Erik Schoep (ArkeFly)

Arke Boeing 787-8
Composite Structure Inspections
Airline Perspective
Erik Schoep
Structures Engineer ArkeFly
Contents
1. Introduction
2. B787 Structures Overview
3. B787 Specific Technologies:
a. Ramp Damage Checker
b. Quick Composite Repair
c. Solid Laminate: Bonded Repair
d. Solid Laminate: Bolted Titanium Repair
4. Scheduled Inspections: Aircraft Maintenance Program
5. Non-scheduled Inspections: Accidental Damage
6. Practical Examples
a. Case 1: Low Energy Surface Damage
b. Case 2: High Energy Impact
7. Questions?
TUI Travel PLC -
2
Contents
1. Introduction
2. B787 Structures Overview
3. B787 Specific Techniques:
a. Ramp Damage Checker
b. Quick Composite Repair
c. Solid Laminate: Bonded Repair
d. Solid Laminate: Bolted Titanium Repair
4. Scheduled Inspections: Aircraft Maintenance Program
5. Non-scheduled Inspections: Accidental Damage
6. Practical Examples
a. Case 1: Low Energy Surface Damage
b. Case 2: High Energy Impact
7. Questions?
TUI Travel PLC -
3
Introduction
TUI Airlines:
Arke (NL)
JetairFly (B)
Thomson Airways (UK)
TUIFly (D)
TUI Nordic (S)
Type
Arke
TUI Airlines
B737NG
5
85
B757
-
15
B767
3 (1)
9
B787-8
1 (3)
8 (13)
E190
-
2
Total
9
119
TUI Travel PLC -
4
Contents
1. Introduction
2. B787 Structures Overview
3. B787 Specific Techniques:
a. Ramp Damage Checker
b. Quick Composite Repair
c. Solid Laminate: Bonded Repair
d. Solid Laminate: Bolted Titanium Repair
4. Scheduled Inspections: Aircraft Maintenance Program
5. Non-scheduled Inspections: Accidental Damage
6. Practical Examples
a. Case 1: Low Energy Surface Damage
b. Case 2: High Energy Impact
7. Questions?
TUI Travel PLC -
5
Structures Overview
TUI Travel PLC -
6
Structures Overview
•
•
•
CFRP Solid Laminate
Material BMS 8-276 (various shapes)
Typical fuselage skin thickness range ± 0,075” (crown area), ±10 plies
± 0,500” (at cutouts), ±70 plies
aerodynamic surface (OML)
P1 plain weave with phosphor bronze mesh
P2 plain weave
P3 UD tape
P4 UD tape
P5 UD tape
P6 UD tape
P(x) UD tape
P(n) plain weave
non-aerodynamic surface (IML)
TUI Travel PLC -
7
Structures Overview
TUI Travel PLC -
8
Structures Overview
Skin and Stringers
(Carbon Epoxy)
TUI Travel PLC -
9
Contents
1. Introduction
2. B787 Structures Overview
3. B787 Specific Techniques:
a. Ramp Damage Checker
b. Quick Composite Repair
c. Solid Laminate: Bonded Repair
d. Solid Laminate: Bolted Titanium Repair
4. Scheduled Inspections: Aircraft Maintenance Program
5. Non-scheduled Inspections: Accidental Damage
6. Practical Examples
a. Case 1: Low Energy Surface Damage
b. Case 2: High Energy Impact
7. Questions?
TUI Travel PLC -
10
Ramp Damage Checker
TUI Travel PLC -
11
Ramp Damage Checker
TUI Travel PLC -
12
Quick Composite Repair
•
•
•
•
•
•
Category C repair: 24 months
GVI every 90 days
Provided in complete kit (approx.
10,000 USD)
6 different patches (carbon/glass fiber,
various thicknesses)
Repair lightning strike damage, dent,
scratch, delamination
Max. damage dimensions: 4,0x0,75 inch
or diam. 2,0 inch (up to 5 plies)
TUI Travel PLC -
13
Quick Composite Repair
TUI Travel PLC -
14
Quick Composite Repair
Post repair inspections:
• Check temperature strip on anti-caul plate
• Visual inspect squeeze out of adhesive at repair edge
• Tap test for complete bonding
Apply:
• Aluminum foil patch
• Reflective patch (white)
TUI Travel PLC -
15
Solid Laminate: Bonded Repair
•
•
•
Category A repair on CFRP solid laminate skin
Double Vacuum Debulk procedure
Thermal survey
TUI Travel PLC -
16
Solid Laminate: Bonded Repair
Post repair inspections:
• Ultrasonic inspection: A-scan or C-scan
• Tap test acceptable in repairs of 4
repair plies or less
Reject repair if:
- Voids, disbonds, delaminations etc.
