Recent Advances in Understanding of Diamond Wire Swing

Recent Advances in Understanding of
Diamond Wire Sawing of Solar Silicon
Shreyes Melkote
Morris M. Bryan, Jr. Professor of
Advanced Manufacturing Systems
Woodruff School of Mechanical Engineering
Georgia Institute of Technology
Atlanta, Georgia
July 8, 2014
c-Si PVMC Workshop on Diamond Wire Sawing
San Franciso, CA
Outline
• Overview of silicon wafering
• Slurry vs. diamond wire sawing
• Diamond scribing studies
• Effect of crystal defects
• Short and long term challenges
Diamond Wire Sawing
Main Features
 Diamond impregnated wire
 Higher MRR (> 2x)
 Better surface quality and
low kerf loss
 Water-based fluid
 In use for single crystal Si diamond grit
steel core
Moller.H.J, Phys.Stat.Sol. 203(4): 659-669(2004)
Clark.W.J., et al., Int.J..Mach.Tool & Manuf., 43:523-532(2003)
Yang.F., et al., J.Elec.Pack.,123:254-259(2001)
V
Feed
Wire
Guide
Nickel coating
Slurry vs. Diamond Wire Sawing
Fixed Diamond Wire Sawing
Loose Abrasive Slurry Sawing
Surface Morphology
Yang et al., Adv. Eng. Mat., 2012
Wafer Thickness Comparison
215
Slurry
Wafer thckness (µm)
210
DWS
205
200
195
190
185
180
0
50
100
Distance from wire entry (mm)
Yang et al., Adv. Eng. Mat., 2012
150
Surface Roughness Comparison
Areal surface roughness, Sa (µm)
0.4
MWSS
DWS
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
50
100
Distance from wire entry (mm)
Yang et al., Adv. Eng. Mat., 2012
150
Weibull Plot
Yang et al., Adv. Eng. Mat., 2012
Diamond Scribing Studies
Ductile mode
Brittle mode
• Brittle vs. ductile cutting?
• How do grit properties and cutting depth affect the cutting
mode?
Surface Morphology
0.123 µm
0.722 µm
1.225 µm
Increasing depth of scribe
Scribing of (111) CZ wafer in the [112] direction at 1mm/min
Wu and Melkote, Mat. Sci. Eng. A, 2012
XFEM Modeling
•
•
XFEM allows modeling of crack (discontinuity) initiation and propagation
Model setup in ABAQUS/Standard
–
–
–
–
Quasi-static model
Linearly increasing scribe depth
Frictional contact between scriber and silicon
Axisymmetric model
CZ (111)<110>
Wu and Melkote, ASME J. Eng. Mat. Tech., 2012
Simulation Results
Scriber I
Scriber II
• Critical depth for crack initiation:
387.6 nm (Scriber I )
34.6nm (Scriber II )
• Implication: higher wire feed rate possible without causing cracks
Wu and Melkote, ASME J. Eng. Mat. Tech., 2012
Validation
SEM of scribed groove (Scriber I)
XFEM model
• ‘Chevron’ type crack geometry observed and simulated
 Measured critical depth = 318±37.2 nm (at location of first observed crack)
 Model predicted critical depth = 387.6 nm
• Hydrostatic pressure (9.45 GPa) predicted prior to cracking is greater than
phase transformation pressure (8.8 GPa)
• Amorphization confirmed by Raman spectroscopy
Wu and Melkote, ASME J. Eng. Mat. Tech., 2012
Effect of Included Angle
Conical tip
• Scriber with larger included angle yields larger critical depth of cut (more
ductile cutting is possible)
Wu and Melkote, ASME J. Eng. Mat. Tech., 2012
Effect of Crystal Defects
Effect of Dislocation Density: Critical Depth of Cut
Region I
Region II
Region III
Region IV
Region V
350
Critical depth (nm)
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
(100) grain
(311) grain
Wu and Melkote, Mat. Sci. Semi. Proc., 2013
Effect of Hard Inclusions
• Smooth scratching motion
disrupted at the SiNx rods
Wu and Melkote, Prec. Eng., 2013
Summary
 Wafering is a critical step in c-Si PV manufacturing
 Wafer surface characteristics and mechanical
properties depend on the process type and material
characteristics
 Abrasive characteristics play an important role in
determining the cutting mode and surface and subsurface quality in diamond wire sawing
 Demand for high-throughput, better surface quality,
and less surface/sub-surface damage calls for
improved understanding of wire sawing process
science
Acknowledgements
• NSF IUCRC on Silicon Solar Consortium