What are the benefits of physical activity? Posttraumatic knee OA

20.03.2014
What are the benefits of physical activity?
Oslo University Hospital Norwegian School Sport Sciences
NIMI
Coronary
hear
disease
& Stroke
Exercises and Musculoskeletal Health
Diabetes
Obesity
Physical
activity & Health
Linköping, Mars 2014
Musculo
skeletal
Professor and physical therapist May Arna Risberg
Norwegian Research Center Active Rehabilitation (NAR)
Mental well‐
beingl
Cancer
Norwegian School of Sport Sciences, NIMI, and Oslo University Hospital, Norway
www.active‐rehab.no
Fysioterapeuten nr 3 2014
The new life style disease – musculoskeletal disorders ‐
Musculoskeletal injury and disorders
•
Musculoskeletal injury and disorders are common
–
–
–
–
•
•
•
•
•
most common cause of severe long‐term pain and disability
20‐30% of adults are affected at one time
25% of the total cost of illness in Sweden Most common cause of health problem limiting work ability
Prevalence of symptomatic OA >50 years ‐ between 7‐15 %
Increase with age and related to negative lifestyle factors as obesity, smoking and physical inactivity
2013
“Plager flest og
Tendon
koster
mest”
– 30% to 50% due to overuse injuries in sport Shoulder: – 16% of general population suffers from shoulder pain
– 21% in the elderly population
Articular cartilage lesions
– 60‐63% had cartilage lesions found in 31.516 knee arthroscopy Woolf AD et al 2004, Picavet HS et al 2003, Jaconson & Lindgren 1996, National Board of Health and welfare, Sweden 2001 , MST Rapport, Oslo , Norway 2013, Rees JD et al 2009, Curl WW et al 1997, Hjelle K et al 2002,
Robi K et al The Physiology of Sports Injuries and repair processes (Chapter 2). In: Current Issues in Sports and Exercise Medicine, 2013 Knee injuries
Posttraumatic knee OA
Musculoskeletal injury and disorders
•
• 40‐50 % of patients with knee OA come from previous injury – onset of the OA disease process • ACL injuries (combined): 21‐48% with symptomatic and radiological knee OA
•
• Full thickness cartilage defects in 36% of athletes
• Cartilage defect associated with decreased knee cartilage volume and increased rate of cartilage loss
•
•
•
Mithoefer 2012, Øiestad 2009, 2010, Flanigan 2010,Brophy 2010, Walczak 2008, Widuchowski 2007, Eckstein 2006, Ding C 2005, Piasecki 2003, Årøen 2004
Musculoskeletal injury or disorders are common
Musculoskeletal injury and disorders are common in all – most common cause of severe long‐term pain and disability
age groups, sport, leisure time and work disorders, and – 20‐30% of adults are affected at one time
high costs for society – 25% of the total cost of illness in Sweden – Most common cause of health problem limiting work ability
Increase with age and related to negative lifestyle factors as obesity, smoking and physical inactivity
Tendon: 30% to 50% due to overuse injuries in sport Shoulder: Studies from primary care show that 16% of general population suffers from shoulder pain ‐ 21% in the elderly population
Articular cartilage lesions: 60‐63% had cartilage lesions found in 31.516 knee arthroscopy Woolf AD et al 2004, Picavet HS et al 2003, Jaconson & Lindgren 1996, National Board of Health and welfare, Sweden 2001 , MST Rapport, Oslo , Norway 2013, Rees JD et al 2009, Curl WW et al 1997, Hjelle K et al 2002,
Robi K et al The Physiology of Sports Injuries and repair processes (Chapter 2). In: Current Issues in Sports and Exercise Medicine, 2013 1
20.03.2014
Musculoskeletal injury and disorders
Musculoskeletal injury and disorders
Why are we not more successful in treatment?
Why are we not more successful in treatment?
