6. 欧米型制度枠組の導入プロセスとその組織論上の問題

A¢é,[óK26mtfeG>KóàZÞKKþ
(2),/5-#01&'%$"!#-+4*#3.
ï ÷
{
ö
#!+'",*
\1¹FL"
'
'
!7û¯9x·!‡¥#çÈ#<Ï#Ž›IHnkdpviK»J00\Y
â9-é,UÁóR]!A¢K*[ó(ls&ou&`)
+]ÕEG9EÊ%G269E2
?"
E´KJ)L!6ZWA¢Ké,[óK26I-9ÖPJC-E!>6JL\1¹’ŸK
¤}/éK*é,ªU+>KTK]QY1;óàZÞKü2IKþ1ð^F-Y6G]Å(;
Y6GJ,Y">ZWL¦9E!IY*[ó+KTRJGHQW<!\Z\ZKyèUõ&]
LY0J%/E!óàKäôJä¸I~ž]™P;">KóàZÞKKþ]«Ð)J!90T
ªU)Jµ¿;Y?SJ!x‚K$CKÆ+0W•×]æSY";I\A$
")>ZLHKV.ImtfeF268ZE2?K0!ÿ1HKV.J=™8=E2?K0!
#)5E’ŸL>ZWK*[ó+]HKV.JyFD4!-0IYÃêF269E2?K0!
$)A¢*[ó+K“ò]I;*@Øӗ+Kã01!\1¹Ké,ªU(E´L6Z]*@
Gӗ+G®N)J-0IY~ž]O/YK0!xÞK$+F,Y"
E´FL>KKþ]!"
'
'
!7û¯90W¾ QFJ–6B?$CKû;)I12!;I\A
*J-SOX+
*ISO+>9E*ë…Ó—çÈé,+JY8=I1WZ:Y"6ZWL-<ZT:
ÒÍå1ÍWù©9E2?TKF,Y1!3J*J-SOX+K26mtfe]$áJ•×]æS
E-3">ZLɔ1¾T 3!0CñÞ߇ÑJœé*R8Z?G-.yFFKé,~žK
ü28G!ºMGC:ÒÍå1M|G9E>K26Kñ³']ÍW"-9E2?6GJVY"
$!)(&%
*J-SOX+JC-EL6ZQFDüIWKèØ!ÀÇ!•È1±‰8ZE2?"909:Ò
K#Y­X>ZWL;OE!‡¥‹!‡¥Â!‡¥ceho£Kavbrgvi!>9E¼
¡UÚCKÆ+0WØ0Z?TKF,B?";I\AA¹é,K܆!26ÐH>"KKþ!
’Ÿ²4ú€njq_rG9EØ0Z?TKF,BE!ޕKKþyÎJ./YTKFI0B
?"¤}‹#óàZ(‡¥‹#¼Z]Ù3—)KVß0W*J-SOX+]ìI0WÔXÞ5
?šI-9ZíL!6ZQFKG6[:ÒJL!ÓSI¤}‹K§šØ#‹‡ÇU¤}
ÒK8¬IH]‘S!ƒ°L#½ï#˜÷(#
!
"
!)1>Ký"
"ÛF*4?/éG‡Ñ/Ë+]
BŒ)JZ:E-YK1NzKXŠF,X!øJ¬™;O2§šL¨C0BE-I-"6ZL
KþÈÝ173â9-G-.@4FI3!*J-SOX+1§šÒ0WTÐH„¤}Ò0WT!ó
àZKKþFLI3‡¥é,KKþG9EGW/WZE2?6G]wJÌ9E-YV.JÄ\
ZY"
ޕKƒ°L#½ï#˜÷(#
!
"
!)L!ºˆK\1¹K*4?/éé,+KKþ+G9E!
'%
&'
NUCB JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS
AND INFORMATION SCIENCE vol.56 No.1
#(Gf#·Œ3}.!$(hokF8ñ3-X@[CJ`fI,PGFW2HF.!%(•
kڞ0úꆇ\á,<X!&(.€ñ6GUWªþ0Gy%y\Žø:B.X@[š¤I
¢Q\Ù"‹<X!D./&A\Î/:B!>IHgòG¢.c\7726B.X"
:2:F3V[¹I˜íJ!>IU/G%4F©‡úêc&\?V:?)ñ6rú*3.2
FXqzgfCÖÃGš¤G=A9YB.@?I2!P?>Y3±h0GE/./c&\‚]
:B.XI2!>:B>YVJ¿µ.2FXˆ£\úêIïûGe0X8DGFXI2!FE
\úêq0GºÆ<X8DG-X"D5GA.&B÷GÖÃGÓV"°:?>I=Aqzgf
\8IÒ3CoôGœÝQõ<X8DJ!©‡úêqILDAI® ÄlD:B!.992I
ȺGFXCJF.2Dº0X"
P?!8IU/Fbz%ny'ŠT(›ÞIñ6~m>ISIG˜<Xc&‚ÔJ!À9#
É4'$
"
"
&(G1.Bîñ6CúêqIhqrú2V!¥RB¸ý0CV“0FhqujyD
:B29YB1W![¹S8YGM/ß3%4."D5G¿LDAIºÆ#äC-X)ISO*
GA.BS<àJ?M?M³Ÿ:!>IƒçFLŸNWGA.BJÇa'$
"
"
*(GãÂF® 3-X"8YVGA.BJ[¹IQõIF2C³Ÿ<X"
„X)óŒÚžðÑñ6*GA.BJ!<CG!5I® qS3*ö9YB4B.X":2
:F3V!.=YSp:©Á’F.:Jð0в–hq'HRM(Túê»;qIÏ32VI
qº3ÚC![¹Ib0IíGìYXSICJF2@?"
[¹Ic&‚ÔIíJ!bz%ny'ŠT(›ÞG#:)@[0©‡*I)S‹0>Üò*
T)`|g|i_p#efitI·Œò*FECJF5!©‡8ñ'F.:úê?dsvmc%
ew|(XYI)±h*D:BI)Sà*D)S^*\q;XD8ZG-X"8I)©‡8ñ*
I-WXG˜:BJ!‰ÿ'#
+
+
)$#
%
((\)©‡–hq*2VI„AI$I0¯D:B¡
7VYU/"<àJ)èW3Sà‹9YG5.@[š¤I>Õ!9VGJð—IefitI>
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
òGS22[V=!!5Iš¤”;\+qzbxtGúQ,
+rmv^yGà5,8DGA.
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
B!!5I5m3O[YF6YKFVF.*
'Z3J…fØ(D<X":2:F3V>I3G
A.BJ!ñ6±h0GS!©‡Ö_0GS!úêqåI%4Fc&3Ë9Y?PPC-X"
P?8YPC*ö9YB4?)@[0©‡q*G1.BS!)@[¶*I>Üò2V)@[
ðq*\º0XSI'Deal#
+
*
((T!@[IëæG16Xë_Q'Is\9\Î/<X® '™4 #
+
)
+$&
'&(!4+ #
+
*
*$*
+&+
#(J-@BS!>8G16X)Sà‹*>ISIIñ
60#±h0Fc&\q;?SIJOD]E`.U/GÍ[YX"[¹J>8\!S‹ðn’
T©Á’IF‘ñ6QõI)¯CU.F3V!)Sàڞ*D)S^ڞ*\ü#j<X©‡
8ñIñ6åI)±h*D:Bq;?."
#!%'"$&
!!&-,%"$#*+)',%'(
„EG)J-SOX*D´KYX)Å_W½G§X?N8ñW½ñ6*DJ!$
"
"
(B(¬Gñ9Y?î:.)¦dâJۅY*GU@B!$
"
"
*B&¬#@¼GÌ<XѤB62V!å
暤ù×G„i1f3ž_K6VY?î:.)«ÊW½ñ6*C-XD./I3!„E0F
hC-Z/"
8Iñ6J!>S>SJa|z|T{%yldtFEI%¨IRéÑ­G(\D:B!T¾
&&
*&
†J¤ñ-døF27mucaB:FøèbâFV!
01VM@ôûAñ(6;(_$nwa#[\ar$N&_Ý SOX N'
)B®HUTN^F6
P>!7DV=(J-SOX N)B6@!V0¶ANñ(5U;NFA*T"J¶AG7AE:F
ù/zõ/R!4,+,HçOÃF;MF4F0ñFñ-+DdøL0b5U@[email protected]!
~?E(COSO)BQHUT(gtfhYZX{€Œ#Á„øè{€Œ)
&Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission'0!"
'
'
#:E!(4F0ñE—7T0´+døL)
B+,LµÛW×6;"4U0'å(COSO Flt$ov$\)B®HUTñ-(dø)A!
