Chapter 9. Research Methods for Alternative Approaches to Transfer – Implications for
Design Experiments
Joanne Lobato
Rep. ħĥ ř
Introduction
} Ėƈ+„øŝ#‚Ī+Şĸ,Ĥ®*ÜB ŎÞ+ĬŽÕ&8useful )ÜƄżǓAđ˜
='
} ÜƄ+ƌ¹(generalization of learning),_SF|ßǓ*
%8ǀƓ)FTu~
} Ʊŧĵü*4#@=ĜńƦ=
,ŔƦŝ)Èǐ*:<ÜƄ+ƌ¹*DŽ=ŔƘ9Ĕ
Ē*#
%,Dž;>ŢũƐ@>%
)
Theoretical Perspectives on the Transfer of Learning and Design Experiments in
Education
} ³+ paper &ŢũƆ+ĉ#Ʊŧ+t_y+Ïì*=ŔƦŝ³đ_SF|ßǓAŜç
=+*òǏ%
='
'AĊē%
=ǕLobato 2003ǖ
!
Classical transfer approach
"
Ʊŧ',subjects ®Ĩƥǐ'Ķƶŝ*Âķ)ZVMAļƐ='
"
ßǓ*:"%ƱŧƬ"+Ƭ"%
)
+AĞ;*=ƕŲŝ&
)"<incorrect performance ')":)ŎÞ+ƌ¹AÂÞ)
Ǖ2B;
, negative transfer =,)+*
"8+AƹåƟš%ƱŧƬ
"',Ɣ))
'8=ǖ
"
ŽĮ'%44)ÜƄżǓ+ƌ¹*DŽ=_~ZA–@*KxLuwr+
revision Ɛ@>=>,Ʊŧƥǐ*ł"8+* instruction AÔ='
Ā
úŁÞ*#)=
!
Actor-oriented transfer approachǕLobato 2003, 2007ǞLobato & Siebert 2002ǖ
"
žˆ+ÜƄƆ+ƌ¹k{XVAŔƘ:'=Dk{~\
"
ƌ¹Aœ:) instructional environments +ƓŹAŽ/#:'=
"
DŽ›þAº­Ơ4'7%KxLuwrĖī9 pedagogical approach +
revision *ņ
Transfer Methods and Design Experiments
} +Ŭ&,Ʊŧ+XJx~_SF|+ĀúŁÞ*òǏ='ƙ'A44)Ʊŧ+
ƔĜ+„&–@>=ŢũĜń*ŅŞ%ƨƦ=
!
Classical modelsǝßǓƚŚń*:<ƱŧAŇÞ=
!
Actor-orientedǝHVdNwiE]M)Ĝń*:=
"
ś)=ĜńƦŝDk{~\_SF|+ĀúŁÞ+7*–_~Z+ĩƫ*òǏ
=
1
"
?
?)Dk{~\¬%%
=+*>;+Dk{~\AľƲ%ģ>
8+æ)
!
Part Iǝ5 #+Ʊŧ+ƔĜ;ĜńƦAęŔ=
!
Part IIǝactor-oriented transfer AƜǂ:'=„&Ŗ4> 2 #+ŢũĜń*#
%ź‰
Part One: Relationships between Theory and Methods in Transfer Models
} 5 #+Ʊŧ+ƔĜ
!
classical / actor-oriented
!
transfer as preparation for future learning (Bransford & Schwartz 1999)
!
the affordance and constraints approach (Greeno et al. 1993)
!
transfer as consequential transitions (Beach, 1999)
>>+ŔƦŝ}ĜńƦŝ)Dk{~\IJƛ=Ʊŧ+ǁ9ƫ*ä%(+:*òǏ
=+AęŔ=
How Research Methods Influence Transfer Definitions
} Þƃ
!
Classical approach
"
Transfer is defined as the application of knowledge learned in one situation to
another situation
!
Actor-oriented
"
Transfer is defined as the generalization of learning, which also can be understood
as the influence of a learner’s prior activities on his or her activity in novel
situation (Lobato, 2003, 2007)
Þƃ,‘%
=:*Ɣ=ß,Ĝńƺ
} Ĝń
!
Classical approach
"
Initial task ' transfer task Aʼn£=>;,Ķƶŝ*,ǒ‘%
=Ƒǎ
ŝ*,ś)"%
=
"
Initial task A)Ƃcontrol group :<8 transfer task &:
performance
&>-ÜƄżǓ+”;+ƾ­Aƌ¹8+'5)
!