1. A heterogeneous group > 200 different clinical health problems
1. A heterogeneous group > 200 different clinical health problems
Clinical health problem
Clinical health problem
Clinical diagnosis
Heterogeneous
Clinical manifestation
Mechanisms/
Biology
Unclear
Yes
Not known
1. Many of the 200
European League Against Rheumatism 2012: http://www.eular.org, Hagen KB et al 2012
Clinical diagnosis
Heterogeneous
Clinical manifestation
Mechanisms/
Biology
1. Many of the 200
Unclear
Yes
Not known
2. Fibromyalgia
Unclear
Yes
Not known
Partly known
3. Osteoarthritis
Yes
Yes
4. Rheumatoid Arthritis
Yes
Yes
Well known
5. Osteoporosis
Yes
Yes
Well known
2. Understanding biology (molecular level) is crucial and the only way to appropriate therapies
3. Exercise therapy programs need to be improved Dose‐response
Progression of exercises
European League Against Rheumatism 2012: Patient education
http://www.eular.org, Hagen KB et al 2012
Dagens praksis ? Exercises and Musculoskeletal Health
Muskel‐ og skjelettskader ”gå hjem og ta det med ro et par uker”
• For decades, inactivity and bed rest were the main treatment strategies for patients with musculoskeletal injury and disorders
Kunnskapsbasert ? Nei
Er dette beste behandling ? Nei
Påføres pasientene funksjonsproblemer? Ja
• A paradigm has evolved
– physical activity and exercises are beneficial to health, not only for traditionally life style diseases, but also for musculoskeletal injury and disorders
– The negative effects of immobilization on musculoskeletal tissue are well known
• How do we treat patients with musculoskeletal injury?
Evidence‐Based Medicine (EBM) Immobilization and rehabilitation ‐changes in quadriceps lean mass‐
Muscles, ligaments, tendons, cartilage, bone
Behandling av muskelskjelettskader
3 x immobilization period!
Immob.
Exercise ‐ Rehabilitation
2 weeks
2 weeks
MAFbx
Calpain 3
6 weeks
24 h
Calpain 1,2
Calpastatin
Myostatin
MAFbx
6 weeks
Calpain 1
Myostatin
Jones et al Physiology, 2004
2
20.03.2014
How to exercise for musculoskeletal health?
What is “exercise”?
Terminology
• Physical activity
– all energy expended by movement
• Bodily movement produced by skeletal muscles that results in energy expenditure
• Physical Fitness
– Set of attributes that determine capacity for physical activity
• Exercises
– Planned, structured and repetitive: to improve fitness and health
• Exercise therapy
– Prescription of a program that involves specific exercises to target symptoms, improving function, and improving, retaining or slowing deterioration of health
Aktiv rehabilitering: Målrettet treningsprogram basert på optimalt dosert øvelsesprogram for å gjenvinne, bevare og utvikle funksjonsevnen
From Exercise therapy to return to physical activities/Sport (Health)
Musculo
skeletal
injury/ disorder
Målrettet basert på: optimalt dosert øvelsesprogram for å gjenvinne, bevare og utvikle funksjonsevnen
Exercise therapy
Planned, structured and repetitive: to improve fitness and health
Exercises
All energy expended by movement:
Everyday activities that involve moving the body
Physical activity
Evidence Exercise and Exercise therapy Adherence to exercises?
Exercise for musculoskeletal conditions
Cochrane Musculoskeletal Group 2012
• Osteoarthritis
Exercise and physical activity is beneficial for the most • Osteoporosis
common types of chronic musculoskeletal pain. • Rheumatoid arthritis, ankylosing
spondylitis, fibromyalgia, juvenile arthritis
However, poor adherence
to exercise and physical activity may • Regional musculoskeletal conditions
limit long‐term effectiveness.
– Knee, low back, neck, shoulder, chronic musculoskeletal pain
3
20.03.2014
Exercise therapy and pain
Exercise therapy and physical function
0.30
0.15
0.40
0.37
0.33
0.10
0.53
0.40
0.49
0.12
Hagen et al 2012
Exercise therapy for bone and muscle health: an overview of systematic review •
Evidence supporting the continued use of exercise therapy for musculoskeletal conditions
•
The effect of exercise on disease pathogenesis
– Lack knowledge on (except for osteoporosis ): disease pathogenesis , the magnitude of the positive effects, clinical relevance and the cost effectiveness
Few adverse effects – safe and well tolerated
•
•
How to exercise for musculoskeletal health?
