƾĊʉŏåLI.FƆT_?ƟɃF
ɾƔ[]d’§lĢŨbǀ;ÙȠ˄š7_12
)^5GIH.\X̜\F)`+ĮȠĕƾɛűěJ
̔ʵȱJd’§lbɠǣŠd¬„¨~¨ȍ
ʴW^ǰɃM̑H/ǬȖ̺ɃF)]’hœˆz
Gųˀ/)B?ßʸȖ/̆Ƈ7_?(Nature
xh¬žŭÿljJ[BEǞ̻[]œ92Ħ͗7_
2011 ʵ1 ŘƄ)>LǣũYșɍʵɛJC*E
?5GF)^/
15)
Ǒ͉ƘǏ̙(hunter-gatherer/forager)
Xọ̈̄àLĊFǫȨ/)^
LjêFMǬȖLɮ²Mːúʉƃ2DZI2GX˸ʘ
ǬȊȓʼ)^*Mà̅ʀLjê(imatriarchy)*6 F)B?
!4ʧ̓9?ȠYƊùFȷ\_?čɹɹƆY5_\
GXȐʄ;^GǬȖ>LXLL“˗”G“Ŝ¶”(beauty
JƱ7_?ȁƗèȯƆè˩ɹIHLǰ˗Ǥ
& prestige)bw¬™¨G9E˞*?Gž,^̉/21
̰̀Ʌ˴
ȕĠJș0^æũɛȍGBEMª›¬bŁ]̓E^
[+JƯa_^>X>XȐɈGMžŭÿʉIƺ
!5Ġťȱ 5 ȕĠo§w LɹƆàš§p©…y/
DŽYƖȆLɭšJĖD2GʠƾJĉ^ȍLąȖY˗
ȍɖː͎LŸ„¨G9?űȕFM©k‡¨
·ǂÝɬąIHș0E*^ƾɛJµKEXı7_
†¬€L“l‹¬”/̮̚F)^
^5GL[+JƯa_^˹ƈLȊ͙ÿŞĭljk
yƒf¬fq¨Œ¨…
16)
M̚ɷ“ǬȊL55`”
LI.F5_\LǰɃb“­e‡y”GM˵͍=<
!6ǬȖ/)\Z^̝FǽJ̬²J²ɰ9Ŝ͋b
ƽAɫȖbǻì^Ŝ¶b̮;^Ljê
³ɜI^”ǬȊ”GŮP5GbĶɾ9̅I^ɮĬm
f¡L[U/,]L?WJ>9Eș0XL;R
E/ɇD2ǬȊL?WJGƷʉIŪ̶bˣġ9E*
^?@ŭɛLŧ9*ǁȲćĵLI.F..^ɿ
˒̕lj/ğF)BEXɍƜ9?.JC*EMũɛL
˒̕ŞĭLȗâGGXJźI^ÿƛʉIśʛ/˚̷G
ž,\_^
8,14)
?@̋̕Iʮɖ̋ͤ/ʗƾLĶ
*ʢ_GĔ*LɗǹF)B?5GMĊ¼*I*
1) żǻʺˤ(1995)˗ǤLɨșʖijɜÿǣˊê
pp.1-10
2) ̟ɐǠȃ(1999)˗ǤLƭŨ̟ɐǠȃɷƞǜɝ
ÂĄƯȹüǣˊ, pp.3-42/429-452
3) x¤¬˜’hl¬(ʚŦɓÜˤ̧(2011):ȍĊL
˴Ų˜ãƾɛɮĬ͏ħLwyƒG…Gʟ
ȍŊQLđƓ9ɅŊ˗ǤJU^“˒̕”G“ȼ=”(1)
67
˴L˴Ų“¦fd¬’hfm¬˾ɷ
̭ǪČʖ
16) Œ§kyƒf¬fq¨Œ…̥̃Ġ
ijpp.92 – 141. (Brian Fagan (2009): The complete ice
Ʈ̧(2000):ǬȊL55`ũɛƯɼȆLjpp.
age. Tuttle Moni Agency, Tokyo)
28-.31 (Hallie Austen Inglehart (1990): The heart of
4) ŽŶ̬Ʃ(2011)d’§lFɨș9?ȍ͍/ʯ̒ȍ
JI^TF}’…¬pȆǪpp.190.
the goddess. Arrangement with Wingbow Press)
17) Brown PJ (1992): The bio- cultural evolution of obesity:
5) Conard NJ (2009): A female figurine from the basal
An anthropological view. In Obesity, Björntrop P and
Aurignacian of Hohle Fels Cave in southern Germany.
Brodoff BN (eds). J. B. Lippincoff Company,
Nature 459(7244; May 14): 248-252.
Philadelphia, pp.320-329.
6) Mellars P (2009): Origin of the female image, Nature
ɃȍŊL˗ǤƪTI89LÆ͋ĒʺǪʌ
459(7249; May 14): 176-77.
7) McDonnell A (2009): Ancient ivory figurine deserves a
more thoughtful label, 459(7249; 18, June): 909.
8) Spitzer M (2010): A further look at obesity. Lancet,
376(October 2): 1144.
9) Conard NJ (2003): Palaeolithic ivory sculptures from
southwestan Germany and the origins of figurative art.
Nature 426 (6968; December 18/25): 830-832.
10) Jennett KD: Female Figurines of Upper Paleolithic
(2008).University
Honor
Program.
Paper
74.
http://ecommons.txstate.edu/honorprog/74
11) n u§¬“¦p§xʚʐȉ̽Ʈ̧
(2005)ȕòLĢŨ­co‡L̙ɋ˶Ùƪã
ǣǪ̌ȆLjpp.56-90. (Catherine Blackedge (2003):
The story of V. Opening Pandora’s Box, Crion
Publishing Group Ltd.).
12) §€ †¦x§®Ŧ͘ş̌(1999)ɝ#
$Ƿ­e‡yǰɃ—Ȗ̸Lɗǹ.w¬™¨.
ȠĕƾɛL˶̜Lĺºȍ͍ƪLʪbë2ãǣ
Ǫ̌ȆLjpp. 263-284. (Richard Rudgey (1998): Lost
civilization of the stone age. Ardrew lownie Literary
Agent, London)
13) d¬–d§¬qx¢¨zn w¢’j
†ȇéƮ̧(2007)ȕòǬȊɜȳŦǧLǬȊ
.\o§w Ȋ͙TFŦǪ̌pp.1-51.(Anne
Baring & Jules Cashford (1991): The myth of the
goddess evolution of an image. Penguin Books Ltd.,
London)
14) Haslam D and Rigby N (2010): The art of medicine, A
long look at obesity, Lancet, 376(July 10): 85-86.
15) ›m©…i©¬q(ãƅȃ̧͘)(1997)
ȩƪƾɛLǬȖxh¬žŭÿƺƭWãǣ
Ǫ̌ȆLjpp.13-22/100-117. (Margaret Ehrenberg
(1997): Women in prehistory, British Museum Press,
London) .
18) ɴɐÏǕ(2011)ɝ 2 Ƿ˵ĘʭCL­e‡y
pp.20-52.