Actor-oriented
"
HVdNwiE]M)Ĝń&³+DM^Eg^E;+òǏAŤÇ=8+A
ƒ;>DM^Eg^EAŵį%IJƛ=ƒ;>ě
ŏŃ'¦ƐŏŃ
*=ĝÛĵü'(+:*ďž+Ǖthe process of “similarity-making”
&)ŏŃ+ƺ
AƔĴ7<ŏŃAÔ='
'8Å6ǖAIJƛ=
2
How Transfer Definitions Affect Research Methods
} Affordances and constraints perspective
!
Classical transfer model D~^EiCM`9ťĚ¹ŝŕÒAº­ƤĞ%
)
'
Ą¯;Ŗ4>
!
Þƃǝtransfer as the extent to which participating in an activity in one situation
influences one’s ability to participate in another activity in a different situation.
(Greeno et al. 1993)
"
žˆ*‚Ô+8+&,)ķ)Ĝń&D~^EiCM`9ˆ'F|ZwMTv
|=Ɖ´'%Þƃ
"
Ʊŧ=7+‚Ô+ affordance 9 constraints "%ÜƄƆ>*Á@=
ñ& transform ='&Ʊŧăū=
#
affordance 9 constraints A­ĭ=7*ˆ+ņ¸+HVdNw
iE]M)¡ǎ&ƤĞ:'
Relationships Among Methods and Other Dimensions of Transfer Theory
} +Š+Ʊŧ+ƔĜ'ŢũĜńƦ'+DŽ›A'* RQ +ū%Ĝ'Ʊŧ+k{XV(&
Ƭ=+'
¡ǎ;IJƛ=
How the Nature of the Research Question is Related to the Methods
} actor-oriented )ƔĜ&Ɛ@>HVdNwiE]M)Ĝń'PFL Dk{~\*=ßǓŝ
Ĝń'AľƲ
!
PFL Dk{~\,classical transfer Dk{~\ˆǃ real world &,ŏŃAĦ·*
–"%ÈǐƘŁ='AŋƖ%
='*ŠŞ%Ɛ@>%
=
"
+:)ßǓŝĜń&,
(+ĬŽƱŧAœƸ'
RQ AĎũ=+
*,Ä
%
=
"
actor-oriented transfer Dk{~\,
ÜƄƆŏŃAƭ%ǒ‘þA(+
:*Ɣ
%
'ŕÒǒ‘þA(+:*Ķă%
='
RQ *–=
#
negative transfer A missing )
#
ļţ*ƙ-actor-oriented transfer Aċ='
',(positive &?
' negative &?')transfer +ŽĮAċ=+&,)ŏŃǃ+DŽ›þ
A(+:*Ķų+k{XV'% transfer Aċ='
'&
=
!
”Ʊŧ%
=+'
'A­ĭ=+,_SF|ßǓ*8ƇÞ
ŝ)ĀÆ=
3
How the Location and Nature of Transfer Processes are Related to One’s Unit of Analysis
} Beach(1999, 2003)+ consequential transitions perspective ' actor-oriented approach ,Ʊ
ŧAŵŦ}ō}Ě¹+ĿʼnAƯ
&­ė=8+'%ċ%
=­ĭ¼’*:"%(+
distributed phenomenon AŢũ+„&³ǎ*¬Ô@"%=
!
Beach +Þƃǝa transition involving the transformation of knowledge, skill, and identity
across multiple forms of social organization.
"
ŽĮ'%+Ô¹(transfer),žˆ9ťŝĚƊ+Ô¹&,)>;+DŽ›þ+
Ô¹'%ċ=
"
­ĭĜń'%ǝdevelopmental “coupling”
#
Ô¹=žˆ'Ô¹=ťņ¸A coupling =>, process +)&Ô¹
=8+'%ċ=
!
actor-oriented transfer perspective +ÑÁ
"
ƌ¹+ņ¸*44)”player”DŽ@"%
=Ǖžˆņ¸+DŽ›Ɔō¶
%>=ˆßư+8+ǖ
"
!