Dose?
Type?
Prescription of exercise programs with optimal health benefits for the individual patient, more knowledge is needed on which particular elements and modes of exercise therapy, as well as the dose and frequency of delivery
Prescriptions – dose?
Exercise therapy
Physical activity
• Healing tissue and restoring/remodeling tissue
• Red flags checked
• Life style changes
•
•
•
•
Muscle Tendon and Ligament
Cartilage
Bone
Dose‐response
Medicine
Physical activity
 Physical capacity (VO2)
 Muscle strength and endurance
 Neuromuscular power
Exercises
• Muscle strength in rehabilitation
Exercise therapy
Dose matters!
Musculo
skeletal injury/ disorder
– Max strength, endurance and power
• Neuromuscular training in rehabilitation?
• Loading response ?  Bone
– Tendon and ligaments
– Cartilage
Lack knowledge
4
20.03.2014
Dose‐response
Dose‐response
– Physical activity
– Exercises
– Exercise therapy – Physical activity
– Exercises
– Exercise therapy • injury or dysfunctions •
Rehabilitation: injury or disorders “Lagom”
Dose‐response
Dose‐response
Muscle strength training
• Guidelines for healthy adults
– Physical activity
– Exercises
– Exercise therapy • Rehabilitation: injury or disorders
• Patient group
– Muscle
– Tendon and ligaments
– Cartilage – Bone – High load, low rep when tolerable
– Variations in loads and exercises to avoid stagnation
– Progressive overload
Progression is need to improve muscle strength • Healing tissue and restoring/remodeling tissue
AMERICAN COLLEGE OF SPORTS MEDICINE POSITION STAND
“SCIENTIFIC STUDIES OF STRENGTH TRAINING PRINCIPLES AND METHODS USED BY ATHLETES SHOULD FORM THE BASIS OF REHABILITATION EXERCISE PROTOCOLS”
Augustsson KSSTA 2012
• Resistance training can be used successfully as a therapeutic modality in several musculoskeletal conditions, especially those of a chronic variety
• Resistance training proven effective in a healthy population, can also be successfully applied in a rehabilitation context
Progression is need to improve muscle strength Raymond MJ et al 2013
5
20.03.2014
Neuromuscular training
The effect of balance or instability training on force output, functional performance, balance
Behn & Colado 2012
• Supplementing traditional strength training to improve function and mitigate abnormal movement patterns
*Di Stasi & Snyder‐Mackler, Clin Biomech 2012, Logerstedt et al JOSPT 2010, Fitzgerald et al Phys Ther 2000
Behn & Colado 2012
Behn & Colado 2012 The effect of instability training on force
The effect of balance or instability training on functional measures
Behn & Colado 2012
Resistance exercises using unstable surfaces
The effect of balance or instability training on balance and stability
• Sport specificity
• Increase stress on the neuromuscular system to a greater extent than the traditional strength training
• In rehab: increase muscle activation, but reduce forces across a joint
• Dose ‐ response?