V0¶F4F0ñbAN~•6@(4F0ñX^$s COSO)B+,JCF(ª|)B6@
ÓSxVU@1;FA*T"
¡YÜCӁNE(MTñ-F‚Zs$sB6@FV0¶F4F0ñFñ-døL0¢ü+
ERR/ED>;FG!#
!
!
&:"
"©#
"6!
(»QLµE£T4F0ñFB‰žI”·F™Ù)
&z
‡(™Ù)
'B!(1#ΙÙ)
&z‡(ΙÙ)
'0¯úyB6@=A5U@/RA*>
;"4F(™Ù)0E'F¼²Û_XbF+,B#
!K2R+!(ΙÙ)0'
!K"*V9@
"
"
!KW%-Tù/à¸DIÞA*T"'"
:4A¬>@+T4BG![7TEH稽O–}>;»Q§ïW=A6@!.Ŋ#“Í
Àä.QI]‘—£ÐEScW/3D+;ME!ÉFQ,E9QB+,4BA*T"
ÿ~E!¦ƒÐ&Ï&'GËÏF:-¨½F=AE*V9@!4F0ñ0X°Eš;6@+
T&HçOþ1D–}+GD+',E?1’éWÇ>@ýLµA1TQ,E!:FÏ4+D
0ñ&^wgu$s'F¾øLWó@6!:F‚ZæŸWeZf\9Q!B+,4BA*T"
:F¢ü+ÔÚB6@!¦ƒÐGK8(÷Ï+D4F0ñF¾øL)Wó@7T4B&ÎÂ
™ÙAG%
#FB‰³UWaÊ'
".QIÒ[DÆ F QmucaE?+@G!
( QF`Uî)
!
( QœØÛ).QI(ra\B0ñFý…)FA&+VPTIۈF($,cfg)
'Wa
Ê6@!:URF(IÛ)ARÊ5U;s$sE?+@!:Fó@æŸB‚ZæŸW(pjd
rw])6@&F‡E59@'
!:UA(þãD)B+,ëßW3;,-A!(4F0ñLµÛ)
W¨½=AÈEý+E)×9QB+,4BA*T"
ÿ5E!Ï&Ëì0+2R(þãD)B¬>@NFÐEGéZA1D+"K;Ï4F(”
·W)O(”·WŒ)Fé\òEN.F8/R­Ž0*T"Ö>@»Q”·W"/7TϐF
mulZf`qisA*T(”·Ní)F¯8Œ§¿0!»Q”·B1ÈE4F0ñF”·N
9Q":F¢ü+DOSMW!âœF(™Ù)
(ΙÙ)F(”·)FÞEà¸E›(6;"
?KSÏ&#Ó*WŒ#”·WDC(4FF0ñ)0š;6@+T/C,/G!(F)F”
·NíE”Ä59TB+,4BA*T"
[7TE4U<3F4BA*T":F(™Ù)N(ΙÙ)N:F²-MOÔÚE?+@
¸/2$9EÛ+@G*T0!/DS#á+A!.ðÌEN¢ü+BG¬-D+(IÛ)A*
T"
/öA*T"âäŒÏB+>@N ÕN›TNÎE:FGG±+":URW‹~+E<UT
s$sDCÛ3TG80D+"*BG(Ñ)B(θUF¨().QI:F(‚Z)FV
!A*T"44/R4Fñ-(dø)FP/FV!,0×@2T"
(˜ Œ§êŒ4F0ñFŒ)F(ΙÙ)F¯úyFI¬G!«ºNXwd$kfgâE÷I¥¹
"'
5U@+T"
%%
'%
NUCB JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS
AND INFORMATION SCIENCE vol.56 No.1
!!./'-#,&$'+0'"%'("*")
EÙK2CDòý®JåçØEœgJ\J&4]„^VSD.?"ˆK>J×V´»^
.:DJ!)J-SOX*J8<s{ihJËcÊJ¥àE-Z"
)J-SOX*"‡J?SJe|fzla|dJ˜ai%zh3ÏPB?JK!#
!
!
'>J(·2
XE-B?">9D>J¾!7:ÝÒJ`tb|m3Õ$F<YÏS?"7JÔ¢?P?P´
† Ž#´gÈV#ghluJ&4èV^¸V9D.??SEÙK!$ܛÇRí³$Ø!°
Á³#Ø!IT ghlu³$Ø!õ)ØJšJFe|fzj|m2XJF²S[Fï3õX
^!iDþ6IƒíEM4þ6Z7FIHB?"ÆÀ0[LAV/G>J'·K:SI¯bä
GۅR3ñi9!'·UJ—Úü^#BD!(·2X7[Ižl;Z®’3ƒóI˜a†
®^hj%m8=?F./7FE-\/"
7[X>J9J÷\Œ?AFJmK!EÙIFBD×IHЧHmL2YE-B?"CX
JmIK!NÄ2fJöì0Hï3)nú*8<J&.ÜF9DJ«.ÖIëF!>Ji%z
hm%cI1.D!*9.ª.13=SX[?">Jª.;Ztb|mKÕJ%1E-Z"
>J%"1"7JÍúQÉYK COSO J)nú*U>[I"‡;Ze|qw%j#ghl
u^W5g9D.Z÷\ŒJe|fzj|mH9EK!P<H‹@@\/F'¼;Z">J
õXIW[L!7[K´†F./WYT!¶Ì#ghluIž;ZÂ3I÷\0E¦ß0H)L
â‰É®*HJ@F¼/"
>J%#1"öÁ9D.ZNÄEJ SOX R"‡J´»ÙHGF./&4Ù3!SOX @!COSO
@F!PZENÄ¡á3;EI]3ÄJRhE-Z2JW/I!G_G_m^ìSZ"P? SOX
R!COSO!©N>JghluI.­9D.Ze|fzj|mJíîKÄ;EK½X[D.Z
2X!û5e|fzj|m±^^9D÷\Œ^”P9H.F!7J64I)æY)[Zyhc*
3-ZF¿^>\0Z"
>J%$1"CXK;OD)ÿ5Jöì ®8_EK'`WH+Ø8_EK!7®$ÜJ,
Ø8_EK!
(7[^£I!®Vs{ihJùYº-9U÷d ERP J8<^ŸRe|qw%j
ghluJ‘•^ìSW/F9D1X[P;*F`nobh9?"CPY)J-SOX*^ƒCJ
)“}*F=S?/0E!>[Ö!Jï3Z0WYT)7[^£I*´†œg'J\(JAT
«‰^/€;ZF./hj|h^ÛB?"CPY)J-SOX*^¨ÜIFB?®V‘øJhhv
E-Z"
>J%%1"ƒB¬.?JK!>J–He|fzj|mjE-Z"ƒ!G/./ÍÓ^;
ZF>_Hj¯IHZJ2FM.?";ZF;J5ïJÍúQ^ÉZ?SIK!P<>JØ
J7F^9B2Y(ZDe3-Z"úé!ïJ+ÇKô!ØšJJp`y|d!®Vs{i
hJO«Iÿ$H!k3De@F./"
7/./ehmYEJI&I"9!CXK#CJvykm^«+9D!>[3ÞKIºÃ/
TJ@F«+9?"ƒCK);J5ï›Ç*^;Z4ØJ&4µÎ2XJ)êd*E-Z"
CPY)›Ç#e|fz$ÜJ4Ø3Ñ8ã¼9?ï3*E-[L!›ÇRíT~ë9D=S
Z@\/F¼/"ÆMFCK!ùØ^™4ÅR$É®IHZ2X!´†mksUžl;ZùJ
\,I>JDeð^?:8=Z?S!÷\ŒF9DJ)¹‚*3De@F./")´†mks
^K:SšJù„^T¤I8=ZJ3!$JƒBJÍÓ'H.9«Q(
*F./¼.Q^Š
32M.?"CPY)rx|nj*@FÀ0D5[F./7FE-Z"e;ZIDeHJK)ê
d*F)¹‚*@F./_E-Z"
&&
!&
Ÿ“ÇGr·TKy}‰nmG=KT?µ:K¤`
,TC[˜BEÐ\G!‡ZQ¥£?AKn%‡mt%h`ó.\%CKg%Š%u1!=
KTT_1ãJ/4\Ÿ“ÇGrKyI,8ÀJç8EK)·TPK–ŸD4*G!=K
)yPKñH*`bnJŠ8E,\5GJº1C3":I_A$
Œ)‘4¡G,-¼/n
êÅ*
!);[f]\†mh*
!Ž)5]`¹JÅ ¨R*
!)B¨Gϕ*
!K%CF+\"
!!#ISO$.%&:@""#ISO$+*'7)0(<9/>.8?
_1ÿL=K#
!
!
'„"
"Í#
"€J)_1ã*KGr·TG8EK)·2*
)þô·2*KÙ©
V‘1…Š7]\TF!™Ox0I0B?"g´Êî`&.)þô·2*1…Š7]E0Z!