coupled unit &,)žˆzly'ťzly&­ĭAƐ
#
F|Zgu~_~Z&žˆ+ÜƄżǓ+ƌ¹+ĜńAÂÞ=
#
Ėà_~ZA–"%ťĶƶ+¡ǎA­ĭ=
­ĭ¼’ś)='&ƌ¹k{XV&eFwF`=¡ǎ8ś)"%=
"
actor-oriented +ÑÁžˆ+ƌ¹AƔ<+ƌ¹ťĚ¹ŝßư*:<(
+:*²Ŷ>%
=+AƔ=+*óū#
Part Two: Specific Methods Used in the Actor-Oriented Transfer Approach
} NwG|_E]a}XJx~*Ï$
ĜńƦ+đı
Method One: How to Establish Evidence of the Transfer of Learning in a Design
Experiment from an Actor-Oriented Transfer Perspective
} _SF|ßǓ+ĚƊ& actor-oriented perspective +Hg_|VA(+:*Ɣ
Structure of Claims
} ƌŝ*ƱŧƬ"'
'A actor-oriented perspective &
);-+:
)ƓŀAňùƓ
!
kz}oV`F|Zgu~;Ʊŧƥǐ*=ĵü9fiI~p|V*ĦĀ)Ô¹
5;>=
!
kzF|Zgu~+°ƥǐ9_SF|ßǓ*= early curriculum activities +fiI
~p|V*
%Ʊŧƥǐ+L~P|Xk`')=ĶăƓŹ2'B(5;>)
!
oV`F|Zgu~+Ʊŧƥǐ*=ÜƄƆ+ĐƦ'_SF|ßǓ„+Ā+DM^
Eg^E*=>'+ǃ*Ùð)ǒ‘þ+DŽ›ăū%
=
!
Ʊŧƥǐ*=ĐƦ+Ô¹,4"¢Ŝŝ*Ķă>8+&,)_SF|ß
4
Ǔ+ǃ*ÜB ''DŽ›%
=
Lobato & Siebert (2002)+ǔİŖAäƩ'P|hu~Zwn+ßư;4'78
+
Design of the Transfer Tasks
} _SF|ßǓ+kzǙoV`&Ɛ»Ķƶ¹F|Zgu~*=ƱŧƥǐA•=
!
Ķƶŝ*,_SF|ßǓ„*Ɛņ¸'‘%
=Ƒǎŝ*,ś)=8+
"
>,classical approach &8Â:*Ɛ"%
=
"
ƥǐ0+Dk{~\, 3 Ŋś)=
#
classical approach &,†7Ł7ŎÞ+ǒ‘þAÜƄƆơš=(
+5A5=actor-oriented perspective &,ÜƄƆ+ÜƄĠ+ŏŃ'Ʊŧƥ
ǐ+ŏŃA#)Ŏ÷ŝ)ĜńAĎũ=+*ƥǐA–
#
classical approach &,”transferor”ĝÛ+ƥǐ'+DŽƷþA«Ŗŗ=VZ
^E]M)k{XV'%ƱŧA5=actor-oriented approach &,Ʊŧƥ
ǐAƋ­š"%
=8+'ǒ‘8+*Ô='&ƘŁ=:)[F
bq]M)k{XV'%ċ=
#
classical approach &,®Ĩƥǐ'ƱŧƥǐÂŮ+ƒNJ+zly*=
+³đ actor-oriented approach &,>A³đ')
Establishing the Four Claims
(1) Ʊŧƥǐ+ĵü¹*=Ô¹=
kzǙoV`+Ʊŧƥǐ*=F|Zgu~+ªá;
(2) ‡³+DŽƷªášƧæ)
_SF|ßǓ+Ĥ®+ĽLJ&ƥǐ+ĵüŝŔƘ4&%
)
'Aţơ
(3) ǒ‘þ+DŽ›ÂÞ&=
oV`F|Zgu~'Âķ+Ĝń&ĐƦ&%
=—Ainstructional sessions + transcript
;­ĭ=k{`Py;¼ŷ*ÜƄƆŏŃ+ǒ‘þ*ƙ¾%
=+AƔ=+,Ŵ¼
Ʊŧ+ƤĞ&,ǒ‘þ+DŽ›A(Ķų%
=ÜƄƆ,"<'ƙ"%
)
'8ƅĂ=1&=ÜƄƆ+44)żǓA#)'Ùð)ĐƦ+‡—+Hg
_|VAlj7='*)=
(4) ĐƦ¢Ŝŝ)8+&,)
}ĘÜĖƈ+¦ƐŢũ;5%8¢Ŝŝ)8+',ƙ
nj
ăĮAƔ%
=
}_SF|ßǓ³+Ü´;5%¢Ŝŝ)8+',ƙ
nj
8+(
}¤'Ƶí+DŽ›þAĶųľ—+ĐƦ&=:*)"'Ƌ“¢Ŝŝ*Ƭ<
$;
5
Method Two: Coordinating Social and Individual Levels of Generalizing Activity in the
Actor-Oriented Transfer Approach
} Actor-oriented perspective ;ƌ¹+ņ¸+ťŝ}žˆŝ¡ǎAęŔ=Ĝń
} NwG|_E]aXJx~*Ï$
%<actor-oriented transfer +(+F|VZ|VĖà
ŕÒ+ƓŹ*:"%DiI~a><²Ŷ>%
=+AƤĞ='*:"%Method
One AĈï%
=
} _~Z,2 #+F|Zgu~_~ZǕ:&ŖõǖǗ15 É+ČijǕÀ 90 ­ĻDŽĘ+
ªáǖ
Phase One: Analysis of Individual Generalizations
} Ïĩŝ*,Method One 'Âķ
} ĀÌŝR|kx|N*:"%”;ƌ¹=;
ĖŤ;Ü3'%
ŖõAƼ/
»Ķƶ¹F|Zgu~AǕ36 ˆ„ 7 Ãǖ
!