Progression is need to improve neuromuscular function
6
20.03.2014
Dose‐response
Dose‐response
Tendon and ligament
Cartilage ‐ joints
Loading
– Optimal stress – strain curve to maintain healthy
1. Mechonotransduction of physical force to biochemical actions
2. Metabolically tenocytes age
3. Repetitive loading • mechanically alters the shape of the fibroblast cells in tendons
• Needs recovery
4. High load ‐ overload
• Needs recovery
• Cartilage
• Biomechanics
• Muscles
• Immobilization has a more rapid effect on mechanical properties than increased load from exercise Evidence for exercises for tendinopathy:
Eccentric training and high intensity progressive resistance training
Eckstein F et al 2006, Sun HB 2010, Leong DJ et al 2011
Nordin M et al 2001
The right dose in the prescription of exercises
Hart & Scott 2013
•
•
•
•
Understanding some basic science will help us as clinicians to approach acute and chronic connective tissue conditions
Mechanical loading and unloading follows key biological principles
Connective tissues of the musculoskeletal system are diverse, but share some common features
– Matrix‐rich tissues with relatively few cells ‐ respond to mechanical active but different environments
– Mechanical loading
– Compressive forces: cartilage, menisci and bone
– shear forces: bone
– tensile loading : muscle, tendons and ligaments
Cells respond to different – mechanical cues (mechanotransduction)
– biological cues from the endocrine system
The right dose in the prescription of exercises
Hart & Scott 2013
•
•
•
•
Understanding some basic science will help us as clinicians to approach acute and chronic connective tissue conditions
Mechanical loading and unloading follows key biological principles
Connective tissues of the musculoskeletal system are diverse, but share some common features
– Matrix‐rich tissues with relatively few cells ‐ respond to mechanical active but different environments
– Mechanical loading
– Compressive forces: cartilage, menisci and bone
– shear forces: bone
– tensile loading: muscle, tendons and ligaments
Cells respond to different Mechano‐
– mechanical cues (mechanotransduction)
transduction
– biological cues from the endocrine system
The right dose in the prescription of exercises
Hart & Scott 2013
•
•
•
•
Understanding some basic science will help us as clinicians to approach acute and chronic connective tissue conditions
Mechanical loading and unloading follows key biological principles
Connective tissues of the musculoskeletal system are diverse, but share some common features
– Matrix‐rich tissues with relatively few cells ‐ respond to mechanical active but different environments
– Mechanical loading
– Compressive forces: cartilage, menisci and bone
– Shear forces: bone
– Tensile loading: muscle, tendons and ligaments
Cells respond to different – mechanical cues (mechanotransduction)
– biological cues from the endocrine system
Mechanotransduction
• Mechanotransduction is the process of converting physical forces into intracellular biochemical responses • The combination of mechanical and biological cues contributes to the anabolic/catabolic balance in the various tissue • In most tissue these processes seem to be regulated by the individual cell, but not in bone
• Bone
– the processes appear to be regulated by two different effector cells, the osteoblast and the osteoclast • Articular cartilage – mechanical loads are absorbed by the cartilage extracellular matrix (ECM) and transmitted to chondrocytes
Yubing Sun & Jianping Fu:
"Mechanobiology: A new frontier for human pluripotent stem cells," Integrative Biology, vol. 5, pp. 450‐457, 2013
7
20.03.2014
Knee injury and osteoarthritis Treatment focus?
•
•
Trauma
•
•
Dynamic mechano‐responsive tissue
Joints in motion – the greates potential for improving the lives of people with OA
Exercise promote tissue healing
The effect of exercise type and dose
Osteoarthritis
Early OA
Secondary
prevention
Severe OA
Tertiary
prevention
Joint failure • Turning movement into tissue healing
, Khan &Scott 2009
Wall ME et al 2005, Cheema U et al 2005, Banes AJ et al 2007, Khan &Scott 2009, Alfredson & Cook 2007, Jonsson P et al 2008
Mechanical loading should be used therapeutically to stimulate tissue repair and remodeling
Evidence Exercise therapy ‐ knee OA
Modality
Effect size‐ Pain
Effect size – Physical function
Aerobics
0.52
0.46
0.32
0.32
Strengthening
OARSI recommendations ‐ Part III. Zhang et al 2010
There is level 1a evidence that exercise therapy has at least short term effect on pain and function (illness)
in people with knee OA
Bennell et al 2013 ‐ the role of muscle in the management of knee OA‐
Evidence 2012– 2013 Exercises and knee OA ‐ 2012 and 2013
• Symptoms and dysfunctions (illness)
– Tanaka et al 2013 – systematic review and meta‐analysis
– Loew et al 2012 –
meta‐analysis: walking programs SMD
Tanaka et al 2013
Modality
Pain
– Wang et al 2012 – systematic review: different PT interventions
– Hiyama et al 2012 –
RCT: walking program
Weigh‐bearing
strengthening exercises
0.70
– Kim et al 2012 – RCT: aquarobic exercises
Non‐weight‐bearing strengthening exercises
1.42
– Ebnezar et al 2012 – RCT: yoga therapy
– Fernandes et al 2013 EULAR recommendations
Aerobic
exercises
0.45
– Abbott JH et al 2013 – RCT: manual therapy and multi‐modal exercises
Total (95% CI)
0.94 (1.31‐0.57)
– Alpayci M et al 2013 – RCT: joint traction
• Structural changes (disease)
– Hunt MA et al 2013 – RCT: strengthening exercises: loading and uCTX‐II
– Beckwee D et al 2013 – why does it work?