L9VE=]`-|Îw:\30Zœ¬nI\žêÅ`©ð8?"=KX[šK{iXÆ[n
}‰nm/YN=K̤JC,EL!œÞK£n`ª]\KF!55FLÑWG8EA]I,"
x2K_™™G8E_]_]L!¸Jûÿ~JYè:\)»W*
)€w„c‡*tK)»m
°*`!S~%z%JZA.8E)VEU?"13´J%
!$°RHK»m4°1)TB?"
808=KgDK‘ÓL¢GWh9nF=K"õW¸F+[!vl)}‰i…‚*
)€w„
c‡*GÕQ\Y-IWKFI0B?"~uGJkÌ:\)Å 6»m*X)@ ÏÔ»
m*F7.W!GEW)N‚K®[sEGÏÔK”‚1:QEK+śJ¢­JI7]E,\
0*
'þô·2K²ú(KP¤Jž.\WKFLI0B?"T?)Ȭ»m*L'CK)œ¨
æW*`øC0I[8æIWKF+B?1!as¦›?\‰!ûD!=-,-‘41Yè:\
5G:ZcZI0B?3Z,F+\"?@8~§LRS=üK—`.\WKFLI0B?"=
8E,;]W!F”K-:,WKF!æW°`¶V#ëK^Çye‹p%JS1*%T\
®F+B?"CT[=5FäÝK6G3ƒü8?5GL!_]_]L)›±*XÙnI)»
W*L–G8E!ȝuGKÿ~»†G8EK)‘4*IH!þýnJLRGaH¡,Jt8
,>]F!¢KŒXWŒqâWI35]TFXBE«E,?G,-Ä3Q2÷þF+B?"
?@8=]ZGL–J“§`ÖB?K1!)ISO*K·œ|be‡K^27F+B?"¥
–K^2I‘4|be‡1=]GL–J«JYè:\G’,E!ˆ=JÄ,?"=-,.M
_1ÿL!"
)
)
(„J ISO)
!
!
"!ª"
)
)
)„J ISO"
%
!
!
"Kƒ7`#z8E,\"sÿK5‹LÙ
ÁÜ÷KìJµ´:\öé@G,-5GFsù!Q¥j‹k‡o‹t`×,!%EK¥jh
…mKQa!K}‰lfhtq%‚`Pe8E!=]>]"„10[K^êÅ`8?GÓ-"
äFWž„/YN$„6GKƒ‹sv‹mKþ Ža1^—@GÓ-¶LY3’,E,?"
808Œò¾I5GJ!‹ý¤`F+]±Ã¤`F+]!ÿj’ "©I¦›j1=^ž'K°%sd‹i/YNžÍKÅLí¦¾IHF!5K ISO =KWKK¯¨XÚ¤
1¾µJ:B?5GLTB?3™rW¡,"_1ÿKÿjL¼/!.DF!Ü<KM‹™­X
Ø¿K‹ýhˆ%‚Jˆ=J-\7,EF+B?"808=KÿjK‹ý#S#±ÃJµ:
\ەL!³¬@mor|K)E´¯*K˜IG!Ò<K&S'J¬#J}#KU#KË#8
C4K³à(G[_4)8C4*KolF+B?"T7J)5aI ISO L,ZI,*
'€È{
lxm#
!
!
!(`dF,3š9F+B?"
"!J-SOX ;53421-/!,/6=
êÅ©ð’áRS"„´!_]_]LžÍ"§!sÿK²åasK¦ÉïG¾K<`øB
?"=K¾µKž(KgF!ˆ=Jß.7<Z]\½¤J¢§WOC0B?"=Kg0Z,©
IWK`!$p@40Q\"
&&
"&
NUCB JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS
AND INFORMATION SCIENCE vol.56 No.1
A"J“K!$á&VIC.DE-Y")æÞ±ñ*JIJ)4çR_r[&I¯<Yq˜
J“ã$
#҅*JH2I)YJ¾q˜KÌxES.HTJFHBD.Y2*F./0
†3-Y"Á”sq|Iw6L!o$3o$FT)w`!?JF1XE<*FZ0YA[/"
;2;ŸÂÜK!)H>+w`,HJ2!¢rèE-YŸÂÜITd^E4YV/I¶­RH
ø¸]ã=*FÇ/")d^E4Y*FK!)¾q˜3ÌxES.@Y*@SJ&V3)(l
9ZD.Y7F*F!?J&VNXIæ×I)“‰9ZD.Y7F*]!Å;DpbqfE
4YV/I=V!F./7FE-Y"7J)(lþ»*F)“‰þ»*]!_rE)‚uo‡
Œg*;@|ŠmlFÛ]!ŸÂÜ3)«Õ*<Y"?J@SIK<OD3)ø¸vô*I
HBD.H6ZLHWH.";2;$áJ3‡™EH.ŸÂÜI—]Å=ZL!?Z3)Ìx
ES.*FhEE4YJ2"$KÆÑJ$á&VJ)ç‘Í61ƒà’*F)$á„Gk%
s*1VM$árF£r‡LFJ)$áž¹µŸ*JæÞ´–]7Jø¸vôE-YF;D!
?JPPPï;@"?;D?ZE÷9Z@"CPXŸÂÜImŠHJK!«Õ?úFHY)Û
6Q*F)vô*
'“‰´–]°R(J<ØA6AF./7FE-Y"
A#J“K!2ðJ)4NJ-bFÄÈJ¦XXD*Jƒ¤–E-Y"P@?Z]v
ô–;@)½´ðô*F)½JZ%'{Š%pƒ%s(
*JŠ·J†BTIC.DEY"
7J&VJ5.KŠ<YI)uÿ~ß*I-Y"A2W©Oš…EK)f¥¿*U)ØÊ*
JÂûUq˜3)[&'iŒsŠ%ˆ(
*pRJ`ŒJCIHY".41.”½rJ½
|Šml3†BIHY"7ZWI¯;DTç_I<EIz§REJúRH³OôK<Ø;@3!
nèK?Z<WT€XI?^HTJ3òëE4YJ2!eE-B@"?J@SätE— Tâ
®]26D!”½rJ{Š_EæDXèJ\@]­Ù;!P@j'jõ(WIÛáJæý]
w.D B@"
?JÛ7ZT¼5O47F3t2B@"i}]4\SY`$Jæ]rdydFó;D
.Yj'jõ(W]ÆæIÝ0D.YJK!WRI)ô2Z:Yˆ%ˆ*J;E-B@"?
JæJZJ8XrtK!iŒz„%oklr€JIE'˶FJ®ET(ä\ó9ZD
.Y"$3};.JK!?ZWJígKU+:d²3|Šg†€NX#PH.h%l3=.2
WE-Y"CPXj'jõ(W3ó;D.YÛáJ=5K!˶J‚]w4!ÎüUe9
Jì.]cx%<YF./k|Šg†€R#“¢R?•E-Y"?Z]ÅáI)ˆ%pŒ*
J8F5rdydFätEþ»hE;ó;D.YJE-Y"
?J)ô2Z:Yˆ%ˆ*FKG/./TJ2"“0L-Y`‰e„†%HŠ,I?•<Y
üÓ!?Jý{]CIU0D15O42"”½rFM/CH3BD.Y…%j%UÎQ¬r
‡A6EH5!öç!7ʓˆr‡!*ÚÎü2WÁà¿PE!isIVXüÓIVX!?