"%:ʼn£%ăƀ8ƍMwV+ƨƦ*8½µ%âǐ8"<9
=ƋéűŔ+&=ŖõƼ->%
} F|Zgu~+ƥǐ, near transfer task ' far transfer task *)=8+AÅ6:*
} F|Zgu~Ż@";HLVf~`'%+³đAčdž%actor-oriented transfer
perspective ;Ŗõ+ĐƦfZ~|*ƒF|V`wMTv|+òǏAŤHg_|VA
Ď
!
'-Ú(8!ƒ;>şſ9ƑA;@7*y=mx+b +Œ@<*
y=x '
ĜŨîAģ
%<Ĥ®+ŪĺAVZ~`oF|`2 #7+ŪĺA”
##Ó=”'ƙ¾%
+Şū">,Ú(8!ĻĜŨîAy
,VZ~`oF|`Ʈ”
##Ó=”= x'%ƌ¹%
:*Ɣ=
!
2 #7+Ūĺ+Ÿ*#
%Ú(8!ĉ"%
=ŔƘA­ĭ=+*J~k|P~_
E|NA%5
ŢũƆ 2 ˆ&­ĭK^QxAŐū%•<
F|Zgu~1 + transcript
AP~_E|NËnj)‡—,ƨƦAƴ%­ǒAŁÞ©ƴ+K^Qx*ƝÞ
K^Qx+ÙðþA^V`=7*transcript +zgu~AƐ"%F
|Zgu~2 ;+_~Z*K^Qx~AƻŘ%ùƓ*û%K^Qx+ÔĢAƐ"
!
+­ĭAƴ%¤*,Ǜ#+ś)=ĀÆ='­"
>8+
ĀÆAÔ¹+ľŒ'%ċ8+&,)"Ǖè'%ċǖ
!
+ŽĮA Classical approach ;5>-transfer .(Øĕ%
='Ō‹;>
%4actor-oriented approach &,,"<'Ƥö´+=ƌ¹+ƞćA
classroom instruction +Ŏ÷A8'*Ğ;*='&=
Phase Two: Analysis of Features of the Instructional Environment
} Čij+g_JA­ĭǕNwG|_]aXJx~ǖ
} instructional environment ĀÌ(+:* 3 ZFk+ƣƘARo~`='*)"
+AƤĞ=7*­ĭ
6
} Čij+ transcript *#
%'*F|Zgu~&Şū"ĘÓ='
iz~W
Å4>=F|VZ|VAJ~k|P~_E|NŽĮ5 #+ĀÆƔ
>+!
ĘÜŝ*ļ
ŔƘ,ǚ# !
ƙƢ+ġğ=7Ėê,Ú(8!_EVK]Tv|&ľŒ+ĀÆ&ĘÓ
='
ƙƎA–"%
'ý"ßLj,è+ĀÆ&Ú(8!–"%
'
J\­"
} ;*Î*#
%_EVK]Tv|)>ÜŸ+HhY~aA formal )8+8 informal
)8+81%lj7€&¤*DŽ= 3 #+ƣƘ*#
%DŽƷ=HhY~aA>>
ljƚ
!
='=ƣƘ,NwiƚŰĹ+±Ř'DŽ›%
!