Adherence is important for exercise efficacy
Lower risk of disability in high adherence subgroups
• Interventions affecting muscle dysfunctions
– Strengthening exercises
• ‐11 % ‐ 50 %
– Neuromuscular exercises – muscle activation
• 5‐14% • changes in voluntary activation predicted 47% of changes in quadriceps strength
– NEMS • Exercise prescriptions for muscle rehabilitation in knee OA
– Guidelines AGS and ACSM
– 40‐60% 1 RM 8‐12 reps 2‐3 t/w
• Patient adherence – Supervised – group based and home based
– Tailored
– Patient education
Bennell KL et al 2013, Wang S‐Y et al 2012
Pietrosimone & Saliba 2012, Scopaz et al 2009, Lange AK et al 2008,
O’Reilly SC et al 1999, Hurley MV et al 1998 8
20.03.2014
Why does exercise improve symptoms and dysfunctions?
How to exercise for musculoskeletal health?
• Muscular and neuromuscular components
Loading –
–
–
–
Muscles
Proprioception, balance and motor learning
Energy absorbing capacity
Stability
The neuromuscular system
Dose?
Type?
Knee OA
• Peri‐articular and intra‐articular components
Loading –
–
–
–
Connective tissue and bone
Cartilage
Inflammation
Joint fluid
• General fitness and health components
Loading – Weight loss, aerobic fitness
• Psychosocial components
– well being, self‐efficacy, depression, placebo
– Gait control mechanisms or Central release of endorphines
•
•
•
•
•
•
Beckwée D et al 2013
Standardized mean difference
RCTs exercise versus non-exercise
ACR criteria for OA
Knee OA (and hip OA if separate analysis)
Pain and disability
48 trials with 4,028 patients
64 years, 75% women, BMI:29
Exercise type:
Pain Disability
Aerobic
0.67
0.56
Resistance
0.62
0.60
Performance
0.48
0.56
Knee injury and osteoarthritis Day 1, 2
Early OA
Primary
prevention
Secondary
prevention
Osteoarthritis
Severe OA
Joint failure Conclusion:
• Optimal exercise program should have one
aim/focus (at a time)
• Patients with poor aerobic capacity, perform
strength and aerobic exercises on different days
• Should be supervised program 3 times weekly for
at least 12 sessions
Trauma
Treatment focus?
Day 3
Progression is need to improve function 9
20.03.2014
Evidence Exercise therapy ‐ focal cartilage defects
How to exercise for musculoskeletal health?
Dose?
Type?
Cartilage lesions
There are no RCTs evaluating the effect of exercises versus surgery or exercises alone
A few RTCs evaluating the effect of postopertive weightbearing on cartilage repair
Ebert J et al 2008, 2012, 2013, Wondrasch et al 2009
The effect of exercises on articular cartilage
The effect of exercises on articular cartilage
1. Specific exercises and short term changes in healthy
1. Exercises and short term changes in healthy
• Single‐leg lunges
• Bilateral knee bending exercises
• Drop landing exercises
• Walking
Deformation ranges from 2.2% to 40%
– 2.8% to 23 %
• Cycling
Deformational patterns depend on – 4.5 %
ROM, load, frequency and intensity as well as properties of patellar, tibial and femoral • Running
cartilage plates
– 2.2‐40% Deformation ranges from 1.8% to 30%
Recovery time dependent on deformation
Greater deformation after static bending compared to dynamic‐
90minutes recovery after 100 bilateral knee bending
Niehoff 2011,
Bingham 2008,
Eckstein 1998, 1999, 2000, 2006, Hudelmaier 2001
Hosseini 2010, Liu 2010, Eckstein 2005, Mayerhoefer 2010, Nag 2004, Niehoff 2011, Boocock 2009, Kersting 2005, Mosher 2005, 2010, Subburaj 2010, Kessler 2006, 2008, Krampla 2001, 2008
The effect of exercises on articular cartilage
The effect of exercises on articular cartilage
1. Exercises and short term changes in patients