larger than 0,5 inch (solid laminate)
- Porosity <4% in area larger than 2 inch2
TUI Travel PLC -
17
Solid Laminate: Bolted Titanium Repair
•
•
•
•
•
Category B repair on CFRP solid laminate skin and stringers
HFEC, LFEC, DET inspections: threshold 12,000 FC; interval 5,000 FC
Titanium doubler installed with hi-loks and blind bolts
Drilling procedure in composite/titanium structure (burn composite, damage
substructure, fiber breakout)
Borescope inspection of blind bolts
TUI Travel PLC -
18
Contents
1. Introduction
2. B787 Structures Overview
3. B787 Specific Techniques:
a. Ramp Damage Checker
b. Quick Composite Repair
c. Solid Laminate: Bonded Repair
d. Solid Laminate: Bolted Titanium Repair
4. Scheduled Inspections: Aircraft Maintenance Program
5. Non-scheduled Inspections: Accidental Damage
6. Practical Examples
a. Case 1: Low Energy Surface Damage
b. Case 2: High Energy Impact
7. Questions?
TUI Travel PLC -
19
Scheduled Inspections: Aircraft Maintenance Program
B767-300
GE CF6
B787-8
GEnX
A-check
850 FH
(60 days)
2000 FH
(130 days)
Servicing/Lubrication
C-check
8500 FH
3000 FC
2 YR
12000 FH
6000 FC
3 YR
- external detailed in general of door cutout structures and door
stops,
- special inspections of vertical fin root bolts (i-Bolts)
13 tasks
light access
12000 FC
6 YR
- internal and external detailed inspections requiring numerous
panel removals,
- inspections focus on MLG, tail and fuselage support structure
27 tasks
deep access
24000 FC
12 YR
- internal and external detailed inspections including deep access
of the interior of the cabin
92 tasks
deep access
Thresholds:
33,000 FC
44,000 FC
FLS
Supplemental Structural Inspections (PSE) In accordance with
Damage Tolerance Rating (DTR) check forms
- Detailed visual and NDT inspections
Fatigue
Inspections
Thresholds:
25,000 FC
40,000 FC
50,000 FC
In general:
• Scheduled inspections (MPD) are detailed visual (borescope) (except PSE)
• Optional to do external NDT instead of internal visual inspections
TUI Travel PLC -
20
Scheduled Inspections: Aircraft Maintenance Program
i-Bolt® Inspection
Load Control Technologies,
an Innovation Plus LLC company
TUI Travel PLC -
21
Contents
1. Introduction
2. B787 Structures Overview
3. B787 Specific Techniques:
a. Ramp Damage Checker
b. Quick Composite Repair
c. Solid Laminate: Bonded Repair
d. Solid Laminate: Bolted Titanium Repair
4. Scheduled Inspections: Aircraft Maintenance Program
5. Non-scheduled Inspections: Accidental Damage
6. Practical Examples
a. Case 1: Low Energy Surface Damage
b. Case 2: High Energy Impact
7. Questions?
TUI Travel PLC -
22
Non-scheduled inspections: Accidental Damage
Barely Visible Impact Damage:
- Small damages that may not be found during
scheduled inspections (GVI)
- Ultimate design strength required during service life
- Validated by testing
impact location
TUI Travel PLC -
23
Non-scheduled inspections: Accidental Damage
TUI Travel PLC -
24
Non-scheduled inspections: Accidental Damage
High energy impact (e.g. GSE >3 km/h, birdstrike)
1. External visual and NDI inspection.
2. Only in case of external findings:
Internal visual and NDI inspection.
3. Evaluate any findings in accordance with SRM.
Low energy impact
1. Evaluate visual damage in accordance with SRM.
2. Ramp Damage Checker or NDI only if SRM requires.
TUI Travel PLC -
25
Contents
1. Introduction
2. B787 Structures Overview
3. B787 Specific Techniques:
a. Ramp Damage Checker
b. Quick Composite Repair
c. Solid Laminate: Bonded Repair
d. Solid Laminate: Bolted Titanium Repair
4. Scheduled Inspections: Aircraft Maintenance Program
5. Non-scheduled Inspections: Accidental Damage
6. Practical Examples
a. Case 1: Low Energy Surface Damage
b. Case 2: High Energy Impact
7. Questions?
TUI Travel PLC -
26
Practical Examples
Case 1: Low energy surface damage
Surface nick at forward cargo door cutout
Beyond SRM allowable limits due to fastener proximity
12 x 12 mm, 4 plies deep
Temp. repair (400 FC): apply aluminum foil tape
Final repair: seal with resin
TUI Travel PLC -
27
Practical Examples
Case 2: High energy impact
Cargo loader impact at aft cargo door cutout at outstation
1. During turnaround in Curaçao:
a. Internal and external detailed visual inspection
b. Ramp Damage Checker (external)
2. Internal and external C-scan inspection during scheduled maintenance within 10 FC.
TUI Travel PLC -
28
Practical Examples
Case 2: High energy impact
Cargo loader impact at aft cargo door cutout at outstation
TUI Travel PLC -
29
Questions?
TUI Travel PLC -
30