+ôNwiƚŰĹ*DŽ=HhY~aAJ~k|P~_E|N%ƚŰĹ+±Ř*
%(+:*ƣƘŖ+A­ĭ
} ­ĭAƁ<ƳĤŻŝ* axial codingǕÌ 9.5p.185ǖA%ǘǜ#+ focusing
phenomena "&44)è*Ú(8!ŅŞ='*)"'AĞ;
*
Discussion: Implications of the Use of Alternative Transfer Perspectives and
Methods in Design Experiments
} ģ
%=' actor-oriented perspective A–+ƍ >lV`'
8
+,ÛÍ)
} '- ethnographic methods ' experimental methods + trade-offs Aƅ%5=
!
experimental methods
"
PFL Dk{~\&,ŎÞ+ preparatory activities ƱŧƥǐAƘƉ´*ƒ=
·Į*#
%ÊĮAţŒƦŝ*ƤĞ={U]MAđ˜
"
ƗãƆ+ perspective *™='?×ÜƄ+ƌ¹+ŨíAƹåƟš%
=
¡ǎ=
"
Ʊŧ*'"%=‰§·Į=)
,
=>)(%)+
'
"Èǐ*,ů;>)
!
ethnographic methods
"
GTA ,ě
ĵü+Ķų9ĵüā+DŽ›AĎũ='&ëƃ*ÜƄ+ƌ¹A
ċ;>=
"
VO~yå)"<ŢũƆ+…ï9ƤĞAƌ¹=+nj)"<
ÙðþIJƞ:<8t_yĶų* =ƾ­=+njŊ
A Multistage Approach to Design Experiments
} _SF|Ţũ+py\V^~Ut_y+„&ĜńAƼĆ='8&=+&,
!
Multistage design model (Bannan-Ritland 2003, Holton 1998)
"
Discovery Stages
7
#
Informed explorationEnactment
!
Actor-oriented perspective Ä
%
=
"
ÜƄ+ƌ¹+ novices *:=k{XVAIJƛ=ĜńAđ˜
"
curricular materials 9 pedagogical approach A revise =ÿÐAđ
˜=7*Ú(8!+ÜƄ+ƌ¹AŢũ='*)=
"
instructional environments +Ŏ÷'Ú(8!+ĐƦfZ~|9f
iI~p|VAĵüŝ*Ž/#='&=
_SF|Ţũ+®ĨV^~U&)
(+:*+ƱŧƬ
=+'
ÊĮ+ƤĞ¿Ɖ*
"
Verification Stages
#
Local impactBroader impact
!
_SF|Ţũ+®ĨĽLJ&,ƕŲŝ=
,ļ
fiI~p|VAƱ
ŧ+Ċĸ'=+,ĖČßư*:"%(+:*ÜƄ+ƌ¹DiI~a
>²Ŷ>%
=+AIJƛ=7*8ƽ%
2:
!
ݨ*`wFDyV^~U*ŧ";_SF|Fdl~Tv|
4¸,)+&HLVf~`t_y*Ï$
Ʊŧ+ perspective 8
–'&= ?
"
classical transfer , broader impact phase *,:
"
Local impact A8;*,PFL +:*œßNj>ÈǐƘŁA
Å7ÜƄ+z_EcVAÌ=:*=+:
"
actor-oriented approach &lj7ÿÐA¥* revise instructional
innovations AßǓŝ*IJƞ<Ùðþ+ǔ
Ƙƿ*ą:)Ž
ƦAIJƞ=+*PFL Dk{~\,ƪő&=
"
Remaining Challenges
#
?
?)V^~U&_SF|ŢũA=*ð"%>>+V^~U&
44)ŢũAŽĮAĵüŝ*ďž=:*ŢũA=*,(>:
'
Èǐ
#
DXVs|`'Ţũ+_SF|discovery stages ' verification stages Aj
x]U&='ŭƆ,ƅ%
=
!
verification stages &, large scale &ǍƕŲŝ)Ʊŧ+‡—A8"'Ɵš
&=:) sophisticated techniques ùƓǕJ|wF|^V`'m
~f~^V`'ǟǖ
!
jx]UAƅ=*ð"%,experimental designs &ƅĂ>%
=
independent variables +Ö instructional approach 'DŽ›%
=
>;+ǃ+ interactions *#
%ƅĂ>%
)
+ÈǐǕŭƆ;+
focusing phenomena studies &,Ėê+DMTv|ĖČƓŹÚ(8
!ĘÜAŔƘ=*ð"%ǑƏ)ƓŹ'+ interactions ơ7;>
%
=ǖ
8

240KB

長期化する不登校児の社会参加支援