2. Long term changes in healthy and patients
• Static compression
– OA patients increased deformation and contact areas
• Single –leg lunge
– ACL and ACLR: increased contact‐deformation Deformational patterns in patients showed responses that may subject the subchondral bone to higher impact stress
OA patients
Static compression have shown increased deformation and increased contact areas compared to healthy
Cotofana S et al 2011, Shin CS et al 2011, Subburaj K et al al 2012
• Articular cartilage functional adaptive changes seem to depend upon
– Age
– Type and level of activity
– Joint
• Healthy
• At risk
• OA/pathology Ans Van Ginckel 2013
10
20.03.2014
The effect of weight‐bearing exercises on knee articular cartilage responses in patients with early knee OA
Load modifying interventions
Van Ginckel A et al 2013
• Dynamic weight‐bearing loading –
30 knee bending exercises
Shorter exercise sessions but with higher frequency – Deformation similar between patients and controls (3.1‐ 3.9%)
‐ alternation between weight‐bearing and non‐weight‐bearing – Recovery tended to be slower in patients
exercises ‐
• Requiring more than 15 minutes after exercise cessation for all cartilage plates to restitute to baseline volumes
JOSPT 2013 The Oslo CARE Study
• Load modifying interventions for knee OA
– Exercise therapy – muscle function
– Gait modifications
– Braces
– Insoles
– Surgery
– Weight reduction!
• Load modifying interventions for focal
cartilage defects
– Exercise therapy – muscle function
– Specific ROM
– Weight reduction!
Wondrasch et al JOSPT 2013 Eligible for cartilage repair n=50
Included n=48
3 months rehab
Post‐testing
Neuromuscular exercises ‐ progression is needed‐
Exercise therapy
n=48
Continued no surgery OR Surgery
Surgery
n=17
No surgery
n=31
65%
Follow‐up 1 year
Surgery
n=17
No surgery
n=31
65%
Follow‐up 2 years
Surgery
n=21
No surgery
n=27
56 %
Slow progression for strength training
11
20.03.2014
Results – Wondrasch et al 2013
Results – Wondrasch et al 2013
Quadriceps strength
+ 29.9%
+ 2.5%
p < 0.0001
**Danneskiold‐Samsøe et al 2009
How to exercise for musculoskeletal health?
Dose?
Type?
Evidence
The effect of exercise therapy after ACL injury • Cochrane review – Trees AH et al 2007 • Systematic reviews
ACL rupture
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
Risberg et al 2004
Wright et al 2008 Zech et al 2009
van Grinsven et al 2010
Kim KM et al 2010
Howells et al 2011
Ardern et al 2011 Barber‐Westin & Noyes 2011
Imoto et al 2012
• RCTs
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
Beard et al 1994 Fitzgerald et al 2000 Mikkelsen et al 2000 Liu‐Ambrose 2003 Risberg et al 2007 Heijne et al 2007 Tagesson et al 2008
Hartigan et al 2009 Gerber et al 2009 Risberg et al 2009 Sekir U et al 2010 Feil et al 2011
Hohmann et al 2011 Lebon et al 2012 Ediz et al 2012
Beynnon et al 2012
Papandreou M et al 2013
Zaffagnini S et al 2013
Baltaci G et al 2013
Our ACL treatment algorithm Rehab
• Phase 3
Post injury
Rehab
• Phase 1,2
• Preop rehab
Tests / Screen
•Milestones
•Criteria
Return
to Sport
• Tests
Postop
Rehab
Return
to Sport
• Milestones
• Criteria
• Tests
Eitzen I, Moksnes H, Snyder-Mackler L, Risberg MA
J Orthop Sport Phys Ther Nov 2010
Neuromuscular and heavy resistance training
‐ progression is needed ‐
NIH grant # 2 RO1 HD 037985‐05.
12
20.03.2014
Røntgenologisk kneartrose – 15 år
Knee injury and osteoarthritis Primary
prevention
Secondary
prevention
Severe OA
Tertiary
prevention
Prosent
Osteoarthritis
Early OA
Joint failure Trauma
Treatment focus?