7EFYO4ý{¨\KŽHY"?ZWK=trLITœLITùÖPEKV5t2BD.H
.A[/"?Z]aç"
!cQVJõ'r‘3!é."yç‘Ih%l8FIº0H3W!7Z
WJˆ%ˆ]“‰;D.YJE-Y"$恡EK7/./kÌåJvqs‹%fIPEÏ
3Yý{¨\4>]){Ô#•Œ#8GJ”Ñ*
!Ž;D)}a‰Œna*FÉ^E.Y"Yõ'r‘Kç_J¯Àr‡KTFVX!]‘JF'”½~ŒI‹^E!.CTUXêX<Y
…%j%Uöç]]Ñ|†;!áJcaŒo%y%st%]ÜJç¢vqs‹%fPEÐH
;D.YFÇ/"7J—IK)MHF7[ªs;@"
7ZWJ)ô2Z:Yˆ%ˆ*K7JV/Iç_A6EH5!¢rJ…%j%FJê’ET
&%
#&
Œy¸/Xš;L_cqzihH?L;(™$L‰E
ŽÏK§f:F-@"?^[L.Bh$½$K£<],]ò‡ŸÓM!•½Þ1[L—8ß_
K÷CFXUJ4*¹Œwû+K:@":1:?^HFW!“¯ödK`@CFç9^F
3@³˜LýŸõL„DG!ÿJ4HWØÈÝLs…L©K0-FW!“¯„X@\HWm
vpxKJC@7H2J-H-."¹ŒûLÜ1a+:c^@`2íW!Æ`^@ˬW*I
.:FÖÑ+Hôa1:6J2[!zKl@<]’W„40Ì-Kµ!-:J2[o{ga
‹:@H-.7HG,C@"
D$Lå–M!íaL*¨“+KD-FG,]"–/N*ìá¥ú+KèLZ.J7‰–2
,]"
*¼‰îM!r2K£<]wheaÁ\<]ÛK!GKr2K£<]p†SJåìA5GJ
4!r2am9>]Kâ]^§!Ć!g»Za]S/!T6Kwheaq:@Š:F-]
1+
"
7^M COSO LÄM(NˆR1"
*
*
'!l&x{$"
")L–éwJIGM!*nÅìSJ³
ƒ‡oLF1a®V]}”'`KH¦SJ³5K£:F'a15F-J-1I.1+H-.Z
.K!1J\":4¶?SKJCF-]"S9K?LH0\G,CF!H¦S³5Høã
LYä’ä€ñ«L´IŽ7?2!v'åÀLØCLĆKJCF-]7HM!TbJu1C
F-]":1:7LZ.KL#SJwÆK9^]H!I.@Š<Q31XXôa1:6]"
”%M ×}-K*7L7‰K@<] ×$LkQ¥úa¶?SK±/FR:-+Hx-F
T@"*?^M›íGÒ/]7H+H-.[/2‘@"
:1:?.Æ`^F—VFÒ/FÂ]H!û1^@x&xLÿJ-KGI.XCF>4L÷
³…K¨“a±/ÕT!S@¼‰XÅ%Lw&k&aƒFF‘@L1H-.VM!¼‰;(™
$LC3J™VG,]"€ëSJr2XB³Mˆ™L7H!*êuA5J[#77A5J[+
H-.BYCH:@x&x‚lXój3!,]-M*rdy{jd+LrURJI!U:_¢L€‘SJð9G,_."?^a*…wŽ9^@x&x+J:K!S@*ì5=QXwû©
˜Z]åÍSJ|þH/Ú+J:K!2`2íL)%¨“aà/F3@L1"”%M?L:
~Jª‰1[ùi:J5^NJ[J-A_."
!!#0%+&*,",$')*.-21(/3
å–G,6@‰³sLü0s…L^3M!•æL¼ÃLJ4H?^K¥E4.™1[&²L
€a–ï:!?^K@:F?L‹œK0-F¦A9^]*rdy{jd+aìÓ:F-]L
G,CF!¾:Fx&xX™’LJ-Ç-S#OžSJWLGMJ-"?7KMû1^FMJ-2x&x2,\!™’2,]"*qzfvt+W*snucx+W¾:F„-`5GMJ
-"A1[*c3KW±/[^]:!fx&q9?G°ŽWù‘]"@A?^[2*wûŽ+
9^F-J-LG,]"
?^M*Ɛ+KZ]û1^@x&xaP;FZ\W!?L&²K05]*w‚+?LWL
aS]8H,KD59>]7HaP;F!±ƒH¡’2J9^F-]LG,]"?^a¤W
("
*
(
)$%
()M*&²<Š0+HZO!‘Ί("
*
*
()M*&²™’+HÉP"-=^WS7
HKT67L$J-šeG,]"
*:D5+HMS9K*&²@Š+L@VL*,?f”+?LWLLlt·—G,]"`2
ÔLÐ%Å%K0-FMÖbGW!?^M:N:N*&S+LURHÆ.ºGÓ`^F-]"
`2íLÐ%G#
!
!
$d"¿1[%¿K15FL$|¿¢G&ÀLåÊٙ("b~$L­³
'&
$'
NUCB JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS
AND INFORMATION SCIENCE vol.56 No.1
`p0)4 C<C9K4.FC(0E"¿Qä†)
"9Pu$éHN_^_^–…Q!:T
;TMUÓ`Í/FÚ`®¢<C"<3<Õø]NñV4½VCFÚQ!ñVï[§ >]¢
{`‡5 ^IÅ#P&S %²``Âáf>]K/0¾Ÿ*ñVrn~&|+PðâJ.FC"
‹¾›Ê#`„G?GüNû–>]K/04!<Ê#`„û>]PNT]"k33]"wòQ
9PKWˆŒMFÚNJ5M¬“`£=C4!9^`5F37N&S —;P<ñ]MÊ#¦
°@4ßT\!U]U]Ê#PvŽ4,aD"B<IéÈn2WB^NƒU`._@]Z0N
Äÿ<I/5!BPT]#kÉ3[Q!'
$
)h¦P <×™«¡`L1>]NæFC"
éȈãNMA*&S+MP3"BP†’§º`ϛ]N6>]9KQg</"wò4É
h9PìPFÚP›—`ñVï+N.OCK5!sQCD*B\XŠkP»ÃDO+KD7d
1C"
hŠaÛPŠöñVQD6P•ñ`ÔÁ<I/6RJ!$N*$Q'S+P_ZK/09K
`Æ0"9P*'S+KQ*&S+N*م+`‘1CWPJ.]"ŠöåP•ñÔÁQ!T
?9P'S P_Z3[ßT]"9PxpfgJy<I*'
!`M[Ré´QÑêŽ!(
!`G7
RÕ΋NM](Šö)
+K<I!BPŸeP—™K³Œ*/ðØéŸ4î:^I/](hŠ
»Ö)~ñ‚ #
!
!
($"
"
))
҄G-éy0bN§>]éŸ`õ\"8]"wò4¹Í3[zj>]#k:P#
!
!
!kN!
9P•ñQ*1’ô­]-é0b+`fi<C"cìP-é{Qikms'<…N!ýB{”
P´4yKÇ-’x¼/PL1œNWKH6!µVI>‰JµNMqªk„0b`^˜<C"
B^Q-é8”e€f|k€nPáfNZ]cì*Õ7N+P0b5¼J.FCK/0"
wò4zjÉ!-é{PMc$Ž`ÀŽ<C#
!
!
'kN9PX¸0b`!–ž¯]Mt~&o
q€o0N<‘—[<C"‰˜‘JW'#PÇ-‘OK!{”VK-é{KP±®`SK>]
u$Ng€u|MWPN<C"—YP=/Q!Ç%-PW·ª¦P*14ÓY+Z\W!þ™
P–žªGbyKBPCVPdy{bri`Ì1]*-é̓+N0bPù``‚>K/0
9KN.FC"BPì”%4!!œYo\P±®NØ<I!„íyòJ.]¤›'Y{”V
K_Z<I®¢<CP4!*¨ž+K*-‡+K/0šlJ.FC"
”%4{&l&P9oN§<Iî<C9^[Py©úQ!BP?&P}N27]<E%
²`/3NË/ç•KÎ/àÌ}v|Jm<I/]3!TCBP–žªGNF>]-%P(
š`L^D7Q3<I/]3K/0``ÕJP“KK<C"B^`ª¦’xFtPAY/PJ
M6!Š-KWBP"Þ!{”VK-é{Pô¥]y`v&iN!ì¦`37I¤<Ï20
K/0_7J.]"
ðQwòï+3GI¶Ž<I/Cï|P¹Í4!€ÐPJ÷e€f|k€n`i^I-é0
b—`ðâ<CK5!ó¡JQ.]4{VK<IP¯44FCK/0»Ã4.]"-é
{V3[*˜èPJ÷e€f|k€nNZ],hzt#fcj(ÝéPJ5:)
-PÜYJB
0MFC+K6:^C"Nr¢Q<M3FC4!KWÆ1M/ƒ££`ëFC"-é{
4A]PQ*SKPfcj+>M_E*¨ž+J.FI!*ÝéPJ5:+K/0WPQL0
/0¨žP-¦`BPwinNT]3J2P?3[½T]WPD"ï|ï+P-é{ìIP»
Ã3[BPì`TJ!B0(=I¬_M3FC3[J.]"
'&
%'
™k»#PŠ0NUZŠqoJBN0û‰úNx;
#!$'"&%
!!"/,+(#&$%'0)"-.*1#
ISO M@Z!ÿß#PM@Z!TCФN J-SOX M@Z!™kO~N-Š0.MO!`7
ÏNçtž6[ÀHfÛ´JXÛ4]SKN-ö6^Cˆ)ˆ.>L`E-jö.QN;D
`\71]"céO-COSO N~‰)„‹)h.JÅP^]D9LnÎö+E”S6{ "
*
*
'%
-€‰m.J-t)ˆm.#ÕI;&
)
(lNr{ö,aWUL7[!œPX-LAkÏIO
;bLQC\,Nßa!—(Jjöš=Z3J>]N6.
J'FLJ;_‹>]Û27=C"
TC6GHcé7ÿß#PM­=H!kÏN9ìjŒkˆrŒwI1]-‚d$iˆ).
6[-jŒ}uŒm)$€sh‰sw.J23øÕÚ+‚diˆ) #
!
!
$,aë\¯@!-j
Œ}uŒm)$vchm…y‡).MG2HWbDJ8XT}I1FC"B^MZ]J!z$
&
!
í…N-’aK.LËSÜd7ïW[^H2]J23"TC-§jŒ}uŒm)NH³M¦Q
=H2]6K36a6"NjŒkˆrŒw7i…=CJ;_!jŒ}uŒm)Nç†MO!„
KM4HI8]VB71];J7i6\T=C.J1]"$
&
!í…XNËSÜda±ó=!i
…=!„KM4H=Z3J23;JNsXBN]X!>IM¡(N€£a989C4H2
]"-D6[B^Iœ7`6]N6'.
J64FH²x7989p[VÛ27=CXNI1]"
;^[N-Š0.M·G>]Mag)‹)xKMeÂ>^P!",
-n…€$vcoh‡
m…Œ.
!>L`E-Ä(N¸tX|BNXNav©M±ó=Z3+±óI8],
.J23-j
öš.QNæ^L2=©ý"#,
-‰ƒ)w†dŒ.>L`E!Çä0ûNòª\i¸J+y
šJ!BN†dŒNúÙM8>]Ä(Nñ¸“NÔ¸ ;J([bŽNv©š!
B=H$,
-n…
€kdp.
!T<M-ütNH„š.I1\!%ŸN"=4HN!;^TC±ˆjöNÔ%I
1]"
ef){)+"
*
'
!&*
$,OáNZ3MóR]"-«ƒ#šO!+yKM¹‡<^Cü“M+A
‚,
!Ä(NØßaªQH];JMZFH!ô!M38ùK+lsz‡s|,LÀ>6[!Ë
&M5:]Ô¸iªNÁ€açË>]Ó-N_$aJ¶>]XNI1]";;I/38ùK0
Lõ€JO!œZ\X¾×_L°2M=C7FH/ÿhN26bax3;JL90õ€>]
;Jas>].
"
<[MTö+"
*
'
!&"
"
&*',O-%!«ƒ#1?N–5K$¨.NÌI-69H!’GMO
/jö0
!YGMO/«ƒ°0
+A‚,7!ÇN½•M52HXÞKL½•M52HXT>T
>’)N@÷N®/MLFH29.J*2H2]"
qÉIO;;TI!J-SOX LKaåKM-#P.JÃ`?#-Š0.JÅbI~C"¡(
OB3ÀL=H8C6[I1]"=6=L7[Z9Z9Ê4^P!-jöê³.JOT<M!
ef){)7TöI23J;_N-«ƒ#K0û.N-®/.L2=-Á€.BNXNIOL
26"
qÉIO-#P.JÃ3¥^a-ÿJÿ1]2Oð<Jð<N¬I¼%<^]à5KIH
KL袭ºNØ0UB^â7aÜ>.XN!1]2O-BN袭ºaÝ4]ˆ)ˆY¿T
\ßaÜ>.
+ÒR$ÖN #
!
!
%&"
'
%*&,XNJH³>]"TC-Á€.a-\åTCOˑ
NÑq,J.
+Èã˜:"`,
!L2=-69Nÿ7B^Mñ3;J7µW[^]®qKLÊ4
o.
+þv£ÏÆãL:&`,NsIÊ4]"Schein+"
*
)
&&"
%,OjšNÓ®IgiMO
-Q.Jî:ë[^H5\!wMÀ4L2!uåKL.
-®qK›H.
+Basic Assumptions,
*&
&*
NUCB JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS
AND INFORMATION SCIENCE vol.56 No.1
5+Õ>]H%f=F0]"
`ËG,þ=¿n-HÂ1H6!OäMiK½2],ûÉV(Artifacts and Creations)H=
FLþ=:J,y(-L®'aJ>!iKU2J0!TA=N=N–áK;2ð[J0“h:
JãŸ:(ô:ϖJ0=&8H01:Ha«–=F0]"
:L6±K®E0FÍ2]H6!MA=FÑFL`5ÐL.¬¶M`>K,¦rþ(ô-H
Â2]B_14"Z7€p}qÜ5æ\ð9],.¬¶R.NÇpHe$G.¦rþ(ô-H
01üàM!íJ7HXd©¬¶a)6>]Ã\!,þ=¿n-:KM©—0LZ1KÙ`^
]"@^M Merton("
(
$
&$"
(
&'#
!
#)501¦rþL,³¯J(Dysfunctions)
-JIGMJ7!
TA@^KZ],¸w;^AeJu(trained incapacity)
-GXJ7!V=_@L,a!è-K
°™=F0]LGMJ04"@LøL¿™M!s7Â2N,k¯:!’7Â2N,*û:G/\!,¯ :,¯J:-G/]Z\X,µA,:-Jþ=¿naÔl=FmF0];K/
]HÙ`^]":Lj/M!?S4(#
!
!
')L¼´5!,(ôL*ç;+
-HÂ1¡HG6t
:K½ÞKâï=F0]"
!!"+,)'#&$%(*
:^TGLW#4[!i&&{:KPÁ>^N!,Ž„&z‹e‘ vs ƒfŽ‘tf,pŠ
#ydqjŒ‚oŠ‘ vs =D8,pŠner vs ­t-H01Z1J-M5T4Oð5
]"@:KMf[4K,þ=¿nL—05/]"=4=!@^[M˜,I:5I1—1L4"
T?`5ÐLþ=¿nHMI101XL4aÍ2Z1"@^M`5ÐLX›HÂÆK÷7Ò
<=F3\!ž%L,Xì›-QL7ʧM!T;=7F`ÆLCÿ4[mF0]Z1KÙ`
^]"
E. Hall("
(
&
%$(
")M!m‘xjqz=LÎ0X›H50X›a·\=!F`JILm‘x
jqz=LÎ0m…‰|l&oŠ‘TAM‡ws&pGM!ó^LSHbI5ù,:m‘xj
qzL3K/]4!Ä%ûKD՛;^F=T0!m&{›;^A!f¢J!<0;^]ÂÆ
L‡ws&pUWKM!ó^5NòKíJ0HÂ1"AB=@LÎ5MX›Lú]=Ï0HM
eª¹BHXÂ1"TA!G. Ferraro("
(
(
!$$
%)M!ƒ&Hm&qLX»a¾K!c‹
û!3Ðû!F`ûHš[L(hÐL"
#LÐda!Xc•+=LÎ5GêKZR!F`ûa
ÓXÎm‘xjqzH=F0]"(ß53Ðû!@=Fc‹û!@^4[š[ûLêHJC
F0])
"EûM0?^X[ÐLX›ûv¤äG/]5!F`ûH@LÂÆKD0FLL[L
QœYê”L²¨ÿKD0FOäKK2>]uMJ0"=4=íJ7HXF`ÆK30FXc
•+ÿ56`WFÎ0H01Ú9M!IBG6]H:_G/_1"
TAM£þ=W#LÛ;4["g(#
!
!
")M!(ôDUK38]uqj1”©GLó^ën
¥@LWSa,(ôc&ixjvˆ&-HÅO![кL¯J:~g‹~&HF`:JýY
:~g‹~&K38]ö:(‡‘u)‚k‹†aM£>]"@=F[кL,Ä\›(individuated)J0=Wo=Aû:Ý×-K-=F!F`ºa,XcØÈ:(context-oriented)J
û:Ý×-HC4E8F0]"
:^[LÛ;KqCFÂ2Nž%M!`5ÐL(ôLþ=¿na!š[ºL,Xìå±-K
-=F!,Xcå±-HÅP:H5ém]Z1KÙ`^]"=4=;[KX1˜]î;aÌC
FÀbKÍ2]H!@^M(ô(J0=õñk&‚)K38],ñ-LÖ\_LC4K÷7
ªx=F0]Z1KÙ`^]"
'$
%'
¨•ÒDnÂPOx~‰—wvKCOP<À7O©\
<OjNH2IP!›^*"
*
*
*%%
!'%+78cZIûèNY,9OµÀ-di³>!C
O,9OŸ±O-K>I!,fui˜{*:›P«N¿@`[O6+
!,°$s&€*:›
PL3°$@U86+
!,:›Om”f*:›dk4I2`ƒW+
!,¾Y²Ë-O%Hdû
>I2`"
ŸâOÛ3,“¢%Ç-7!¨•ÒO»¹Dg,“2%Ç-K¥·N Kd®@`OP!<
O,°$s&€-K,:›Om”f-OŸ2J1`Kã4^a`OJPM26"C<JP!