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
ACL rekonstruert kne
47%
Motsatt sides kne
21%
Artrose i motsatt kne som var uskadet: 15%
6%
0
1
2
3
4
Røntgenskår (K&L)
75 % tibiofemoral OA
Oiestad et al 2010
Symptomatic TFOA and PFOA 20 years after ACL reconstruction
How to exercise for musculoskeletal health?
Dose?
Type?
Exercise therapy for musculoskeletal health in patients with hip OA
Hip OA
Hip function
Active Rehabilitation
THA
Baseline testing
Hip OA
Screened n=220
Included n=109
Interventions
Post‐testing
SE+PE
n=55
PE
n=54
Follow‐up
THA=4
Lost=4
THA=5
Lost=4
Follow‐up
16 months
THA=6
Lost=7
THA=12
Lost=7
Follow‐up
29 months
THA=10
Lost=4
THA=17
Lost=8
6 years survival analysis n=109
THA?
THA?
10 months Fernandes et al 2010
Svege et al 2014
www.active‐rehab.no
13
20.03.2014
Fernandes et al 2010
Fernandes et al 2010
Progression is need to improve function Active rehabilitation program for patients with hip osteoarthritis
Exercise therapy and patient education was significantly better in improving function compared to patient education alone
in patients with mild to moderate hip OA.
But not for pain.
Summary – 1 Benefits of exercises for musculoskeletal health
Svege et al 2014
Supervised exercise therapy p=0.03
Coronary
Exercise and physical activity is beneficial for the most hear
disease
common types of chronic musculoskeletal pain. & Stroke
However, poor adherence to exercise and physical activity may Diabetes
Obesity
limit long‐term effectiveness.
Physical
activity & Health
Musculo
skeletal
Eitzen et al 2012
Mental well‐
beingl
Cancer
Summary – 2
Exercise therapy for musculoskeletal health
• Musculoskeletal injury
– Avoid immobilization after injury
• Understanding the mechanisms of mechanical loading of musculoskeletal tissue will help us understanding type and dose of exercise interventions (Mechanotransduction)
– Bone
– Tendon and ligaments
Mechanotherapy
– Cartilage
Significant for understanding understanding how exercises, loading and dose‐response affect structural changes and change patients symptoms/dysfunction Summary – 3
Exercise therapy for musculoskeletal health
• Knee OA
– Exercises improve function and reduce pain
– Optimal exercise program should have one aim/focus (at a time): aerobic, strength, and performance exercises
– Should be supervised program 3 times weekly for at least 12 sessions
– Adherence is important!
Adherence is needed
• Knee articular cartilage
– Shorter exercise sessions with longer recovery (weightbearing and non‐
weighbearing exercises)
– Adaptive changes seem to depend upon: Age, type and level of activity and joint pathology
Progression is need to improve function
– Progress slowly
– Muscle function can be improved!
14
20.03.2014
Summary – 4
Exercise therapy for musculoskeletal health
Exercise therapy for musculoskeletal health
Progression and Adherence
Progression of exercises
• ACL injury
– Evidence for improving function but very little on secondary prevention of knee OA
• More focus on articular cartilage degeneration early after injury for secondary prevention of OA
Progression is need to improve function • Hip OA
Adherence is needed
– Same as knee OA ? probably not, but – Exercise therapy is effective for pain and disabilities and reduces the need for THA
Take home messages
Exercise therapy for musculoskeletal health
• Mechanical loading should be used therapeutically to stimulate tissue repair and remodeling
– significant for understanding dose‐response
• We need to develop our exercise therapy program to improve
– Muscular function Day 1
Day 2
Next step
• Understanding loading of tendon, ligament and cartilage
– Monitoring
• Type and dose of exercises
• Understanding patients perspectives
The next step?
• Muscle activation – to influence magnitude and rate of loading
• Muscle strength
– dose‐response
– to influence magnitude and rate of loading
– Tendon repair and cartilage remodeling Progression is need to improve muscle strength and neuromuscular function Thank you for your attention!
The Norwegian Research Center for Active Rehabilitation Oslo, Norway
15