[K[K™ÍOoæNe-@`£U,_O,c¾ÛÞ*h˜z&ˆi—&t}‰$“˜r&
u+
-K>I!:›Om”fK>IOÛÞs&€ÃdCaVL…]=B`Œ±7M6GD
K23½ög‚Ô7?e=a`"C>ICaE:N!COs‘‚q&t’˜Ovzh•7!
!¯¼+Oµ°\!;ÏNX@`½ögP<gÕ­O¸°K23ŠÛÞgM°$s&€N[8
9œV@`K23ÓJO!8cZIyžgM…idA;I8DOJ1b3"
.GICaP×>I,fui˜{-\,¾Y²Ë-dÀZI!M9,ã4œ7Ÿ3-«JP
M2"[89žM`OP!Õ£sDN52IÿìNÁ>I2`,‰—p“Ž-\,Œ‚‘f
•-dk]>¡°$\ävŇd̬ª>I29s‘‚q&t’˜OœM2>‰—wv
EKã4`U8J1GI!C<=4¦=4aQ!×>I¥4^aM2“ªO–JPM2Eb3"
!!"0+#,.%$-/)*$&'(&
"
*
*
!€Z݆6^O<O"
!B€¾OÕ£P<O[8M˜ªP!,¨•N¬GI}ŸN¤2
„-PdFNw?*]3M+„*ÂP+dï`K23Ÿvz˜vJ!x~=a(®=aI
³D"
>6>M7^!c7æO ISO*
!
!
"OÊ\!yN ISO"
%
!
!
"O3µæNˆ¸>IOž¯MV
L{/>DS¬S_*ò§ #
!
!
)+P! W«d¡@`O6"tŸ*#
!
!
$%#
)
#+7÷f@`
K5_!
"
*
*
!€ZL†OC²Oüv#вN5:`GôEKHTþP!
@JNc7æ77±G
I5_!,¨•ÁÐOX}.Èm}|f}‰/O`´-N1GD"HW_<OÊOÚ¢P!
[KPæì~ñN5:`Ž´d‰:]3K23ÁJ1_!CO1KPæ|вˆg&•€N5
:`,8_aa”vo-dÎa`§”R%Ç!M2>,P<P·ä*ˆe}t’˜+N>D7
3-OK23Dn™ºJ1GD*çt$ól #
!
!
%%#
!
''(+
"
½ÍšM\x—j}t’˜TO&_PXNH2I[!c7æHTÐO½ÍÆ0O³…mº
KCOI‹pøO@17!C²ObJaaI2`K23<KPM2"håÐN¿>IÛ4Q!
åî~˜rD_õ°jƒ•n&PC²Jé5J1_!WDß9OšMžëWDNH2I[!¼
4Q}•z$kæN5:`"
!
! ú¾1D_Oë¶ù܅GÙB*ÉÐ"(R¿uú¾0"
!
! +
P!•æ#
)#
)!z"
$#
(NX>I!}ŸP!#
$K!M9֟2O–Š•J1`*}Շuƒv #
!
!
%%
%
%+
"<O]3M;Ï©J!L3>Ic7æOÕ£"7¨•Oþ\½Í\šMO,Â1-d
=¦¨N¹SÄNM`Eb36"¥^6NN2P—OK<bN1`"
CaJPÕ£CO[O\l…˜vN¿@`¯!DnNH2IPL36"
¼4Q!"
*
*
(€Ny‚&7P?ZIx~>Dý䪡K23‹v~ÂPP!cA6&)'€
J ÄNôв$Ñ­²MWNà7GD"
=^N„)ž¤ðNH2I[!#
!
!
*€'ØR¯*¸újJ!q6$
$Ð'’»JOHTÐO ‘79¯!OÿN$
%†&w˜~dJZ`#
*
%!7x~êXK23*tŸV6 #
!
!
*%"
$+
"še
º%ˆ¶\>¯!OVíMLº%áF7ž¤ðOŽ±MQrBO¯!d42Iã4`K!<O
'&
('
NUCB JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS
AND INFORMATION SCIENCE vol.56 No.1
‚¸T^ZVE-L0_"ôQ€÷P¡öZ{û–ÞcªøG¡LÄ·>E"höQÚ0
P;~M¤¦pºc²X„x(lNµ!cíHK4^!D`]PgêG©MêážV5]@`
R!¿¥CLPªž4#60V^OZ]8!ªž$êáz¦*PBR+6"zc5N^š£HK
1E"IV^¤¦P{eŠw5]Æ`R!—]5OhöQ,{ûM*†Å-M>K,4oN{
†-M¯¯=`_…pl6Ô5HE"D`QSN_˜‰Sø¶LQN1"hîP„YMüŒP
ë«5]Ñ3K!IR ThP-”M>K€÷6ÈôO¬?K1E|‡snƒ(QÄ>K'=8
QN5HE"
>5>ŽLQ!#
!
!
&vO6›=`E,‘¡;X¡öQ!#
!
"
!vOèHKN4!œ##
%
!
!
ö[Pƒsƒ+,¡öL!bA5%
(ö*>5Zir"
&öQt§m†(|+L!#$
$._e*t
’®Ù›»¡ZÙ #
!
"
!+M12¾8U7]1‚¸ecñ@ë«Z0_"ÎOÑ3`R!;`
F9ªøÿéF!³¿žV”FMŠÖÁgêŸê’ø¶6­QO+^N6]Z!b6ÖPÂ
”÷QŠÖP\2O›‘ýc•<FO’7+:_;MN8!VEø¢ªøZªžc+)=B
_EYOԖNj…p}a CEO P¦ƒ(±O‘H@_M12k7ZÆBK1N1"
!!"*,.0-#&'$()2.%1+/
D`OZ55b]A!NCb6ÖPá¿¥Q™Š´#P,®D-c;P\2OúŸ>K7E
P5"D`Q06eyD.¬612M;aP,6e‹©-MÉ2§wL¤¢=`_"EF>b
6ÖP³¿6SOÃÕ>˜þ>K7EPLN1bQ!BÓL"UEM4^L0_"
Swidler*"
)
(
&+Q!Ê3PÒkåÍOI1KïP\2NƎcñ@"@NbGˆ›M12
ZPc!™QOM—@_EYO¡1_,nÀ}*t(†ksv+Z>8Qx©[WóP,‡
z(v…(-MWN>!3'QD`c™Q<MOAR>â1‡9_M12,ҎP?¨*strategy of action+cíHK1_"Ä>K3'QSOˆ›6ŽÍJ9_žV°O|]`KÒk>K
1_PLQN1!M"
;Pç`QK‡!™Š3ò1\^Zt’3O\^¤¢>[@1PLQN15"t’3QË£!
¦£P2dFˆ›[6eOM>K!DP\2NNecMHK7E",9 ˆ—5]PIVW/
1-M,Û\ŒUø¶*±à "
)
(
&&"
&+QZ—ð5]ãVHELN8!ËOO­ìc¨
dLœ–MDWÕbB!²fP¥ª6c! ¹M°«Q¦>Kƒ‡mu>EM75]P!“b
R“JaNciMLZÉ3\2"
>5>;P"
!5vPqpPP7Nk7Q!ci[“J7F9LQ¤¢L7N1"D;OQS
N_mˆ(y†›P¼16ea‹©MDPùõARM“2F9LQ=—>7`N1!t’³¿
P…ßNk7MDP?¨*ARǤ+6@dL1_\2Oæb`_"
;PbOI7!Øj%àd*#
!
!
'&#
(
")$
"
&+Q!,nÀ}*t(†ksv+M>KPˆ›,Ҏ?¨,6e̞Pˆosl-M12$IPfhufc.^×dF,…Õ?¨‚u†c^&>!,ARalZ-M,â1‡9-12Ҏ?¨P…ÕO\^!’ÐLù^+:E%ë
«OM>KZ!=oaN{‡(€‰(lc^ñ>K1_"D>K}lˆ*6eˆ›+)q*D
.+)~lˆ*Ê3+P$EPu`äÏIP‚u†O\HK!ÆëO;P\2NARalZÒ
kc=—>K1_"
€÷P;`VLP‡:LQ!;P,}lˆ-c™Š6øm@_Ö܁#›Pmˆ(y†P
{g(†w!,q-6b6ÖPá¿¥CL!D>K,~lˆ-6ʋ³¿!DP,}lˆ/
q-P•½©cú9íIP6r¦P,8«Ý-L0^!,q/~lˆ-cT2P6>šŸ
)%
()
„V¢ì8uøL?FruigG>LøâtàLe(
ewftjwmÔ.F+ZG,-êÉF².E2?"9096LsltFU!’öJòb92
[I,71ÀZ"
CRY>L)õ*4>2*G)Á,T4*G,-]1¶¤ÍL³}ôpM!J-SOX J/,
EM!,0IZK/—ÚJWBEõ*7[?ULIL0">9E>LK/M!ªn4J´n4
F!R?¬Ë4JU":@G,.ZL0H-0!G,-'2IœeF+Z"
R<>2Lp%hMbŒF+Z"ÅL?F^üè9!R?du%qtIÆ 6Ž^èTZ
?TJM!ðOyàJ• ‡0>LULL¶¸;~—ÚJWZOÊYÝì8^?F=8Z^B
I,"
909PÞILM†®!V¶L COSO L)UÛϝ*^!]1¶L¤Í?AM03U
x|Ja\LJÓj9?L0G,-7F+Z">LniLOGC^MÍM!¬¹L¤mkr
ùL!)E]¢øâ*PLŠäJ+ZG².Z"CRY,0IZuøF+[!$4JMGY
+.<)ì8*G9EÓj9!~[FÌC4JME]¢L)øâªn*^ÑBE,3">-,
-Á,T4JWBE!H_Iì8uøFU!ÈT?ALÃ-G/Y†GFUÁ,6I=Z">
L)–l7*PLŠä1!„V¢Lì8?FJ03U)kI%8^ÐX=ZLF+\-"
·OGCLniM!6-,-ì8žtLÓ4GT[È#0X3Ze(Lv܅I,9¦ÄJ
+ZW-JÃ][Z"CRYì8e(MR<FY°F!>[M)öÌ4I¤‰(0*
!)óf
TgL›Ø4‰(0*G,-£4€ÞFTs7[Z">9E>[1+ZRfL)óf4#›
Ø4e(*GI[N!ªýG9E>LRf,:ÍJöc4JzKX[Z"ÖBE!J-SOX L?
F1§¾ZµàLUۅ» @G)>LALófˆ*0X­][[N!¤nRfV‹¥ÂI,
9ófLewftjwmG=FÕT@G².Z">9E>[yàJ!
>L¤øâàL]Ê4#
ªn4I{^^².I3IBE9R-LF+\-"039E J-SOX V ISO M!>LuøL
©Gófˆewftjwm?A0XL`nqagJ/4Z%CLc%v%nJWY!¯ÍJT
s7[?LF+\-"
9096[RF¡YX9ÙQE2?G/Y)UÛϝ*M§9E+IZ)uø*FMI,"
¬¹L]1¶¤é1Î2E^ûB?"
(
'
!H&RFLÇ&M)E]4¤*1ß¿7[?)U
_ϝ*LÇ&F+B?"9096L"
!ëH][][13c9E2E,Z„V¢L)UÛϝ*
M!>[X)U_ϝ*GMøâL—÷LRTFªn4J$o9!]mroM9I,ULF+
Z">L6GJÕTI@¼^<0=Z6GI3!)J-SOX*$‚MMÍ13ñ1Z!3L‹Ì
J/,EU!¤nRfLÒ^¤E!ewftjwmJRZ957[E9RB?W-J©.Z"
CR;ì'J-SOX(LM:TELZµ1×þB?L1#
!
!
(H$¨§¾F+B?"909>L
ç9,Zµì81W-V3$HdJM,B?¬¹!;FJ]1¶½ FM!ç9,¶¸‹¥
—ÚF+Z IFRS'International Financial Reporting Standards$¶¸º`Zµ—Ú(5lLžt1
]…9E,Z"æYX[N6LW-I• ‹¥Vbqowgì8L¶¸NڅL=2M!>
LW±LS1H_H_'23IZG>ÇJ!ƒ9˜=ZIL”‘1R;R;-3IBE2E,
Z",RV‹¥ì8LRT4I›Øe(G9E0?D4X[Ze(FI,6GJ!ú3™Q0
KNIXI,"
R?)U_ϝ*LøâJ!“qìøâL—÷F+Z)UÛϝ*^58JJ´;ZG­6GM!2]TED9,F+\-">U>Uªn4Jîc0X$o;ZUL^!HLW-Jø
S´]=ZL0"HAX01híJI[N!>LTÿ[1åã7[Z"«Fïw2]RYI
, `šÙÛF>L» ^;ì'ewmu%t(9I1X!~[F)ÈTFáŸK/^9E™
&&
(&
NUCB JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS
AND INFORMATION SCIENCE vol.56 No.1
aš3=Ch5a=_+JOÎ1L/D_0"B03J/FH*KE[WSKSKM+J/0
NOÞWÂæI.]"KE[WWcxTL,MJÎ0NO!@-Nldr~j€MJFHތ
N,M!?L`E@-˛N²q?J/0țaWC[?3[I.]"
#!#$"
!+$'(,&"%$-)*
o‹_ǔ4Êb;^C"
)
(
!pO3[?IM$
!pÁ6ǝ=C"J6M9N"
!6pNǔ©
ºN‡˜O!Ûm_MWf‡&v…MW!BN@-f8N>^aY]4?P5L×E_#ô_
‡”aWC[=C"
Ûm_MO!@-Np¢×9J¡A×E4P56‡`FC"÷ûNÌ'M™1H…9½Ž
™Nߖ46NåÌW.\!p¢×943GHNyƒ~mqÄ3[!áZ/x&…xˆÄM¨
?M‡`FH=TFC"TC9N"
!6p!ömIN IT N§–X@-Nzƒmp˜#‚smp
8N1gMZ\!¡A×EWá36ƒ¦;^…C6LFC"TCP¥0H4$pŽmM$
!w&
kˆpŽ*4œ.?]J/0÷pANóN‡˜N‘R4P56ú\*8[^êVH/]"
9N9JOQ“¶_MñN9JaŒ=H/]"?L`E`4ÛN*„ù¶+aõô_M
í1H5C.+N OJT J*Í+ +4Y=6øK˜=H/]J/09J"&S N*=G7+X
„&l&J=HN*4« +aûú\Fú\Õ0];6ìj=H5C*é#<sJ/FC*’
¦o…+NIãX4«¬Ã4°uML\!ª›.I.FHW£òN|ª›Mv[^H!÷
û#ÒsN’9MTIÿƒ4t^L6LFH5H/]JÎ09J"GT\!
3GHy;aÑF
C`4ÛNf…&{#ldr~eiO!?IMCe[bI5H/]NIOL/3#)"
3GHO*P¥:§a\>Hýk=C•%LUóXµ"4òƒNWI“²_MfÙ;^+
*¸
V[^]Þ]ÏNïôq 4Å9;^+
(„‚š¥(N*üÀ ’9í–ðÀ GP+NԈ„
Z\).À4J=Hòž9Z;AHØ6NO!PH04aߖ=C®ÀN’¦I.FC"B^
4öm¼’!J\`7tG<N*é#<sCENÞW!˜LèðNPJGI.FC"z[O0
4ÒsCEN*’¦o…+J=H*&3^<]…&…+N„?Ka!õ=a\>HT]:
J¼1ÜbI5C"B=HB^O'L6JW"
)
)
!pO%VTIO!B^L\M²q=H5C"
Ýo*üÀ +N’94P¥M»6¸V[^]Z0MLFCrÆMO!9N*„¼’N7
O$D\gin€+N²q?J/0Í)4.]Z0Më`^]"=3=L4[9NaMG/
HNçÀŸ#¼’ŸN·£OJWM*ߖ#ü.§h+
J/0Í)ŽQNL—MŸTFH/]"
/TPJGf‡&v…˜N‘RMG/HO!;[M2ÚL‡˜4:>H/]"BNQ“O±
M#RH5C@-zc&…qNf‡&v…˜I.]"ŠM27]*Ûâ˜+J!ï‹X:ç
¹aBNWNN*f‡&v…˜+JO!BN•¿X8d_ NôW†|…WBNdÙ/4?
6‘L]"*X«Î—+X*„+4\–?]7Ÿ4KbKb¾TFH5H/]"
QnM4N‘R4.]!/TXSMÍV‰44ÍV4ߖa?]MŸT[@!o‹N‹‚4
7Ÿ` a¤bI¢Û4aCe{­bDf‡&v…ß–4‹¤˜=H5H/]"J6Nf
‡&v…P®ÀIO!@-4ð8daÛm#ž¢Nn‹žH8d3[!f‡&v…4ð8dM
`4ÛN*Í+ +NøK˜MG/HO!±MJ64Ó[^H5H/]4!lM#
!
!$pdM!P®ÀNÖ+
#)
Í+IP³LœàX43ðÐ4€w=C9J3[!;[MP56ú\*8[^]Z0MLFC"BNO}
¡J=H,oÇxhti-#
!
!
%p$É(o!$
!'%
&†*lþ#sm}ˆNÍ+4¯L/+4.]"i&IOB
NlþN}îM$*uä\a/U,$GN¥+J=H!‰~BOÍ+IL6pm{!Š|nƒˆSKðÐ
a´9?!‹*…&…+9B5NNêT\!J&/H/]"
''
!'
Ša­$H~-NNSs{ihJAN-ö|òNq9
„gŒ?\L762=H1\"ANsLL7N?I!+^jå¤,MWJG8-öJ$Om
Z5MAN¹“`{A=ÕVH1\"
:NY2LL7J`Â=H7B+^ïå¤,NùKO!AN-ö^ŒNË BZM41H!
$H¶vòN6w`µÍŒ=!3H:N"
!"TN¿1DbŒI!ANlí`„.0[=Hu
H1\Y2MÖ_]\"$HN+~-,C9N+Ò1]9,NFW[6!+€ÿ@<\°Ž,
`WBZ=ÕVH1\"A=H_6ÈN®‡nls.N486!:N:JMiCé]¢6F1
H1L1J:^M!Ë8Nxhd60\JÁ3Z]\"
&!"%$#
:NY2L-ö|òN¶vDL6wq9MF1H!áOXãàüÉNJ:^!gÀN+4_
[M,J=H£ìI7\SKN–ºB\¬5Ð`ÜFMÙEH1L1"
J-SOX M=HW!#
!
"
"T'±NÝEIY2X8$±¯ÑâN$‘pN+dÇï,6ëH8
\J12<•I0\"$HNSNBVN„ÝDLf|gyj|nWtXâOþ²WN87LY
;`:L=B!gIN€hIN½ôDL+J-SOX,fhn$*X!-öOZQN$HD$^ŒD
ˆ©6!®‡ãàüM>_>_Já›;]\Y2ML\NW!XO[:N#
!
"
"TH}ÄN:J
I0^2"=5W!?IMþ&Nž÷O!+IFRS,LKÞNø=1+$H~-,NNSM[!
+OZJ$,X+ISO,LKO¦NnrldhML[!®‡šZN}9M;3ò6ZL8LE
H7H1\"TB:]Z6Oc=H1\-ö|ò!fhnòN87LlíXq9W!AN@)
N;IãBDMJEH;3!?IMy'k|Œ=BªkJ=HI,Ú;]\MÙEH1\"
=5=L6Z:]ZO¯=Hð;Lq9IOL1"+^ïå¤,J+^jå¤,J12®‡
J$N+$H¶v,N‚1NË BZMO!XO[-ö^ŒN8q96+aI1\"E. Hall
)"
)
(
'%#
#
#*OÞNY2M×C?\"?L_D+^ŒN…]B¿1`mZ5M?\õ¨O!
RF0\"„FO!ä1#7M¼5EH\Û)^Œ*`*m=L9]PLZL1óÅI0[!
W2„FO!·ÍáÌMýÂ=FF0\Y2M!
FJDL^Œ$H6e’=ÕV\J7I0\"
,
1T_6ȟªN®‡-öN48OT;M!n‹I!:NRFNúÆLõ¨MMÝM@n=F
F0\NIOL15"
=5=L6Z:NY2L-öb'cmdkv'N¶vJW¸2R7tj$y'y)y'yN
y'y*Nb¾OyÓ®z~3%60[!êPLb¾OQ=1)(o #
!
!
"%"
%
)(&
!*
"FT[
:Nb—O/Iݝ655\J12:JI0\"ûMe{'pyLÚEIƒEBä1Þ#7Q
N»76AN¯VæML\J?]P!A]Zø#7N>´X-öb—M6=H!®‡˜!-ö
|6·ÝEI15L\ó`ŽB=2\5!A]6T;MÉ!q_]H1\NIOL1C^2
5"
}
ò
'Gx¥-œÊdèN”ß(_&#
"T$±¯Ñ(,
-癮‡Îk.#
!
!)#
"
!#
"
##No#
#
)
$(MY]P!OZJ
$*
$œÊJÔV¡zqw'NáØMY\œÊfhnNòñO!:î_«I'
$/)$8œÊfþIO(!/*!?‰
=I&
'/)M&
(/*JN:JI0\6!áÌN½ôDfhnO!U=^:]MU2âONOZœÊZrN0
§Xªks{ihZrM49\!y'yN†tXuojx|eϪNBVNâOþ²WN08NS26!O
\5MúÆLY;MLEH1\Y2MÖ_]\"
('
"(
NUCB JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS
AND INFORMATION SCIENCE vol.56 No.1
!$#"
0Šöq*#
!!
"+
"0o™(Ry1HÃ:C1NTT ðm
Dale, Peter. N.*"
*)'+The Myth of Japanese Uniqueness, London, Croom Helm.
Ferraro, G. P.*"**
!+The Cultural Dimension of International Business, N.J. PrenticeHall Inc.*2"*
*#!ʔ¹Š$;
P+Å Œ0ˆz’wn`y‚j&ÏÕq`naEz’%›œ1[z¢+
X†ì$‰Špê$B‹ËÛ$Ð'Š"¿*#
!
!
*+
.L<Mië…*ÖI\bü°)#
!
!*c'¸8–RYK5C/
&aÍ!õჇ "#)#
$
0õჇ No#
")(
(1
!#
!
!
*c*¸#
X†–Æ*#!
!$+0fšÉE­7)a†IäZçÚ±JGA®3I71FÂŸÿæ
X†–Æ$U¬?œ#
"'§ COE NIB9P¶»«c‚d(*#
!!
(+
0NIB9P¶œ)/9±RJ5QÚÞ61Ázæ
Hall, E.T.*"*('+Beyond Culture, NY. Anchor Press/Doubleday,.*2"
**
$!¤P´ã$B=Œ0z’RJ5C1TBS
s~dmY#+
uV$\€(t*#!
!
$+
0]‚rh‚_($sf[fj)\b7O‘KD1uV]‚^€hU‚\\€(t
†Cµe*"***+0ûIwn`y‚j)¶Iÿp}eVx1NTT ðm
¤P˜Ü*"*(
)+
0½>a†I¶wS1a†¶Ôÿ{æ
“À‹GD*"
**(+0a†³¶Ixº).NIB9P/I.#8T`TR~5Q1PHP »«ó
“À‹GD*#
!!(+
.¶âŸ%|ϔ¥±Wã8a†HG>KG3’Ž/
0t`i‚j1#!
!
(c#¸"
#aÍ!
(
t`i‚jæ##
')#
“À‹GD$Ò2þÇ$¨:N©*#
!"
!+
0](v(j$Zol‚aI¶œ)–æWãIÿ=3p}eVx1
nš
“Xñq$÷úŸ$·v?*#
!
!
)+
.4ýI,ï<-E4ýÉ9)@#—IÑIy17O/
0Š¯q`naq|(1
#!
!)!SPR#%!)&(
Merton, R.K.,*"*
&(+Social Theory and Social Structure, revised.. Illinois, The Free Press,*2"*
'"!!U¿$!Ät$
²Aå$FT—;žŒ0斒ŸEæ–É91L?@ô„!
+
£Ù"D*"
*)
'+
0.zˆŸI˜“/R^M1úž!¤gôO
׊‚d*#!
!)+
.(RM…šI-)$~IyYmbx)a†H6:Q ISO"
%!
!
"Iuªáœy1/
04ý•œ1
#
%
"*$+
!%
$)&%
%}
a¶q`naîv*#
!
!
!+
0;SG¶éƒJ3OG31@#ù.;SG ISO J3OG3/%
())
&}
a¶q`naîv*#
!
!
%+
.]î$mfv‚I½û8¦G3/
0a¶q`na1#!
!%c$¸)aÍ!$
!)%
#'!#
&')#
'(Øø
a¶ÿ{æ*#
!
!)+0a†QÚ$ŽèVbxIH31a¶q`na%z¾*òð#!
!
%+""
*)"
‘:¡Š*"*
*(+0¶¡’Ÿ1nš
ÐX‰Ó$ÙP"‰•*#!
!
%+
0(REz’)4ýRZ7?¼5G3š1a†¶Ôÿ{æ
Schein, E.H.*"*
)
&+Organizational Culture and Leadership, S.F. Jossey-Bass Inc.*2"*
)*!,&§q$rPÇ  Œ
04ýz’E~(e(_ft)~(e(Jz’RF4~›?Q71eV{z‚kæ+
)'.
Swidler, A.*"
*)
'+Culture in Action)Symbols and Strategies, American Sociologial Review,&"*#+
&#
($)#
PFjí*"
*)
)+
0a†M¶I‡¡’1[z¢
jfkWXV‡‹–4ý‡‹–!KŒà$lP$`$ÌPszŒ*"
*
*'+0_vW(IWÎM 4L%’Ÿ
€1
0[$g(€€1
!kVô„
WX(o("M#'™ÈݞŒ*"
*
'
!+
0ßhI斜$ƒ15zæ*Weber, M. Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft, Grundriss der verstehenden Soziologie, Kapitel „, Soziologie der Herrschaft,"*
&'+
)'
#)